Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Diabetes / March 2006
Is This A Good Idea?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Ron - 19 Mar 2006 01:07 GMT My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in her being in the hospital. The apparent cause was her doctor screwing around with her insulin dosage; raising it up to a doseage that she *knew* had caused my mother problems before. Quite a few people think my mother's doctor is an idiot, but that's not the issue.
My mother just came home from the hospital [again] today. The same old same old. But this time the doctors at the hospital has decided to do something totally different: they told her to stop taking insulin all together. it sounds like a loopy idea to me, but I might be wrong. Can I have your opinions if stopping her insulin completely is a good-- or even safe-- idea?
Thanks.
Ron
Susan - 19 Mar 2006 01:21 GMT > My mother just came home from the hospital [again] today. The same old > same old. But this time the doctors at the hospital has decided to do > something totally different: they told her to stop taking insulin all > together. it sounds like a loopy idea to me, but I might be wrong. Can > I have your opinions if stopping her insulin completely is a good-- or > even safe-- idea? Ron it sounds as if your mother has been having a really tough time, sorry about that.
There's no way that we on this ng can know enough about your mother's health or medical needs to tell you if she needs insulin, other medications, or not. I would offer, though, that it sounds as if she may need a new doctor, though, since you seem to have lost confidence in the old one.
I sure hope they made that recommendation along with a very intensive bg monitoring recommendation, with instructions for the appropriate dietary adjustments based upon her monitored readings.
Susan
guy - 19 Mar 2006 01:58 GMT >My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or >ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > >Ron I was in the hospital and saw my self going into a hypo.
The nurse came in and was preparing to inject insulin. I was fussng but she was going ahead. Doctor's orders.
At that time my Latin wife came in. It was a real event but I received some antihypo treatment and finally they had to find me some food.
The point is that six years ago and there was very unqualified people serving diabetics.
And a strong Latin wife is not one to be messed with.
Anyway It got me home, which I wanted. The doctor ordered routine will get me very aggressive.
Most are better off if they are the central person in their diabetic care.
BUT hell it no fun to do that.. Gets in the way of insults, politics, religion, and trying to be the expert.
Ozgirl - 19 Mar 2006 02:04 GMT > My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or > ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in > her being in the hospital. The apparent cause was her doctor screwing > around with her insulin dosage; raising it up to a dosage that she
> *knew* had caused my mother problems before. Quite a few people think > my mother's doctor is an idiot, but that's not the issue. [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > I have your opinions if stopping her insulin completely is a good-- or > even safe-- idea? She would have to be a type 2 diabetic for the hospital doctors to say that. If the regular doctor raised it then she is maybe showing higher numbers? How is her diet? She may be able to get by on diet and oral meds. If her doctor isn't an endocrinologist I would urge you to help her to get to one rather than fool around with conflicting advice. Insulin needs to have doses finetuned to suit the amount of carbs a person is eating. A one dose doesn't fit all. A type 2 has insulin resistance, she really needs to be on an oral anti insulin resistance med as well as insulin if needed. But if it was me I would be seeing further advice from a specialist.
Alan S - 19 Mar 2006 04:21 GMT >My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or >ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > >Ron Ron, as Susan said, we couldn't possibly suggest solutions based on that information.
I'd strongly recommend two things. First, see if you can get a doctor - any doctor - to refer her to an endocrinologist as a matter of urgency. If you don't need referrals in your system, then just make the appointment. Make sure that she goes to the appointment armed with a full history of her medical situation. If you don't know where to find an endo, contact a local diabetes support group to see if you can get recommendations. If she needs, and wants, your support go with her.
Second, while she waits for the appointment, read this and pass it on to her: http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org/NewlyDiagnosed.htm
PS If her doctor is an idiot - it IS an issue. But first, get her to one that isn't.
Cheers, Alan, T2, Australia. d&e, metformin 2x500mg
 Signature Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter.
Julie Bove - 19 Mar 2006 06:28 GMT > My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or > ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > I have your opinions if stopping her insulin completely is a good-- or > even safe-- idea? Is your mom type 1 or 2? A type 1 without insulin will die. A type 2 may or may not need insulin. Did the Dr. do a C-Peptide test? And why did the Dr. screw around with her insulin dose? Isn't this something the patient does using a sliding scale? I really don't know. I've never used insulin.
 Signature See my webpage: http://mysite.verizon.net/juliebove/index.htm
oldal4865 - 19 Mar 2006 13:54 GMT Ron wrote in message <1142726874.108093.115950@p10g2000cwp.googlegroups.com>...
>My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or >ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > >Ron ". . . .The apparent cause was her doctor screwing around with her insulin dosage. . ."
I control my own insulin dosage and have done so for years. Your mother doesn't seem able to do this so the hospital doctors suggested that she just stop all together. I would guess that they did this because many docs regard the risk of hypos to be worst than the risk of high blood sugars in older folks.
Maybe she can stop insulin, maybe she can't. Some comments (guesses ? ?) in random order:
1. She is probably Type 2. That means she should be doing something about her Insulin Resistance as well. You didn't mention anti-Insulin Resistance meds. . .metformin and/or (Actos or Avandia). They are now the preferred "first meds" for T2 diabetics. If she is not taking any, perhaps starting one or two might give her enough control to allow her to go off insulin.
2. Some docs give patients beta stimulators such as Glucotrol, Glyburide, Amaryl, etc. They force her beta cells to pour out whatever insulin they can. This can lead to trouble with hypos, especially if the patient is also taking the more controllable insulin injections.
Making a choice between beta stimulator therapy and insulin injections can be tricky in older folks. In younger folks, the insulin injections have more favorable effects. In older folks, the care and attention needed for insulin therapy may be too daunting.
Note that I am 64, choose my own insulin doses and inject several times a day. My friend Jim is in his late 70's and does the same. "Daunting" and "Older folks" are relative terms.
3. As convenient as pills can be for Type 2 diabetes therapy, there often comes a time when enough beta cells are dead that none of the pills will do the job by themselves. If she has reached that level of cell death, insulin is the only therapy that will work and that's that.
However, steady insulin therapy has been shown to permit Type 2 beta cells to rest and regenerate. Nine years of insulin therapy may have allowed enough of your mother's beta cells to regenerate so that she can now get by with pills, exercise and diet control.
4. There are 10-classroom-hour insulin training courses at many hospitals. Doctors can't match a 10-classroom-hour training course in a few 30-minute office visits. If she hasn't had classroom insulin training, maybe it's time she did. Perhaps then she could control her own dosages and avoid these surprise hypoglycemic incidents.
If she takes a class, she has a chance of getting to know a good Nurse-Certified Diabetes Educator (CDE). A good CDE will beat a doc when it comes to insulin management. They do this all day, every day and can spend an hour on the phone with a patient. The docs just can't squeeze out the time to do this kind of stuff
5. The old-fashioned insulin, "Insulin N" (NPH) is notorious for causing surprise hypoglycemic incidents. I hope your mother is/was using one of the more modern and more controllable basal metabolism insulins such as Lantus or Levemir. If not, she needs some advice from a diabetes expert.
6. The older, standard before-meal insulin, "Insulin R" (Regular) tends to produce surprise hypoglycemic incidents because of its slow action. Folks get lulled into taking too high a dose because the slow Insulin R absorption allows sugars to spike. Then the diabetic experiences hypos when the food is totally digested but the slow Insulin R is still entering her blood. The more modern before-meal insulins such as Humalog and Novolog are faster and thus can more closely match insulin absorption rate with food digestion rate.
That's six questions for the two of you and her medical team to debate. Come on back after the debates, we can keep going. We haven't even started on DAFNE and the basal-bolus approach.
Note especially that Type 2 diabetes is strongly hereditary. All this stuff about anti-Insulin Resistance meds, diet and exercise apply to you and your siblings as well. In fact, right now you would be best served if you took strong action to:
1. Lose fat lb, especially abdominal fat 2. Gain muscle lb (Ugh, weight lifting) 3. Exercise every day, the more vigorously the better 4. Cut your carb intake, aim for the slowly-digesting carbs, spread your daily carb over several small meals.
That regime has been proven in formal medical clinical trials to delay the onset of Type 2 diabetes in folks with diabetes genes.
Regards Old Al
Loretta Eisenberg - 19 Mar 2006 21:53 GMT Ron, I cant answer this question, but I would seek a second opinion from a qualified endocrinologist. Doctors in hospitals make lots of mistakes. My friend was in the hospital. She had a seizure. She has been on phenobarbital for fifteen years. They told her to stop as it was ineffective. She was checked by three other doctors who all increased the amount of the pheno, not eliminated it.
Loretta
-- In tribute to the United States of America and the State of Israel, two bastions of strength in a world filled with strife and terrorism.
Ron - 20 Mar 2006 05:04 GMT Well, they told my mother to stop with her insulin, but see her regular doctor. It was after one incident a doctor at the hospital made a suggestion that worked pretty well for her, then her regular doctor started raing it back up again until it was as high as it had been when my mother had her last attack... I could see what waas going to come of that and I wasn't wrong: the day after she started taking this higher doseage she had an attack and was back in the hospital. This seems like a dangerous an stupid cycle. She seems to be doing okay without it, so far anyway, but I wonder if it's safe for her to go for a long period until she finds a better doctor who specializes in diabetes.
Ron
W. Baker - 20 Mar 2006 15:13 GMT : Well, they told my mother to stop with her insulin, but see her regular : doctor. It was after one incident a doctor at the hospital made a [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] : it, so far anyway, but I wonder if it's safe for her to go for a long : period until she finds a better doctor who specializes in diabetes.
: Ron I am not a type 1 diabeteic, but I think it is safe to say tht your Mother is a type 2, as you woudl hav eknown quite rapidly, if she needed the insulin for her short term survival.
Sounds like she is not controlling her diet wel, so may get high numbers for her blood sugars or the three month HbA1c test, which gives a rough average of blood sugars over the last three months. When her doctor see tis she increses the insulin, but it is too much for your Mother. She needs a new doctor ver soon, as well as soem diabetes education, and , perhaps, nutrition education witha dietician to learn how what she eats affects her blood sugars. This seems to me, to be theonl plausible explaination for this situation.
Is your Mom in full possession of her facuties? does she plan and make her own meal, etc? If so she needs the education. If not, then whoever is taking care of her needs the education to know how to really handle the situation. Let us know how it comes out.
Wendy
Jenny - 20 Mar 2006 15:23 GMT She seems to be doing okay without
> it, so far anyway, but I wonder if it's safe for her to go for a long > period until she finds a better doctor who specializes in diabetes. It sounds like your mother isn't testing her blood sugar which would explain why insulin is so dangerous to her. As is her doctor.
If she could test her blood sugar after meals she'd quickly find out if her blood sugar was rising (or falling) to dangerous levels.
You really need to find her a new doctor right away. If you have to wait months for an endocrinologist appointment, find a local young family practitioner who has a nurse practitioner in his practice who can help your mom learn how to test and deal with her insulin needs if she has them. Get an emergency appointment for your mom.
To find this doctor, you might try calling around to local practices and ask to talk to the nurse. Explain your situation to the nurse and see what happens. If they won't let you talk to a nurse or if the nurse doesn't get why you need to be seen, you haven't found the doctor you are looking for. You should be able to find one if you are patient.
Good luck!
--Jenny
http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes Diabetes Info
http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org/newlydiagnosed.htm Get Your Blood Sugar Under Control
Ma¢k - 20 Mar 2006 17:42 GMT >My mother is diabetic and has been taking insulin for the last nine or >ten years now. But lately she has had a few incidents that resulted in [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > >Ron If she's a type 1, she'll die.
If she's a type 2, which is probably the case based on what you've described it really shouldn't be that much of a problem if she is going to manage her BG through diet, exercise and or oral medications.
For her sake, if you can, get her in to see an endocrinologist. They specialize in diabetes care.
 Signature Mâck©® Deltec CoZmore Pumper Type 1 since 1975 http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org http://www.diabetic-talk.org http://www.insulin-pumpers.org
"To announce that there must be no criticism of the President, or that we are to stand by the President right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public." ...Theodore Roosevelt
(o ô) --ooO-(_)-Ooo--------------------
"I don't know half of you half as well as I should like; and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve." ....Bilbo Baggins
Jesus never hated anyone.
DISCLAIMER If you find a posting or message from me offensive, inappropriate, or disruptive, please ignore it. If you don't know how to ignore a posting, complain to me and I will be only too happy to demonstrate... .
Ozgirl - 20 Mar 2006 23:38 GMT Oops didn't realise this is another Sally troll post. She is baiting you guys.
Loretta Eisenberg - 21 Mar 2006 00:19 GMT Ozgirl, how do you know it is Sally?
Loretta
-- In tribute to the United States of America and the State of Israel, two bastions of strength in a world filled with strife and terrorism.
Ozgirl - 21 Mar 2006 01:02 GMT > Ozgirl, how do you know it is Sally? Headers
Susan - 21 Mar 2006 01:40 GMT >>Ozgirl, how do you know it is Sally? > > Headers Please share the identifying details.
And just a note; one response would no doubt suffice.
Susan
Alan S - 21 Mar 2006 04:20 GMT >x-no-archive: yes > [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > >Susan Yep. I'd be interested in a short course on "How to identify posters by headers" myself.
Cheers, Alan, T2, Australia. d&e, metformin 2x500mg
 Signature Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter.
Cheri - 21 Mar 2006 04:28 GMT Boy, so would I. Carmen is so good at it and so was Charles Evans. On the other hand, some things may be best left alone for me. ;-)
-- Cheri
>Yep. I'd be interested in a short course on "How to identify >posters by headers" myself. [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >-- >Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter. David - 21 Mar 2006 00:34 GMT > Oops didn't realise this is another Sally troll post. She is > baiting you guys. Please prove it, or stop accusing someone who may not be reading the newsgroup at this time. PROVE IT.
Dave
|
|
|