Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Lupus / September 2005
Newbie question re: vertigo
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Alicia - 19 Sep 2005 15:20 GMT Dear All--
I've been lurking for a while, but have finally decided to come out in the open. I've had systemic lupus since I was 17 (33 years), way back when nobody knew what lupus was. In 1983, I was also diagnosed with antiphospholipid antibody syndrome (Hughes) after a long series of deep vein thromboses, miscarriages, leg ulcerations, and other circulatory miseries, and I have to take Coumadin for life. After years of alternating between non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, Prednisone, and Plaquenil, I finally settled into a fairly stable lupus remission in 2002 on 400 mg. daily of Plaquenil.
Then in April of this year, I developed a very mysterious case of vertigo which has yet to let up. Extensive testing (auditory, balance, autoimmune, cerebral) has yielded negative or normal results in most cases, and the doctors (neurologist, rheumatologist, neurotologist, physiatrist) have not been able to come up with a clear cause for the vertigo or a cure. The two prevailing theories regarding my case are that: 1) it's autoimmune vertigo (although it did not respond to Prednisone) or 2) it's due to vestibular neuritis caused by a virus. At first, I partially controlled the spinning, tilting, loss of balance, and nausea with Antivert, but now the doctors are asking me to stop using it and work on developing cerebral compensation via Vestibular Rehabilitation Therapy.
I'd like to know if anyone else in this group has suffered from similar symptoms or has any recommendations to make regarding possible causes and/or treatment of this vertigo. Any input would be greatly appreciated, since I'm really tired of lurching around like a drunken sailor.
Alicia
George Parton - 19 Sep 2005 19:48 GMT Dear Alicia, I was afflicted with the vertigo early on in my Lupus experience. After trying the medical solutions I was referred by my doctor directly to Doctor William H. Philpott MD in Oklahoma. My doctor sent my records to him, he prescribed magnetic field therapy and provided the magnets and apparatus needed to use them. It worked! It worked very quickly! Compared to the prospect of taking the mind numbing dope I had been prescribed for up to a year it was a Godsend! Dr. Philpott is considered to be the ultimate magnetic field guru but I didn't know that at the time. I would suggest caution in purchasing magnets from other than a quality source as some of the fad driven knock-offs are a joke. The magnets I have are 1/2 inch thick and about 2 1/2 inches in diameter and are worn over the temple area while sleeping. Some of the knock-offs were about the size of a dime. I think the following is his correct address: Philpott, William H 17171 SE 29th St., Choctaw, OK 73020-6453 (405) 390-4898
I hope this will be of help to you, it was for me.
George Parton
> Dear All-- > [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Alicia janersagain - 19 Sep 2005 20:08 GMT I am sure they ruled out Menier's (spelling disease) but the only other thing is "what medications are you on.
I was on a drug called zelnorm for IBS constipation. I was on it for 6 months and had weird experiences with vertigo. Drove me crazy. Then all of a sudden I got some medical update on my nursing folder. Well what do you know, zelnorm can and does cause extreme vertigo in some people. Then came the warning to GI docs to make sure they know this when prescribing.
I stopped it and bingo..gone.
I surely hope your case is as simple as this one. I feel badly for you. Wish there was more to tell you on this one.
janers
Alicia - 20 Sep 2005 14:00 GMT Dear George, Janers, and IronJustice-- Thanks for your rapid responses. George, I will try out the magnet therapy, although I must admit I don't have much faith in the idea. Janers, Meniers was ruled out early on, since I have no tinnitus and no hearing loss. As for medications, I am on Plaquenil 400 mg, which can cause dizziness, but I suspended Plaquenil for two weeks to test if that was the cause, and there was no change. I didn't think there would be since I've been on Plaquenil since 2001 with no ill effects. My other medications at this point are Prednisone (now at 5 mg. and tapering off). This was started AFTER the vertigo began in the hopes that the vertigo was autoimmune in nature. My last medication is Coumadin (10 mg.) which is necessary to control my antiphospholipid antibodies syndrome. It is not associated with vertigo. As for the possibility of the vertigo being due to Polycythemia / erythrocytosis, IronJustice, my most recent blood tests indicate that my hematocrit and red blood count are normal, so that's not the problem. If anyone else has any suggestions, I'd love to hear them. Again, thanks to all who responded. This group is great! Alicia
== 2 of 4 == Date: Mon 19 Sep 2005 11:50 From: George Parton
Dear Alicia, I was afflicted with the vertigo early on in my Lupus experience. After trying the medical solutions I was referred by my doctor directly to Doctor William H. Philpott MD in Oklahoma. My doctor sent my records to him, he prescribed magnetic field therapy and provided the magnets and apparatus needed to use them. It worked! It worked very quickly! Compared to the prospect of taking the mind numbing dope I had been prescribed for up to a year it was a Godsend! Dr. Philpott is considered to be the ultimate magnetic field guru but I didn't know that at the time. I would suggest caution in purchasing magnets from other than a quality source as some of the fad driven knock-offs are a joke. The magnets I have are 1/2 inch thick and about 2 1/2 inches in diameter and are worn over the temple area while sleeping. Some of the knock-offs were about the size of a dime.
I think the following is his correct address: Philpott, William H 17171 SE 29th St., Choctaw, OK 73020-6453 (405) 390-4898
I hope this will be of help to you, it was for me.
George Parton
Alicia wrote:
> Dear All-- > [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Alicia == 3 of 4 == Date: Mon 19 Sep 2005 15:08 From: "janersagain"
I am sure they ruled out Menier's (spelling disease) but the only other thing is "what medications are you on.
I was on a drug called zelnorm for IBS constipation. I was on it for 6 months and had weird experiences with vertigo. Drove me crazy. Then all of a sudden I got some medical update on my nursing folder. Well what do you know, zelnorm can and does cause extreme vertigo in some people. Then came the warning to GI docs to make sure they know this when prescribing.
I stopped it and bingo..gone.
I surely hope your case is as simple as this one. I feel badly for you. Wish there was more to tell you on this one.
janers
== 4 of 4 == Date: Mon 19 Sep 2005 19:36 From: "ironjustice@aol.com"
All of your above problems INCLUDING vertigo have been shown to be linked to excessive oxidation in the body ..
Polycythemia / erythrocytosis .. too many red blood cells .. leads to MANY problems .. and erythrocytosis / polycythemia leads to increased iron levels in the body and increased iron levels lead to excessive oxidation / rust ..
Oxidation / rust leads to DECREASED anti-oxidants in the body.
Coincidentally Dr. Shute over fifty years ago claimed vitamin E / tocopherol to be a CURE for spontaneous abortion / miscarriage. -----------------------------------------
Symptoms caused by the elevated hematocrit are present initially in 30 to 50% of patients and may cause the patient to seek medical attention for symptoms such as plethora (too much blood), headache, dizziness, visual disturbances, inability to concentrate and parethesis (numbness). Related findings at diagnosis can include hypertension, a high cardiac output state and evidence of vascular status. Significant arterial or venous thrombosis occurs in one third to one half of uncontrolled cases, and these events may precede the diagnosis (heart attack, stroke, pulmonary embolism, portal vein clots (veins leading to liver), etc.
There are a number of other metabolic abnormalities which occur in MPD patients, including patients with PV. Briefly, MPD patients, including PV patients may exhibit high uric acid levels (hyperuricemia, 50%) which can lead to joint pain and gout, low cholesterol levels (hypocholesterolemia), high histamine levels (hyperhistaminea) and histaminuria occur in two thirds of MPD patients which can produce puritus (itching), heart burn, acid eructation, peptic ulcer, small bowel hyper motility, flushing and angioneurotic edema. Hypermetabolism is commonly manifested as weakness and fatigue that occur in MPD patients not experiencing anemia.
Phlebotomy has been one of the most common initial therapies for many polycythemic patients. There has been a lot of experience with it. The purpose of phlebotomy is to reduce the red blood cell mass (RBC mass)-that is, the total number of circulating red blood cells, and to do it fairly quickly, at least in the beginning when the hematocrit (Hct) is high.
the rest of the story is at
http://www.acor.org/mpd/PVFAQ.html#1
Who loves ya. Tom
George Parton - 20 Sep 2005 19:53 GMT Dear Alicia, I am not surprised that you do not have any faith in the magnetic therapy. Neither did I when it was prescribed by not one but two medical doctors. For me it worked and made a believer out of me. I only suggest that you investigate the possibility. YMMV Blessings and best wishes, George Parton
> Dear George, Janers, and IronJustice-- > Thanks for your rapid responses. George, I will try out the magnet [quoted text clipped - 173 lines] > Who loves ya. > Tom ironjustice@aol.com - 20 Sep 2005 03:36 GMT All of your above problems INCLUDING vertigo have been shown to be linked to excessive oxidation in the body ..
Polycythemia / erythrocytosis .. too many red blood cells .. leads to MANY problems .. and erythrocytosis / polycythemia leads to increased iron levels in the body and increased iron levels lead to excessive oxidation / rust ..
Oxidation / rust leads to DECREASED anti-oxidants in the body.
Coincidentally Dr. Shute over fifty years ago claimed vitamin E / tocopherol to be a CURE for spontaneous abortion / miscarriage. -----------------------------------------
Symptoms caused by the elevated hematocrit are present initially in 30 to 50% of patients and may cause the patient to seek medical attention for symptoms such as plethora (too much blood), headache, dizziness, visual disturbances, inability to concentrate and parethesis (numbness). Related findings at diagnosis can include hypertension, a high cardiac output state and evidence of vascular status. Significant arterial or venous thrombosis occurs in one third to one half of uncontrolled cases, and these events may precede the diagnosis (heart attack, stroke, pulmonary embolism, portal vein clots (veins leading to liver), etc.
There are a number of other metabolic abnormalities which occur in MPD patients, including patients with PV. Briefly, MPD patients, including PV patients may exhibit high uric acid levels (hyperuricemia, 50%) which can lead to joint pain and gout, low cholesterol levels (hypocholesterolemia), high histamine levels (hyperhistaminea) and histaminuria occur in two thirds of MPD patients which can produce puritus (itching), heart burn, acid eructation, peptic ulcer, small bowel hyper motility, flushing and angioneurotic edema. Hypermetabolism is commonly manifested as weakness and fatigue that occur in MPD patients not experiencing anemia.
Phlebotomy has been one of the most common initial therapies for many polycythemic patients. There has been a lot of experience with it. The purpose of phlebotomy is to reduce the red blood cell mass (RBC mass)-that is, the total number of circulating red blood cells, and to do it fairly quickly, at least in the beginning when the hematocrit (Hct) is high.
the rest of the story is at
http://www.acor.org/mpd/PVFAQ.html#1
Who loves ya. Tom
Jesus Was A Vegetarian! http://jesuswasavegetarian.7h.com
Man Is A Herbivore! http://pages.ivillage.com/ironjustice/manisaherbivore
DEAD PEOPLE WALKING http://pages.ivillage.com/ironjustice/deadpeoplewalking
REP - 20 Sep 2005 11:12 GMT > Then in April of this year, I developed a very mysterious case of > vertigo which has yet to let up. Extensive testing (auditory, balance, > autoimmune, cerebral) has yielded negative or normal results in most > cases, and the doctors (neurologist, rheumatologist, neurotologist, > physiatrist) have not been able to come up with a clear cause for the > vertigo or a cure. I don't have SLE; that's finally been ruled out but I have many of the same symptoms/clinical signs, incuding weird connective tissue. Anyway, keep this in mind - I don't have Lupus! I have about a thousand other things wrong with me, and one of them is recurring months' long bouts of vertigo (dizziness, "sinking feeling,' nausea, anorexia and fainting). I haven't had quite the extensive work-up you have (I don't take steroids; perhaps that's why) but have been given a tentative dx of Meniere's, which really has no signs that shows up on tests. This dx is a little wacky because Meniere's is not supposed to last for a months without break, but hell, it's a dx of something Not Fatal for a change.
Even if your ultimate dx is something else, you might want to ask your doc about Scop-Derm patches, which are worn behind the ear for three days and then changed. They are enormously helpful to me when I'm having a spell of whatever the hell it is.
 Signature "Did Father shoot him? I will eat Grandfather for dinner." - Helen Keller, on learning of the death of her grandfather
Ruth Tay - 20 Sep 2005 15:49 GMT HI Alicia Welcome With Lupus you get all sorts of extra problems such as vertigo. When I had it the treatment was the same as you have are using. One doctor thought it might be low thyroid. Have you been put on a restricted salt regime? Another doctor suggested power walks which was a trial but managed with two canes and always looking straight ahead. Have had lupus for 21 years. Mine went after my heart, esophagus and joints [had to have a shoulder replacement]. Thank heaven for the times in between flares! Wishing you the best ruth
> Dear All-- > [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Alicia Alicia - 23 Sep 2005 14:51 GMT Dear REB and Ruth:
Thanks for your comments and suggestions.
Scopolamine is fine for acute episodes (I used to use the patches for airplane and boat rides), but long-term it interferes with the brain's ability to compensate for the vertigo, so my doctors advise against using it unless absolutely necessary. Ditto for mezclizine (Antivert, Dramamine, or Bonine).
Early I on checked my thyroid, and it's normal. I've been on a low salt diet with high water intake since early August. I'm also using a pedometer and trying to walk at least 3,500 steps (1 mile) a day.
I started vestibular rehabilitation therapy last week and am already seeing some good results. Today I've actually had some short periods of clear headedness, and the exercises (focusing on an object while turning head rapidly from side to side and then up and down, bending down and then looking up, etc.) are becoming much easier to do without feeling nauseous. I feel hopeful that the VRT may be the solution. Of course, that still leaves me in the dark about causes.
Has anyone else had any experience with VRT?
Alicia
== 1 of 4 ==
Date: Tues 20 Sep 2005 10:12
From: REP
Even if your ultimate dx is something else, you might want to ask your
doc about Scop-Derm patches, which are worn behind the ear for three
days and then changed. They are enormously helpful to me when I'm having
a spell of whatever the hell it is.
== 3 of 4 ==
Date: Tues 20 Sep 2005 07:49
From: Ruth Tay
HI Alicia
Welcome With Lupus you get all sorts of extra problems such as
vertigo. When I had it the treatment was the same as you have are
using. One doctor thought it might be low thyroid. Have you been put
on a restricted salt regime? Another doctor suggested power walks which
was a trial but managed with two canes and always looking straight
ahead. Have had lupus for 21 years. Mine went after my heart, esophagus
and joints [had to have a shoulder replacement]. Thank heaven for
the times in between flares! Wishing you the best ruth
Herbwormwood - 22 Sep 2005 09:34 GMT X-No-Archive
Hi, Welcome to the group. I also have systemic Lupus (diagnosed 26 years ago) and antiphospholipid antibody syndrome (Hughes) which was diagnosed around 10 years ago after a series of CNS problems including vertigo. I am stabilised with the antiphospholipid antibody syndrome (Hughes) on warfarin and aspirin but I have residual balance problems de to damage to cerebellum. Ask your docs to rule this out for you as antiphospholipid antibody syndrome (Hughes) often affects the CNS. The other thing I had a couple of times was labrynthitis (not sure if spelled OK) but if your ENT check which came out clear it is probably not that. Please come back soon and let us know how you get on! Herb Tyneside, UK
Alicia - 23 Sep 2005 14:57 GMT Dear Herb--Yesterday I saw my neurotologist, and he basically has given up trying to find the cause of my problems. He told me to trust in the vestibular rehabilitation therapy and get on with my life. Needless to say, I am not satisfied with this conclusion. I want to know if there's more I should be doing to prevent the vertigo from hitting me again and again.
How would I go about checking whether it's the antiphospholipid syndrome at work? Is there a test I should have? My rheumatologist considers that all we can do is keep me adequately anti-coagulated. Is there some other treatment I should consider?
Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Alicia
Herbwormwood - 26 Sep 2005 14:57 GMT X-No-Archive
Hi, Unfortunately antiphospholipid syndrome can cause problems even when you are on anti coagulants, your anti coagulation needs to be at the right level, mine was upped to 3- 4.5 as I continued to have symptoms at 2-3. I am on a yahoo suppport group for antiphospholipid syndrome and some people there continue to have symptoms while heavily anti coagulated. I also take prescribed aspirin as an anti coagulant. I don't know of any test which checks whether antiphospholipid syndrome can cause your vertigo, but it did cause it with me. It was due to seizures. I went dizzy, the room would spin, I was trembling all over, pouring with sweat, very nauseous as if I was going to vomit and so weak I collapsed, sometimes I would get hallucinations of blinding lights obscuring my vision, or feeling of impending doom, tingling or numbness, this happened many times over a few years.Your neurologist should be able to advise on this issue and tests for it. I don't know if your vert igo is the same as my "seizures". Best wishes, Herb, UK http://members.lycos.co.uk/herbwormwood/
Alicia - 27 Sep 2005 14:25 GMT TOPIC: Newbie question re: vertigo http://groups.google.com/group/alt.support.lupus/browse_thread/thread/e6557d857d 403ae2 ============================================================================== Dear Herbwormwood--
Thanks for the response. A lot of what you said applies to me. I will consult my neurologist to see if she has any recommendations regarding the antiphospholipid syndrome. (I had only asked my rheumatologist, but the only thing he does is keep me at INR=3 at all times.) Maybe I'll contact Dr. Hughes in London and see what he has to say. I will also check out the antiphospholipid group on-line. Thanks again for the suggestions.
Alicia
== 1 of 1 == Date: Mon 26 Sep 2005 06:57 From: "Herbwormwood"
X-No-Archive
Hi, Unfortunately antiphospholipid syndrome can cause problems even when you are on anti coagulants, your anti coagulation needs to be at the right level, mine was upped to 3- 4.5 as I continued to have symptoms at 2-3. I am on a yahoo suppport group for antiphospholipid syndrome and some people there continue to have symptoms while heavily anti coagulated. I also take prescribed aspirin as an anti coagulant. I don't know of any test which checks whether antiphospholipid syndrome can cause your vertigo, but it did cause it with me. It was due to seizures. I went dizzy, the room would spin, I was trembling all over, pouring with sweat, very nauseous as if I was going to vomit and so weak I collapsed, sometimes I would get hallucinations of blinding lights obscuring my vision, or feeling of impending doom, tingling or numbness, this happened many times over a few years.Your neurologist should be able to advise on this issue and tests for it. I don't know if your vert igo is the same as my "seizures". Best wishes, Herb, UK http://members.lycos.co.uk/herbwormwood/
Andy - 27 Sep 2005 15:56 GMT [
> Maybe I'll >contact Dr. Hughes in London and see what he has to say. You need to know that he either just has retired, or very soon will be.
 Signature Andy Taylor [Chair, N E Lupus Group] See http://www.northeastlupus.org.uk for more!
Alicia - 29 Sep 2005 00:02 GMT Dear Andy--Thanks for telling me that. If I can't contact him, I'll contact one of his associates.
Alicia
BJ - 23 Sep 2005 15:27 GMT Hi Alicia, I suffer from that when I am in a major flare. Occasionally at other times too. It is never an ongoing problem like it is for you. That sure must be tough. I don't have any suggestions. I see that others had some ideas for you though. I really just wanted to welcome you. I am glad you found us. BJ-Sk. Canada
> Dear All-- > [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Alicia Alicia - 29 Sep 2005 00:06 GMT Dear BJ--Thanks for your support. Everybody's been really welcoming and helpful.
Alicia
> Hi Alicia, > I suffer from that when I am in a major flare. Occasionally at other times [quoted text clipped - 34 lines] > > > > Alicia Alicia - 29 Sep 2005 00:07 GMT Dear BJ--Thanks for your support. Everybody's been really welcoming and helpful.
Alicia
> Hi Alicia, > I suffer from that when I am in a major flare. Occasionally at other times > too. It is never an ongoing problem like it is for you. That sure must be > tough. I don't have any suggestions. I see that others had some ideas for > you though. I really just wanted to welcome you. I am glad you found us. > BJ-Sk. Canada
|
|
|