http://www.nature.com/nsu/020429/020429-13.html - snippets from an
interesting longer article.
The frequencies of chimaerism and mosaicism are unknown, but doctors
might benefit from a better understanding of both conditions. In recent
years, tantalizing hints have emerged that pockets of genetically
mismatched cells may contribute to conditions as common as infertility,
autism and Alzheimer's disease. "I think mosaicism has been neglected as
an underlying cause of disease," says Huntington Potter, who works on
the genetics of Alzheimer's at the University of South Florida in Tampa.
And if chimaeras and mosaics are more common than we realize, they will
complicate future efforts to tailor drug treatments to people's
individual genetic constitutions. Two genetically different tissues in
one body might produce an unpredictable response to a drug, speculates
Roland Wolf, who studies pharmacogenetics at the University of Dundee,
UK. "It's completely unknown," he says.
The twin within
Human chimaerism first came to light with the advent of blood typing -
some people, it emerged, have more than one blood group. Most are 'blood
chimaeras', non-identical twins who shared a blood supply in the womb.
Those who were not born a twin are thought to be pumping around the
remnants of a sibling that died early in gestation and was spontaneously
aborted. One British woman, for instance, was unaware that she once had
a twin until routine blood tests during her pregnancy in the early 1980s
revealed a population of chromosomally male blood cells2.
Twin embryos often share a blood supply in the placenta, allowing blood
stem cells to pass from one embryo and settle in the bone marrow of the
other, seeding a lasting source of blood. As a result, as many as 8% of
non-identical twin pairs have chimaeric blood3. And given that most
multiple conceptions that result in live births involve the loss of one
twin early in pregnancy4, there may also be significant numbers of blood
chimaeras among single births.
Even more people have 'microchimaerism', carrying smaller numbers of
foreign blood cells that may, for instance, have passed between mother
and fetus across the placenta, or persist from a blood transfusion. Some
researchers argue that the presence of foreign white blood cells might
help to explain autoimmune diseases, in which the immune system turns on
the body's own tissues5.
Hard to spot
True chimaeras, including both of those identified by Bonthron's team,
generally only come to light if they contain male and female cells, when
they can cause hermaphroditism or a mismatch between a person's sexual
organs and their chromosomal sex as revealed by a blood test. So might
the condition be more common than we realize? "I'm convinced that on the
streets of London and Hamburg there are many undetected chimaeras," says
Rudolf Happle, a dermatologist at the University of Marburg, Germany,
who has long been fascinated by mosaicism and chimaerism.
Mosaicism causes these unusual pigmented patterns called Blaschko's
lines. <see picture>
© R. Hepple
The rise of in vitro fertilization (IVF) is almost certainly bringing
more chimaeras into the world. To improve success rates, two or more
embryos are placed in the uterus, which explains why women undergoing
IVF have up to 25% more twin pregnancies than usual. More twins means
more chimaeras, says Bonthron, who notes that the British hermaphrodite
boy was an IVF baby1.
Mosaicism is more common than chimaerism and is also better studied.
Human mosaics arise when a mistake during cell division in the early
embryo stops the correct number of chromosomes segregating to each cell,
or creates a mutation in a single gene. If this happens in one of the
first few cell divisions after fertilization, a large proportion of
cells will inherit the defect.
Patchy diseases, in which only regions of tissue are affected, might be
caused by mosaicism. Another telltale sign of the condition is a
characteristic variation in skin pigmentation that causes patterns
called Blaschko's lines, including V-shaped streaks on the back that are
sometimes only visible under ultraviolet light.
Other researchers suspect that mosaicism could be involved in more
common diseases. Wendy Robinson of the University of British Columbia in
Vancouver, for instance, is intrigued by the observation that the
placenta becomes mosaic in about 2% of pregnancies. Often, these mosaic
placentas contain patches of cells that have an extra chromosome - a
condition called trisomy. Because both fetus and placenta develop from
the same cells, Robinson wonders if many fetuses contain undetected
patches of trisomic tissues that persist into adult life. "People could
have little pockets of trisomic cells sitting around inside them that
later lead to disease," she suggests. Intriguingly, her team has found
that some women who experience recurrent miscarriage carry trisomic
cells7.
Maggie - 22 May 2004 01:41 GMT
J, you been watching CSI too, huh?
That tripped me out last night. So kewl!
KCat - 22 May 2004 02:51 GMT
> J, you been watching CSI too, huh?
> That tripped me out last night. So kewl!
Totally fer shuuure.
I love CSI - especially the original and Petersen's dry wit.
Good episode - as always.
J - 22 May 2004 11:27 GMT
> J, you been watching CSI too, huh?
> That tripped me out last night. So kewl!
Yep, it was very kewl and then when I saw autoimmune (and other factors)
mentioned when I was researching it, I decided what the hey, might as
well post it here.
This brings up other questions in my mind too !
Like they swab the mouth to check DNA but they (authorities) may be
clearing people with this chmerism or related by not doing
bloodwork..and hence having unsolved cases. Ever thought of that?
J
Maggie - 22 May 2004 14:10 GMT
Oh man, J! I went into some deep thinking after you posted
this....almost got lost.
Then I remembered that the swab did show that they were looking for a
sibling...ahem...a brother. lol! (Love that goofy boy!) So, hopefully,
it won't leave them with unsolved cases once they come to a dead end
with all family members & make sure no chromosomes got mixed up in the
sisters. lol! Too wild!
Maggie
J - 22 May 2004 22:33 GMT
> Oh man, J! I went into some deep thinking after you posted
> this....almost got lost.
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> Maggie
Hi Maggie, actually I was referring to real life unsolved cases.
This gets even more interesting microchimerism and Hashimoto's (autoimmune)
thyroid
All women had given birth to a male with 12-46 years before diagnosis
http://tinyurl.com/2yee4
(the pdf is here http://www.biol.vt.edu/faculty/sible/Ayesha1.pdf for
others)
Actually (unless I was dreaming) I think I saw cases where parts of the lung
(after surgery) grew back and were proven to be chimeristic (born of
"foreign" blood cells either from transplants or already in the person's
body from having had a child or mutations after some medications - chemo
specifically is the one I was looking at.).
So there's good potential and bad potential to this chimera.
JMO - I'm not an expert, but find this very interesting.
J
Maggie - 23 May 2004 00:16 GMT
Hi J,
Are ya sayin' I watch too much TV? lol! Okay, I probably do.
I really was referring to real life. My 'magination wasn't, but I was
still here with ya. : )
The way I understand it is; the twin in the Chimera would have
similarites in their DNA. Enough for the authorities to know it was a
relative, namely a sibling. The similarities would be that prominent.
(I read an article about CSI awhile back that said they are extremely
accurate on their shows.) So, I would think they would go after the
sibling's & when none of them checked out, then, thanks to this weeks
episode, <g> someone would put it together & start taking blood samples.
Actually, I think they do take blood samples anyway. It's just easier
to film a swab on TV, rather than a blood draw. lol!
So interesting though. I was in awe at the end of this weeks show.
Still am. : ) Going to read your new links.....
Hugs,
Maggie
Mair - 22 May 2004 02:02 GMT
And for further study...
http://www.unifi.it/unifi/surfchem/solid/bardi/chimera/
I just can't help myself... lord knows I try.
Mair
> http://www.nature.com/nsu/020429/020429-13.html - snippets from an
> interesting longer article.
[quoted text clipped - 86 lines]
> that some women who experience recurrent miscarriage carry trisomic
> cells7.
J - 24 May 2004 09:13 GMT
> And for further study...
> http://www.unifi.it/unifi/surfchem/solid/bardi/chimera/
> I just can't help myself... lord knows I try.
>
> Mair
Yes you do, hugs Mair, very interesting website, fascinating artwork
Did you see the last one, a guy cuddling up to a leopard with a human female's
head?
That's even better than my male nude just above me here :-)
J