Is it a true statement that a Generic drug only needs to have 75% of the
active ingredient of the Brand. I have heard this from several Doctors and
want to know whether it is true.
thanks, ken
AC - 10 Oct 2003 19:51 GMT
NO
> Is it a true statement that a Generic drug only needs to have 75% of the
> active ingredient of the Brand. I have heard this from several Doctors and
> want to know whether it is true.
>
> thanks, ken
Bob G - 11 Oct 2003 13:11 GMT
> Is it a true statement that a Generic drug only needs to have 75% of the
> active ingredient of the Brand. I have heard this from several Doctors and
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
>=================
Change Doctors...
Seriously I respect physicians BUT doubt ANY would make such a
statement. It is flat out wrong !
Bob Griffiths
James Pinkerton - 11 Oct 2003 13:41 GMT
> > Is it a true statement that a Generic drug only needs to have 75% of the
> > active ingredient of the Brand. I have heard this from several Doctors and
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> Bob Griffiths
Generic drugs and brands are allowed a certain range of values from the
average amount of drug in a particular tablet. If the tablet is supposed to
contain 325 mg of aspirin (labeled amount), it may in fact contain plus or
minus a certain percentage. Maybe ten percent. Then the tablet could
contain from 292 mg to about 357 mg of aspirin and still be within
specifications. On a drug like ferrous sulfate (iron tablet) ten percent or
maybe more would be nothing to be worried about.
A drug like warfarin would have a tighter range. Perhaps some fairly
harmless drugs can have 75% of the labeled active ingredient and still be OK
and meet the government standards. A drug like Premarin extracted from horse
urine probably has a wide variation between lots of the brand name. It also
makes it extremely hard to duplicate as each lot is different.
Brad - 11 Oct 2003 15:47 GMT
Nope.
Generic and brand name drugs are held to the same standards.
Brad
> Is it a true statement that a Generic drug only needs to have 75% of the
> active ingredient of the Brand. I have heard this from several Doctors and
> want to know whether it is true.
>
> thanks, ken