Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Diabetes / August 2007
I'm gonna try it.
|
|
Thread rating:  |
hoodyup@yahoo.com - 30 Jul 2007 22:44 GMT Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health food store today and bought a box. It is not labeled as a sweetener but a "supplement". But it is packaged in little packets just like Splenda, NutraSweet or Sweet n Low. I will try it for the first time in my coffee tomorrow AS a sweetener NOT a supplement (rebel that I am). First, let me clarify: I, 1) am a diabetic, t2 since 9/06 2) have been attempting to control my diabetes with diet and excercise 3) am in general trying to eat more healthy, less processed foods 4) like my coffee to taste sweet, but want to avoid sugar or artificial sweeteners 5) respect the many thoughtful posters in this group and value their input 6) do not understand the anger, intolerance or level of intensity that simply posting on sweetener topics provokes in, of all places, a diabetic forum 7) am not a troll, nor do I wish to purchase a bridge 8) do not eat, read or support SPAM 9) have no friends named Betty and don't drink Martinis with Rich Murray 10) welcome any responses from people who use Stevia, have issues with Stevia or just want to talk about how much they hate people who post about sweeteners 11) apologize in advance for any anxiety caused to Ted 12) believe people who number individual sentences are obsessive
Wish me luck. Best to everyone on the group. Happy Monday!
Andrew t2 since 9/06 (see item #1) D&E (see item #2) A1c 5.5
Cheri - 30 Jul 2007 22:50 GMT hoodyup@yahoo.com wrote in message
>10) welcome any responses from people who use Stevia, have issues with >Stevia or just want to talk about how much they hate people who post >about sweeteners I have a box of Stevia packets in my cupboard. Also, I have the Stevia drops. I hate the taste of both of them, that's why they're still there. I've spent a few years, testing a bit in some foods to see if it could hide the taste etc., but no luck so far.
Cheri
Julie Bove - 31 Jul 2007 01:24 GMT > hoodyup@yahoo.com wrote in message >>10) welcome any responses from people who use Stevia, have issues [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > there. I've spent a few years, testing a bit in some foods to see if > it could hide the taste etc., but no luck so far. You couldn't pay me to try that stuff. My mom tried it and said it was horrid.
hoodyup@yahoo.com - 31 Jul 2007 03:36 GMT Well, I was intending to wait to try it in my coffee, but...I was over at my mother-in-law's house and it so happened she had some in a bowl. So I stuck my finger in and licked it...e. eer . kkkk...thud (falls over dead). Nah, not terrible...but it don't taste natural. It tastes exactly like saccharin. Right down to the sickly sweet forever aftertaste.. I'll still try it in my coffee tomorrow and test my BG's afterward. With the amount of heavy cream I use, it should kill the aftertaste if I don't use too much. My wife believes I should go sweetener free in my coffee but I'm holding onto this one simple pleasure like a drowning rat. She's lucky, she's Norwegian and has an updated pancreas. She can eat carbs all day with sugar on top and have a BG of 80 the whole time. (Grrrr). I'm interested in peoples opinions on the health aspect of this (Stevia) and any articles relating to it's safety. I've read lots of New Age stuff promoting it and a few vague articles saying "may" or "possibly linked to" against it, but nothing definitive. Oh, well....it only has to sweeten one cup of coffee per day, not raise the dead. Love Y'all, Andrew
johnniemccoy@ - 31 Jul 2007 03:47 GMT > Well, I was intending to wait to try it in my coffee, but...I was over > at my mother-in-law's house and it so happened she had some in a [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > sweeten one cup of coffee per day, not raise the dead. Love Y'all, > Andrew That's all you'll find.... "may cause", etc.... the same as every other known item has been shown to "may cause" something. Academic though, since everybody says it tastes like crap....haha.
John
johnniemccoy@ - 30 Jul 2007 22:50 GMT > Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks > around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Andrew Right on... damn the naysayers. I hope you find it to be the best thing since sliced bread... uh, well, maybe not bread... but good, anyway.
John
ted rosenberg - 30 Jul 2007 23:01 GMT > Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks > around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > > The anger is because Stevia is bad for people, and Rick, Betty, and all are trying to make money off of scamming diabetics
Beware, you are probably getting pure sugar with a little anise added for flavor\Since the crap is a "supplement", it is not covered by the Pure Food and Drug Act. Unless it contains imported Stevia (which is illegal) ) they can put just about anything in the box, and call it just about anything. LETTUCE requires proper identification, "Stevia" doesn't \\I hope you don't do too much damage to yourself putting whatever they are selling into your system - if you are lucky, it won't be Stevia.
Will, T2 - 31 Jul 2007 00:04 GMT y
>> 10) welcome any responses from people who use Stevia, have issues with >> Stevia or just want to talk about how much they hate people who post [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] >\\I hope you don't do too much damage to yourself putting whatever they >are selling into your system - if you are lucky, it won't be Stevia. Hi Andrew...
I think Ted is right... I tried Stevia in 2005, when I was new to diabetes.... It turned out to be wholly unsatisfactory and a waste of money. Maybe your experiece will be different, but I doubt it. In my experience, I think Splenda is just about the best non-sugar, non-caloric sweetener out there, but I really do enjoy a diet coke, every now and then, and there are absolutely no ill effects from the aspertame. Diet Ginger-Ale is my runner up favorite.
Whatever you do, good luck.
Will, T2
johnniemccoy@ - 31 Jul 2007 01:05 GMT > y >>> 10) welcome any responses from people who use Stevia, have issues with [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > > Will, T2 Diet drinks, at least to me, have come a long way. I remember when they first came out...yuuuck. Now, again just to me, they taste just as good as the sticky sweet ones. I think, if aspertame were dangerous, we'd be dropping like flies by now....lol.
John
Cheri - 31 Jul 2007 01:07 GMT johnniemccoy@ wrote in message ...
>Diet drinks, at least to me, have come a long way. I remember when they >first came out...yuuuck. Now, again just to me, they taste just as good as >the sticky sweet ones. I think, if aspertame were dangerous, we'd be >dropping like flies by now....lol. > >John I love aspartame, but I can't handle Splenda, due to a really nasty aftertaste. I'm not worried about the safety of either of them though.
Cheri
Jim Horne - 31 Jul 2007 00:43 GMT >> > The anger is because Stevia is bad for people, and Rick, Betty, and all [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > \\I hope you don't do too much damage to yourself putting whatever they > are selling into your system - if you are lucky, it won't be Stevia. Anger is bad, Ted. Many things we do are bad. Individualism is not bad, Ted. Let him do as he wants.
As for what's in the stuff, there's no telling what's in your properly labeled food any longer...Ask China.
BTW, I'm an old timer (If 7 years is an old timer) here. So no need to go beating up the archives to check me out to see if I'm somebody's shill. This place hasn't changes a bit in some ways...sigh...
Jim
johnniemccoy@ - 31 Jul 2007 01:01 GMT > The anger is because Stevia is bad for people, Yeah, I've heard that.... can't find any reference to it though. Seen a lot of articles that boil down to "who knows" but no "definitely is."
John
Loretta Eisenberg - 31 Jul 2007 00:10 GMT Andrew welcome to our group. I see from this post, you dont take yourself too seriously and probably a lot of fun.
I have never seen Stevia, I dont know much about Stevia but I would like to hear how you enjoyed it.
I myself like Splenda over the other known kinds
loretta
Alan S - 31 Jul 2007 00:22 GMT >Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks >around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] >Andrew t2 since 9/06 (see item #1) >D&E (see item #2) A1c 5.5 I'd appreciate advice of the results of the experiment, both on taste and BG's. Cheers, Alan, T2, Australia. d&e, metformin 1500mg, ezetrol 10mg Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter. -- http://loraltraveloz.blogspot.com/ latest: Mossman Gorge in the Daintree Rainforest http://loraldiabetes.blogspot.com/ latest: Self-Testing and Type 2 Management
johnniemccoy@ - 31 Jul 2007 01:08 GMT >>Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks >>around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health [quoted text clipped - 34 lines] > > Cheers, Alan, I don't remember seeing any posts about people liking it... just trashing it....lol
John
Alan S - 31 Jul 2007 04:04 GMT >I don't remember seeing any posts about people liking it... just trashing >it....lol > >John I wrote what follows back in May 2004. I haven't seen a lot to change my mind since. I should add that I've never used the stuff, I'm just interested in rational evaluation of any product that may assist us as diabetics.
Sadly, neither the anti-Stevia people here nor the anti-aspartame twits like Murray read it in full and both used it to support their irrational platforms.
So here it is again. I haven't checked if there is further research since that time. Those interested could try searching on Highwire, Scholar or Medline - or any other good medical search resource.
Babies and Bathwater http://tinyurl.com/37dsxj
Try something difficult. Forget Martini for a moment. Forget the spammers, twits, MLMers, and weirdos.
Now, pretend it's not Stevia, it's not a sweetener, it's not promoted as an alternative to aspartame. And I'll repeat that I have no personal interest for or against.
Let's call it "kickapoo joy juice", but in Europe the scientists named it after their chief scientist's girlfriend, Stephanie. And discovered that it had some interesting outcomes when researching glycemic control for diabetics.
I'll repeat that: not as a sweetener - as a possible future medication, after proper research, refinement, approval and controlled production, for glycemic control in diabetes.
Now read what I originally said again.
In case it's disappeared off your newsreader, I've repeated it below:
from "Stevia and Glycemic Hypertension Control" May 15th 2004
Hullo All.
It appears that many people did not see this the first time round, and it got "lost" in the expected argument on supplements etc.
But in the various arguments on Stevia, it's safety, or danger of side-effects, and use as a sweetener, it seems to have been missed that there are other implications apart from sweetness as a sugar substitute.
I should preface what follows by saying that I started investigating this knowing nothing about Stevia other than the statements, some quite strongly negative, made by posters on this group and m.h.d. So I was expecting to find negative reports on the safety of stevia.
I had no real interest in the product, have never used it, and would not know where to buy it. But, with a little time on my hands I decided to do a little research.
I still found no info on medscape, and little on druginfo. But get ready for a surprise, below is what I found on medline. The studies may be devalued by some because some are on small groups, some are on rats, none are in the US.
But they were all recent, well after the FDA and EU decisions, and they were all positive.
And the most surprising thing for me was not just that they imply or say stevia is safe, but that they imply that it may be a future drug for type 2 diabetes management. I have only selected some of the reports, and I have only searched medscape and medline with the term:
"stevia rebaudiana bertoni". I won't be doing any more research at this stage, but it is certainly food for thought. You may wish to extend this start if you have an interest.
I will at least have an open mind on this product for the future.
I have used selective snipping for brevity. Use the links for further details.
[note, I've updated old links - Alan S 2007] http://www.medscape.com/medline/abstract/14681845
Small study in Denmark on "Twelve type 2 diabetic patients were included in an acute, paired cross-over study."
Stevioside acts directly on pancreatic beta cells to secrete insulin: actions independent of cyclic adenosine monophosphate and adenosine triphosphate-sensitive K+-channel activity.
"In conclusion, stevioside and steviol stimulate insulin secretion via a direct action on beta cells. The results indicate that the compounds may have a potential role as antihyperglycemic agents in the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus."
http://www.medscape.com/medline/abstract/14561506
Geuns JM Laboratory of Plant Physiology, Catholic University of Leuven, Kasteelpark Arenberg 31, B 3001 Leuven, Belgium
"The conclusion is that Stevia and stevioside are safe when used as a sweetener. It is suited for both diabetics, and PKU patients, as well as for obese persons intending to lose weight by avoiding sugar supplements in the diet. No allergic reactions to it seem to exist."
http://www.medscape.com/medline/abstract/11924770
Phytomedicine 2002 Jan;9(1):9-14 (ISSN: 0944-7113) Study in Denmark on rats.
"In conclusion, stevioside exerts antihyperglycaemic, insulinotropic, and glucagonostatic actions in the type 2 diabetic GK rat, and may have the potential of becoming a new antidiabetic drug for use in type 2 diabetes."
http://www.medscape.com/medline/abstract/14693305
Clin Ther 2003 Nov;25(11):2797-808 (ISSN: 0149-2918) This study was undertaken to investigate the long-term (2-year) efficacy and tolerability of stevioside in patients with mild essential hypertension.
This was a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in Chinese men and women aged between 20 and 75 years with mild essential hypertension (systolic blood pressure [SBP] 140-159 mm Hg and diastolic blood pressure [DBP] 90-99 mm Hg). Patients took capsules containing 500 mg stevioside powder or placebo 3 times daily for 2 years "after 2 years, 6 of 52 patients (11.5%) in the stevioside group had left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH), compared with 17 of 50 patients (34.0%) in the placebo group (P < 0.001). Of those who did not have LVH at baseline, 3 of 46 patients (6.5%) in the stevioside group had developed LVH after 2 years, compared with 9 of 37 patients (24.3%) in the placebo group (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: In this 2-year study in Chinese patients with mild hypertension, oral stevioside significantly decreased SBP and DBP compared with placebo. QOL was improved, and no significant adverse effects were noted." Cheers, Alan, T2, Australia. d&e, metformin 1500mg, ezetrol 10mg Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter. -- http://loraltraveloz.blogspot.com/ latest: Mossman Gorge in the Daintree Rainforest http://loraldiabetes.blogspot.com/ latest: Self-Testing and Type 2 Management
johnniemccoy@ - 31 Jul 2007 04:26 GMT >>I don't remember seeing any posts about people liking it... just trashing >>it....lol [quoted text clipped - 156 lines] > > Cheers, Alan, But, Alan, this run contray to the unshakable belief that, "that stuff is poisen."....lol
John
hoodyup@yahoo.com - 31 Jul 2007 07:17 GMT > On Tue, 31 Jul 2007 00:08:00 GMT, "johnniemccoy@" > [quoted text clipped - 162 lines] > latest: Mossman Gorge in the Daintree Rainforesthttp://loraldiabetes.blogspot.com/ > latest: Self-Testing and Type 2 Management Yes, Alan, these studies were the kind of things I was curious about. I mean, come on, it's a sugar substitute--no, it's a diabetic medication--No, it's a floor polish...Sound too good to be true? I've seen lot's of weird concoctions on the internet since my DX. I wouldn't think of just trying all or any of them without getting some real info, from doctors, scientists, people on this group...Thank you for for posting these studies. I did search ASD 2004 and found yours to be one of the few sane posts at the time. I felt pretty safe about trying this stuff, seems pretty benign and it's been around for a while. The FDA is not my ultimate authority on matters of my personal choice. Our govenment has a history of supression for not altogether altrusitic reasons. Although, the packets that I bought also contains rice maltodextrin which is, in fact, a sugar. I think it is in there for bulking it up because otherwise you'd use way too much. So I will probably want to look for 100% pure Stevioside or maybe even the leaves and make my own extract. I just prefer things to be less processed. I really don't use sweeteners for much other than coffee. If I'm going to be bad, I have a nibble of whatever my wife is eating. Thanks again for the links to the studies. Cheers!
Andrew
Nicky - 31 Jul 2007 18:26 GMT >Wish me luck. Best to everyone on the group. Happy Monday! Luck - you rebel, you : )
Nicky. T2 dx 05/04 + underactive thyroid D&E, 100ug thyroxine Last A1c 5.6% BMI 25
dlflick@aol.com - 31 Jul 2007 18:37 GMT On Jul 30, 5:44 pm, hood...@yahoo.com wrote:
> Stevia. There. I said it. Stevia, stevia, stevia. Whew. (looks > around after ducking to avoid the pelting). I went out to the health [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] > Andrew t2 since 9/06 (see item #1) > D&E (see item #2) A1c 5.5 The first thing that I missed being able to put plenty of sugar in after diagnosis was my morning coffee. I have found that equal parts of "Sweet"n Low" and "Equal" tastes more like real sugar than anything else I have found. Dave
hoodyup@yahoo.com - 31 Jul 2007 20:21 GMT On Jul 31, 10:37 am, dlfl...@aol.com wrote:
> On Jul 30, 5:44 pm, hood...@yahoo.com wrote: > [quoted text clipped - 39 lines] > > - Show quoted text - Well, I just finished my Stevia-laden (2 packets) coffee. I tried it after a just one packet and there was no noticeable sweetening going on. So I dumped in the second one. I'd say it tastes no different than 2 packets of Aspartame. It wasn't really that sweet (but I like my coffee reeeeally strong). So, I'm wondering if I should just tough it out and go without the sweetness. I used to just pour sugar into the coffee and count to say 4 or 5 seconds worth in my 20oz cup of coffee. It was too sweet even for the ants. I cut back to just 4 packets worth of real sugar and it was still pretty sweet. Then I got DX'd and my wife got on me to quit the sugar. I really liked the sugar, but I got used to Aspartame. Then I tried Splenda for a couple weeks and at first I thought it was making me tweeky. But it probably was just the bulk coffee I buy that may have had some "killer beans" in it. Anywhoo, Splenda tastes just fine to me also, but my wife is against me using a substance made from chlorine and sugar. I can't say much in favor of the whole chemical product thing, I feel the same way. Margarine was supposed to be great and "much healthier than butter" back in the 50's. Then 40 years later they figured out that all that trans fat was giving people heart attacks. I don't necessarily want to grow a tail or mutate into a fish in 20 or so years. But part of me says "what the hell, you've already got diabetes--grow the tail". Ramble ramble (incoherent coffee mumblings). BG before the coffee -- 126 BG 30 mins after coffee 131. Not too much difference, could be the meter, could be me. Anyway, Stevia's not the cure for my T2 that the New Ager's were peddling. Possibly the saccharine taste turns off so many people that they run from any sweet things in horror thus lowering their BG's from the exercise. The packets do have "rice maltodextrin" in it, 1g. Total sugars 1g. Hmmmm....the Splenda also has "maltodextrin" and Aspartame has "Dextrose with Maltodextrin"....Ahh, foooey. Can't get away from that stuff. The outside of the box of Stevia says "contains no sugar, salt, yeast, wheat, gluten, corn, soy, milk, egg, shellfish, preservatives, artificial colors or artificial flavors". So what is "rice maltodextrin"? Anyway, I'm leaving the sweetener debates to the diehards. I'm not sold on anything at this point except Diet and Exercise, low-carb, moderation in your vices and excess in your virtues. Or, something like that. Love and Peace,
Andrew t2 (still) D&E a1c5.5
BG 121 1 hr after the coffee. No miracles, but I am getting reeeeally hungry.
W. Baker - 31 Jul 2007 21:12 GMT : Well, I just finished my Stevia-laden (2 packets) coffee. I tried it : after a just one packet and there was no noticeable sweetening going [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] : sugar, but I got used to Aspartame. Then I tried Splenda for a couple : weeks and at first I thought it was making me tweeky. But it probably I was lucky, I guess. I first strted drinking cofee in High School when I wnted a drink that wa not fattening as I was a chubby(far from obese) teen. I wanted something tht wasn't "babyish" to drink when I was out with my friends adn there was no diet soda at that time. I learned to drink the coffee black and unsweetened adn do so to this day.
Wendy
Julie Bove - 01 Aug 2007 02:18 GMT > I was lucky, I guess. I first strted drinking cofee in High School when I > wnted a drink that wa not fattening as I was a chubby(far from obese) > teen. I wanted something tht wasn't "babyish" to drink when I was out > with my friends adn there was no diet soda at that time. I learned to > drink the coffee black and unsweetened adn do so to this day. I started drinking coffee in high school too. We had diet soda, but in those days refills weren't free. Now it seems they are at most restaurants. You only had to pay for coffee once and the refills were limitless. I always drank it black. Now here in the Seattle area, it's difficult to get a plain cup of regular coffee. Everyone is pushing the fancy blends and flavors. I don't like those.
Nicky - 31 Jul 2007 22:47 GMT >The packets do have "rice maltodextrin" in it, 1g. >Total sugars 1g. Hmmmm....the Splenda also has "maltodextrin" and >Aspartame has "Dextrose with Maltodextrin"....Ahh, foooey. Can't get >away from that stuff. I buy liquid Splenda from Canada, no fillers. I use a single drop in my morning tea, just the right amount of sweet : ) You could probably buy liquid Stevia, too, or try the uncut leaf - personally, as it's illegal to own over here, I'll just stick with the chlorinated sugar...
Nicky. T2 dx 05/04 + underactive thyroid D&E, 100ug thyroxine Last A1c 5.6% BMI 25
Alan S - 31 Jul 2007 22:54 GMT >Well, I just finished my Stevia-laden (2 packets) coffee. I tried it >after a just one packet and there was no noticeable sweetening going [quoted text clipped - 39 lines] >BG 121 1 hr after the coffee. No miracles, but I am getting reeeeally >hungry. Nothing to do with stevia, but have you thought of trying cinnamon with your coffee. I had never been a black coffee drinker, always took milk. However, I found that even the small quantity of carbs in the milk in my morning coffee would spike me. So I tried it black and didn't like it much regardless of the sweetener I used.
Then someone asked the regular standard "what about cinnamon for BG's" question (we should post a standard monthly answer to that one:-) and I decided to check it out. It did nothing for my BG's - but made the black coffee palatable - and now I like it as a start to the day (excuse me ...sip ...*aaaahh*).
I found that powdered cinnamon was no good - it caused a gluggy mess at the bottom of the mug. Instead I crumble some of a piece of cinnamon bark into the ground beans in my coffee-maker so only the flavour is infused and not the powder. Cheers, Alan, T2, Australia. d&e, metformin 1500mg, ezetrol 10mg Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter. -- http://loraltraveloz.blogspot.com/ latest: Mossman Gorge in the Daintree Rainforest http://loraldiabetes.blogspot.com/ latest: Self-Testing and Type 2 Management
hoodyup@yahoo.com - 31 Jul 2007 23:45 GMT > Nothing to do with stevia, but have you thought of trying > cinnamon with your coffee. I had never been a black coffee [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > > - Show quoted text - I'll have to try that. I don't know if I can live without the cream, though. It doesn't spike me, although I get spikes from as little as 5 strawberries or half a cup of cooked veggies in the morning...and sometimes not. I've spent more time blogging about my diabetes these last few days than managing it. Gotta exercise more than my fingers. Enjoy that coffee, mate!
Andrew
Cheri - 31 Jul 2007 23:54 GMT hoodyup@yahoo.com wrote in message
>I'll have to try that. I don't know if I can live without the cream, >though. It doesn't spike me, although I get spikes from as little as [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > >Andrew Cream shouldn't spike you, although milk might depending on the amount. I used to use sugar in my coffee, but no cream. Then I stopped the sugar and started using 1 TBS of cream. It took about a month or so to get used to it, and now I wouldn't like sugar in my coffee, so I guess it's what you get used to.
Cheri
SugarQueen - 01 Aug 2007 00:07 GMT > Well, I just finished my Stevia-laden (2 packets) coffee. I tried it > after a just one packet and there was no noticeable sweetening going [quoted text clipped - 39 lines] > BG 121 1 hr after the coffee. No miracles, but I am getting reeeeally > hungry.- Hide quoted text - WHO NEEDS ALL THAT WEIRD STUFF ANYWAY?
|
|
|