Hi guys,

Here is a copy of the e-mail I wrote to Karen about the contradiction I
mentioned earlier (in one of her web pages).  Damn it I still haven't soaked
yet, and now my butt is really killing me.  I wonder if she will write me
back.  Enjoy...Pete

Hi Karen,

I would like to point out (what I consider) a contradiction in one of your
web pages regarding cinnamon, beta sitosterol, and saw palmetto - and would
appreciate your comments back.  The web page I am referring to is below.

http://www.herbnet.com/ask%20the%20herbalist/asktheherbalist_questions%20on%20ma
le%20issues.htm

In the web page, you state the following about cinnamon (which contains beta
sitosterol) and prostate cancer:

[[ Since you didn't give me the context of the answer on prostate issues and
cinnamon, I have to assume that I was referring to prostate cancer and not
just prostate problems. Cinnamon, as well as the ginsengs, cordyceps,
ephedra, epimedium, sarsaparilla and horsetail contain high amounts of a
chemical called betasitosterol, which has been shown to encourage the growth
of prostate cancer cells. Those suffering from or recovering from prostate
cancer should avoid these herbs. Of course, if they encourage the growth of
those types of cells, I'd imagine you'd want to avoid them anyway. That's
why it's dangerous to self medicate. Just because an herb has certain
qualities, (Others I have read recommend  cinnamon to enhance blood
circulation, which should aid the prostate.) doesn't mean that other
considerations can be forgotten.]]

I note that you state "Of course, if they encourage the growth of those
types of cells, I'd imagine you'd want to avoid them anyway".

Later on in the web page you state that saw palmetto is good for both BPH
and prostatitis.  Let me point out that the active ingredient in saw
palmetto that makes it effective for reducing DHT in the treatment of BPH,
is beta sitosterol (i.e. saw palmetto has beta sitosterol as does cinnamon).
I grant you that BPH and prostatitis by themselves are not prostate cancer,
but based on your comment "Of course, if they encourage the growth of those
types of cells, I'd imagine you'd want to avoid them anyway", I see a
contradiction in your recommending saw palmetto for BPH, prostatitis, or
anything else for that matter.

Could you please expand on this a little (perhaps I am missing something or
looking at it in the wrong light).  Also, could you provide a good solid
reference article (or some reputable studies under controlled conditions)
that indicate that beta sitosterol encourages the growth of prostate cancer
cells.

Looking forward to hearing from you...Pete