Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Epilepsy / March 2004
Opinions On How Seizures Are Classified
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Dawn Compton - 07 Mar 2004 06:42 GMT I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your opinions, not what doctors would say. Usually, if I tell someone I have seizures, they automatically classify me as epileptic. How do you all feel about this also?
Mary Fisher - 07 Mar 2004 08:58 GMT I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your opinions, not what doctors would say. Usually, if I tell someone I have seizures, they automatically classify me as epileptic. How do you all feel about this also?
I would say that's true but I believe that even my husband's twitches as he's falling asleep are a form of epilepsy. That's an opinion.
Another is that posts in rich text (HTML), especially when they are coloured and even more so when they contain movement, are irritating and inappropriate for Usenet.
Please Dawn, will you adjust your pc to send Plain Text messages to the newsgroup? I know that it's inventive and fun for you but it's not for everyone and if you want us to read your posts and take them seriously we must be encouraged to do so.
Thanks in advance,
Mary
BillX - 07 Mar 2004 11:29 GMT This definition on the meaning of "epilepsy" comes directly from Webster:
any of various disorders marked by disturbed electrical rhythms of the central nervous system and typically manifested by convulsive attacks usually with clouding of consciousness
So anyone with disturbed electrical rhythms regardless of source or manifestation fits under the epilepsy umbrella... at least according to Webster :-)
Mary Fisher - 07 Mar 2004 16:54 GMT > This definition on the meaning of "epilepsy" comes directly from Webster: > [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > manifestation fits under the epilepsy umbrella... at least according to > Webster :-) Makes sense to me. Mary
CyberCafe - 07 Mar 2004 17:33 GMT > I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of > seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your > opinions, not what doctors would say. Usually, if I tell someone I > have > seizures, they automatically classify me as epileptic. How do you all > feel about this also? In my head, mentally, I do separate people who have temporary seizures from those who have a more permanent type. I mean, anybody can have a seizure if the conditions are right. What about febrile seizures that a child will outgrow or seizures caused by pregnacy. For some reason, I don't include examples like those just given as true epilepsy. I don't know if doctors would agree, but that's just the way my head thinks about it.
Barb
Dick - 09 Mar 2004 06:10 GMT > > I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of > > seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > Barb > I have an AVM and I don't classify it as epilepsy. Pablo - 10 Mar 2004 07:30 GMT > In my head, mentally, I do separate people who have temporary seizures > from those who have a more permanent type. I mean, anybody can have a [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > > Barb G'day barb that sounds just about right on the money to me. my father had a couple of seizures after he had a stroke but it's been two years since then and he hasn't had any more seizures (and doesn't take aed's) so you hardly class him as having epilepsy. so where as in this excerpt from webster's dictionary says:- "any of various disorders marked by disturbed electrical rhythms of the central nervous system and typically manifested by convulsive attacks usually with clouding of consciousness" it doesn't differentiate between someone who may suffer a seizure due to a trauma to the head or a medical condition as opposed to those of us who are permanently afflicted with the condition. pablo
Dawn Compton - 14 Mar 2004 20:19 GMT In my opinion, I think if someone has seizures (more than one and for a longer period of time than a few months), then it should be dianosed as epilepsy.
NMF - 15 Mar 2004 02:29 GMT Dear Dawn,
Typically the diagnosis of epilepsy involves the minimum criteria of recurrent seizures. The individual most often will display recurrent seizures in order to be diagnosis with status epilepticus. However, the various factors that can influence the severity and type of seizure will all be used in the classification schema of epilepsy syndrome. Thus, the "recurrent seizures" category will be one "check" in the many categories that must be present in order for the diagnosis of epileptic syndrome to be valid.
The site that you looked at stating that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of seizure disorder is not entirely correct . For example, seizures can be a secondary consequences of a variety of different factors (i.e. traumatic head injury, vascular disruption). This really boils down to the argument: Can one have a seizure or convulsion without being effectively an epileptic? The simplest answer is, "Yes". The prime example of this are single febrile seizures during childhood associated with fever. The individual may exhibit only one seizure, yet not considered epileptic. Thus, seizure number even though it may be a good indicator suggesting an underlying epilepsy syndrome may not be the most appropriate diagnosis.
We are use to often seeing the continual pairing of "convulsion" or "seizure" with epilepsy that it tends to be one in the same to some people. Thus, it is no surprise that most ordinary people, when they hear the word "seizure", think the person has epilepsy. There are many of examples of these inappropriate associations within medical and general language.
One thing that must be considered is that even though the measurement involves essentially the same manifested behavior, i.e. seizure or convulsion, the underlying etiology involved in each of these circumstances may be quite different fundamentally. This really means that although the clinical symptoms can be similar, the actual source of the problem could be quite different. Diagnosis of epilepsy and their classifications are somewhat of an a ongoing practice and there is still considerable debate in this area. Thus, your confusion regarding the subject is well warranted.
I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your opinions, not what doctors would say. Usually, if I tell someone I have seizures, they automatically classify me as epileptic. How do you all feel about this also?
gaross - 15 Mar 2004 05:28 GMT Dawn wrote I read on one site that epilepsy is defined as having any kind of seizure disorder. Do you all agree about this? I just want your opinions, not what doctors would say. Usually, if I tell someone I have seizures, they automatically classify me as epileptic. How do you all feel about this also?
G: Below is an Extract from a Post I did about a month ago. Except for 'Howdy Dave's' Website (usually follow one of his posts), these ones from Idaho give a good description (under the First Aid Charts) of what several of the most common seizure types 'look like'.
Within the Idaho site, or via Dave's site if you still have some of his Posts up, there's a link to the Ep. Foundation of America, or try http://efa.org
Julie's site (Idaho), and Howdy Dave's have more detail on information about epilepsy **from a **patient's point of view.** The EFA site has detailed information Plus a Medications Glossary if you've been prescribed anything for the type of seizure you have. The Medication Description will describe which seizure types (sometimes more than one) that it is commonly Prescribed For. You might find your 'type' there if you have something prescribed. (This will ALSO reduce time spent, reading Search Sites or other sites, about Seizure Types that don't apply TO YOU.)
If you've been given a Name for the type you might have, it would help. Alternatively you might be able to tell which type you are having, from the Symptoms others might witness, under the First Aid Chart which describes some symptoms that are different or specific for some of the more common seizure types. Others will post later, likely after the weekend is over. (Schools are out in Canada, not sure about U.S. so some of the regulars might be away for the weekend.)
Older post I did (extract) [Comments at top were more specific to the person I replied to then] /G. -->
There are a number of sites around the group that get posted from time to time. Some of the symptoms (at bottom) that you might see, might be displayed on one of the First Aid for Seizures Websites below -- likely to first 'seizure' one. If you look down the first aid chart, I think it shows 3 or 4 main types of seizures down one column, then the types of things that can be done. Under the Symptoms or Sensations columns are the types of 'aura' or sensation that might be specific to a particular seizure type. That is usually used by a Doctor at first to identify possible location where the seizure is Launching From. Then further tests (EEG, MRI, CT) might look at more detailed internals. For *your use, all you likely need is the chart, and the Symptoms with the First Aid for whichever type most closely matches what he has. NOTE - within Julie's Idaho Main website, and on Howdy Dave's there are links to the Ep. Foundation of America that has a Medications Glossary and more detail on specific seizure types that you can search out at your own pace. I also included the one entrance at bottom below. Also some of the minor seizures that don't result in loss of consciousness, might be grouped under either 'absences' (if a person appears to 'zone out' for short periods), or simple partials (that might just include an Aura then a return to normal. *If someone has been having these for a long time, these *might seem like the New Normal for them so they may not be Aware that those are an Aura. OR they might prefer to 'not see them' for what they are. //
*********************************************************** Each of the sites can be put on a Bookmark or Favourite so that you can then refer back to see if there are updates without needing to remember the www address each time. hth. G.R. ********** For anyone who hasn't seen these already --> The General Site that Julie operates for Epilepsy Idaho group is at: http://www.epilepsyidaho.org .
The 'First Aid chart' I frequently refer to can be located by entering and wandering about site above, but can be reached direct at http://www.epilepsyidaho.org/seizure.htm . There's a Second topic added about 4 months ago that goes more into First Aid in Water, on Aircraft, etc. It's at http://www.epilepsyidaho.org/seizure2.htm .
Also accessible from top site, but more detail on Learning about Epilepsy can be found at http://www.epilepsyidaho/learn.htm . That one has quite a few more links, information on kids newly diagnosed? (I think) and general questions that others might ask, or those newly diagnosed.
If there's no link there to a Medications Glossary, the Ep. Foundation of America has one (of several) within http://efa.org . G./
> "Chakolate" <> wrote in message > > Hi, > > I assume that everyone has different warning signs for a seizure, but is > > there a list somewhere of common ones? > > TIA, > > Chakolate
|
|
|