Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Tinnitus / July 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Desperate !

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Christian - 23 Jul 2005 22:29 GMT
HI

Ive suffered from tinnitus for many years ( im 32) and odd episodes of
dizziness too ( for months on end at times). i have to say that i blame
myself because i suspect i caused the tinnitus etc but listening to
music on my walkman when i was young and foolish.  It had been at least
4 years
since my last episode of dizziness.  However, about 7 weeks ago, i
started
to get a fluttering sensation and thumping sound in my left ear and
movement
felt in my right.  i couldnt sleep, it was very bad and distracting.
Then i
flew to Mexico and on descent it was quite painful and i was virtually
deaf
and feeling dizzy... and the next night after the 10 hour flight there
was
no such fluttering ( ???) but then i was hit by dizziness for 2 weeks
and
now the fluttering has returned since a day after my return flight and
i have the tinnitus too.  Whilst
i was in mexico, i saw a doctor and he tested me...he said my
eustachian
tubes were both swollen and this would account for the noise.  I should
also
add that 2 months before all this i had felt blockage in my left ear
and
maybe maybe very foolishy i had it syringed which didnt seem to make a
difference ( and myabe i should have left it because it was probably an
infection).  So, any thoughts anyone ?
fyfpoon@gmail.com - 24 Jul 2005 00:00 GMT
Do you trust your doctor who has personally diagnosed you?  do you
place more faith on a bunch of online amateurs here?
Eli - 24 Jul 2005 12:01 GMT
X-No-Archive

I am not a professional. As far as I know, both tinnitus and dizziness
are symptoms of:
·Meniere's disease (or endolymphatic hydrops. I understand they are
related but not the same thing)
·Circulatory disorders
·Diabetes
·Thyroid-related disorders (especially hypothyroidism), and
·Allergies (may be food allergies)
alfred - 24 Jul 2005 12:26 GMT
it's not sound exposure.

you'll have to get some help from family and friends and find a doctor
who knows what is going on, which will depend on the effectiveness of
YOUR research.

medicine hasn't ever studied this issue in depth.

there are liquids in the ear that determine our sensations of both
hearing and movement.

any problems tied to these liquids will set off massive problems.

the sense of hearing is the most closely wired to our emotional brain
centre, so we feel the illness much more than you might expect.
Christian - 24 Jul 2005 12:38 GMT
hi

I have to disagree with alfred.  Of curse it is due to sound exposure
originally.  Im sure that STEPHEN NAGLER will back this up if he is
reading this.  so, i know i only have myself to blame.  Ive seen lots
of docs in the past and nothing has ever helped.  So, im totally alone
on this one and my life is ruined.

> it's not sound exposure.
>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> the sense of hearing is the most closely wired to our emotional brain
> centre, so we feel the illness much more than you might expect.
Eli - 24 Jul 2005 14:33 GMT
X-No-Archive

Dizziness cannot be attributed to sound exposure only.

Endolymphatic hydrops, which I stated in my previous reply, is related
to the "liquids in the ear that determine our sensations of both
hearing and movement" that alfred referred to in his reply.

As far as I know: There is a sac in the inner ear. It gets swollen with
liquid, and then shrinks. Gets swollen, and shrinks... and so on. Two
nerves are passing on this sac: Nerves for hearing and balance. In case
of endolymphatic hydrops, the sac gets swollen with liquid, but cannot
shrink. That puts pressure on the nerves of hearing and balance.
Related to hearing: Tinnitus develops. There may be temporary hearing
loss, which may be permanent if endolymphatic hydrops is not treated.
Related to balance: There may be dizziness attacks. I think they do
"balance tests" for diagnosis. This disease (Meniere's disease) is not
common.

The dizziness and tinnitus may also be due to a metabolic (diabetes or
thyroid) or circulatory problem. Dizziness cannot be attributed to
sound exposure only. I think you should have a holistic approach. Some
doctors (e.g. ENT) become so specialized and concentrated on their
specific field that they sometimes do not realize the relations to
other fields.
fyfpoon@gmail.com - 25 Jul 2005 19:54 GMT
How many doctors have you seen?  Are they from the same discipline?
Christian - 25 Jul 2005 08:38 GMT
Hi all...

to return to my original posting...  I am adamant that my exposure to
loud music many years ago is now the continuing course of my dizziness.
15 years ago when i suddenly started suffering from tinnitus ( after a
session of listening to music by headphones), not long after i began to
eventaully suffer from dizziness and vertigo.  there is surely no
coincidence.  the sound expose has damaged my ears originally and now i
am going to suffer the consequences of my foolish actions, surely.
Susan - 24 Jul 2005 18:25 GMT
> X-No-Archive
>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> ·Thyroid-related disorders (especially hypothyroidism), and
> ·Allergies (may be food allergies)

And infectious diseases, including tick borne infections.

Susan
Staff - 24 Jul 2005 18:39 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> Susan

I don't mean to be contentious Susan and Elly, but an individual's tinnitus
can be associated with any other condition they might have in the absence of
a genuine cause/effect relationship.  While the tick borne stuff isn't all
that common (thankfully) the conditions Elly mentions are.

An effect of Diabetes, for example, is high blood glucose level.  Everyone
with T2 diabetes will have this condition.  They won't all have tinnitus,
however, and no direct correlation has been established.  I know several
people with T2 diabetes but not tinnitus which tells me these conditions can
coexist without a relationship.  Same goes for allergies.


Susan - 24 Jul 2005 19:00 GMT
> I don't mean to be contentious Susan and Elly, but an individual's tinnitus
> can be associated with any other condition they might have in the absence of
> a genuine cause/effect relationship.

I responded with an additional association.

 > While the tick borne stuff isn't all
> that common (thankfully) the conditions Elly mentions are.

The "tick borne stuff" is extremely common.  Not only is it the fastest
growing/spreading infectious disease (or one of the top few), but
virtually all TBD patients not lucky enough to catch it immediately
develop T or H or both.

> An effect of Diabetes, for example, is high blood glucose level.  Everyone
> with T2 diabetes will have this condition.
 > They won't all have tinnitus,
> however, and no direct correlation has been established.  I know several
> people with T2 diabetes but not tinnitus which tells me these conditions can
> coexist without a relationship.  Same goes for allergies.

Which says nothing about the fact that tick borne disease is common,
rarely diagnosed early, and disseminates rapidly, and is very efficient
at infecting/inflaming the cranial nerves, the CNS and the brain,
thereby causing T and H, and severe vertigo, too.

Susan <spent years researching tick borne disease and decades living
with it>
Staff - 24 Jul 2005 19:24 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
> Susan <spent years researching tick borne disease and decades living with
> it>
Yes, I know you have Susan.  There were 497 reported cases of Lymes disease
in Maryland in 1997, and probably tens of thousands of cases of T2 diabetes.
With conditions as common as tinnitus and T2 diabetes, it is extremely
likely the two will coexist in many people.  I have tinnitus.  Did it cause
my T2 diabetes?  I don't think so.
Susan - 24 Jul 2005 19:38 GMT
> Yes, I know you have Susan.  There were 497 reported cases of Lymes disease
> in Maryland in 1997, and probably tens of thousands of cases of T2 diabetes.

You realize that reported cases are an underestimation by at least 100
fold, right?

> With conditions as common as tinnitus and T2 diabetes, it is extremely
> likely the two will coexist in many people.  I have tinnitus.  Did it cause
> my T2 diabetes?  I don't think so.

Virtually all tbd patients will get T and A.  Some TBD patients
experience sudden, severe hearing loss, too.  My then 8 y.o. had severe
T and H with tbds, as an anecdote, and they went away upon initiation of
antibiotic therapy.

Not so with diabetics, though some research did conclude that a low carb
diet (the best clinical course for diabetes) helps T; maybe it's not a
coincidence.  Excess glucose and insulinemia promotes inflammation.

I never said all T and A is caused by tbds, just that they are *a*
cause.  All I ever recommend folks do is get a thorough medical workup
that doesn't overlook the possibility.

Susan
Staff - 24 Jul 2005 20:44 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> You realize that reported cases are an underestimation by at least 100
> fold, right?

Yes, with both T2 diabetis and Lymes disease.

> Virtually all tbd patients will get T and A.  Some TBD patients experience
> sudden, severe hearing loss, too.  My then 8 y.o. had severe T and H with
> tbds, as an anecdote, and they went away upon initiation of antibiotic
> therapy.

I didn't know that.  Where did you discover this?

> I never said all T and A is caused by tbds, just that they are *a* cause.
> All I ever recommend folks do is get a thorough medical workup that
> doesn't overlook the possibility.
>
> Susan
I never said what the cause of tinnitus was or wasn't.  I don't think the
cause of most tinnitus is known.  My point was and is that tinnitus is so
common as to be associated with many illnesses even when no relationship is
known to exist.  Making a list of very common conditions and listing them as
causes of tinnitus is, well, couldn't we just take a list of every known
malady and say that sometimes the people with these have tinnitus too?

If tbd *caused* tinnitus then everyone so infected would have tinnitus.
People who have AIDS sometimes die from pneumonia but AIDS doesn't cause
pneumonia.  People with tbd may be more susceptible to whatever causes
tinnitus.
drfrank21@gmail.com - 24 Jul 2005 22:40 GMT
> > x-no-archive: yes
> >
[quoted text clipped - 30 lines]
> pneumonia.  People with tbd may be more susceptible to whatever causes
> tinnitus.

To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
link of cause and effect can be dicey for many people with T.

frank
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 03:09 GMT
> To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
> idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
> link of cause and effect can be dicey for many people with T.

Everything is caused by something, but we are often unable to discover
what that something is.  It still *has* a cause.

Susan
drfrank21@gmail.com - 25 Jul 2005 04:12 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> Susan

I just diagnosed last week a patient with a retinal detachment (will
likely be a good outcome- I caught it in time for her and the retinal
surgeon did a great job in surgery). There was no apparent cause.
The patient had no predispositions, no trauma, no anything to have
"caused" this. One can then say that the rd (retinal detachment) was
caused by
a retinal weakness- what caused the retinal weakness?? The retinal
weakness was caused by a cellular layer defect- what caused the the
retinal cell layer weakness?? And so on. Maybe it can be taken on a
metaphysical level.

Understanding that a certain condition has no "apparent cause" is
different
than a condition with no cause. Interesting debate. I do believe that
the above
patient falls into the latter category (and obviously, that there are
conditions
that have no cause).

frank
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 04:20 GMT
> I just diagnosed last week a patient with a retinal detachment (will
> likely be a good outcome- I caught it in time for her and the retinal
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> conditions
> that have no cause).

I think no apparent cause is just that; I don't think we have to get
metaphysical to accept that we just aren't as equipped to see/find
what's going on.

I think the term idiopathic is a neat ICD 9 code, and it means you get
to move on to treating the problem while getting that nice relief you
feel when you stop banging your head against the wall.  ;-)

I would suggest that every condition has a cause; whether you or I will
ever guess or find it is another matter.  Sometimes there's just no
point in delving into cause, as long as the remedy is found to be
effective, no?

Susan
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 04:46 GMT
> I just diagnosed last week a patient with a retinal detachment (will
> likely be a good outcome- I caught it in time for her and the retinal
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> conditions
> that have no cause).

Here's a bonus FYI since you're an eyecare professional:

: Int Ophthalmol Clin. 1997 Spring;37(2):13-28.     Related Articles, Links

    The ocular manifestations of Lyme disease.

    Zaidman GW.

    New York Medical College, Valhalla, USA.

    LD (with its ocular manifestations) is a worldwide disorder that is
increasing in frequency. It is a treatable multisystemic disease that
presents in three stages of severity. It can present with unusual forms
of conjunctivitis, keratitis, cranial nerve palsies, optic nerve
disease, uveitis, vitreitis, and other forms of posterior segment
inflammatory disease. A patient with any of these ocular manifestations
should be questioned for exposure to an area endemic for LD, tick bites,
skin rash, or arthritis. Such patients should undergo serological
testing. If the clinical presentation is suggestive of LD, a course of
oral antibiotics should be used (unless the patient gives a history of
adequate therapy). Topical corticosteroids can be used for anterior
segment inflammation. An antibiotic therapeutic trial can be used for
posterior segment or neuroophthalmic disease. Systemic corticosteroids
without concomitant antibiotics should not be used in the treatment of
ocular LD. If ocular LD is discovered and treated early, response to
therapy usually is satisfactory.

    Publication Types:

        * Review
        * Review, Tutorial

    PMID: 9269595 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

I would suggest that even if you've never thought of looking for Lyme
disease as a cause of such cases, they still had a non-idiopathic cause
(generic you, not you specifically).  I also know of folks for whom the
first manifestation was dental pain with no apparent cause.

Susan
Elly Byrne - 25 Jul 2005 21:08 GMT
>To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
>idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
>link of cause and effect can be dicey for many people with T.

If one can accept that muscle tension is a large component of
tinnitus, then 99 % of T cases will fall into that category.

If one cannot or will not consider that option then research will
continue to wonder in useless directions.

This clinic in Sweden is the most promising one.
He will send you a report of his work if you ask him.
http://www.yts.se/english/index.htm

Elly's Tinnitus Resources
http://eebee.net/
Staff - 25 Jul 2005 22:50 GMT
>>To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
>>idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
>>link of cause and effect can be dicey for many people with T.
>
> If one can accept that muscle tension is a large component of
> tinnitus, then 99 % of T cases will fall into that category.

This is SO TRUE Elly.  Once a person decides that their tinnitus was caused
by some coexisting condition, they cannot be convinced to look elsewhere.
This phenomena is benign except to the extent that it hinders habituation.
Jim Chinnis - 26 Jul 2005 01:09 GMT
"Staff" <Staff@Usenet.net> wrote in part:

>>>To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
>>>idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>by some coexisting condition, they cannot be convinced to look elsewhere.
>This phenomena is benign except to the extent that it hinders habituation.

:-D
Signature

Jim Chinnis / Warrenton, Virginia, USA
Want to discuss Meniere's? See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MenieresDG

drfrank21@gmail.com - 26 Jul 2005 01:25 GMT
> >To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
> >idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> He will send you a report of his work if you ask him.
> http://www.yts.se/english/index.htm

I can accept that muscle tension can be a cause of tinnitus.
I can not accept that muscle tension causes 99% of tinnitus.
Maybe you can show me the studies that back this up,Elly.
If this was indeed true, there are many effective
treatments for muscle tension and tinnitus would be
a non-factor.

frank

> Elly's Tinnitus Resources
> http://eebee.net/
Christian - 26 Jul 2005 09:34 GMT
well, i am sure that all my problems are due to noise exposure.  thats
why my dizziness is so bad
Jim Chinnis - 26 Jul 2005 21:42 GMT
"Christian" <christiangee@hotmail.co.uk> wrote in part:

>well, i am sure that all my problems are due to noise exposure.  thats
>why my dizziness is so bad

It is very rare for noise exposure to cause vertigo/dizziness.
When it does, it is generally subsequent to severe hearing loss.
Have you had severe hearing loss?
Signature

Jim Chinnis / Warrenton, Virginia, USA
Want to discuss Meniere's? See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MenieresDG

Murray Grossan - 29 Jul 2005 04:11 GMT
On 7/26/05 1:34 AM, in article
1122366861.068986.186110@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com, "Christian"
<christiangee@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:

> well, i am sure that all my problems are due to noise exposure.  thats
> why my dizziness is so bad

I believe it is a mistake to wonder if noise is causing your dizzyness when
it is simple to test for it.
Once the test is done then you know positively yes or no and can take proper
steps and treatment.
A simple test is to set up for an eletronystagmogram. This records the
jerknog movements of your eyes when you are dizzy. Then apply sound at
various volumes. If the volume elicits dizzyness as shown by the ENG then
you have a positive diagnosis. If it doesn¹t then again you now what you
have.
Not knowing the diagnosis is tough in any symptom. If your finger hurts and
the x ray shows it's fractured, then you can relax and be at ease. Its tough
when the X ray is normal and the finger hurts.
Elly Byrne - 26 Jul 2005 21:52 GMT
>I can accept that muscle tension can be a cause of tinnitus.
>I can not accept that muscle tension causes 99% of tinnitus.
>Maybe you can show me the studies that back this up,Elly.
>If this was indeed true, there are many effective
>treatments for muscle tension and tinnitus would be
>a non-factor.

There are no studies to my knowledge to back this up. The medical
fraternity refuses to look in this direction or even to consider it.

But I have been reading the internet over 10 years and the majority of
symptoms can fall into this category.

Assar Bjorn (Sweden) has published a study that explains his
treatment. His main focus is the posture of the patient and relaxation
techniques. TMJ is always seen to and a few other things.
http://www.yts.se/english/treatment.htm

His patients only come to him after they have exhausted all other
avenues and the treatment is effective.

Elly's Tinnitus Resources
http://eebee.net/
drfrank21@gmail.com - 27 Jul 2005 01:30 GMT
> >I can accept that muscle tension can be a cause of tinnitus.
> >I can not accept that muscle tension causes 99% of tinnitus.
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> His patients only come to him after they have exhausted all other
> avenues and the treatment is effective.

You should be clarifying then Elly, that IN YOUR OPINION, 99%
of tinnitus is muscle tension related. Don't throw it out
as a fact. Your views are just so extremely myopic. Again,
I'm puzzled, if T is indeed only muscle tension related,
why chiro's and PT's haven't jumped on the bandwagon? It's
easy enough to reduce muscle tension. Anybody can do
relaxation techniques. And there would be a 99% success
rate to boot.

Do you wonder why "the medical establishment" has refused
to look in this direction? Maybe there's a good reason
other than going into a conspiracy theory.

frank
Elly Byrne - 27 Jul 2005 21:08 GMT
>I'm puzzled, if T is indeed only muscle tension related,
>why chiro's and PT's haven't jumped on the bandwagon?

Funny you should say that. I just visited a chiro on Tuesday - not for
T - and I mentioned tinnitus to him. He gets quite a few patients with
T. He does something to the 2 top vertebrae in the neck and that seems
to work.

I must get back to him and get more details.

Why haven't they jumped on the bandwagon?
They don't know there is a badwagon to jump on.
Or they know that it is a useless exercise as the medical
establishment never believe them.
Or the patients are too scared of chiros.

Not every chiro knows what to do. There is no standard treatment. I
have visited half a dozen or so in the past 10 years and they all do
different things. One I went to informed me she had been 'invited' to
help with the tinnitus problem. She  was no use whatever.

Elly's Tinnitus Resources
http://eebee.net/
Eric J. Scharer - 27 Jul 2005 01:05 GMT
Elly, is there anyone in the US providing treatment similar
to this clinic in Sweden?

>>To make it even more confusing, I think some cases of tinnitus are
>>idiopathic (without apparent cause). Thus trying to make a definite
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> Elly's Tinnitus Resources
> http://eebee.net/ 
Elly Byrne - 27 Jul 2005 21:02 GMT
Eric, I don't know that. But you can contact the clinic via the
website and have a fruitful email discussion.
http://www.yts.se/english/index.htm

Elly's Tinnitus Resources
http://eebee.net/

>Elly, is there anyone in the US providing treatment similar
>to this clinic in Sweden?
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
>> Elly's Tinnitus Resources
>> http://eebee.net/ 
Jim Chinnis - 25 Jul 2005 02:23 GMT
"Staff" <Staff@Usenet.net> wrote in part:

>If tbd *caused* tinnitus then everyone so infected would have tinnitus.

Tbd in the right host treated/untreated in a particular way causes
tinnitus.
Signature

Jim Chinnis / Warrenton, Virginia, USA
Want to discuss Meniere's? See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MenieresDG

Susan - 25 Jul 2005 04:08 GMT
> "Staff" <Staff@Usenet.net> wrote in part:
>
>>If tbd *caused* tinnitus then everyone so infected would have tinnitus.
>
> Tbd in the right host treated/untreated in a particular way causes
> tinnitus.

Yes, a very quick search of Medline and even just googling demonstrates
that infections, including Lyme, are well documented causes of both
hearing loss, Meniere's and tinnitus.  Tullio phenomenon has been
documented, as well.

Susan
Jim Chinnis - 25 Jul 2005 14:38 GMT
Susan <nevermind@nomail.com> wrote in part:

>x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>hearing loss, Meniere's and tinnitus.  Tullio phenomenon has been
>documented, as well.

As long as we are discussing metaphysical causes:

Meniere's is by definition idiopathic. That means that some
day--when a cause is found--it will either become categorized as
something else or its definition will change.
Signature

Jim Chinnis / Warrenton, Virginia, USA
Want to discuss Meniere's? See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MenieresDG

Susan - 25 Jul 2005 03:06 GMT
> Yes, with both T2 diabetis and Lymes disease.

There isn't any reporting requirement for diabetes cases.  If you were
to say that the "normal" glucose ranges are too high and that fasting
blood glucose misses most diabetics until they're well advance into
their disease, I'd agree, as a long undiagnosed type 2 diabetic who
developed complications of severe peripheral neuropathy and *still* went
undiagnosed.

But there are reliable tests for diabetes, and it does become obvious
what it is at *some* point and no reliable tests for TBDs.  There is a
reporting requirement for Lyme yet a minute % ever get reported.

>>Virtually all tbd patients will get T and A.  Some TBD patients experience
>>sudden, severe hearing loss, too.  My then 8 y.o. had severe T and H with
>>tbds, as an anecdote, and they went away upon initiation of antibiotic
>>therapy.
>
> I didn't know that.  Where did you discover this?

Discover which?  I've posted abstracts about Tulio phenomenon due to
Lyme, sudden hearing loss etc... all from Medline.

san

> I never said what the cause of tinnitus was or wasn't.  I don't think the
> cause of most tinnitus is known.  My point was and is that tinnitus is so
> common as to be associated with many illnesses even when no relationship is
> known to exist.

But neuroborreliosis is well known to cause these symptoms.  I'd suggest
that any brain/CNS infection can, not only TBDs.

 > Making a list of very common conditions and listing them as
> causes of tinnitus is, well, couldn't we just take a list of every known
> malady and say that sometimes the people with these have tinnitus too?

The list also presented Meniere's as a cause; I think it's just a
related symptom at times.

I wasn't rating the quality of the list, just adding a piece of
information for folks with tinnitus to consider.  The severe intrusive
tinnitus that brought me to ast is virtually gone, and often I can't
hear it even if I listen for it. That's because I had a treatable
infectious cause, same as my child.

There may be folks reading this ng who will investigate the possibility
and get just as lucky.

> If tbd *caused* tinnitus then everyone so infected would have tinnitus.

If diabetes causes peripheral neuropathy, by your logic, then everyone
with diabetes should get it.  And kidney failure, too.

The fact is there are hundreds of strains of borrelia, many combinations
of coinfections that occur at once, and the degree to which each of us
suffers the effects has a lot to do with the uniqueness of our own
immune competence and other individual factors.

Since many folks are infected by ticks and never become ill and others
get sudden heart block and die, some get severe psychiatric
manifestations and others get lung complications but few folks get all
the same type of tick symptoms, your assertion just doesn't wash with me.

> People who have AIDS sometimes die from pneumonia but AIDS doesn't cause
> pneumonia.  People with tbd may be more susceptible to whatever causes
> tinnitus.

AIDS does cause disease destroying immune response to a particular type
of parasitic pneumonia due to immune compromise.

In the case of tbd, folks are susceptible to cranial nerve infection by
borrelia.  Lyme disease causes tinnitus and hyperacusis whether you feel
like being cranky about it or not.  Not all T and H is caused by TBDs,
but all TBD or other infection related T and H may be easily treated and
improved.

Susan
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 03:24 GMT
>> I didn't know that.  Where did you discover this?
>
> Discover which?  I've posted abstracts about Tulio phenomenon due to
> Lyme, sudden hearing loss etc... all from Medline.

Addendum:  I know about my kid's T and H because it began during the
illness and went away as soon as antibiotics were administered.

Correction:

> AIDS does cause disease *by* destroying immune response to a particular type
> of parasitic pneumonia due to immune compromise.

> Susan
Staff - 25 Jul 2005 08:23 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
>> Susan
Sorry, Susan, but the cause of either bacterial or viral pneumonia is the
bacteria or virus.  The disease is then facilitated by the lack of immune
response.  This explains why people who don't have AIDS can get pneumonia.
Whatever causes tinnitus might also be facilitated by tbd and this would
explain why people without a tbd can get tinnitus.  AIDS isn't the cause of
pneumonia.  Can you say with certainty that tbd cause tinnitus?  Or do they
facilitate tinnitus with a different cause?  Anyone?
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 15:26 GMT
> Sorry, Susan, but the cause of either bacterial or viral pneumonia is the
> bacteria or virus.  The disease is then facilitated by the lack of immune
> response.  This explains why people who don't have AIDS can get pneumonia.

There is such a thing as primary cause and secondary cause.  People with
AIDS have a very high incidence of a parasitic pneumonia, not ordinary
pneumonia that is caused in very high incident rates by AIDS related
immune compromise.  AIDS causes illnesses that do not occur in infected
non-immune compromised hosts.

> Whatever causes tinnitus might also be facilitated by tbd and this would
> explain why people without a tbd can get tinnitus.  AIDS isn't the cause of
> pneumonia.  Can you say with certainty that tbd cause tinnitus?  Or do they
> facilitate tinnitus with a different cause?  Anyone?

Yes, I can say with certainty that TBDs cause tinnitus.  So can other
infections of the CNS and brain.

I understand that your argument with discussing causes is that most
folks will never know what caused their tinnitus and will have to rely
on habituation.

My stance is the same, but only after all potentially treatable causes
have been considered.  TBDs are among those.

Susan
Staff - 25 Jul 2005 18:48 GMT
> x-no-archive: yes
>
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>
> Susan
We have learned of several conditions that exacerbate tinnitus, including
stress and fatigue.  The root cause of most tinnitus remains unknown.
Treating conditions that exacerbate tinnitus can help but there is no
treatment for the unknown root cause.  What we have here is an exercise in
semantics.  To me, the cause is simply that which causes the condition.  To
you, apparently, the cause can be that which facilitates or exacerbates the
condition.
Susan - 25 Jul 2005 19:06 GMT
> We have learned of several conditions that exacerbate tinnitus, including
> stress and fatigue.

Right.

  The root cause of most tinnitus remains unknown.

Right.  Undiscovered, perhaps, not looked for, as in the case of infections.

> Treating conditions that exacerbate tinnitus can help but there is no
> treatment for the unknown root cause.

Right.

  >What we have here is an exercise in
> semantics.  To me, the cause is simply that which causes the condition.  To
> you, apparently, the cause can be that which facilitates or exacerbates the
> condition.

I don't argue semantics, Bill, I consider that arguing for the sake of
argument.

I'm discussing the peer reviewed scientific findings.  Some infections
may transiently exacerbate tinnitus.

Some infections *cause* deafness (Mumps, Lyme disease, syphilis to name
a few), tinnitus, hyperacusis and vertigo.

I've provided authoritative citations to back every one of my assertions
here.  There's a lot more where they came from.  This information may
help some folks find a cure or effective treatment for their T and H, as
it did for me and my child.

Susan
Jim Chinnis - 25 Jul 2005 15:31 GMT
"Staff" <Staff@Usenet.net> wrote in part:

>Can you say with certainty that tbd cause tinnitus?  Or do they
>facilitate tinnitus with a different cause?  Anyone?

Quite a variety of pathogens, including those from TBDs, can cause
tinnitus by disrupting the function of nerves and nuclei in the
auditory system or the ear itself. There are studies showing
inflammation and damage to the auditory nerve, as an example.

Usually, without an autopsy, the specific damage cannot be seen
with current techniques, so "proof" in an individual case is
always based on the available evidence.
Signature

Jim Chinnis / Warrenton, Virginia, USA
Want to discuss Meniere's? See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MenieresDG


Rate this thread:






 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.