Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Epilepsy / September 2004
Emergency Room Experience
|
|
Thread rating:  |
TIMMCO - 01 Sep 2004 20:29 GMT Greetings - I had a grand mal last Saturday night while attending an AA meeting - despite the Depakote treatment. The other alcoholics and drug addicts freaked out and 911 was dialed. I came to in the hospital emergency room with blood samples being drawn, as has happened many times before. Aware of the course of events, I got off the stretcher and walked home - though first being stopped by an attentive nurse who insisted on removing the needle from my arm.
It is such a waste of effort for everyone, yet what is to be done? Does anyone else have a solution to prevent people from dialing 911 and involving all the wasted expense of the ambulance. I did have a seizure in a Quaker meeting where they had the innate sense to just leave me alone and I finished the meeting normally after regaining consciousness. Thanks, Tim
Charani - 01 Sep 2004 21:05 GMT > Greetings - I had a grand mal last Saturday night while attending an AA meeting > - despite the Depakote treatment. The other alcoholics and drug addicts [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > meeting normally after regaining consciousness. > I would have said the best course of action would be to tell them that *if* you have a seizure, not to panic or dial 911. Do tell them what *does* need to be done though, if anything.
My 12 year old son deals with his seizures considerably better than the vast majority of adults around him. His peers are usually better at dealing with them than the adults.
Satch - 02 Sep 2004 05:18 GMT > My 12 year old son deals with his seizures considerably better than > the vast majority of adults around him. His peers are usually better > at dealing with them than the adults. Most adults are responsible while children are not -that is a difference. Wearing a neck bracelet may help as Gaross suggested but as you can see in my case, they stopped their cars / people on bikes stopped bicylcing, etc. They all called 911. I think this is just one of those "nice" things we will have to start living with as part of epilepsy. Sometimes it indeed is a waste of time and money, but people simply panic as they are unfamiliar with it.
In addition to this and again, let's take my experience as an example, after the ambulance arrived, all people went away still thinking they did the best in my interest, so the next time they will act exactly the same. In my case, I was glad however that I was brought into an ambulance as it was my first time experience but that is a different story.
Cheers, Marco
Charani - 02 Sep 2004 10:14 GMT > Most adults are responsible while children are not -that is a difference. > Wearing a neck bracelet may help as Gaross suggested but as you can see in [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > waste of time and money, but people simply panic as they are unfamiliar with > it. As you say, people, especially adults, tend to panic; whereas children seem much better at taking these things in their stride.
My son doesn't have a Medic Alert bracelet and I've often thought that he should have one. I'm also considering applying for an Assistance Dog for him. There's an organisation in the UK called Dogs for the Disabled. The dogs are specially trained for each person depending on the person's needs.
> In addition to this and again, let's take my experience as an example, after > the ambulance arrived, all people went away still thinking they did the best > in my interest, so the next time they will act exactly the same. In my case, > I was glad however that I was brought into an ambulance as it was my first > time experience but that is a different story. We have a 3-tier system in some places over here. When a 999/911 call goes in, someone called a First Responder is sent immediately. They are usually locally based people familiar with the area. They are trained in First Aid. They assess the situation, whilst giving initial First Aid.
If the situation is serious enough, a Paramedic is then sent in who would have oxygen and other equipment available to them. In areas where there are no First Responders, a Paramedic is the first one on the scene. They give medical care until an ambulance arrives if the Paramedic decides that is necessary.
In your case, and in Tim's, had you been over here, then a Paramedic would have attended you and it's unlikely an ambulance would have been called as well.
We're in a rural area and the nearest ambulance stations are quite a distance away but there are Paramedics and First Responders who can be with a "casualty" very much more quickly.
gaross - 02 Sep 2004 14:06 GMT > > Most adults are responsible while children are not **G** See my comment at bottom about hospital not wanting me to leave one time, as I had 6-8 more seizures After I had arrived at the hospital. (I first was taken there after a seizure elsewhere.)
-that is a difference.
> > Wearing a neck bracelet may help as Gaross suggested but as you can see in > > my case, they stopped their cars / people on bikes stopped bicylcing, etc. [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > As you say, people, especially adults, tend to panic; whereas children > seem much better at taking these things in their stride. **G* Some types of seizures produce erratic behaviours and unconsciousness, and can also mimic other conditions (Heart or Stroke health problems). Most public places here (Canada) prefer to make sure that someone doesn't die while they wait for us to 'take it in stride'. Unless there are people nearby who can recognize that it's a Petit Mal or Grand Mal type seizure and not a Stroke or Heart Attack, they prefer to take a safer approach. (Most times we don't pay for Ambulances here -- taxes and Social Medicine covers that, and has for almost 40 years. )
> My son doesn't have a Medic Alert bracelet and I've often thought that > he should have one. I'm also considering applying for an Assistance [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > I was glad however that I was brought into an ambulance as it was my first > > time experience but that is a different story. **G** I agree, that was my feeling too. I had other incidents where people walked by and assumed I was 'drunk or on drugs' even though I wasn't dressed for whatever that Profile might look like. /
> We have a 3-tier system in some places over here. When a 999/911 call > goes in, someone called a First Responder is sent immediately. They [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > distance away but there are Paramedics and First Responders who can be > with a "casualty" very much more quickly. Some of us live in larger cities where the 'target' for 911 calls is arrival in under 10-15? minutes. Many symptoms during some of the seizure types could mimic a Heart Attack or a Stroke. One study found that chance of Recovery from a Stroke decreased with longer time of First Response to someone having a stroke. While the system you described, with Paramedic being first responder, would indeed save some of our systems costs as our population of Baby Boomers ages, we also risk *losing people who *could have been treated in a timely manner and recovered.
(I lost a Dear Friend ~4 years ago after she had a stroke in her sleep. Although they got her to hospital within about 5 hours of onset (I just happened to phone her that morning or she could have been disabled for several days before Neighbours noticed she hadn't been outdoors) -- she didn't 'last' more than 5 days in Intensive Care. :-< )
It was following above that I heard a Radio program about health, CPR and Heart and Stroke issues, that the time to 'Emerg.' (hospital) can determine the *chances and rate of recovery from those types of conditions. I don't know if any of the Epilepsy types would fall into that profile, but as I said, some of our symptoms can 'look' like a stroke or heart attack to an outsider, without medical equipment or training.
We don't normally get 'billed' for being taken unconscious to hospital in Canada, but I guess other places have other 'priorities' and Billing Issues that take precedence to people's well-being. My other reply was based on what is done here wrt. emergency response currently. (I even had to wait one time for my Wife to come 'sign me out' before the Hospital would let me leave-- otherwise they wanted to admit me for observation overnight, as I had been having ~6-8 seizures before I was given a relaxant there to slow them down. ) G./
turbinado - 05 Sep 2004 00:53 GMT (snip)
> We don't normally get 'billed' for being taken unconscious to hospital in > Canada, but I guess other places have other 'priorities' and Billing Issues [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > observation overnight, as I had been having ~6-8 seizures before I was given > a relaxant there to slow them down. ) G./ I live in Vancouver and when I got an involuntary ambulance ride after having a seizure on the bus, I was sent a bill for $50 or $75 (sorry, it was a while ago). These things vary by province. The hospital also wouldn't let me leave until my hubby arrived to sign me out, and insisted on giving me IV Dilantin over my strenuous objections.
Charani - 05 Sep 2004 10:14 GMT > I live in Vancouver and when I got an involuntary ambulance ride after > having a seizure on the bus, I was sent a bill for $50 or $75 (sorry, it was > a while ago). These things vary by province. > The hospital also wouldn't let me leave until my hubby arrived to sign me > out, and insisted on giving me IV Dilantin over my strenuous objections. We don't get billed in the UK as a general rule. I *think* the only exception to that is a road accident under certain circumstances, although I've never heard of any charges actually being implemented. Possibly someone else in the UK may have heard.
UnknowableOrigin - 02 Sep 2004 14:55 GMT >We have a 3-tier system in some places over here. When a 999/911 call >goes in, someone called a First Responder is sent immediately. They >are usually locally based people familiar with the area. They are >trained in First Aid. They assess the situation, whilst giving >initial First Aid. that sounds like an eminently sensible system. Are we speaking of Great Britain? Hurray for reason actually getting implemented into national policy!
:-) Charani - 02 Sep 2004 15:16 GMT >>We have a 3-tier system in some places over here. When a 999/911 call >>goes in, someone called a First Responder is sent immediately. They [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > Britain? Hurray for reason actually getting implemented into national policy! > :-) Yes, that is in GB :))
I don't know how widespread the system is :))
Satch - 01 Sep 2004 22:16 GMT > Greetings - I had a grand mal last Saturday night while attending an AA > meeting [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > > Thanks, Tim Hello Tim,
I am sorry to hear this, but I am affraid there are still too many people out there that do not really know what is happening with people suffering from a grand mal / tonic clonic seizure experience. If they are not aware of your condition, then there first reaction will most likely be to call 911. Once I had my tonic clonic seizure, it happened nearby a busy cross road and almost everyone stopped their car, stopped bicycling / stopped walking and they all seems to call 911 (when the 911 operator did not pay attention, 10 ambulances should have come to rescue me).
My boss also suffers from similar symptoms (no epilepsy by the way) and once I came in the office, my colleagues were on top of him to stop him shaking all over his body while my boss was laying on the floor. Seeing that behavior was not nice because you know that this is not part of "first aid" in these kind of situation and I also thought that "this could happen to me".
You can tell these guys what to do, trying to educate them, but there are always people freeking out making things worse.
Cheers, Marco
gaross - 02 Sep 2004 00:05 GMT > Greetings - I had a grand mal last Saturday night while attending an AA meeting > - despite the Depakote treatment. The other alcoholics and drug addicts [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > meeting normally after regaining consciousness. > Thanks, Tim I expect you have a Medic Alert Bracelet, although they'd probably Still call an ambulance anyway.
About 5 years ago I found out the Toronto Ep. Association had business cards whose Reverse lists--
FIRST AID FOR SEIZURES -- the 5 items under that--> " Remain Calm -- let the seizure run its course -- Protect the person from further injury -- Do not put anything in their mouth -- Roll the person onto their side -- In rare occasions, if the seizure lasts more than (RED TEXT HERE ) 5 MINUTES (end red text) or repeats, CALL FOR MEDICAL ATTENTION. " I had 3 of those cards plastic-coated for about 40 cents each -- I carry One in the front of my wallet (where someone would find it if looking for ID), in the Front Pocket of my Shirt-Pocket Daytimer/Calendar pad (ditto if looking for id.), and the third is just a spare. Places where I was having repeated seizures before I had control I told the security guards there about the Cards and showed them one, since they **hadn't had a CPR Course ( !! ). That won't prevent someone panicking and calling 911 or ?? if they don't look for ID. on you. But maybe when we get Old, we'll appreciate people who at least *care enough about our well-being to CALL for Help. It's better than just stepping over us or thinking we're Drunk... G./
Anna LeBlanc - 07 Sep 2004 20:06 GMT Tim and all, When my son was 28 he had his first seizure. His wife of 8 months was pretty sure what was going on, got him to the floor, on his side, moved furniture out of the way, called 911 and got dressed. Because he'd not had a seizure before I feel that was a reasonable thing to do.
The firefighters/paramedics arrived and set out to assess whether it could be caused by a blood sugar problem. Since his wife couldn't assure them that it wasn't, they felt they needed to draw a blood sample then and there. He was, by then, post ichtal, disoriented, and quite resistive of having a blood draw. In the process they wrestled him to the floor, put a knee in his back and got their damned blood. Guess what, no blood sugar problem. Eventually they packed him up and took him about five minutes away to the hospital where he had a one more seizure.
The really bad news is that in the process of getting the blood sample they fractured several of his vertebrae. That has caused him ongoing pain, and other limitations. He's somewhat better now, though a couple of inches shorter, and will never be as he was.
He brought a lawsuit against the city paramedics. They tried to claim that he must have injured himself in the seizure, that the kind of pressure they applied couldn't have produced the kind of injury he had, etc. The issue became whether they were following their own procedures. Apparently they were. He lost the law suit, at considerable expense for expert witnesses. The only good news is that the city has modified their procedures. I don¹t know all the details.
Well, the other good news is that he is stabilized on his medications and has no further seizures. And he has been able to put this horrible incident behind him and not let it run his life now.
Does anyone know whether there are *national* guidelines a group of paramedics could adopt that would have prevented this?
Anna
> Greetings - I had a grand mal last Saturday night while attending an AA > meeting [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > > Thanks, Tim
|
|
|