The TURP statistics I cited emanate from two sources. The first is
from a free booklet entitled "Treating Your Enlarded Prostate,"
published and distributed by the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services, AHCPR Publication No. 94-0584. On pages 20-21 it lists
"Chance of experiencing inability to get an erection (impotence) as a
result of treatment: 3% to 35%; Chance of uncontrollable urinary
leakage as a result of treatment: .7% to 1.4%; Chance of dying within
three months after treatment: .5% to 3.3%."
Another source is "The Prostate Report," by Phillips Publishing, Inc.,
Potomac, Maryland, which quotes data attributed to Dr. John Wennberg
of the Dartmouth Medical School as follows: "the death rate is as
high as 1.3% (one death per 56 procedures; 8% of the men having the
procedure have complications requiring hopitalization within three
months, and 5% of them develop impotence. Also, 20% of all men need
to repeat the procedure within eight years. Other reports show that
for 15% of TURP patients symptoms can return in about a year and 4% of
the patients suffer from incontinence."
These data have been around for some time as has the TURP. The
numbers vary slightly depending on whose data you examine, but the
amount of variation is minor.
It appears that most urologists do not volunteer this information to
prospective surgery candidates.
Burr - 13 Jul 2004 14:14 GMT
Thanks for the detailed info Rob.
Burr
> The TURP statistics I cited emanate from two sources. The first is
> from a free booklet entitled "Treating Your Enlarded Prostate,"
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> It appears that most urologists do not volunteer this information to
> prospective surgery candidates.
riserman@optonline.net - 13 Jul 2004 15:38 GMT
Rob,
I would hope that my Urologist is enough up-to-date to not cite these
numbers because, as the website archiving the publication says, "This
document is no longer viewed as guidance for current medical practice."
In short, its out of date.
Bob
> The TURP statistics I cited emanate from two sources. The first is
> from a free booklet entitled "Treating Your Enlarded Prostate,"
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> It appears that most urologists do not volunteer this information to
> prospective surgery candidates.
Liz - 13 Jul 2004 23:51 GMT
> Rob,
>
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Bob
I looked it up and it is 1994, 10 years old, and it had a different title.
Perhaps the number "94-0584" is not right. Also, you have to state what
the "treatment" was, not just "the treatment" there are several to choose
from. And is "the treatment" for BPH or for Cancer.
> > The TURP statistics I cited emanate from two sources. The first is
> > from a free booklet entitled "Treating Your Enlarded Prostate,"
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> > It appears that most urologists do not volunteer this information to
> > prospective surgery candidates.