Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Hepatitis / March 2007
What About This Info-Two?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
amzolt - 09 Mar 2007 05:01 GMT >From this site: http://www.healthyhepper.com/naomi/naomi.htm
I have clipped sections of an article about Naomi Judd's Program written by AlternativeMedicine.com. I have added my own comments and observations as well as added hyperlinks.
"To the amazement of her conventional doctors, Naomi's alternative program sent the hepatitis into remission in two years. Conventional medicine says that once you get hepatitis C, you have it for life, yet her symptoms are gone. Recently Naomi decided that remission is not enough and that she is 'going for the cure,' determined that the virus will leave her body. Naomi reports that her view of medicine has changed radically as a result of her experience with hepatitis. 'I see modern medicine as a last resort. You can't beat it when it comes to trauma care, antibiotics, surgery, or organ transplantation. Someday the rest of medicine is going to be viewed as barbaric. Hopefully when my grandchildren look back and see pictures of a human on life support, it's going to be the way we now look at the medieval practice of leeches.'"
"Naomi's message these days is that people need to simplify their lives -figure out what really matters and let the rest go. Have regular do not disturb days when you turn off the phone and the fax machine and have no schedule, Naomi suggests. Insist on personal time, reserve your limited spare time only for those who are very special, know when to say no, turn off the TV, spend time outdoors, and educate yourself about holistic medicine."
Waterspider - 09 Mar 2007 05:11 GMT > >From this site: > http://www.healthyhepper.com/naomi/naomi.htm [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > to say no, turn off the TV, spend time outdoors, and educate yourself > about holistic medicine." Unadulterated horse sh.t.
I doubt Naomi's "conventional doctors" were amazed, I expect they were disgusted. Hepatitis c does not go "into remissison." Hepatitis c can show no symptoms for many years, until one's liver begins to shut down from damage caused by the virus. No symptoms does not mean no disease. No symptoms does not mean no progression of the disease.
greyhackles - 09 Mar 2007 14:59 GMT >>From this site: >http://www.healthyhepper.com/naomi/naomi.htm > > I have clipped sections of an article about Naomi Judd's Program >written by AlternativeMedicine.com. I have added my own comments and >observations as well as added hyperlinks. [...]
Aside from not seeing any comments or added hyperlinks....One can only wonder what your agenda is...
amzolt - 11 Mar 2007 00:47 GMT > Aside from not seeing any comments or added hyperlinks....One can only wonder > what your agenda is... Agenda? Wanted to know what folks thought about it... A nurse who's into Alternative tx gave me the links...
~ Alex
greyhackles - 11 Mar 2007 01:12 GMT >> Aside from not seeing any comments or added hyperlinks....One can only wonder >> what your agenda is... > >Agenda? >Wanted to know what folks thought about it... >A nurse who's into Alternative tx gave me the links... Ah - ok, fair enough.
There are plenty of folks out there with HCV who are asymptomatic walking time-bombs.
But, eventually, there will be one hell of a price to pay...
hth
/greyhackles
Waterspider - 11 Mar 2007 01:55 GMT >> Aside from not seeing any comments or added hyperlinks....One can only >> wonder [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > Wanted to know what folks thought about it... > A nurse who's into Alternative tx gave me the links... Well then, here's my thoughts... A nurse into alternative tx is an idiot. There is no alternative tx.
amzolt - 11 Mar 2007 23:29 GMT Waterspider & Greyhackles,
I've appreciated all the various things I've seen you both say in this group. Do ya think, rather than just saying there is no alternative to the standard treatment, trying to explain Why there isn't?
~ Alex
elmoemerson@webtv.net - 12 Mar 2007 00:26 GMT Re: What About This Info-Two? Group: sci.med.diseases.hepatitis Date: Sun, Mar 11, 2007, 3:29pm (CDT-2) From: amzolt@gmail.com (amzolt) Waterspider & Greyhackles, I've appreciated all the various things I've seen you both say in this group. Do ya think, rather than just saying there is no alternative to the standard treatment, trying to explain Why there isn't? ~ Alex ///////////// There is an alternative to standard treatment for many patients....it's called 'liver failure' or 'liver transplant'. elmo
http://community.webtv.net/elmoemerson/DocElmosHepFile
http://community.webtv.net/elmoemerson/TheFamilyAlbum
Thomas Wagner - 12 Mar 2007 01:56 GMT >Do ya think, rather than just saying there is no alternative to the >standard treatment, trying to explain Why there isn't? I'm not Waterspider, but I'll still answer...
Why? Because none of the alternative "treatments" can eliminate the virus. And as long as the virus is in your body, it is killing your liver cells. No matter how much milk thistle you take, no matter what else you try to stave of the damage, the virus is more powerful than anything you can do. It's as simple as that. Kill the virus, stop the damage. And only interferon and riba can kill the virus (at least so far). Normal LFT values are no indication that the liver isn't being damaged. Low viral counts don't correlate to less damage. So all the alternative "treatments" do is to give people a false sense of security. Pretty crappy results, don't you agree?
Thomas
 Signature To reach me, complete my last name in the address.
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 03:01 GMT your immune system is the real fighter.
Waterspider - 12 Mar 2007 02:03 GMT > Waterspider & Greyhackles, > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > standard treatment, trying to explain Why there isn't? > ~ Alex That's like asking why there isn't a herbal tea that will cure cancer, or an elixir that will cure getting run over by a crosstown bus!
Maybe someday we'll be able to take a pill to erradicate hepatits C from our blood and our livers, but I think we're a long way away from it. HCV is one tough virus, and it requires tough treatment. Unfortunately, there has been nothing, absolutely nothing, in the alternative field which succeeded in curing hep c. Absolutely nothing.
But, it's a tough treatment. So, when we're faced with this treatment, it's natural to want to make sure that maybe there's not something out there, something easier, that we've missed. So, we look on the internet and we read books and magazines, maybe hear an interview with a star on television. Doing this, it's possible to find a whole range of "cures" like colodial silver, liver flushes, herbal mixtures, etc. etc. etc. Of course these claims will be accompanied by glowing testimonials from people like "Greg in Kansas" who thank God and Brand X for their renewed health and longevity. And, we all have a friend who had a friend who read so-and-so's book and followed the instructions to be cured of hep c.
Sorry, but it's all crap and snakeoil, desperate people wanting so badly to believe in something that they'll let themselves die of liver failure rather than accept that traditional medical science is the only answer. The only chance. Everything else wastes precious time, letting hep c continue destroying your liver for another day, and another month, another year... until you're in the ER, all yellow and bloated, bleeding internally, sicker than you can imagine... hearing that you're going on the transplant list, usually a two-year wait, but you've only got six months to live.
In the first couple of months after my diagnosis, I spent way too much money on milkthistle, vitamin combos, enzymes, herbal teas and some really bad books with no science behind them, and way too much time meditating on making my body heal. But, luckily I'm a geek, a researcher by trade, so I soon learned that there was no other option than the Big Guns. I had cirrhosis and my symptoms were preventing me from functioning anywhere near like a normal human being. I was scared shitless because I knew the treatment was horrible, and I knew it was the only chance I had at not being dead in 3-5 years (doctor's prognosis if I kept f.cking around with the alternative crap). The only way I could gather the courage to undertake it was to remind myself that, if it turned out to be that bad, if I couldn't handle it, then I would simply not bother taking any more pills, not bother with the next shot. I really had nothing to lose.
Guess what? The first, the worst, shot didn't kill me. So I did the next one, and it wasn't as bad. So, I continued, and yes it was a bitch, but it was quite do-able. I even worked through most of it. And, the treatment worked. I no longer have hepatitis c. I no longer have that horrible virus replecating in my liver as much as three billion times a day. No more symptoms, no more fatigue, no more brain fog, no more fevers and dizzy spells. No more fear. Oh yeah, and my hair grew back thicker and better than ever (treatment will definitely thin your hair).
In other words, I know how you feel and I know where you're coming from. But it's time for a reality check... you won't live forever and I have a feeling that you're not ready to roll over and die yet.
Btw, Naomi Judd at some point made a serious reality check and underwent peg-interferon and ribavirin treatment for her hepatitis c. Now she's helping raise money for the American Liver Foundation to fund more research on hepatitis c. Here is a link to that page on her website: http://www.naomijudd.com/Pages/hepc.html
All the best,
Waterspider
Paul - 12 Mar 2007 17:55 GMT On Sun, 11 Mar 2007 18:03:24 -0700, "Waterspider" <nospam@all.com>, in message ID <12v99n7pqbnipb0@corp.supernews.com>, in the newsgroup sci.med.diseases.hepatitis wrote:
>In the first couple of months after my diagnosis, I spent way too much money >on milkthistle, vitamin combos, enzymes, herbal teas and some really bad [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >handle it, then I would simply not bother taking any more pills, not bother >with the next shot. I really had nothing to lose. Yeah. I bought a few weird things and tried to read myself better too WS. I was in the unfortunate position of having seen someone die on tx - probably one of those rare people whose immune system attacked their liver. Unfortunate I may have been but not as unfortunate as he - especially as his liver was pretty healthy for a hepper until his immune system went into overdrive on it. I suppose I had better reasons than most for looking for an alternative. I got lucky. My research brought me here. At stage 2 grade 3, I may well have still been a decade away from cirrhosis and perhaps 20 years from liver failure. However, I doubt the last few years would have had any quality to them. Since my (succesful) tx in '04, I have witnessed another friend die - more directly due to hep-c this time. We treated at the same time. Mine worked. His didn't. So that's two deaths I've witnessed in recent years. The first one I was there when the ventilator was switched off. The second one died half an hour after I left the hospital. I would like to have been there at the moment of his death but there was no way of knowing if he had another day or two left in him. I don't feel right about not sticking around but I don't have a crystal ball. The yellowing, the bloating and the mental confusion as the toxins start to affect the brain. Both good people who I shared many a laugh with. You know what I would like to do to these rip off snake oil selling bastards don't you? I'd like to cut their f.cking livers out and give them to someone who needs them. Snake oil salespeople are as close to murderers as you can get. They can be so convincing with their slimey lies and can cause vulnerable people to delay essential, possibly life saving treatment.
You know, I spent quite a few years with hep-c ruling a large part of my life - either mine or other peoples. I'm wondering if the time has come to move on as the whole thing has been pretty distressing at times. I feel like I'm stuck in a time warp mourning friends whose lives have gone and not yet fully able to enjoy my own life.
Feel like I'm at a crossroads (I think you call them 4 way stops over there) and unsure which road to head down.
amzolt - 13 Mar 2007 04:23 GMT Paul, Thomas, Waterspider, & Elmo!
Thanks for the feedback. Your reasoning is sound. I appreciate your honesty.
~ Alex
Waterspider - 13 Mar 2007 07:01 GMT > Paul, Thomas, Waterspider, & Elmo! > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > ~ Alex You're welcome! Twice.
amzolt - 13 Mar 2007 05:52 GMT Paul, Thomas, Waterspider, & Elmo!
Thanks for the feedback. Your reasoning is sound. I appreciate your honesty.
~ Alex
Waterspider - 13 Mar 2007 07:01 GMT > On Sun, 11 Mar 2007 18:03:24 -0700, "Waterspider" <nospam@all.com>, in > message ID <12v99n7pqbnipb0@corp.supernews.com>, in the newsgroup [quoted text clipped - 58 lines] > Feel like I'm at a crossroads (I think you call them 4 way stops over > there) and unsure which road to head down. Paul, we've shared some similar experiences. I know what it's like to do the hep c deathwatch at the hospital bedside. I know what it's like to lose friends to liver failure. Sometimes it makes me feel lucky (because I'm still here, I'm healthy) and sometimes it breaks my heart. Like you, that hep c connection is a strong part of my life and I'm unable or unwilling to walk away from it. I am not a religious person, which I think you already know, but I seem compelled to spend time doing what I can to help anyone newly diagnosed, coping with the disease, undergoing treatment, perhaps trying to carry on after failed treatment. This all goes back to when I was newly diagnosed, a basket-case and a physical wreck, and a couple of good folks, strangers, came out of the woodwork to offer support, advice and help in all kinds of ways. Some were in my community, some were friends of friends in other towns, some were on these newsgroups. It still blows me away that they helped me so much, and I think I'll always be here for anyone who wants to listen to what I have to say. Payback. Goes around, comes around. I do enjoy life again, being healthy and without the anxiety of simply having the disease, but I feel good about being able to give something back. Still, it sucks when someone dies, when someone fails treatment, when someone is so thick-headed and scared that they won't even try treatment. But at least I know that I'm doing something, maybe not much, but at least I'm not walking away from it all. In other words, if we're as alike as I suspect, you're stuck! Might as well resign yourself to the fact that you're a person willing to share whatever wisdom gained throughout this long strange trip. Whaddya got to lose?
Paul - 13 Mar 2007 10:17 GMT On Mon, 12 Mar 2007 23:01:33 -0700, "Waterspider" <nospam@all.com>, in message ID <12vcfic3qaa0c4a@corp.supernews.com>, in the newsgroup sci.med.diseases.hepatitis wrote:
>Paul, we've shared some similar experiences. I know what it's like to do the >hep c deathwatch at the hospital bedside. I know what it's like to lose [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] >that you're a person willing to share whatever wisdom gained throughout this >long strange trip. Whaddya got to lose? I guess I am stuck but the pain is still raw. I'm going away for a few days break in a minute. Maybe that's what I really need. Just feeling a little worn out by life at the moment. It passes. I do give plenty of help on hep-c away from the internet too. I use an addiction self help group so meet plenty along the way with hep-c. I find it amazing that there are still people out there (here in the UK) who have had LFTs done by a GP, got a "normal" result and it gets left at that. If I had listened to such nonsense, I would probably still be "normal" with a deteriorating liver. I tell these people, go back to your GP, ask to be referred to a liver specialist/gastro to arrange a biopsy. DO NOT TAKE NO FOR AN ANSWER. If they insist on saying no - get a second opinion (most doctors hate that and will relent). Anyway, off now for a three/four day break. Catch ya soon.
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 03:00 GMT you can try to improve your immune system. try eating good food. veggies and water. limit meats to small portions. exercise if able. dont put alcohol or drugs in the bod.. unless truely needed. limit sugar(cane) have regular liver/iron tests done. cbc/with diff (blood test) dont get anemic or iron-overloaded. And at least consider the peg/co-peg treatment. it would be good if there was some special diet/alternative treatment that we could hang our hats onto... not yet! interferon/ribivirin are the best so far. and be cool. always be sure of what you post. some people are easily misled with holistic/alternative plans. alot of that stuff can help overall health. but hcv is one mean son of a bitch with a mind of its own. kinda like a dragon.... your intentions prob. are good, education is the best for you. i have read about hcv and virus function for over 10 yrs. the sh.t is deep. peace...
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:46 GMT his agenda? hes a communist leach killer..... an overgrown cockroach.....
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:33 GMT idiot, naomi judd is one case. that will no change millions of cases/outcomes. trying to build ones immune system up is all good. speading bullshit to hcv folks is like treason. if naomis way is a perfect example, everyone else would be well by now.....
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:35 GMT get hip on whats going on in 2007. stay out of the way-back machine. travel forward, not backward!
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:37 GMT f.ck naomi! not everyone has her money to f.ck off. get real cat! youre hung up in some time warp or something.
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:39 GMT read what you wrote.... her way sent her into remission in two yrs. undetected may or even may not mean clear! perhaps you should try to be naomis lap-dog!
Randy T. - 24 Mar 2007 02:44 GMT medeival practice of leaches? you are in a fuckin' coma! go post ina sit-down comics ng. did you come here to learn or to spread more dung on yourself? by the way, you have access to the internet.... try using it. start with leach therapy for various "modern medical uses" when you finish that, try typing in HCV 2007 news. And take off the loin cloth.... and walk up-right like modern man....
|
|
|