>Why so bitter
> about foreigners who are professionals trying to get legit training/work in
> the North America? Many big names in early dentistry (and medicine for that
> matter) in North America weren't born here.
Where did I express bitterness?
But if you think about how just 3 yrs of PG can provide a foreign
dentist with both US licensure and specialty status, it doesn't sound
right. Most foreign dental schools begin right after high school,
meaning in the same 8 yrs required for a US student to become a
general dentist, a foreign dentist can even become a specialist in the
US.
> > What's the main reason for her wanting to get out of India so bad? I
> > don't specifically know about the other listed countries but, in the
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> might take it, too. Being a dentist in the USA or Canada maybe a whole lot
> better for this person than being one in India.
Even Canadians want to become dentists in the US. I also saw plenty
from the UK, Taiwan, and Spain, which are all far from being third
world.
I wasn't talking about general immigration; I'm not of the Anglo-Saxon
US blood myself.
I was wondering if there was something with dentistry in the US that
makes it so desirable.
John & Ninetta - 04 Jul 2007 19:59 GMT
>>Why so bitter
>> about foreigners who are professionals trying to get legit training/work
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Where did I express bitterness?
I think you answered your own question in your paragraph below:
> But if you think about how just 3 yrs of PG can provide a foreign
> dentist with both US licensure and specialty status, it doesn't sound
> right. Most foreign dental schools begin right after high school,
> meaning in the same 8 yrs required for a US student to become a
> general dentist, a foreign dentist can even become a specialist in the
> US.
How much of that undergraduate education do you actually use as a dentist?
Zero. The only benefit you get with a few years of undergrad is that you
should be a more mature person. It has no bearing on your ability as a
dentist. An American or a Canadian can go to India to get their dental
education, right out of high school as you put it, but my sense is no one
does that. The 6-8 year North American thing is just the way it is here.
>> > What's the main reason for her wanting to get out of India so bad? I
>> > don't specifically know about the other listed countries but, in the
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> from the UK, Taiwan, and Spain, which are all far from being third
> world.
There are more good opportunities from a professional standpoint in the USA
than in any other country. Sure, if you just want to be the neighbourhood
dentist in a busy town, you might have a tough slug at it. But move to
rural Maine and you will be busy. Move to Northern Ontario (Canada) and you
will be busy. Also, lots of good dental schools in the USA to teach at, if
that is your desire.
> I wasn't talking about general immigration; I'm not of the Anglo-Saxon
> US blood myself.
I know you weren't.
> I was wondering if there was something with dentistry in the US that
> makes it so desirable.
Like I said...opportunity.
John
seagate1556@hotmail.com - 04 Jul 2007 21:27 GMT
> <seagate1...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
>
> > Where did I express bitterness?
>
> I think you answered your own question in your paragraph below:
Originally, I was mentioning how one can alternatively head right to a
PG program for licensure (+ bonus of an added specialty ). I was
merely answering the OP's question. And just because I feel this
pathway to licensure is advantageous and provides a bonus to foreign
dentists doesn't mean I'm bitter. And I'm even admitting to you that
I'm not of Anglo-Saxon blood.
Out of curiosity, I was also asking if it was a problem with dentistry
that makes a foreign dentist want to move away from her country.
No reason to get defensive. But if you were offended in any way, then
I acknowledge I should have been more sensitive in this discussion.
nospam - 04 Jul 2007 20:00 GMT
Like medicine, dentistry in the US is highly renumerative. I think that
this is also the case in Germany. As I recall, in the early eighties,
German dentists were the most prosperous members of the artze klasse,
and made much more than their US counterparts, even under the socialized
system in BRD. One sees very few German dentists emigrating to the USA
but there are many Irish, British, Indian, South African, Arab, and
Pakistani dentists in the US. I know an Irish periodontist who practiced
in the US for 10 years then went back to Eire in 1993 to ply his craft.
He was back in the US in 1995 because his specialty was not appreciated
or renumerative in his homeland. The USA still presents a very
attractive place to practice, hence the restrictions.
I really don't think that a BDS can get into a specialty training
program unless he/she first gets a DDS/DMD - that usually means 2 more
years of pre-doctoral training.