Medical Forum / General / Nutrition / February 2005
2 Questions: Healthiest vegetables? & Risk of vitamin A overdose?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
chris - 20 Feb 2005 01:30 GMT 2 questions for the experts out there...
1. I'm sure many of you would agree that an ideal diet should include a wide variety of vegetables everyday, but if for some reason you had to eat the same, say, 4 or 5 vegetables each day, which would be the healthiest to consume?
2. If my daily diet includes a big bowl of raw spinach, steamed broccoli, carrots, tomatoes, and other vegetables, am I at risk of overdosing on vitamin A, which I understand has high concentrations in spinach and other vegetables? If so, how do you recommend I change my diet?
any thoughts would be much appreciated..
thanks chris
Curly Sue - 20 Feb 2005 01:54 GMT >2 questions for the experts out there... > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >spinach and other vegetables? If so, how do you recommend I change my >diet? the vegetables have beta-carotene, which is a sort of precursor of vitamin A. beta-carotene is not as toxic as vitamin A. But don't eat the same ones every day; you should get some crucifera vegetables (cabbage, brussels sprouts, cauliflower, broccoli) among others.
Sue(tm) Lead me not into temptation... I can find it myself!
MMu - 21 Feb 2005 09:22 GMT 1) eating the same vegetables (or anything else for that matter) is never recommendable. variety is the key to a balanced diet.
2) you can't overdose on beta carotene when thinking of vitamin a toxicity because it's only split to vitamin a on demand.
problems with very high beta carotene (probably not possible to reach this level with food) however may arise if you are smoking. (see the finland study on smokers and beta carotene)
>>2 questions for the experts out there... >> [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > Sue(tm) > Lead me not into temptation... I can find it myself! Juhana Harju - 21 Feb 2005 12:06 GMT :::: [...]If my daily diet includes a big bowl of raw spinach, steamed :::: broccoli, carrots, tomatoes, and other vegetables, am I at risk of [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] :: reach this level with food) however may arise if you are smoking. :: (see the finland study on smokers and beta carotene) The Finnish study was done with isolated beta carotene supplements and the beta carotene was not in its natural form. Beta carotene from food sources is perfectly alright.
 Signature Juhana, Finland
John Que - 22 Feb 2005 07:17 GMT > The Finnish study was done with isolated beta carotene supplements and > the beta carotene was not in its natural form. Beta carotene from food > sources is perfectly alright. all trans-beta carotene.
natural would be a mix of trans and cis
Juhana Harju - 22 Feb 2005 07:38 GMT ::: The Finnish study was done with isolated beta carotene supplements ::: and the beta carotene was not in its natural form. Beta carotene [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] :: :: natural would be a mix of trans and cis That's right. This is the Finnish Study:
The effect of vitamin E and beta carotene on the incidence of lung cancer and other cancers in male smokers. The Alpha-Tocopherol, Beta Carotene Cancer Prevention Study Group. N Engl J Med. 1994 Apr 14;330(15):1029-35. PMID: 8127329
"Unexpectedly, we observed a higher incidence of lung cancer among the men who received beta carotene than among those who did not."
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstra ct&list_uids=8127329
But there are also studies where an *inverse* relationship between beta carotene and lung cancer was found, so the situation is not so clear:
Connett JE, Kuller LH, Kjelsberg MO, Polk BF, Collins G, Rider A, Hulley SB. Relationship between carotenoids and cancer. The Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial (MRFIT) Study. Cancer. 1989 Jul 1;64(1):126-34. PMID: 2731108
"The results of this study provide further evidence for a possible protective effect of beta carotene against lung cancer among cigarette smokers."
Menkes MS, Comstock GW, Vuilleumier JP, Helsing KJ, Rider AA, Brookmeyer R. Serum beta-carotene, vitamins A and E, selenium, and the risk of lung cancer. N Engl J Med. 1986 Nov 13;315(20):1250-4. PMID: 3773937
 Signature Juhana
John Que - 22 Feb 2005 08:24 GMT > ::: The Finnish study was done with isolated beta carotene supplements > ::: and the beta carotene was not in its natural form. Beta carotene [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > "Unexpectedly, we observed a higher incidence of lung cancer among the > men who received beta carotene than among those who did not." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstra ct&list_uids=8127329
> But there are also studies where an *inverse* relationship between beta > carotene and lung cancer was found, so the situation is not so clear: [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > R. Serum beta-carotene, vitamins A and E, selenium, and the risk of lung > cancer. N Engl J Med. 1986 Nov 13;315(20):1250-4. PMID: 3773937 The positive reports are based on correlation. The old saying goes " correlation doesn't prove causation." Now that I've said that, I state the obvious which you are aware. The 1986 and 1989 studies are based the dietary source apparently. The involved beta carotenoid would be both trans and cis. There would likely be a great mix of carotenoids especially in the diets of the healthier subjects.
aem - 20 Feb 2005 02:14 GMT > 2 questions for the experts out there... > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > spinach and other vegetables? If so, how do you recommend I change my > diet? Even with 4 or 5 veggies you can have variety, especially if they are from different families--i.e., cabbage and broccoli would give less variety than broccoli and tomatoes. A friend ate several carrots every single day without fail for months and her skin turned yellow. Other strange symptoms appeared, she went to the doc, who diagnosed vitamin A overdose. His prescription was, stop eating so many carrots.
I doubt there is a real answer to "which would be the healthiest."
-aem
John Que - 20 Feb 2005 04:39 GMT > > 2 questions for the experts out there... > > [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > > -aem I've a couple of comments. First, she may have been low thyroid or developing diabetes. I understand such person tned to accumulate carotene. Second, there is a report going back in WW2 in Great Britian in which people starting huge amounts of home grow carrots as it was what they had. They started having problem that were attributed to the carrots. The claim was that carrots contain a toxin that gets to be too much when they are too big a portion of the diet. In light of this the advice the others gave to vary and rotate your vegetable makes lots of sense. I doubt carrots are the only vegetable with one might get too much of a plant toxin.
Phil Scott - 20 Feb 2005 05:45 GMT > 2 questions for the experts out there... > [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > overdosing on vitamin A, which I understand has high concentrations in > spinach and other vegetables? No risk.. not even if you juice them and consume that at 5x the volume..get a book on raw juicing therapy. or search those key words on google
If so, how do you recommend I change my
> diet? > > any thoughts would be much appreciated.. > > thanks > chris Juhana Harju - 20 Feb 2005 06:17 GMT ::: 2 questions for the experts out there... ::: ::: 1. I'm sure many of you would agree that an ideal diet should ::: include a wide variety of vegetables everyday, but if for some ::: reason you had to eat the same, say, 4 or 5 vegetables each day, ::: which would be the healthiest to consume? No one has dared to answer your question directly, so I give a try although there is no absolutely correct answer as the nutritional needs are individual. It is also a question of which health conditions you want to treat or prevent.
Here is one suggestion: - parsley (a rich source of many phytochemicals, minerals) - red onions (a rich source of quercetin) - spinach (lutein, minerals) - broccoli (sulphoraphane) - tomatoes (lycopene)
Carrots, sweet potatoes, orange sweet peppers, garlic (is it a vegetable or a herb?)and romaine lettuce would also be excellent choices.
::: 2. If my daily diet includes a big bowl of raw spinach, steamed ::: broccoli, carrots, tomatoes, and other vegetables, am I at risk of [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] :: the volume..get a book on raw juicing therapy. or search those :: key words on google I agree. Beta carotene is not toxic.
 Signature Juhana
Juhana Harju - 20 Feb 2005 15:34 GMT :: Phil Scott wrote: ::::: [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] :: - broccoli (sulphoraphane) :: - tomatoes (lycopene) Spinach and broccoli are sources of beta carotene also.
:: Carrots, sweet potatoes, orange sweet peppers, garlic (is it a :: vegetable or a herb?)and romaine lettuce would also be excellent :: choices.
 Signature Juhana
Juhana Harju - 20 Feb 2005 16:15 GMT :: Juhana Harju wrote: :::: Phil Scott wrote: [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] :::: :: Spinach and broccoli are sources of beta carotene also. And even better (but more costly) suggestion:
Parsley Red onions Spinach Broccoli sprouts Cherry tomatoes
 Signature Juhana
Julia Altshuler - 20 Feb 2005 14:31 GMT You've said any thoughts would be appreciated so here goes. I'm no expert in science and nutrition but have thought about your questions before from the standpoint of a cook.
For the 5 vegetables each day, I'd try to get one from each of the following categories:
1) Something in the cabbage family. That could be broccoli, cabbage, kale, collards, cauliflower, etc.
2) Something dark orange with beta carotene in it like carrots, sweet pototaoes, rutabaga (also in the cabbage family), etc.
3) Dark leafy greens including spinach, kale, arugula, parsley or chard.
4) A squash like butternut, acorn, buttercup (also in category #2), or zucchini.
5) A flavor punch like tomatoes or mushrooms.
I'm assuming that your question doesn't mean that you intend to eat ONLY vegetables and not get grains, beans, eggs, dairy, etc. If that were the case, I'd suggest more in the way of something with calories. That leads to my thoughts on your second question. If you're getting plenty of other foods besides the 5 vegetables, it is unlikely that you'd get so much of any one of them that you'd be at risk for an overdose. You'd be getting calories from other sources. If you were trying to limit your total foods to the vegetables on the list and not eat anything else, then a vitamin overdose wouldn't be the worst of your worries, but I suppose it could happen.
--Lia
> 2 questions for the experts out there... > [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > thanks > chris John Sankey - 20 Feb 2005 17:24 GMT Just for the heck of it, I asked my optimization routine which 5 fresh vegetables by themselves (i.e. eat nothing else) give the best balanced diet as measured by NAS RDA's: the answer is corn, onion, parsnip, sweet potato and winter squash.
If you want nutrients per calorie, nothing comes close to spinach.
Do you consider beans to be a veg? Botanically, they are. (Of course, to us tomato is a fruit.)
For a few other number-based views of nutrition, see http://sankey.ws/miscellanea.html
chris - 20 Feb 2005 23:04 GMT Thanks for all your thoughtful suggestions.. and to anyone yet to respond, I neglected to mention that I am a 39-yr-old male lacto-vegetarian in good health who eats a well-balanced diet including plenty of fresh fruit, whole grains, and very few processed or sugary foods (no colas, etc.).
chris
Julia Altshuler - 21 Feb 2005 00:44 GMT > Thanks for all your thoughtful suggestions.. and to anyone yet to > respond, I neglected to mention that I am a 39-yr-old male > lacto-vegetarian in good health who eats a well-balanced diet > including plenty of fresh fruit, whole grains, and very few processed > or sugary foods (no colas, etc.). While I suppose it is none of my business, I'm curious enough to ask the reason for your questions. Why would you want to know about limiting to vegetables? I could picture it for a science fiction story where the survivors on a planet have room in the space ship for only 5 packets of seeds and then get strange symptoms that turn out to be overdoses of vitamin A or something like that but can't picture a limit to 5 vegetables as part of a well-balanced diet in this time and place.
--Lia
chris - 21 Feb 2005 15:54 GMT Lia wrote:
> While I suppose it is none of my business, I'm curious enough to ask the > reason for your questions. Why would you want to know about limiting to [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > vitamin A or something like that but can't picture a limit to 5 > vegetables as part of a well-balanced diet in this time and place. I eat a well-balanced diet of veggies, fruits, grains, beans, dairy, and nuts/seeds everyday, but I'm lazy, so I tend to eat the same foods each day. I try to vary it up as much I can, but I wanted to know if there was a better combination of veggies than my daily staple of spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, and carrots (I also eat cucumbers and alfalfa sprouts at lunch).
thanks, chris
Julia Altshuler - 21 Feb 2005 16:01 GMT > I eat a well-balanced diet of veggies, fruits, grains, beans, dairy, > and nuts/seeds everyday, but I'm lazy, so I tend to eat the same foods > each day. I try to vary it up as much I can, but I wanted to know if > there was a better combination of veggies than my daily staple of > spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, and carrots (I also eat cucumbers and > alfalfa sprouts at lunch). Ah, now I understand, and it makes sense. If you want to vary your diet more without sacrificing your essential laziness (something else I understand), come here (rfc) for recipes or take a look at the thread on best vegetarian cookbooks. Oddly enough, it looks like you followed my earlier advice without knowing what it was. You have something in the leafy green category (spinach), something in the cabbage family category (broccoli), something dark orange (carrots) and something flavorful (tomato). The only think I'd add is a squash like butternut squash.
--Lia
Alf Christophersen - 21 Feb 2005 22:57 GMT >I eat a well-balanced diet of veggies, fruits, grains, beans, dairy, >and nuts/seeds everyday, but I'm lazy, so I tend to eat the same foods >each day. I try to vary it up as much I can, but I wanted to know if >there was a better combination of veggies than my daily staple of >spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, and carrots (I also eat cucumbers and >alfalfa sprouts at lunch). I think maybe you are at risk of essential aminoacids deficiency. And probably betaine/choline deficiency. try some beets, preferably grown in salty areas as that induce betaine production, and use more beans. Also wheat bran, wheat germ, whole wheat
Look at http://www.vitaminexpress.com/healthnotes/newswire_2004_04_08_1.htm
http://www.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/133/5/1302 also contains some tables on betaine and choline. (and there are several others)
Spinach is also a good source, but in all vegetable where free amino acids and stuff like betaine is primarily used as osmolytes in order to keep constant water turgor (hydration level and pressure inside cells), stress conditions are important. Plants watered daily during drought spell express far less of these compounds than in vegetables and other plants irregularly watered during dry periods.
janetconti1970@yahoo.com - 22 Feb 2005 00:59 GMT Seems important not to miss out on eating berries. Blueberries, blackberries, and other berries are very high in anitoxidants. Higher than the foods mentioned, I think. I eat them every day even when I was only able to buy frozen ones, since I'm guessing berries that were frozen still contain tons of anthocyanins (sp?).
John Que - 22 Feb 2005 08:30 GMT > Seems important not to miss out on eating berries. Blueberries, > blackberries, and other berries are very high in anitoxidants. Higher > than the foods mentioned, I think. I eat them every day even when I > was only able to buy frozen ones, since I'm guessing berries that were > frozen still contain tons of anthocyanins (sp?). Yes, they still contain it. Anthocyanins are purple. Berries are an excellent food. Plums and prune (both fresh and dried) are also good sources.
chris - 22 Feb 2005 16:03 GMT Janet wrote:
> Seems important not to miss out on eating berries. Blueberries, > blackberries, and other berries are very high in anitoxidants. Higher > than the foods mentioned, I think. I eat them every day even when I > was only able to buy frozen ones, since I'm guessing berries that were > frozen still contain tons of anthocyanins (sp?). Agreed. I eat half a cup of fresh blueberries everyday, year-round. I also eat 2 bananas everyday, as well as other fruits like raisins, occasionally grapes and strawberries.
thanks again to everyone for their useful advice.. chris
Juhana Harju - 22 Feb 2005 10:43 GMT ::: I eat a well-balanced diet of veggies, fruits, grains, beans, dairy, ::: and nuts/seeds everyday, but I'm lazy, so I tend to eat the same [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] :: :: I think maybe you are at risk of essential aminoacids deficiency. Essential amino acids deficiency with a lactovegetarian diet containing beans, grains and nuts/seeds everyday? :-) Please show some evidence.
 Signature Juhana
Alf Christophersen - 22 Feb 2005 15:29 GMT >Essential amino acids deficiency with a lactovegetarian diet containing >beans, grains and nuts/seeds everyday? :-) Please show some evidence. oVerlooked the bean :-) Without beans,you are at high risk.
But lysine may be low.
Juhana Harju - 21 Feb 2005 05:56 GMT :: Thanks for all your thoughtful suggestions.. and to anyone yet to :: respond, I neglected to mention that I am a 39-yr-old male :: lacto-vegetarian in good health who eats a well-balanced diet :: including plenty of fresh fruit, whole grains, and very few processed :: or sugary foods (no colas, etc.). For males favoring onions, tomatoes and broccoli would probably give some protection against prostate cancer also.
 Signature Juhana
|
|
|