This is uncalled for for any reason.  There are multiple fatal flaws in
his thesis, but this personal attack does nothing for it's poster but
evoke pity and distain.

If you look at googlegroups, I have replied to his thesis perhaps more
then any other poster.  I have tried to address the info he presents and
how it fails his thesis.  When I found myself getting personal I corrected
myself.  Your slurs against him served little purpose and spoke ill of
you.