Hi, Got involved with a woman with herpes(type 2) two years ago,
went for a blood test six months ago and it was shown positive
with IgG = 1.5 (note: above one >1 is positive) for HSV2.
And I do have most of the symptoms of genital herpes
But a recent blood test was shown as follows:-
IgG = 0, IgM =0, for HSV2
IgG =7.7, IgM =0, for HSV1
It was taken twice with the same result.
My questions are :
How accurate is the blood test.
Do I have HSV2.
Could it be the HSV1 infected my genital area.
Does the HSV1 in the genital area have same symptoms
as HSV2.
Grant - 15 Oct 2003 19:03 GMT
Hi John,
Someone who is better at reading test results will be able to confirm
everything for you better than I. I'm sure someone will be along soon
enough.
In the meantime, I can offer my opinions.
This is the problem with some of the Elisa blood tests. The older ones tend
to get the type confused. So, you may test positive for type 1 when you
really have type 2. The Herpes Specific Western Blot is the best test and
it will leave no room for interpretation. It just says: positive for type
____.
However, the newer Elisas are more accurate. So, it's hard to say what
happened in your situation. If you could find out exactly what kind of
blood test you had done, we can help you more. Also, are you sure the first
test said type 2? Oh, and one more problem with the blood tests....they
can't tell you WHERE you have your outbreaks. So, someone with type 1 might
not ever know if they have it genitally or orally or both, unless they have
visible outbreaks.
Now, to answer your questions:
> How accurate is the blood test.
Very accurate. If you test positive for a blood test then you have herpes.
Depending on the test, the question would be, what type do you have? If you
test negative on a blood test, you might have been tested to early on in the
infection for their to be adequate antibodies to count. So, you would have
to be retested again. It's best to be tested after 16 weeks of being
infected. And the Western Blot is very, very accurate.
> Do I have HSV2.
Have no idea.
> Could it be the HSV1 infected my genital area.
Many people with genital herpes actually have type 1. It's passed through
oral sex most of the time. And as I mentioned above, it's difficult to know
where you are infected through just a blood test.
> Does the HSV1 in the genital area have same symptoms
> as HSV2.
Exactly the same.
Take care,
ar
John - 15 Oct 2003 20:43 GMT
> Hi John,
>
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
> Now, to answer your questions:
Thank you for your reply.
Regarding your reply if my first test is type2,
Yes, very sure, I went for type2 only and
type1 was not included.
Actually my first test is from a different clinic
whereas the 2nd and 3rd is from another.
the duration from my first test till the recent
ones is about 5 months.
Further opinions please, Thanks
Grant - 15 Oct 2003 22:05 GMT
The only test I'm aware of that tests only for type 2 is the POCKit. I
thought it wasn't being offered anymore.
I would wait until one of our expert test readers shows up and gives you an
answer. I would also say to get the Western Blot test run.
Take care,
ar
> > Hi John,
> >
[quoted text clipped - 34 lines]
>
> Further opinions please, Thanks
Angela - 15 Oct 2003 22:57 GMT
John,
You might get a faster response to your test results by posting them here:
http://boards.webmd.com/topic.asp?topic_id=90
Angela
John - 16 Oct 2003 13:02 GMT
To Grant and Angela, thank you both, regads.
> John,
>
> You might get a faster response to your test results by posting them here:
> http://boards.webmd.com/topic.asp?topic_id=90
>
> Angela
M.L.S. - 17 Oct 2003 03:56 GMT
>Hi, Got involved with a woman with herpes(type 2) two years ago,
>went for a blood test six months ago and it was shown positive
>with IgG = 1.5 (note: above one >1 is positive) for HSV2.
>And I do have most of the symptoms of genital herpes
>But a recent blood test was shown as follows:-
>IgG = 0, IgM =0, for HSV2
>IgG =7.7, IgM =0, for HSV1
>It was taken twice with the same result.
>My questions are :
>How accurate is the blood test.
Depends on the which brand and type of test you had. It could be that
the first test you had returned a cross-reacted result (it confused
type 1 and type 2), or maybe it was just plum wrong. I'd have to
believe the two subsequent tests that agreed with each other. Sounds
to me like you have HSV1 genitally.
>Do I have HSV2.
Hard to say conclusively, but it seems that you do have one of the
simplexes.
>Could it be the HSV1 infected my genital area.
Yep.
>Does the HSV1 in the genital area have same symptoms
>as HSV2.
Outbreaks tend to be less severe and farther between. Many people
only report the initial HSV1 outbreak and then the virus seems
deceptively inactive. There is still a slight risk of shedding,
though, which means it can still be passed on, and care should be
taken in that regard, but for the host it seems to be easier to live
with than the average HSV2 case.
Take care,
Mike
tcchai - 17 Oct 2003 10:50 GMT
Thank You Mike.
> Outbreaks tend to be less severe and farther between. Many people
> only report the initial HSV1 outbreak and then the virus seems
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> Mike
Guy - 18 Oct 2003 00:29 GMT
Hi John
I'd immediately request a herpes specific Western Blot blood test. You're
getting rather old ELISA tests, if they're listing both IgG and IgM
antibody. There are much more reliable tests around...the most reliable one
being the western blot.
Hang in
-G
> Hi, Got involved with a woman with herpes(type 2) two years ago,
> went for a blood test six months ago and it was shown positive
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> Does the HSV1 in the genital area have same symptoms
> as HSV2.
John - 18 Oct 2003 15:25 GMT
Thanks GUY,
> Hi John
>
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
> > Does the HSV1 in the genital area have same symptoms
> > as HSV2.