This letter should go to the people in Washington that want to ban Amalgam.
Many people would opt for an amalgam filling rather than a porcelain jacket
on the tooth. I had three composite restorations in the same place on the
same tooth with three different dentists and three different bills within
two or three weeks. Amalgam may not be the best choice, but there is no
best choice besides extraction.
Gail
> I just had a patient call the office yesterday. This is a patient who we
> had been treating for many years. This past year, they opted for an HMO
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> ps. I was flustered last night with slipping pegs. Drove me nuts trying to
> tune up. I have to install some fine tuners on that thing.
IME, any tooth that cannot be restored with composite is very
unlikely to be successfully treated with amalgam either.
(assuming a competent dentist placing both restorations)
Amalgam advantages are fast, cheap, easy. Nothing there
about quality of the final restoration.
Dartos
> This letter should go to the people in Washington that want to ban Amalgam.
> Many people would opt for an amalgam filling rather than a porcelain jacket
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> best choice besides extraction.
> Gail
kureforcrohns@sbcglobal.net - 01 Nov 2005 17:02 GMT
Apparently the ratio is 3-1 with whom I thought were very good dentists.
You could be right, but how much to spend finding the right dentist and that
is if the tooth holds up. I assume you have a very good personal
dentist.
On one visit, I noticed a former retured dentist getting his teeth cleaned
from my then present dentist. What could be a better recommendation.
Gail
> IME, any tooth that cannot be restored with composite is very
> unlikely to be successfully treated with amalgam either.
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> > best choice besides extraction.
> > Gail
> This letter should go to the people in Washington that want to ban Amalgam.
> Many people would opt for an amalgam filling rather than a porcelain jacket
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> best choice besides extraction.
> Gail
This is a bit of a non-sequitur, since this isn't an amalgam story.
2-3 years is not bad in this situation, depending on the particulars of
the fracture, any parafunction, etc.
I have a couple that hold up very well--even big ones--because the
patient has severe open bite. OTOH, I have some young patients whom I
don't want to do crowns on, with the entire incisal edge fractured off
from mesial to distal. These tend to be difficult, and a continuous
maintenance problem. One 8 year old girl will likely need endo and a
crown or veneer very soon, which almost guarantees it will have to be
redone by her teens.
Steve
>>I just had a patient call the office yesterday. This is a patient who we
>>had been treating for many years. This past year, they opted for an HMO
[quoted text clipped - 45 lines]
>
>>tune up. I have to install some fine tuners on that thing.

Signature
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Amatus Cremona - 01 Nov 2005 17:42 GMT
> 2-3 years is not bad in this situation, depending on the particulars of
> the fracture, any parafunction, etc.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> One 8 year old girl will likely need endo and a crown or veneer very soon,
> which almost guarantees it will have to be redone by her teens.
Unfortunately, if you were to put a veneer, PFM or jacket on this tooth, the
patient would just chip that porcelain as well. Parafunction is
_all-powerful_. You can lessen its destruction with an NTI or other
appliance, but there will be times when the patient does not wear the
appliance and will therefore eventually chip it again. I have lots of
incisal edge repairs which have held up for twenty years. This is not one
of those. Heck I have composites out there which virtually build up the
entire tooth above the soft tissues, and hold up for over ten years.
However, like you said, it depends on the parafunction intensity.

Signature
/
Amatus
/
>
>> This letter should go to the people in Washington that want to ban
[quoted text clipped - 73 lines]
>>
>>>tune up. I have to install some fine tuners on that thing.