Medical Forum / General / General / August 2005
Catch a cold with wet hair?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
MS - 28 Jun 2005 14:19 GMT Hi,
You are all familiar with the phrase 'you'll catch your death' and the similar. Often these are said to someone who is about to go outside with, say, wet hair on a cold day, or out in the rain without a waterproof jacket. Recently a nurse told me it is a bad idea to wash your hair with cold water as you can catch a cold (I was highly sceptical).
A cold is a virus and you need exposure to the virus in order to catch it, so at first 'glance' the idea that exposure to cold or wet weather means you could catch a virus seems to be invalid. However often there is truth to 'old wives tales' and I was wondering if there is any scientific basis to this one? Perhaps the physiology of keeping your head warm if you're outside in cold weather with wet hair means that your immune system suffers and you become more likely to catch a virus?
Anyone know anything about this?
Thanks,
MS
Dr. Wayne Simon - 28 Jun 2005 15:46 GMT many virus's ie; rhinoviruses, rotoviruses etc. are somewhat ubiquitous, so exposure is usually there, but altering the immune system is the usual way one catches a cold. ie; by weakening the immunesystem.
Rafael Almeida - 28 Jun 2005 16:26 GMT > many virus's ie; rhinoviruses, rotoviruses etc. are somewhat ubiquitous, so > exposure is usually there, but altering the immune system is the usual way > one catches a cold. ie; by weakening the immunesystem. Can a wet hair get your immunesystem weaker? I went out with wet hair thousands of times, i've also went in the rain without a waterproof more than once and I've never seen a relation between having cold water in my body and getting a cold. I usually get a cold when I'm stressed out from college.
MS - 28 Jun 2005 17:21 GMT Dr. Wayne Simon emailed this:
> many virus's ie; rhinoviruses, rotoviruses etc. are somewhat ubiquitous, so > exposure is usually there, but altering the immune system is the usual way > one catches a cold. ie; by weakening the immunesystem. Thanks but I'm afraid you've slightly missed the point. I'll rephrase the question. Can wet hair in cold weather, or getting wet in the rain, etc., or even sleeping in a cool air-conditioned room, weaken your immune system so that you are more likely to catch a cold?
Thanks,
MS
Twittering One - 28 Jun 2005 17:27 GMT Ms. Martin, no, that never worked.
MS - 28 Jun 2005 19:03 GMT Twittering One emailed this:
> Ms. > Martin, no, that never worked. Can you explain what you mean? Did you maybe reply to the wrong post because there is no context to what your wrote: what never worked?
MS
Twittering One - 30 Jun 2005 07:24 GMT "What never worked?" ~ MS
"Catching a cold on the Berkley Street Bridge, headed Toward Chandler ..." ~ Twittering
Twittering One - 30 Jun 2005 07:28 GMT "One Friday, 4:30 pm, ca. 1980, January, no shirt, Unzipped jacket ..." ~ Folly
Anonymous - 29 Jun 2005 05:49 GMT > Hi, > [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > > MS http://www.commoncold.org/special1.htm (see myth 3)
http://www.surgerydoor.co.uk/coe/paincentre/fact.shtml (4th myth down)
http://www.chic.org.uk/chicmco/spotlight/downloads/coldandflu.pdf (page 6)
One person's myth is another person's reality ...
 Signature Anonymous ----------------------------------------------------- Work harder. Millions on benefits are relying on you! -----------------------------------------------------
MS - 29 Jun 2005 13:12 GMT > http://www.commoncold.org/special1.htm (see myth 3) > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > One person's myth is another person's reality ... Many thanks those links answered everything I wanted to know and more.
So the answer is: NO - cold weather, wet hair, etc. do not contribute to catching a cold.
MS
Daniele Focosi - 29 Jun 2005 16:57 GMT "Anonymous" gave us great references (www.commoncold.org seems to be a very good website) : despite it is proved that rhinoviruses (the true aetiological agents of the properly named common cold) grow better at cold temperatures, it seems as there is no randomized controlled trial to support the idea that exposure to cold weather facilitates common colds. Anyway as cold air paralyzes the cilia of out respiratory tract (which help to clear the tract from bacteria), it is common experience that exposure to cold air increases incidence of bacterial respiratory infections (pharyngitis, pharyngotonsillitis, laryngitis, bronchitis and even pneumonia), so anyway the old advice of not going out in the rain without a waterproof jacket is still good for you.. Hope this helps
> > Hi, > > [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > > One person's myth is another person's reality ... Shylirin - 16 Aug 2005 09:18 GMT > "Anonymous" gave us great references (www.commoncold.org seems to be a > very good website) : despite it is proved that rhinoviruses (the true > aetiological agents of the properly named common cold) grow better at > cold temperatures, it seems as there is no randomized controlled trial > to support the idea that exposure to cold weather facilitates common > colds. Something to consider regarding the cold weather and colds... people tend to congregate in enclosed groups to keep out of the cold weather, which provides an excellent environment for virus transmission. Given this phenomenon, one would expect that viral transmission would be greater and lead an observer to link an increase in illness to the weather. :) Makes you want to go out and play in the snow...
Anyway as cold air paralyzes the cilia of out respiratory tract
> (which help to clear the tract from bacteria), it is common experience > that exposure to cold air increases incidence of bacterial respiratory [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > > > > > > MS Shylirin
PF Riley - 30 Jun 2005 07:03 GMT >You are all familiar with the phrase 'you'll catch your death' and the >similar. Often these are said to someone who is about to go outside with, [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >outside in cold weather with wet hair means that your immune system >suffers and you become more likely to catch a virus? A "cold" has been called a "cold" for probably many centuries based upon the belief that cold weather or cold exposure caused them. This was before anyone knew anything about viruses. It seemed intuitive, of course, because of the natural seasonality of many cold viruses, many being more prevalent in the fall and winter, that coldness causes the symptoms.
But no one really understands why or how viruses have attained seasonal patterns. We do know, however, that it isn't as simple as exposure to cold weather making one more susceptible to a cold virus.
The myth continues, thought, as demonstrated by some of the responses to your question in this thread, which use a classic form of fallacious thinking in which one modifies or even invents "facts" in order to continue supporting a theory that is eroding. In this case, the theory is that cold weather causes colds. When faced with the fact that viruses actually cause colds, instead of rejecting then the idea that the weather does it, some in this thread assert that cold weather must somehow "weaken" the "immune system", thus making one more susceptible to colds.
This is similar to the flat earthers from a few centuries ago, when asked why ships disappear over the horizon, proclaiming that light waves must bend downwards just a little bit so that, when objects are viewed from a great distance over the ocean, the light from the boats hits the water before it reaches your eyes!
PF
Anonymous - 30 Jun 2005 08:41 GMT > Hi, > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > jacket. Recently a nurse told me it is a bad idea to wash your hair with > cold water as you can catch a cold (I was highly sceptical). < snipped >
When asked for examples of health beliefs that they had acquired during their upbringing nursing students at a UK university gave these for the common cold:
Don't go to bed with your hair wet or you will get pneumonia Keep your feet warm - this stops colds and chills Feed a cold and starve a fever
Other beliefs not cold related were:
An apple a day keeps the doctor away Eat crusts on bread - it makes your hair curly Sitting on a cold surface gives you haemorrhoids Eating raw jelly makes your nails strong If you suffer heartburn in pregnancy your baby will have lots of hair Masturbation makes you blind/mad Cheese gives you nightmares (avoid at bedtime) Avoid sexual intercourse during pregnancy - it may damage the baby's head During pregnancy, boys are carried at the back and girls are carried at the front Avoid swimming/sexual intercourse/washing your hair while you are menstruating When a person has shingles (herpes zoster), if the lines meet in the middle they may die Colicky babies should be given treacle - it settles the stomach Fresh air for babies strengthens the lungs Bananas are good for digestion Bananas and hot mild are very good for insomnia Drink Guinness when you are pregnant - it is rich in iron Eating lots of fish makes you intelligent (good brain food) Garlic thins the blood
Ways to induce labour in pregnancy: drink castor oil; sexual intercourse; an enema; a hot curry; walk with one foot on the pavement and one foot in the road; a bumpy car drive.
Source; Holland, K and Hogg, C (20010 Cultural awareness in nursing and health care. London: Arnold.
 Signature Anonymous ----------------------------------------------------- Work harder. Millions on benefits are relying on you! -----------------------------------------------------
Anonymous - 30 Jun 2005 10:08 GMT Couple of typeos:
Bananas and hot MILK are very good for insomnia
Source: Holland, K and Hogg, C (2001) Cultural awareness in nursing and health care. London: Arnold.
I am surprised the students didn't mention that one shouldn't mix red and white flowers in the same vase (always results in a patient dying) and that deaths come in threes.
 Signature Anonymous ----------------------------------------------------- Work harder. Millions on benefits are relying on you! -----------------------------------------------------
|
|
|