Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Herpes / March 2008
HELP - partner forgot she'd had HSV2
|
|
Thread rating:  |
BD - 16 Jan 2008 02:50 GMT Hey, folks.
I've been dating a gal whom I've known for about a year.
She has been out of the dating scene for a long time, as she had a substantial weight / self-image problem. The weight issue was dealt with, through gastric bypass.
We've been friends for about a year, and decided to ramp it up to a dating scenario almost 2 months ago. I've not been really committed to the relationship, as she has a 9-year-old boy who's rather active and an occasional discipline issue - and I've never been a parent. But, on her encouragement, we've been spending time together, and exploring the relationship.
We 'ramped up' the relationship a month ago, and have had intercourse a few times. Unprotected. To be honest, I thought that since she'd been out of the scene for so long, STDs were kind of a non-issue. ((let's please just avoid the scolding on this point - I've beaten myself up quite a bit about this point))
She came to me recently and said that just about when her child was born, she had an HSV2 outbreak. Just one, and she'd completely forgotten all about it - until it flared up again, after we began our physical relationship. I believe her when she says that the reason it flared up again was a combination of the activity, and hormonal changes due to recently going on the pill - as well as some antibiotics she's been taking.
Our last contact was 15 days ago. She broke the news to me 2 days ago, when she finally realized what was going on. It would seem that she completely forgot about the first outbreak, because it was isolated. I don't know how to respond to that claim.
To this point, I have no noteworthy symptoms. Went to a clinic to discuss it with a practitioner, and based on what he heard, he estimated that I was probably fine. He took a swab of an area on which I did see some extremely tiny red marks, which he suggested were likely a more generic irritation, and not a result of HSV2.
I have an appointment with my family doctor next week, and will discuss it with him then - I may go whole hog and get the bloodwork done after awhile.
I think I'm in mild shock, simply because I spent most of the afternoon without even thinking about this, and then would hear this little voice in my head, saying "She FORGOT?"
I really don't know how to respond to all this. New relationship, my faith in the dynamic still being established, kid involved, and then I get this bombshell dropped on me.
I've done some basic reading, and appreciate the stigma associated with HSV, versus the reality. I know it's manageable, and in reality it's an overblown inconvenience. But I also have no way of knowing how impactful this will be on a still-new relationship, where we're still discovering each other's histories. Trust is in jeopardy, progression of intimacy, etc. The phrase 'is it worth it' has dribbled into my mind quite a few times.
At this point, I am not compelled to run to the hills, simply because I consider myself to not be quite that reactive. But, I am strongly tempted to change the dynamic of the relationship (ie go back to 'just friends'), until I can wrap my head around it all. I can't in good conscience tell her it's all okay, simply because I think I'm still emotionally detached from the reality of everything.
I'd appreciate any general feedback that can be offered.
Thanks!
BD - 16 Jan 2008 02:56 GMT > it's an overblown inconvenience. I should apologize for that point. I'd intended to convey that it is not life-threatening. I don't mean to belittle or minimize the suffering it causes. Clearly I'm upset - my internal censors are not functioning properly.
harmony - 16 Jan 2008 08:46 GMT I'm sorry you are going through this. As someone who has the virus myself, I must be honest with you and say it generally isn't something you 'just forget'! I wish a week went by when I didn't think about it! Perhaps that is the underlying reason she has been out of the dating scene? Look I don't mean to judge, it's hard to know whether that is the case or not, I just find it a little hard to believe. But then, it is common to find out you have the virus during childbirth or pregnancy and perhaps having a child completely takes your mind off those sorts of things, I don't know.
I don't really know what advice to give you. If she is worth it, then I wouldn't let a virus (which as you rightly said is more of an inconvenience than a life-threatening situation), get in the way of what could be an incredible relationship. My concern would be more so around the issue of trust than the virus itself. I think you are well within your rights to tread cautiously in an effort to ascertain whether you can trust this person and whether it was in fact an honest mistake. People deserve to have the opportunity to make an informed decision as to whether to take the risk with an HSV positive person, not have that decision made for them.
Re: the tests, from my experience, the swab test is more accurate than blood tests. Blood tests have been known to come back negative even though the person may in fact have the herpes virus. The swab test needs to be done when there are symptoms present though.
Hope it helps. Harmony http://www.harmonyonline.com.au
ccarney9 - 16 Jan 2008 21:31 GMT Even if the test results are positive, it's possible that you already had HSV2. I've read 70-80% of the one out of four Americans that have it, don't know they have it. You might be one of these 56 million Americans.
M2slo2cht@nospam.invalid - 17 Jan 2008 02:58 GMT Personally, I have no problem at all believing her when she says she simply forgot. So she had an outbreak 9 years ago and zippity do da since? And she's been out of the dating scene so presumably no reason to give it a thought? It's been completely out of sight and out of mind? Why wouldn't she forget? I think *most* people would forget. She remembers now though, and she told you about it when she did. I'd give her points for that.
As far as the risk to you, it's probably pretty slim. Granted, precautions are in order but I certainly wouldn't let this get in the way if everything else about the relationship is working.
As for blood tests, the older ones weren't very accurate but the current ones are *very* accurate. The only thing is, they're good only after 12-16 weeks of infection. They look for antibodies in the blood and it takes that long for the immune system to build them up to detectable levels. Check this out: http://yoshi2me.com/genital-herpes.html Be aware that many healthcare professionals don't know beans about Herpes even though they won't let you know that. And a few unintentionally even spread misinformation about it. If yours is up to date on it, and word seems to be getting out to some of them lately, you're a lucky man.
As for your statement about the severity of Herpes, you were right the first time. As many as 90% of the people infected with Genital Herp don't even know they have it. Even if I knew nothing about it, that stat alone would make me wonder "so what's the big deal?" Fact is, it's a big deal for a very small percentage of people. I personally know several infected women who have had relationships with uninfected men for years without ever passing it along. Granted sometimes it happens but not as often as you might think. Anyhow, you asked for some general feedback so there's mine. M2
>Hey, folks. >I've been dating a gal whom I've known for about a year. [quoted text clipped - 65 lines] > >Thanks! taintedlover1@gmail.com - 24 Feb 2008 15:37 GMT > Hey, folks. > [quoted text clipped - 66 lines] > > Thanks! Im a little skeptical about her NOT remembering she has herpes. Has anyone else only ever had one outbreak? Even if she only ad one outbreak, thats not something you forget about. I remember crying for days when i first found out. Its a huge deal. Its something like getting kicked in the nads...sure it was a long time ago, but you never really forget.
~nony mouse - 18 Mar 2008 18:54 GMT > Im a little skeptical about her NOT remembering she has herpes. Has > anyone else only ever had one outbreak? Even if she only ad one > outbreak, thats not something you forget about. I remember crying for > days when i first found out. Its a huge deal. Its something like > getting kicked in the nads...sure it was a long time ago, but you > never really forget. I had only one major outbreak with no other symptoms (that I could associate directly with herp) in the first 10 years.
About 10 years in, I started having neuralgia and maybe an inconsequential rawness or single blister--nothing I would have noticed if I weren't already on the lookout for it. However, I've never forgotten that I have the herp. My first experience was so traumatic, there's no way to forget it. But initial outbreaks--when they occur--vary in severity.
Thus, I can see someone having a more minor initial outbreak (compared to what I had), not going to the doctor, and sort of forgetting about it--like a repressed memory. Memories are weird that way.
So I wouldn't assume the worst, but if I were you, I would proceed not with skepticism but with eyes open. Is this a part of a larger pattern of dubious behavior, or is it an exception to an otherwise open person? And if she deliberately mislead you, why would she point it out now when you've shown no symptoms? Wouldn't she wait for you to get symptoms and then suddenly go, "Oh, wait, I forgot, I've got herpes."
Alas, there are no clear cut answers. If you like her, I'd give her the benefit of the doubt, as much as you can, if she seems to have otherwise been an open and honest person.
Cheers, nony mouse
MamaZ - 18 Mar 2008 20:34 GMT I don't even remember my first outbreak, but it wasn't genital. I have herpetic whitlow (hsv2), it breaks out on the palm of my hand. I didn't know what the blisters were when I first starting getting them and asked my acupuncturist what he thought it was. His reply: "Looks like herpes to me". He was right! So, it is possible, in some cases not even to KNOW you have herpes. mamaZ On Jan 15, 9:50 pm, BD <robert.d...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hey, folks. > [quoted text clipped - 66 lines] > > Thanks! Im a little skeptical about her NOT remembering she has herpes. Has anyone else only ever had one outbreak? Even if she only ad one outbreak, thats not something you forget about. I remember crying for days when i first found out. Its a huge deal. Its something like getting kicked in the nads...sure it was a long time ago, but you never really forget.
|
|
|