Let me know if I'm off base, or there's a better approach, please.
I found a dentist nearby, fairly recent UCLA grad, whose work I really
appreciated. Over an 18 month period he did about $6K worth of
work...many crowns replaced, couple root canals, etc. During this time
scheduling was often difficult, and I learned he had another office
that he owned outright.
Recently scheduling became crazy, and I showed up TWICE for
appointments and was told "sorry, Doctor isn't able to be here, didn't
anyone call you to reschedule?" After two weeks of this nonesense I
arrived and was told "the office has been sold, and a new dentist will
be helping you." No thanks, I said.
So I learned where my preferred dentist's other office is located,
called for an appointment, and advised I was previously his client at
"ABC Dental" and would appreciate their obtaining my Xrays, since I'd
quite recently paid for a complete set. "No problem" the new office
told me.
The day before my appointment the office called and told me "sorry,
since Doctor is no longer affiliated with ABC Dental, we can't get his
records and we'll need to do a complete new workup on you." I asked if
it isn't customary for dental offices to allow xrays to follow
patients, and the was transferred to another Bryman School graduate,
the "office manager" who explained "Doctor is no longer afilliated,
blah blah blah." I asked to please have my dentist call me, and was
told "No, you must talk with me." Again I asked to leave a message for
him to call me.
What's up...the dentist is a young guy, barely 30, and we seemed to
have excellent rapport. He'd had no compunction calling me when I had
questions about my care before. If feels like he has clumsy stooges
running the show up front. Is this some standard procedure that's
intended to make clients learn their place (eg. not be assertive).
Does he really need to "take a new history and do a new workup for me"
even though he's the only guy who's looked at my teeth for over two
years?
Thanks for the benefit of any professional insight you can share.
Mark & Steven Bornfeld - 07 Dec 2006 13:56 GMT
> Let me know if I'm off base, or there's a better approach, please.
>
[quoted text clipped - 36 lines]
>
> Thanks for the benefit of any professional insight you can share.
There MAY be a legitimate need for a new set of x-rays if significant
restorative treatment was done after the last set was taken. OTOH, (and
I think this is the case in most or all states) you have a right to a
COPY (not originals) of all records, for which a reasonable fee must be
charged for duplication.
Sometimes a dentist wants a tough "traffic cop" at the front desk;
still, if you ever get to see him you should report the rude behavior at
the front desk. That's the only way a dentist is going to find out
about it.
Steve

Signature
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Bill - 07 Dec 2006 18:08 GMT
> Let me know if I'm off base, or there's a better approach, please.
>
[quoted text clipped - 36 lines]
>
> Thanks for the benefit of any professional insight you can share.
_______________________
In California (and in many other states as well) you are entitled to a
copy of your former dental records at "ABC Dental" (which I assume is a
made-up name for purposes of posting your question on the internet).
Since most mass-production volume-oriented clinics are far more
interested in your money than in your health, you can count on them
wanting to make a "reasonable" charge for a copy of your dental
records.
Depending on the complexity and extent of your dental records, even
traditional dentists are now starting to charge a small amount for the
expense of copying radiographs and photographs, if they are in your
records.
The point is that the law states that YOU are the person entitled to
the copies of your records, not your next dentist, or the next dental
office. Under the law, the clinic can refuse to send copies to another
dentist requesting the records, but they have to make copies for YOU if
you request it in writing.
The obvious solution is to get the records copies yourself, then you
can take them to as many dentists as you want. Problem solved!
Best regards,
- dentaldoc
gcomstock@excite.com - 07 Dec 2006 19:54 GMT
*snip*
Thanks for everyone's help. Finally this am "ABC Dental" said they
would, after all, make my xrays available for a $25 copying charge, but
they would NOT provide copies of my dental records. It's less the
dollars than the obfuscative, unfriendly approach that bugs me.
My dentist (or at least I used to think he was "my dentist") had me
take a full mouth set two months ago, with no restorative work since.
Every procedure has required additional Xrays...which is fine, laudable
even.
What's really stuck in my craw (other than crappy old man teeth) is
that the dentist personally seemed quite free of any condescending
approach. We compared our UCLA experience, talked about the Persian
Festival here in Orange County, and frequently discuss US / Iran
politics without problem. All questions about my dental care, costs,
prioritizing etc. have been handled in a way that makes him seem 100%
open and candid. I'm sure he has a half million in school bills, but
I've never had any sense he's seeing me as a boat payment.
But having googled his name, looked up the details of his license etc.
the only way I can tell him his front office buffoons are dicking me
around...is to wait in his parking lot until his old used car pulls in
the driveway. I'm sure he'll tell me that due to the sale I need to go
get my own xrays / records from the former office (probably there's a
covenant to not compete) and then we can move forward. But the high
school dropouts up front are insisting I schedule a new patient
consultation etc.
Rant over, thanks expressed, and recognition that "it's hard to find
good help" expressed
Mark & Steven Bornfeld - 07 Dec 2006 20:16 GMT
> *snip*
>
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
> Rant over, thanks expressed, and recognition that "it's hard to find
> good help" expressed
Suggest you inform the front desk lovelies that they can release a copy
of ALL your records (for which you are willing to pay a reasonable
copying fee) or you will sign a release authorizing your lawyer to
request them.
Steve

Signature
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Newbie - 07 Dec 2006 20:17 GMT
>*snip*
>
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
>Rant over, thanks expressed, and recognition that "it's hard to find
>good help" expressed
Why not schedule the 'consultation' and when you get to see
the doc in person, explain the situation.
Otherwise, have you tried to contact the dentist at his home phone ?