it's yellow 5. i quit the red stuff.
> it's yellow 5. i quit the red stuff.
LOL. See the same Red40 website. Yellow #5 (tartrazine) is related, and
has an even worse reputation, mainly due to the occasional person who's
allergic to it. And of course, all those Feingold diet people who think
their kids have ADHD due to food dyes, with yellow #5 heading the list.
Whether there's anything to this, I don't know. There is at least one
good double blind study of tartrazine and mood, which was positive.
In any case, in your stuff, for red they should have used beet juice
:). And for yellow, beta carotene. Yellow solid foods (like mustard)
are usually colored with Natural Yellow #3, which is curcumin. Which is
probably good for you. So you have to read the labels carefully.
SBH
bob@coolgroups.com - 27 Oct 2005 03:10 GMT
beta carotene causes lung cancer. plus, it's not yellow.
> > it's yellow 5. i quit the red stuff.
>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>
> SBH
Sbharris[atsign]ix.netcom.com - 27 Oct 2005 03:16 GMT
b...@coolgroups.com wrote:
> beta carotene causes lung cancer. plus, it's not yellow.
Solutions of it are, I promise. Ask how I know.
It only causes lung cancer in smokers.
SBH
bob@coolgroups.com - 27 Oct 2005 15:30 GMT
how do u know it's only smokers
also, why do you think it's yellow
MMu - 27 Oct 2005 16:27 GMT
> how do u know it's only smokers
read the (already famous) finland-study!
(smokers and non-smokers supplemented with beta carotene were screened for
cancer risk;
smokers supplemented with beta carotene had higher risk, so the study had to
be stopped.)
it does not "cause" cancer however.
> also, why do you think it's yellow
a dilution effect probably.. lycopene should be the yellow carotinoid while
beta carotene could be yellow if diluted and is orange otherwise.
Sbharris[atsign]ix.netcom.com - 27 Oct 2005 19:37 GMT
> > also, why do you think it's yellow
>
> a dilution effect probably.. lycopene should be the yellow carotinoid while
> beta carotene could be yellow if diluted and is orange otherwise.
Yep. All carotenoids are basically yellow in dilution, as true
solutions or microemulsions. And they get pretty yellow before they
begin to show orange or red.