Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / General / Nutrition / July 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Beta Sitosterol, Bee Honey and Quercetin

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Pete - 16 Jun 2005 05:10 GMT
Hi everyone,

I am currently taking all three of the above supplements in desperate hope
for some relief from prostatitis/BPH.  I had a TURP over two months ago (and
have never recovered), and now I am ten times worse, and the doctors can not
help me.  I am in serious constant pain, and quite knowledgeable in the
fields of medicine and prescription drugs, so no lectures please on getting
second opinions and taking various pain pills and anti-depressants that have
an off label use for neuropathy.  I have  been to over 75 doctors in my life
and have nothing to show for it.  I also have other medical problems
including upper GI, sarcoidosis and a T-4 cell deficiency (non-HIV, cause
unknown).

I have studied the above supplements at length and am currently (just
started yesterday) taking 500 mg of beta sitosterol (that's for the beta
portion of the pill), 1000 mg of bee pollen (don't know how much is actual
pollen), and 1000 mg of quercetin (actual) - all split into equal bi-daily
doses.

I would like to know if that may pose any safety issues regarding side
effects (especially due to any additive effects - e.g. taking two different
anti-inflammatories and antioxidants, etc.).  I have read that too much
quercetin may have an opposite effect on inflammation, and may even cause
cancer, even though it is purported to be a preventative for certain types
of cancer (i.e. the door swings both ways).  I assume this would only apply
if
you were taking large doses (way more than what I am taking).  Do you
concur.

There is a nationally renown urologist who has printed some journals touting
Cernilton (extract of bee pollen) and quercetin as showing promise for
chronic non bacterial prostatitis, and there have been studies indicating
that beta sitosterol may have a role in decreasing the production of DHT,
which is partly responsible for enlargement of the prostate gland.

So here I am writing this in pain, basically asking for your comments on any
safety issues you may know of for the above supplements.  I have been to an
inordinate amount of sites and naturally the sellers of products will not
say anything bad (e.g. "no known side effects").  But then when you go to
other sites by doing different search criteria, you read about how quercetin
(in particular) may not be so harmless.

I welcome your comments on all three supplements (both taking them alone, or
all together at once like I am).  I am sick now (malaise with nausea), and
was sick before I started taking them, so I wouldn't know if the pills are
causing additional nausea.  I know the malaise and nausea is from the
prostatitis, but if you tell a uro that they will tell you maybe you have a
virus - right.  Just for your info I was on antibiotics (various) for the
better part of five months (before and after my surgery) and they did not
help.  My last visit to the uro (I went back 3 times after the surgery), he
said to stop them and just wait for the surgery to heal.  I got a second
opinion from a uro in another town and he said to wait also (never even
examined me), but it has been over two months now and the pain is getting
worse if anything.  The uro will probably drop me on my upcoming visit, and
all six of the uros where I live are in one office, so I will be out of
luck.

I had a Pelvic catscan and it was normal.  I can't handle the prep for a
colonoscopy right now but if the pain and discomfort in my rectum, groin and
pelvic floor (which I know is from the prostate surgery) gets any worse I
will have to get one anyway, to rule out any colon/rectal problems.  Sorry
this is so long, and for getting carried away at the end.

Pete
montygram - 16 Jun 2005 06:03 GMT
Good news, Pete - I think I have the answer for you.  Actually, the
research scientists do, but sometimes the information doesn't make it
to the doctors.  I recently asked a doctor a simple chemistry question
(about sodium chloride) and he had not idea.

Prostate problems (with very few exceptions) are due to free radical
stress.  Start taking selenium (not in the selenate/selenite forms) -
even a teaspoon a day of nutritional yeast should do the job.  But most
importantly, do not eat any food with more than small amounts of
unsaturated fatty acids.  If you must eat meat high in unsaturated
fatty acids, boil it - do not cook it while exposed to air (boil eggs
too).  Do not eat baked goods unless they are fat free or nearly so,
and don't eat them if they have eggs or dairy in the list of
ingredients.  Never use oils such as vegetable, corn, canola, flax,
soybean, safflower, sunflower,e tc., and to be safe, since you're in
bad shape, only use coconut oil.  My favorite is coconut oil supreme,
which is available on the internet.  If price is a factor, just use
butter.  Try to warm up food whenever possible.  In other words, boil
the meat (if you're not a vegetarian) then add it to a sauce that
you've  got warmed up (which could have butter in it).  Eat antioxidant
rich foods with your meals.  Berries, dark chocolate, lightly cooked
broccoli florets, etc.  Drink white tea (I get organic white tea in
unbleached tea bags from iherb.com).  Stay away from fish oil.  I'd
guess if you don't accidently eat the wrong thing (for example, a
sandwich at a deli is bad news as far as free radical damage is
concerned), you will feel better in a month or less.  If you do try
this out, please email me directly and let me know how things worked
out for you.

If you have any doubts about what I'm saying, you can do your own
research at pubmed.com  Do searches for things like "oxidative stress
prostate," for example.

Good luck!
Hi There - 16 Jun 2005 06:15 GMT
> Prostate problems (with very few exceptions) are due to free radical
> stress.  Start taking selenium (not in the selenate/selenite forms) -

Bullshit. And selenium is toxic, so watch out!
http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=39194
Pete - 16 Jun 2005 18:32 GMT
For pete's sake montygram,  I have a hard enough time just eating as it is
without doing all the stuff you recommend.  Thanks anyway...Pete

> Good news, Pete - I think I have the answer for you.  Actually, the
> research scientists do, but sometimes the information doesn't make it
[quoted text clipped - 30 lines]
>
> Good luck!
montygram - 16 Jun 2005 06:03 GMT
Good news, Pete - I think I have the answer for you.  Actually, the
research scientists do, but sometimes the information doesn't make it
to the doctors.  I recently asked a doctor a simple chemistry question
(about sodium chloride) and he had not idea.

Prostate problems (with very few exceptions) are due to free radical
stress.  Start taking selenium (not in the selenate/selenite forms) -
even a teaspoon a day of nutritional yeast should do the job.  But most
importantly, do not eat any food with more than small amounts of
unsaturated fatty acids.  If you must eat meat high in unsaturated
fatty acids, boil it - do not cook it while exposed to air (boil eggs
too).  Do not eat baked goods unless they are fat free or nearly so,
and don't eat them if they have eggs or dairy in the list of
ingredients.  Never use oils such as vegetable, corn, canola, flax,
soybean, safflower, sunflower,e tc., and to be safe, since you're in
bad shape, only use coconut oil.  My favorite is coconut oil supreme,
which is available on the internet.  If price is a factor, just use
butter.  Try to warm up food whenever possible.  In other words, boil
the meat (if you're not a vegetarian) then add it to a sauce that
you've  got warmed up (which could have butter in it).  Eat antioxidant
rich foods with your meals.  Berries, dark chocolate, lightly cooked
broccoli florets, etc.  Drink white tea (I get organic white tea in
unbleached tea bags from iherb.com).  Stay away from fish oil.  I'd
guess if you don't accidently eat the wrong thing (for example, a
sandwich at a deli is bad news as far as free radical damage is
concerned), you will feel better in a month or less.  If you do try
this out, please email me directly and let me know how things worked
out for you.

If you have any doubts about what I'm saying, you can do your own
research at pubmed.com  Do searches for things like "oxidative stress
prostate," for example.

Good luck!
Dr. Wayne Simon - 16 Jun 2005 07:07 GMT
how about an epidural block
John Sankey - 16 Jun 2005 14:28 GMT
Just to note that quercetin is equivalent to cholesterol, so
you in effect are taking 3x the maximum dietary recommendation
of the heart people. Unless you feel it improves your condition,
I'd be cautious about that dose.
John Sankey - 16 Jun 2005 15:42 GMT
"The uro will probably drop me on my upcoming visit"

If he does, you should contact your state/provincial medical
licensing body, fast.

"they will tell you maybe you have a virus - right. Just for your
info I was on antibiotics..."

Antibiotics are of no use against viruses. Try to locate a virologist
to see if there are any tests that can be usefully done.

"If you have any doubts about what I'm saying, you can do your own
research at pubmed.com  Do searches for things like "oxidative stress
prostate," for example."

It's true that montygram is a stuck record on PUFAs, but if you
haven't yet tried research on pubmed, I recommend it. If you aren't
used to scientific language though, it can be tough to understand and
put in context. In searching the web, I strongly recommend skipping
any site that sells supplements - many of them wear blinkers at best
and are downright dangerous at worst.

Aflatoxins in nuts are indeed extremely dangerous, but can easily be
avoided. Buy your nuts from a source where they smell fresh and dry,
with not the slightest hint of mould or rot, then keep them that way
in jars in a frig until you eat them.

Most of all, keep asking questions as long as you are suffering the
way you are. And, try to find a local support or self/help group -
even just knowing you aren't alone can help a great deal.
John Sankey - 17 Jun 2005 01:46 GMT
"Just to note that quercetin is equivalent to cholesterol"
My apologies - I mixed up two chemical names.
"Quercetin is a potent antioxidant" is correct.
John Sankey - 17 Jun 2005 01:56 GMT
"I can see you haven't been to many doctors"

Not exactly - I just forget sometimes how different the medical world
is in the USA than Canada.
Ray K - 29 Jun 2005 22:58 GMT
> Hi everyone,
>
[quoted text clipped - 60 lines]
>
> Pete

You took antibiotics for over five months. Have you tried taking
probiotics to replace the good bacteria than the antibiotics killed? It
probably won't do anything to relieve pain, but without a healthy "bowel
ecology" you can't be healthy.

You can learn more about bowel ecology here: http://majidali.com/

If you are in the New York/New Jersey area, you might want to make an
appointment with Ali.

Best wishes,

Ray
Cosmo - 02 Jul 2005 06:00 GMT
I am sorry to hear of your condition.  Have you checked this site?
http://www.prostatitis.org/  or
http://kidney.niddk.nih.gov/kudiseases/pubs/prostatitis/

I would like to invite you to check our website at
www.trulyhealthyandwealthy.com
Check out the products and read up on the ESSENTIALS (a comprehensive
supplement rated as the #1 in North America) and PALMETTO PLUS for the
Prostate and PROFLAVANOL 90 which is a powerful antioxidant and anti
inflamatory.

I think you will be impressed with the research and science behind the
products.

Email me at cosmo@trulyhealthyandwealthy.com for any additional information
required.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.