Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Lupus / January 2007
Another Sad Story
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Jason Johnson - 06 Jan 2007 18:26 GMT As I stated in former posts, I have a neighbor that is my best friend. She has Lupus and a major eating disorder. Her weight is 250 to 300 pounds. She takes about 7 to 9 types of medications each day.
This happened yesterday:
Sarah does not take any vitamins or minerals since she says that vitamins and minerals capsules or pills upset her stomach.
She seems to think that Coca Cola is the best treatment for an upset stomach. Therefore, she drinks about 3 to 5 cokes per day.
Yesterday, I purchased a bottle of "Propel Fitness Water" for her. It contains Calcium, Niacin, B6, B12 and Pantothenic Acid. It only has 15 mg of sodium. The water is flavored to make it taste better.
She gave it back to me and stated, "I don't like the taste of flavored water". I told her that the vitamins should help her and since they were mixed in the water that they should not cause her to have an upset stomach. She still refused to accept it.
Sarah must not realize that Coca Cola is flavored water and it contains huge amounts of acid and harmful chemicals. She does not seem to realize that the acid in coke will NOT cure an upset stomach. In fact, coke can cause someone that already has high acid levels to have an upset stomach.
"Beem me up Scotty, there is no intelligent life down here."
Have a Happy New Year, Jason
J - 06 Jan 2007 20:30 GMT > As I stated in former posts, I have a neighbor that is my best friend. > She has Lupus and a major eating disorder. Her weight is 250 to 300 pounds. > She takes about 7 to 9 types of medications each day. > > This happened yesterday: Jason, I have a suggestion for you. Accept your friend the way she is or move on and find a new friend. You'll be doing her, you and this newsgroup a favor. J
ChelleSmiles - 06 Jan 2007 22:06 GMT > Jason, > I have a suggestion for you. > Accept your friend the way she is or move on and find a new friend. > You'll be doing her, you and this newsgroup a favor. > J Woah, now. #1, I do agree with accepting your friends the way they are, but #2, that's what this group is here for, and I know that Jason Johnson has shown nothing but care and concern. If anyone feels that helping out with and listening to other people's cares and concerns is beneath them or an imposition, maybe a support group board isn' t the place for them "J". One on one counseling may be more beneficial to people who aren't interested in the concerns of others.
As for me, I am appreciative of the support, advice, and laughs I have gotten here, and Jason, your posts are welcome.
Jason, one thing I would say, is that with all the changes Lupus has made in my life, if someone kept telling me to stop drinking or eating something I love, I would get really frustrated. Our choices are our own, and while you are well-intentioned, maybe you're pushing a little hard on this one. I personally take vitamins, but there are other ways to get vitamins, such as eating vitamin fortified cereals. I don't think Coke is either ther best or worst thing your friend could be doing. If anyone could get her to stop drinking 5 Cokes a Day, it might be her doctor, if she has the threat of becoming diabetic, but even then some people just don't want to give up things they love.
Let this one go. Get her some tasty cereal bars if you must, but please don't be hurt if she doesn't love the idea. I know I am a grown woman, and I sometimes find it insulting and condescending that other people seem to think they need to tell me what I should and shouldn't eat. I'm not a baby or a child. I'm just sick.
So anyway, I appreciate that you have some concern for your friend, but you probably should give her some more space in the decision-making area. I think she will appreciate it and may become more open to the idea of trying other vitamin-fortified foods if they're not being pushed on her.
I hope this helps.
Michelle
Jason Johnson - 07 Jan 2007 00:08 GMT J wrote:
> Jason, > I have a suggestion for you. > Accept your friend the way she is or move on and find a new friend. > You'll be doing her, you and this newsgroup a favor. > J Woah, now. #1, I do agree with accepting your friends the way they are, but #2, that's what this group is here for, and I know that Jason Johnson has shown nothing but care and concern. If anyone feels that helping out with and listening to other people's cares and concerns is beneath them or an imposition, maybe a support group board isn' t the place for them "J". One on one counseling may be more beneficial to people who aren't interested in the concerns of others. As for me, I am appreciative of the support, advice, and laughs I have gotten here, and Jason, your posts are welcome. Jason, one thing I would say, is that with all the changes Lupus has made in my life, if someone kept telling me to stop drinking or eating something I love, I would get really frustrated. Our choices are our own, and while you are well-intentioned, maybe you're pushing a little hard on this one. I personally take vitamins, but there are other ways to get vitamins, such as eating vitamin fortified cereals. I don't think Coke is either ther best or worst thing your friend could be doing. If anyone could get her to stop drinking 5 Cokes a Day, it might be her doctor, if she has the threat of becoming diabetic, but even then some people just don't want to give up things they love. Let this one go. Get her some tasty cereal bars if you must, but please don't be hurt if she doesn't love the idea. I know I am a grown woman, and I sometimes find it insulting and condescending that other people seem to think they need to tell me what I should and shouldn't eat. I'm not a baby or a child. I'm just sick. So anyway, I appreciate that you have some concern for your friend, but you probably should give her some more space in the decision-making area. I think she will appreciate it and may become more open to the idea of trying other vitamin-fortified foods if they're not being pushed on her. I hope this helps. Michelle
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Michelle, Thanks for your excellent post. I will take your advice. I hope that you and everyone else in this newsgroup has a happy New Year. Jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
gazorpf@yahoo.com - 07 Jan 2007 13:13 GMT If she has been on prednisone for a long time, at relatively high doses, it could be responsible for part of her weight.
Coke has been used to quiet upset stomachs for a long time.
She is most likely depressed.
She probably knows what she is doing is not good for her.
Many people, with good hearts and good intentions, try to "fix" us lupus patients. I happen to be just the right weight, take supplements, am a vegetarian, and exercise regularly despite the lupus. However, when someone tells me what I "should" do to get better I still get very angry. What you intend and what she hears may be two very different things. I would be willing to bet that she hears your good intentions as a judgement against her and that only makes her feel worse.
Try some really active listening. You might be surprised at what you hear.
Linda
> As I stated in former posts, I have a neighbor that is my best friend. > She has Lupus and a major eating disorder. Her weight is 250 to 300 pounds. [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > Have a Happy New Year, > Jason kodama - 07 Jan 2007 18:16 GMT Hi Jason,
I have had lupus for years and like your friend there, I drink diet coke to help my stomach feel better. It's not from the Lupus it's from all the meds, they ruin your stomach. I think your friend knows what works for her. Water flavored or not does not settle an upset stomach. I personally think it has something to do with the carbonation, all I know is that it works. I've tried water and it doesn't work. And like your friend I have friends who think I shouldn't drink diet coke. However, I don't drink alcohol, I don't smoke, I exercise when I am able, wear a seatbelt, etc. So I hardly see drinking coke as a terrible thing. I think everyone is entitled to one bad habit, don't you? ; ) I guess what I'm trying to say is that drinking coke is probably the least of your friends medical problems right now. And as the other person suggested perhaps trying to find vitamin enriched food she would like would be a better approach.
Good luck and keep being a great friend to her, I'm sure she really needs and appreciates your support.
Jeanne
Jason Johnson - 07 Jan 2007 21:57 GMT Hi Jason, I have had lupus for years and like your friend there, I drink diet coke to help my stomach feel better. It's not from the Lupus it's from all the meds, they ruin your stomach. I think your friend knows what works for her. Water flavored or not does not settle an upset stomach. I personally think it has something to do with the carbonation, all I know is that it works. I've tried water and it doesn't work. And like your friend I have friends who think I shouldn't drink diet coke. However, I don't drink alcohol, I don't smoke, I exercise when I am able, wear a seatbelt, etc. So I hardly see drinking coke as a terrible thing. I think everyone is entitled to one bad habit, don't you? ; ) I guess what I'm trying to say is that drinking coke is probably the least of your friends medical problems right now. And as the other person suggested perhaps trying to find vitamin enriched food she would like would be a better approach. Good luck and keep being a great friend to her, I'm sure she really needs and appreciates your support. Jeanne
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Jeanne, Thanks for the kind words. I did not realize that Coke was a treatment option for an upset stomach until today. Thanks for the education. It must be because of the carbonation. I will suggest the vitamin enriched foods to her the next time that I take her to the grocery store. She is not able to drive due to the pain related meds. I admire you for performing such a great job is dealing with Lupus. Sarah is depending on the meds to treat her problem and is NOT trying any diet programs or exercise programs at this point in time. I believe she has a really bad case of depression which is the reason she is does not care about diet and exercise as treatment options. Another neighbor gave her info. about a local Lupus Support Group and Sarah told me that she is not planning to attend any of the meetings. I gave her a book related to Lupus but she has not read it. I have decided to no longer even mention diet or exercise in future conversations with her. However, I will always be her best friend. Jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Jason Johnson - 07 Jan 2007 21:46 GMT If she has been on prednisone for a long time, at relatively high doses, it could be responsible for part of her weight. Coke has been used to quiet upset stomachs for a long time. She is most likely depressed. She probably knows what she is doing is not good for her. Many people, with good hearts and good intentions, try to "fix" us lupus patients. I happen to be just the right weight, take supplements, am a vegetarian, and exercise regularly despite the lupus. However, when someone tells me what I "should" do to get better I still get very angry. What you intend and what she hears may be two very different things. I would be willing to bet that she hears your good intentions as a judgement against her and that only makes her feel worse. Try some really active listening. You might be surprised at what you hear. Linda
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Linda, Thanks for your advice. I will take your advice and will no longer give her advice related to what she eats or drinks. I did not know that Coca Cola was a treatment option for an upset stomach. I have problems with high acid levels so know that Coca Cola would not be a treatment option for me since Coke would make my acid problems much worse. However, it might be a treatment option for Sarah and other people that do not have acid related problems. I will try some active listening. I should note that Sarah gives me advice on a regular basis related to eating the wrong types of foods. What should I tell her the next time that she gives me advice related to my diet? Thanks for your kind words, Have a Happy New Year, jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
gazorpf@yahoo.com - 08 Jan 2007 11:21 GMT The next time she criticizes what you eat try this. Tell her she is right. Talk about how hard it is to always make the right food choices. In this way, you are affirming her struggle and forming a bond. After a little while get a bright idea. "Hey, why don't we work on this together? Maybe if we are nutrition buddies we will both be able to do it." From there, and maybe not that day, but over the course of time, start to talk about nutrition. "Ooo look at this wonderful recipe I found. It sounds good and is super healthy. Let's make it together!" Weight Watchers has recipes on line at www.weigthwatchers.com. You do not have to subscribe to access many of them. Vegeterian Times emails a daily recipe, subscribe at www.vegetariantimes.com. Suggest you both keep food journals and compare. You can nicely critique one another's journal at the end of the week.
One of the nasty things that lupus does is make us feel like we have lost control in our lives. At her weight, she probably feels that the weight is so bad it, too, is beyond her control. As the two of you work together, she will begin to see that she DOES have some control in her life.
Remember, if she tries ALL OR NOTHING, for her nutrition plan, she will fail once and say, "What's the use? I am a failure. I just can't do it." Instead, help her (and you) build a plan that allows special treats but in controlled portions and not too often.
Please note that Ensure and Boost, although they do have vitamins are relatively high in calories. You and your friend can begin reading the nutrition info on the back of packages. As a lifetime Weight Watchers member for some 35 years, I still read labels. I look for the lowest fat and highest fiber content in foods. If I have a craving for cheescake, I go ahead and have a slice. I compensate by reducing points later in the week. Points are calculated on the basis of calories per serving, grams of fat and grams of fiber. They have a little easy to use slide rule.
Good luck and do keep us posted!
Linda
> If she has been on prednisone for a long time, at relatively high > doses, it could be responsible for part of her weight. [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > jason > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Jason Johnson - 09 Jan 2007 04:16 GMT The next time she criticizes what you eat try this. Tell her she is right. Talk about how hard it is to always make the right food choices. In this way, you are affirming her struggle and forming a bond. After a little while get a bright idea. "Hey, why don't we work on this together? Maybe if we are nutrition buddies we will both be able to do it." From there, and maybe not that day, but over the course of time, start to talk about nutrition. "Ooo look at this wonderful recipe I found. It sounds good and is super healthy. Let's make it together!" Weight Watchers has recipes on line at www.weigthwatchers.com. You do not have to subscribe to access many of them. Vegeterian Times emails a daily recipe, subscribe at www.vegetariantimes.com. Suggest you both keep food journals and compare. You can nicely critique one another's journal at the end of the week. One of the nasty things that lupus does is make us feel like we have lost control in our lives. At her weight, she probably feels that the weight is so bad it, too, is beyond her control. As the two of you work together, she will begin to see that she DOES have some control in her life. Remember, if she tries ALL OR NOTHING, for her nutrition plan, she will fail once and say, "What's the use? I am a failure. I just can't do it." Instead, help her (and you) build a plan that allows special treats but in controlled portions and not too often. Please note that Ensure and Boost, although they do have vitamins are relatively high in calories. You and your friend can begin reading the nutrition info on the back of packages. As a lifetime Weight Watchers member for some 35 years, I still read labels. I look for the lowest fat and highest fiber content in foods. If I have a craving for cheescake, I go ahead and have a slice. I compensate by reducing points later in the week. Points are calculated on the basis of calories per serving, grams of fat and grams of fiber. They have a little easy to use slide rule. Good luck and do keep us posted! Linda Jason Johnson wrote:
> In article <1168175633.414678.177930@i15g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>, > "gazorpf@yahoo.com" <gazorpf@yahoo.com> wrote: [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] > > Linda
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Linda, Thanks for the excellent advice. Make sure you take protein supplements such as protein powder. I have read that many vegetarians do not get enough protein in thier diets. I am also a vegetarian but I cheat from time to time. I eat fish once a week. That probably means that I am not a true vegetarian. You seem to have control over your medical problems. Make sure you keep that control. I have weak kidneys so have to be very careful related to the foods that I eat and liquids that I drink.
Have a Happy New Year, Jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
SuperLupus@gmail.com - 08 Jan 2007 02:04 GMT Oi! I've been agonizing over your post for a while here. I completely understand both sides. I can see you really have love and concern for her. Sometimes trying to "help" people comes off as trying to "fix" people. And as miserable as she can feel at times she really is perfect as is.
Vitamins/minerals seem fairly innocuous, but they really can upset an already sensitive stomach. Carbonated beverages actually do soothe, she's not yanking your chain there. but at 150 cal/can it isn't the best option. I'd very much recommend not suggesting diet products. The artificial sweetners tend to be harsh on kidneys... a major concern for lupies. Sounds like she's soothing her upset stomach and her upset emotions with consumption (like alot of people do). I know it's another med, but there are anti nausia things by RX that can help.
About vitamins, there really are alot of options. Ensure/Boost those types of products are packed with nutrition. And come flavored like chocolate shakes or strawberry... there are other liquid forms of multivits too. Much easier on a stomach than trying to break down a pill. And doesn't have to be presented as an alternative, but rather an addition. Who knows...
Just make sure you let her know that you love her as she is. If she wants to try something different you'll be there. Your concern for her is noticed and appreciated. This is the perfect place for you to come and get support with any Lupus questions.
> As I stated in former posts, I have a neighbor that is my best friend. > She has Lupus and a major eating disorder. Her weight is 250 to 300 pounds. [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > Have a Happy New Year, > Jason Jason Johnson - 08 Jan 2007 06:20 GMT Oi! I've been agonizing over your post for a while here. I completely understand both sides. I can see you really have love and concern for her. Sometimes trying to "help" people comes off as trying to "fix" people. And as miserable as she can feel at times she really is perfect as is. Vitamins/minerals seem fairly innocuous, but they really can upset an already sensitive stomach. Carbonated beverages actually do soothe, she's not yanking your chain there. but at 150 cal/can it isn't the best option. I'd very much recommend not suggesting diet products. The artificial sweetners tend to be harsh on kidneys... a major concern for lupies. Sounds like she's soothing her upset stomach and her upset emotions with consumption (like alot of people do). I know it's another med, but there are anti nausia things by RX that can help. About vitamins, there really are alot of options. Ensure/Boost those types of products are packed with nutrition. And come flavored like chocolate shakes or strawberry... there are other liquid forms of multivits too. Much easier on a stomach than trying to break down a pill. And doesn't have to be presented as an alternative, but rather an addition. Who knows... Just make sure you let her know that you love her as she is. If she wants to try something different you'll be there. Your concern for her is noticed and appreciated. This is the perfect place for you to come and get support with any Lupus questions.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
S.L., Thanks for your advice. I have decided to not give her any advice related to her diet. However, the next time that I take her to the grocery store, I'll make sure I ask her if she wants to try Ensure or Boost. If she says, "NO", I will not start an argument or get upset. She already knows that I love her but I will remind her more often. You are a wonderful person. Jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Beverley - 09 Jan 2007 05:01 GMT Cola syrup was used for years to settle a tummy - it's not the same a Coca-Cola
Flavored waters are also sweetened with Splenda, etc. This stuff virtually turns into a chlorine-like substance in our systems, for many folks that is pure poison.
Just remember you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink! Bev
> As I stated in former posts, I have a neighbor that is my best friend. > She has Lupus and a major eating disorder. Her weight is 250 to 300 pounds. [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > Have a Happy New Year, > Jason Jason Johnson - 09 Jan 2007 20:10 GMT Cola syrup was used for years to settle a tummy - it's not the same a Coca-Cola Flavored waters are also sweetened with Splenda, etc. This stuff virtually turns into a chlorine-like substance in our systems, for many folks that is pure poison. Just remember you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink! Bev ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Beverley, Thanks for your post. I was referring to Coca-Cola instead of Cola syrup. Sarah drinks a Coca Cola (not diet Coke) whenever she gets an upset stomach which is very often since she eats lots of high acid foods.
The carbonation in Coca Cola may be an excellent short term solution to an upset stomach but anyone that has done research on pH levels or acid levels knows that Coca-Cola contains high levels of acid.
I do not drink any Cola drinks or liquids that contain Spenda. That could be one of the reasons that I now have kidney problems. When I was much younger, I drunk lots of Diet Cokes and Diet Doctor Peppers. Some of the medications such as statins and Avapro also (in my opinion) damaged my kidneys. I no longer take any medications and control my BP and chol. levels by my diet and exercise program. Jason ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
SuperLupus@gmail.com - 12 Jan 2007 22:44 GMT Fun little thing about coca cola... some state troopers carry 2liters in their trunks. In case of an accident that leaves blood on the highway. Pour it right over. The acid neutralizes any harmful bio material and the sugars that remain on the highway attract microbes to come an clean up more later. neato- and i still occasionally do enjoy a coke.
> Cola syrup was used for years to settle a tummy - it's not the same a > Coca-Cola [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > Jason > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
|
|
|