Many of the goodies for diabetics in vegies can be lost in microwaving,
unless cooking water is also consumed:
NY Times
_________________________________________________________________
October 21, 2003
VITAL SIGNS
Nutrition: Cooking Broccoli, Out of the Box
By JOHN O'NEIL
Broccoli is prized as a healthy food in part because it contains high
levels of chemicals believed to protect against heart disease and some
kinds of cancer. Now a new study from Spain suggests that health
lovers hoping to get those benefits keep their broccoli away from the
microwave.
The study, published in the November issue of The Journal of the
Science of Food and Agriculture, found that broccoli cooked by
microwave lost 74 percent to 97 percent of its antioxidant compounds,
which are believed to be healthful. The researchers, from the
University of Murcia at Espinardo, found by contrast that broccoli
cooked by steaming lost less than 10 percent of the same chemicals.
The study's lead researcher, Dr. Cristina Garcia-Viguera, wrote that
nutrients were leached out of the broccoli into its cooking water
during microwaving. Because there is less contact between water and
vegetable during steaming, fewer chemicals are lost, she said.
Marianne Turow, an associate professor of nutrition and food safety at
the Culinary Institute of America, said that she had no reason to
doubt the validity of the study, but that she would not change her
regular practices to keep her broccoli or other vegetables out of
microwaves entirely.
She said it was possible to microwave vegetables with less water than
the researchers used, and sometimes frozen vegetables can be
microwaved without adding any water. "Unless you like raw potatoes,"
she said, "you've got to cook usually, so there will be some loss."
_________________________________________________________________
Alan - 21 Oct 2003 12:51 GMT
>The study's lead researcher, Dr. Cristina Garcia-Viguera, wrote that
> nutrients were leached out of the broccoli into its cooking water
> during microwaving.
Try cooking your greens in the microwave with only the water used to
wash them; I haven't tried it with broccoli but it certainly works for
silverbeet, peas, green beans, and spinach. Serve that small amount of
liquid with the greens and no nutrients are lost.
Also, with veges, always undercook slightly in the microwave, both to
preserve moisture and allow for the internal heat to continue the
cooking process after the microwave is finished.
They will also taste crisper and fresher.
Cheers Alan, T2, Oz
--
Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter.
W. Baker - 21 Oct 2003 16:30 GMT
: Many of the goodies for diabetics in vegies can be lost in microwaving,
: unless cooking water is also consumed:
: NY Times
: _________________________________________________________________
: October 21, 2003
:
: VITAL SIGNS
: Nutrition: Cooking Broccoli, Out of the Box
:
: By JOHN O'NEIL
: Broccoli is prized as a healthy food in part because it contains high
: levels of chemicals believed to protect against heart disease and some
: kinds of cancer. Now a new study from Spain suggests that health
: lovers hoping to get those benefits keep their broccoli away from the
: microwave.
: The study, published in the November issue of The Journal of the
: Science of Food and Agriculture, found that broccoli cooked by
: microwave lost 74 percent to 97 percent of its antioxidant compounds,
: which are believed to be healthful. The researchers, from the
: University of Murcia at Espinardo, found by contrast that broccoli
: cooked by steaming lost less than 10 percent of the same chemicals.
: The study's lead researcher, Dr. Cristina Garcia-Viguera, wrote that
: nutrients were leached out of the broccoli into its cooking water
: during microwaving. Because there is less contact between water and
: vegetable during steaming, fewer chemicals are lost, she said.
: Marianne Turow, an associate professor of nutrition and food safety at
: the Culinary Institute of America, said that she had no reason to
: doubt the validity of the study, but that she would not change her
: regular practices to keep her broccoli or other vegetables out of
: microwaves entirely.
: She said it was possible to microwave vegetables with less water than
: the researchers used, and sometimes frozen vegetables can be
: microwaved without adding any water. "Unless you like raw potatoes,"
: she said, "you've got to cook usually, so there will be some loss."
: _________________________________________________________________
i regularly microwave my fresh vegetables with no added water. they may
have just a bit on them from washing, but there is no need to use lots of
water at all. they taste great and keep their color and i generally cook
them kind of al dente. i can't see why you would use lots of water as it
would take so much more time to heat it up and take out a great deal of
the flavor.
i remember many years ago in cooking class at school being told to steam,
no boil vegetables to retain the vitamins. it looks like this is the same
advice.
wendy-off to more physical therapy- a nice name for organized pain:-)
My wife's computer - 21 Oct 2003 16:33 GMT
> Many of the goodies for diabetics in vegies can be lost in microwaving,
> unless cooking water is also consumed:
Water? Why would one add water to them when microwaving to begin with? It isn't
needed.
--
Chuck
-ô¿ô-
~
email: perry1940@mchsi.com
All outgoing messages checked by Norton Anti-Virus
For psoriasis information go to:
http://www.psoriasis.org/forum/
markd@toad-net.com - 21 Oct 2003 17:54 GMT
One element lost in this news account was in the original study boiling,
microwaving, and steaming were tested. Microwaving was worst, boiling 2nd
and steaming last in goodies lost.
>i regularly microwave my fresh vegetables with no added water. they may
>have just a bit on them from washing, but there is no need to use lots of
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
>wendy-off to more physical therapy- a nice name for organized pain:-)