Study Links Cancer Cases In Sweden to Chernobyl
By Mattias Karen
Associated Press
Sunday, November 21, 2004; Page A26
STOCKHOLM, Nov. 20 -- More than 800 people in northern Sweden may have
cancer as a result of the fallout that spewed over the region after the
Chernobyl nuclear accident in 1986, according to a new study by Swedish
scientists.
The figure is significantly higher than any previous estimate, and the study
drew immediate fire from critics who said they doubted the accuracy of the
results.
The radiation was released on April 26, 1986, when reactor No. 4 at the
Chernobyl nuclear plant exploded and caught fire, contaminating an area
roughly half the size of Colorado. The accident forced the resettlement of
hundreds of thousands of people and ruined some of Europe's most fertile
farmland.
The study monitored cancer cases among the more than 1.1 million people in
the northern parts of Sweden who were exposed to radioactive fallout.
Researchers found that the cancer risk increased in areas with higher levels
of fallout, which was spread by winds.
Of the 22,400 cancer cases among the group, 849 can be statistically
attributed to Chernobyl, said Martin Tondel, a researcher at Linkoeping
University who headed the study. The findings were first published in this
month's issue of the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, a science
magazine.
Leif Moberg, a radiation expert with the Swedish Radiation Protection
Authority, questioned the findings. "The radiation dosage that we in Sweden
got after the accident was too low to produce this many cancer cases,"
Moberg said, adding that it was probably too early to see any definite
results of Chernobyl. "Most cancer cases don't develop until 20, 30 or 50
years later," he said.
Tondel said that although the increase in cases cannot directly be
attributed to Chernobyl, he could not see any other explanation. "We've
tried our best to explain it in other ways, but we can't," he said.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A827-2004Nov20.html
Thomas Palm - 21 Nov 2004 15:30 GMT
> STOCKHOLM, Nov. 20 -- More than 800 people in northern Sweden may have
> cancer as a result of the fallout that spewed over the region after
> the Chernobyl nuclear accident in 1986, according to a new study by
> Swedish scientists.
Here is a link to the study itself:
http://wpy.waymaker.net/wpyfs/00/04/EA/FE/wkr0003.pdf
> The figure is significantly higher than any previous estimate, and the
> study drew immediate fire from critics who said they doubted the
> accuracy of the results.
The result is strange. Not only did it affect more people than expected,
but tumours came far too early and affects all types of cancer equally
much, which radiation normally doesn't.
> Tondel said that although the increase in cases cannot directly be
> attributed to Chernobyl, he could not see any other explanation.
> "We've tried our best to explain it in other ways, but we can't," he
> said.
We'll see if someone else can find another explanation. No doubt the
article will be scrutinized carefully.