Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Epilepsy / October 2004
Complex partial seizures - is medication always necessary?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
pamela in florida - 23 Oct 2004 19:21 GMT My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG (abnormal). He was seen by a resident who took the interview and then the neurologist who saw him for about 10 minutes. They are recommending 1) Trileptol or 2)Topamax (history of headaches). (He doesn't have another appointment til April and we can only talk to nurses, the doctor being so overbooked.)
At this point the "episodes" that I have seen he has are very, very mild. Perhaps every 3-4 weeks, a 10-20 second period of confusion, mumbling, he says he can't hear and can only follow visual commands. Afterwards,he rebounds completely with no after effects. He has said on two occassions he feels slightly nauseated during the episode. He knows when they are going to come on and he has described them as a "zoning out with extreme deja vu". In two years I have probably seen 7 such episodes and heard about another 2 or 3 from his classmates and friends. He is not admitting to there being more. They have occured in front of the computer, in front of the T.V., in the car, on a friends couch in a classroom, and at band camp. (He is a base drummer in a high school marching band.)
From what I read about the side effects of thees meds - they sound alot worse than these episodes, possible language problems, muscle coordination, weight gain, weight loss, gait problems, headache, agitation, etc., etc.
My temptation is to encourage him to wait it out a bit and hope he outgrows it. Can anyone give me advice one way or the other. Are there people out there who are not taking meds and living with episodes similar to my son's? His father lives in the Netherlands and based on this same information, a Dutch family friend who also happens to be a neurologist is encouraging us not to go to the medications yet, encourage a healthy lifestyle with plenty of rest, limited computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some advice? It would be much appreciated.
gaross - 23 Oct 2004 21:05 GMT The Ep. Foundation of America http://efa.org plus Julie's Idaho website (at end of any of her posts about a week ago if any are still up on your reader), describe Complex Partial seizure symptoms. Older sites might also list it under Temporal Lobe seizures -- since the Deja Vu he's having is coming from the Right Temporal Lobe (like mine). I haven't used either of those medications although others 'around here' might have opinions on them. With respect to Complex Partial types, while not controlled those can end in loss of consciousness if they generalized (spread) to rest of the brain as the seizure progresses. If he's having these or starts to, you will be able to recognize them, as he will lose consciousness for 5 -15 minutes at the end. (See other posts we were doing about Swimming and seizures.) Whatever is prescribed if you decide to use them it's important that he take the dose the rate the Dr. says and not SKIP doses, by accident or on purpose. Some of our pills react negatively if stopped abruptly and skipping a dose will produce that effect. Also if the Dr. does periodic bloodwork to check for Med. levels in his blood, he will assume he's taking the prescribed dose, so if only Half the expected amount of med. shows in the Blood Test, the Dr. will Double the pills he should take-- then he could end up at Toxic levels of the pills.
I take a different set of pills than he is recommended but the Dr. may be avoiding mine as some can affect tooth and bone (Calcium) development in someone still growing or maturing. It took me about 2-3 years adjusting doses of Tegretol and another anti-seizure med. before I got to a clean level that didn't have a seizure each 2-3 weeks, then each ~6 weeks, up to 3 months, then longer. Now it's at almost 7 years.
There is probably a Chapter (office) of the Ep. Foundation of America somewhere near you, or they have a Medications glossary that will describe those 2 pills and side effects (if you don't want to talk to a real person if one were available at your local chapter who'd know about medications). Even if you haven't filled the prescriptions you could go into your regular pharmacy and ask if the have a www site OR can print information on the particular pill types the Dr. is recommending. On that you will see what to avoid, and which side effects are possible. The Ep. Foundation of America is at http://efa.org
The symptoms that are *possible (I had None of the possible ones for Tegretol), will not include All the possible ones you listed at 2nd last paragraph of your's at bottom here. And may include none of them.
You'd have to assess the risk of his having a seizure (see other posts about swimming with seizures) where it might affect his safety. Most states, he shouldn't Drive so long as he's not controlled, so in 2? years time if he's still not controlled he won't be able to drive while his peers will...
If he's not losing consciousness, his form of C.P. seizure must be less strong than some of the rest of us. Before I was controlled with pills, all mine would end with loss of awareness of where I was or loss of consciousness, and were potentially dangerous to me. I also got a Medic Alert bracelet at the suggestion of my Neuro.
It's too bad that your area doesn't have enough Doctors and Neuros to handle your Population size. As someone who can't vote where you are, perhaps that's something you should take up with your Politicians vs. where they're currently spending all your Tax money. :-< My Dr. told me that here (Canada) we will run out of specialists and Neurologists within about 5 years, as there weren't enough residency spots for them to complete their training properly here. Once they've moved South or to Europe to finish their training, they have no real reason to return. G./
With respect to your advice at end below, since I don't know what's causing his seizures, he can't 'prescribe' like your neuro did there. If they're not photo-sensitive seizures causing the CP type, the CRT thing doesn't apply. Lifestyle, rest and exercise will help most things, and also seizures. But depending what's causing them, they likely won't cure them. e.g. WHY did the EEG show Electrical waves that were abnormal? and why does your Neuro Friend think that was unimportant? That was rhetorical, I don't need an answer, as I was just thinking out loud. G./
> My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > advice? It would be much appreciated. pamela in florida - 24 Oct 2004 22:17 GMT > The Ep. Foundation of America http://efa.org plus Julie's Idaho website (at > end of any of her posts about a week ago if any are still up on your [quoted text clipped - 103 lines] > > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > > advice? It would be much appreciated. My son's EEG (allnight sleep deprived) indicated that "a single burst of synchronous spike wave discharge was seen mostly over the occupital head region." Is that still considered a temporal lobe seizure or would that now be changed to an occipital lobe seizure with different medications prescribed? At the time the American neurologist recommended the meds he had only heard symptoms and had results in yet. Thanks for all your input, suggestions and references. It helps alot to know others care.
Bob - 24 Oct 2004 00:09 GMT > My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > advice? It would be much appreciated. Hi!
That's a pretty tough call and my own inclination if it were me would be to grin & bear it and not use drugs unless they were absolutely necessary.
There is an additional consideration though and I'll mention it in the interest of giving you more of the full picture. There is a theory with some backing by various scientists that having seizures leads to the likelihood of having more seizures. i.e. It's like beating a path in the brain.
They may cause other brain damage and I quote: "However, scientific data are slowly accumulating to suggest that recurring seizures may contribute to nerve cell injury in the brain, and this may be associated with declines in cognitive function and quality of life."
I do feel that it's fair to say though that it is only theory at the present time and will require more proof. The extent of any possible damage is also open to question. You can read a bit about it at http://www.epilepsy.com/articles/ar_1064856376.html
Bob
Satch - 24 Oct 2004 08:08 GMT Hello,
Uncontrolled mild epilepsy can develop itself to uncontrolled epilepsy causing the epilepsy and its seizures to effectively become worse I am afraid. This is because of the learning capabilities of the human brain. I read several books about this and they all discusses this a bit. Though I am not a neurologist, I do believe this is true.
You may want to have a look at:
Partial Seizure Disorders Help for Patients and Families Author: Mitzi Waltz ISBN: 0-596-50003-3 9000
On page 123 I quote:
If two or more unprovoked seizures have occurred, there is a higher risk that there will be more seizures in the future. Repeated seizures may harm the brain if they are left untreated, although the risk varies greatly depending on the type and length of the seizures.
Let's assume your son does not take the prescribed medications. When he wants to get his license at the age of 18 (that is law in the Netherlands) there is a possibility that his instructor never sees he is suffering from these mild seizures, so let's assume he does get his license. No one is watching out for him and he starts driving. Now there are two possibilities: 1. he has a mild seizure while he is driving and gets involved in an accident with material damage only. 2. he has a mild seizure while he is driving and gets involved in an accident with severe personal damage to someone else and himself.
In cases like this, the insurance company of both car drivers involved wants to find out how this could have happened and looks at your son's medical file...
Also understand that your 14 year old son grows up and that he will go to school which means out of your sight, that he will go out to have fun with this friends, he will start drinking alcohol (alcohol = trigger one), will go out for a party on Saterday night (lack of sleep = trigger 2), etc., etc. He may also have to deal with stress sometime (stress = trigger 3).
My personal opinion is that you should not leave this mild complex partial seizures uncontrolled -especially when the doctor recommends medication. There are too many risks involved doing so.
 Signature Thanks.
Marco The Netherlands
CyberCafe - 24 Oct 2004 21:58 GMT > Hello, > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > read several books about this and they all discusses this a bit. Though I am > not a neurologist, I do believe this is true. Well guys, I am living proof that things can get worse. I started out with very few symptoms (simple partials) and over time (untreated) more and more symptoms were added, not fun ones either, which progressed to complex partial seizures over time. My original neurologist did tell me that if I had continued to go untreated, the possibility of them turning into grand mal was possible. All the tests except for the EEG were normal, so apparently there's nothing structurally wrong with my brain.
The original poster wanted to know though if it was necessary for her son to be treated. I think you could go without treatment depending on how much grief seizures are giving you and you are willing to put up with and you are not in danger or a danger to others. The thing is nobody knows what the long-term effects will be (will they get worse, memory problems, etc.).
Sometimes I feel like a pill pusher, but I'm not; just the opposite in some aspects. In this case though, they might want to put him on medications because the son might not recognize some of the chronic symptoms as being associated with his seizures. It's also possible that he's having a heck of a lot more seizures than people are observing or he is reporting. He could be having seizures he doesn't even know about (like during sleep). They can always wean the medications when/if they think he outgrows them.
Satch, that's a good excerpt you included.
Barb
> You may want to have a look at: > [quoted text clipped - 39 lines] > Marco > The Netherlands CyberCafe - 24 Oct 2004 20:46 GMT > My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > coordination, weight gain, weight loss, gait problems, headache, > agitation, etc., etc. I've been on two seizure meds and haven't had any of that stuff. I think there can be a real problem with denial on both the patient's part and on the part of parents or significant others. No one wants to have epilepsy. Parents don't want a child to have epilepsy. What kind of things might be included in denial: failure to take meds regularly, engaging in risky behavior, "forgetting" to pick up a prescription or go to a doctor's appointment, thinking the symptoms aren't so bad, you can manage just fine without medical management, etc. Tons and tons of stuff come under the denial heading. In my experience, denial is a tough one, and so far I haven't beaten it totally.
> My temptation is to encourage him to wait it out a bit and hope he > outgrows it. Can anyone give me advice one way or the other. Are [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > advice? It would be much appreciated. My history: Started having simple seizure symptoms around 1967 (maybe earlier), was untreated until 1989 by which time the simple seizures had progressed into complex partial seizures. In my experience, you can live without medication if symptoms are mild and sleep is not disrupted and there are no mental things (such as the fear component) affecting your life, and a person is able to avoid triggers (if any).
For myself during all those years I was not treated, the bad parts beside the actual seizures themselves were: tiredness, which you can learn to live with, but it might prevent a person from becoming all they can be or doing all you want to do; the fear component, which you might not realize for what it really is. For myself, I had a real concern about the pureness of food and water, which resulted in a 50 pound weight loss over the years. The other part of the fear component that ended up being spooky was a mistrust of people, government, etc. Then also part of the whole symptoms thing for myself was really heightened startling to unexpected sounds and noises. Can a person live with this stuff? Of course you can if quality of life is not high priority.
Some problems I noticed due to MY undiagnosed seizures. Additional symptoms can creep up very slowly and you end up just living with it because you think it is a normal part of aging or whatever. You may not be aware of seizures happening when you sleep, which can make the next day hard to get through. Untreated seizures could get worse over time (they became significantly worse for me).
Advantages your son has: He knows he has epilepsy and can avoid risky situations or activities. It can be faster for him to get treatment if he needs it. Other people might be able to help him if they know he has a seizure disorder.
Some stuff I think parents and others should know about simple and complex partial seizures (in my opinion): The patient may not be aware they had a seizure. The patient may be closed-mouthed about inner feelings, thoughts that are happening. The patient may not always recognize what symptoms are definitely related to the seizures and what's not related to them. There can be a lot of stuff going on before, in-between, and after seizures.. Even if a person has a simple complex or partial complex seizure right in front of you, an observer, you may not know it. Seizures can affect a person physically such as changing the heart rate. Most people need to recover from seizures because they generally wear a person out, and the amount of recovery time seems to vary. There is a higher percentage of depression in people with certain types of epilepsy than the normal population.
My thoughts are that you could do an adequate trial run of anti-convulsants and let your son judge how much improvement he thinks he is receiving. You know, he could always be weaned off of them later.
Barb
CyberCafe - 24 Oct 2004 21:32 GMT I should have added that the ability to remember things might be affected. There seems to be some difference on that among the folks here. In my case, for me, that problem came at any time it wished; it wasn't just associated with actual seizures. The thing is you don't know what you forgot. You can't remember a movie if you didn't see it, and that's pretty much what this memory/recall thing is like; I didn't see the movie even though I was in the theater. Even a hugh amount of effort to remember the things you want to remember might be hopeless. You might remember things today, tomorrow, or two weeks from now, or longer, but after that it can be like you weren't even there when the event happened. So you don't know when this memory problem will happen, how long it will last, how deep it will be, and so on. I don't see how you could ever fault a child for not learning his lessons or finishing homework or a school project because you just don't know if the kid was lax or if seizure activity is interfering. So that's another one of the goofy things that might go unrecognized by parents, teachers, or even the patient at times.
Barb that's my opinion
> > My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 93 lines] > > Barb Julie - 25 Oct 2004 19:15 GMT Welcome to our group Pamela. I continue to take medication even though I haven't had a tonic clonic seizure for 9 years. The probable reason I have gone this long without a tonic clonic or complex partial seizure: 1. Take medication regularly 2. Pay attention to what triggers my seizures and try to stay away from those problems 3. When I do feel like I'm worn out - that a seizure could come, I rest.
Take care, Julie Walton, Volunteer Webmaster Epilepsy Foundation of Idaho http://www.epilepsyidaho.org
> My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > advice? It would be much appreciated. Daz_n_Pat - 25 Oct 2004 22:47 GMT Hi Pamela,
I've had complex partial seizures for 30 years now, and although they have always been treated, one thing I have found with them is their propensity to change unexpectedly. What I'm referring to is the nature of the seizure - how it manifests itself. For example; I went many years before my seizures started to involve feelings of either extreme anger or extreme fear. This just suddenly appeared in the seizures for no apparent reason. Later the seizures also became more physically violent - thrashing around, clenched fists, frantically rubbing my head, stomping my feet. Another way they unexpectedly changed is that I always knew when a seizure was approaching....had an aura before them. I was dum enough to think this was good enough to make it safe to drive, but that all changed suddenly and dramatically and now a man is dead because of it. What I'm trying to say is that epilepsy is pretty unpredictable and whether treated or not it can change a lot, so my bet would be to have it treated to get the best control early on and hopefully it won't have a chance to change into something much worse.
All the best to you and your son.
Darryl.
> My 14 year old son has recently been diagnosed with complex partial > seizures. He has had an MRI (normal) and a sleep deprived EEG [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > advice? It would be much appreciated. pamela in florida - 26 Oct 2004 23:04 GMT Thanks to all who responded to my query about medication for my son. I really appreciate all the time and effort you have put into making things clearer to me. I also greatly appreciate your honesty and suggestions. We may wait a bit. We have some time to really analyze the triggers (thanks Marco for pointing out alcohol, lack of sleep and stress). I am also still gathering info about side effects of both drugs, insurance coverage for medication, etc. I can't quite believe how expensive the drugs are. I think I figured about $250-300 for a 1 mos. supply of trileptol at the therapeutic dose they are recommending. Does anyone have feelings one way or the other about generic drugs. Insurance will only cover 60% of brand name drugs vs. 80% of generic. If I am hogging this board, let me know. Thanks. Pamela
> Hi Pamela, > [quoted text clipped - 54 lines] > > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > > advice? It would be much appreciated. Julie - 27 Oct 2004 19:17 GMT Pamela, please never feel that you are "hogging" the newsgroup. We are here to help and welcome your participation.
Regarding generic drugs, here is an article written by the Executive Director of Epilepsy Foundation of Idaho. Statement on Subsitution of Generic Anti-Epileptic Drugs. http://www.epilepsyidaho.org/generic-aed.htm
Also there is help from drug companies if you cannot afford prescriptions.
Take care, Julie Walton, Volunteer Webmaster Epilepsy Foundation of Idaho http://www.epilepsyidaho.org
> Thanks to all who responded to my query about medication for my son. > I really appreciate all the time and effort you have put into making [quoted text clipped - 68 lines] > > > computer time, good food and exercise. Anyone out there with some > > > advice? It would be much appreciated. Tomlongrifle - 30 Oct 2004 23:58 GMT I've had partial seizures now for almost 20 years and used lots of different meds in conjunction with a healthy diet, exercise, and regular sleep.
For me, the seizures became worse when I turned 21 and decided to add alcohol to my diet.
I would encourge you to work with the doctors, and question their reasons for trying the meds they're considering. Ask them about side effects, complications, how the med will affect his day to day activities, and ask them about possible seizure triggers you may be able to eliminate from his environment, such as the computer...if that is indeed a trigger.
There are some food additives thought to trigger seizures in people who are seizure prone, and some amino acids that can be used to help attain seizure control. Ask lots of questions and insist they explore every option. If meds are necessary, insist on finding the lowesty possible dosage toi control the seizures. Often, a neurologist will insist on what they call "theraputic blood levels," which is necessary in intractable seizures, but not always necessary if the seizures are mild.
I'm not a doctor, just a man with 20 years of seizure history, who's tried many different meds and many different doctors. I think female neuros are a little more compassionate and more willing to work with the patient to find the right dosage than the male doctors.
Hope this helps. Tom tomdaltonz@hotmail.com
|
|
|