Medical Forum / General / Dentistry / November 2004
The Root Of Root Canals
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Jan - 21 Nov 2004 02:00 GMT http://tinyurl.com/59cko
Can ROOT CANAL and APICOECTOMY dental treatment adversely affect our health? These treatment procedures allow us to keep our teeth, but we need to be aware of the side effects in order to make an informed choice, in conjunction with our dentist.
QUOTING from Dr. David Williams' October 2003 monthly newsletter.
Should You Accept Root Canals at Face Value?
Dear Friend:
There are five painfully expensive words no one likes to hear from their dentist or endodontist: "You need a root canal." It's bad enough to hear this once, but some people have had three, four, or even ten root canals. In fact, for most people, this procedure is just another routine and accepted solution to tooth problems, just like a filling, but it shouldn't be.
One fellow I met went to his dentist with an achy tooth he'd had for several months. The dentist took an x-ray, made an immediate diagnosis, and told him he needed a root canal. The patient had decided years before—after reading about potential negative consequences—that a root canal would be a last ditch option, so he sought a second opinion. The second dentist told him, "You're getting older, you have some minor cracks in your teeth, but you don't need a root canal. It's not unusual to have some minor tooth pain; it's normal, and will probably pass soon." The pain did pass, and after many years the problem hasn't recurred. (I might add that this fellow added green tea to his supplement regimen after that experience.)
The story isn't always going have a happy ending. Here are three things to keep in mind about tooth problems:
Don't put off getting a diagnosis. Maintain a healthy skepticism when you get a diagnosis that will have a serious (and expensive) health consequence, such as a root canal. Get a second, and possibly even a third, opinion.
What's at the Root of Root Canals?
Three parts of the tooth are of particular importance: the pulp chamber, the dentin, and the enamel. The inner pulp chamber contains blood vessels, nerves, and lymph fluid.
Nutrients and blood, which keep the tooth alive, enter the pulp through lateral accessory canals and the main canal at the root of the tooth. From there, these circulating fluids pass through the microscopic network of tubules called the dentin and eventually reach the enamel. We tend to think of the enamel as a hard, impenetrable substance, but it is actually living tissue much like the skin. It presents a more formidable barrier than the skin, but fluids, minerals, and nutrients from both the saliva and the dentin can still pass back and forth through enamel.
The dentin makes up the majority of the tooth's structure. To the naked eye it appears to be solid; however, when viewed through a microscope, millions of small hollow tubules are visible. If all of the tubules in an average-size front tooth were placed end to end they would form a hollow tube over three miles long!
Problems can begin when the tooth is damaged from trauma, poor bite, or from caries (Caries is Latin for rot or rotten. In this case, it means tooth decay, or cavities.) Caries begin with the formation of plaque, a sticky film created from saliva and food compounds. Plaque harbors large numbers of bacteria, which rely on carbohydrates (sugars) to grow and multiply. These bacteria release various acids and enzymes, which digest the protective protein and calcium layers of the enamel, creating a cavity, or caries. Bacteria in deep, inflamed pockets in the gum tissue of adjoining teeth can also enter the pulp through one of the lateral canals and infect the tooth.
You Say "Root Canal," I Say Risky
When dental caries or infection has damaged the dentin and pulp, a simple filling will not always arrest the decay. In an effort to save the tooth, dentists perform a root canal; a process where the pulp material is mechanically stripped from the tooth and the remaining cavity is temporarily packed with medication in an attempt to sterilize the area. The pulp chamber and root canals are then filled with a pliable, hopefully inert, material which later dries and hardens. The problem, a curious doctor named Dr. Weston Price found, was that the materials used to fill the pulp chamber and root canals exhibited a significant degree of shrinkage as they cooled and hardened. The shrinkage provided enough space for bacteria to flourish until an escape route into the body's general circulation could be found. Unsatisfied with the results of root canals Dr. Price spent 25 years in the early 1900s researching the relationship between root canals and many of the degenerative diseases (heart disease, arthritis, kidney and bladder problems, etc.) He found a direct link.
Learning the dangers associated with root canals will change your thoughts forever about this simple procedure, and quite possibly change the quality and length of your life. To order the Alternatives back issue this Dispatch is based on, and learn what you need to know in order to make an informed decision about root canals, click here.
If You're Still Not Convinced
Much of the research was performed 80 to 100 years ago [a dentist who doesn't use mercury amalgam and whom we respect for his dental work, said that Dr. Meinig's work is 'old research'. He adds that if it is done well there shouldn't be any problems. See my article below - TD], so if you are a little skeptical about avoiding root canals I wouldn't be surprised. You would think that changes in root canal procedures, along with the introduction of better materials and more effective antibiotics, would have made the research obsolete. But, strange as it may seem, that's not the case. Very little about root canal procedures has changed. Today's antibiotics are still unable to permeate and sterilize the three miles of dentin tubules, and the most popular root canal filling material in Dr. Price's time, guttapercha, is still the most widely used today. One possible bright spot concerning root canals is that newer laser technology may help improve the ability to disinfect these areas of the tooth. Initial research looks promising. Hopefully this will happen in the near future.
Should you get a root canal? Knowing what I know right now, I would say no. I won't have one done, and I wouldn't recommend the procedure until better techniques have been developed and tested.
Millions of root canals are performed each year in the United States. It's long past time to re-evaluate what's being done and develop procedures to guarantee that the health of the patient isn't being placed in jeopardy. Until this happens, I'd avoid root canals like the plague.
Till Next Time, Dr. David Williams UNQUOTE http://www.drdavidwilliams.com/index.asp "Alternatives".
Joel M. Eichen - 21 Nov 2004 13:35 GMT >QUOTING from Dr. David Williams' October 2003 monthly newsletter. > >Should You Accept Root Canals at Face Value? He is the chiropractor, right?
Joel
Shad J. Lewis, DMD, MA - 21 Nov 2004 15:42 GMT No, he's the voo doo witch doctor.
 Signature Shad Lewis www.WyomissingSmiles.com
Joel M. Eichen - 21 Nov 2004 16:50 GMT >No, he's the voo doo witch doctor. How does hedoo the voodoo that youdo?
WAS A SONG .......
CWatters - 21 Nov 2004 22:08 GMT > Much of the research was performed 80 to 100 years ago. Says it all really.
Dr Steve - 24 Nov 2004 12:43 GMT ATTENTION ! ! !
For the sake of any new readers to this newsgroup. Jan is a retired day care worker (owner according to her) who makes a lot of noise about amalgam toxicity. She is not a dentist, has no training in dentistry, and does not really understand scientific methods. In addition, she flat out refuses to engage in any discussion about this issue even when the specific point of discussion does not contradict her own point of view. She cannot communicate much beyond pasting the words of other people to responses, even when the quotes do not apply to what is being said. She, also, does not give any credit to the person from which she takes these quotations. Her behavior is very similar to a software program designed to post specific remarks to key words. Please be cautious if you choose to follow any advice presented by her.
Recognize that her views do NOT reflect those of modern dentistry. Her views mirror those of dishonest people who survive by preying on the innocent. If you watch and read carefully, you will see her accuse anyone who does not agree with all her views (uneducated as they may be) of being a liar. When that does not get enough attention, she will resort to calling people "heifer", "Jew-boy", Atheist, queer, etc. Her behavior is certainly not civil nor compassionate.
If you read exactly what her claims are in regard to amalgam toxicity, you will find that her claims do not make scientific sense. She claims to have been healed of neurological defects during the time that her bodily mercury levels would have been at their highest. If she really had mercury toxicity, she should have been more ill during this time, not feeling better than she had in many years. She is either badly mistaken, or she is lying about what made her ill.
Even those individuals who would like to see amalgam banned from use, find her posting methods and refusal to discuss any topics despicable.
Please recognize that there are far more people sensitive to Penicillin, latex, peanuts, and even to bananas than there are people sensitive to dental amalgam and the metals it contains. None of those materials have been banned, nor will they be banned in the future. .. Stephen Mancuso, D.D.S. Troy, Michigan, USA
Jan - 25 Nov 2004 04:19 GMT >Subject: Re: The Root Of Root Canals >From: "Dr Steve" nospam@home.net >Date: 11/24/2004 4:43 AM Pacific Standard Time >Message-id: <_l%od.30082$5b1.14807@newssvr17.news.prodigy.com> > >ATTENTION ! ! ! http://tinyurl.com/59cko
Can ROOT CANAL and APICOECTOMY dental treatment adversely affect our health? These treatment procedures allow us to keep our teeth, but we need to be aware of the side effects in order to make an informed choice, in conjunction with our dentist.
QUOTING from Dr. David Williams' October 2003 monthly newsletter.
Should You Accept Root Canals at Face Value?
Dear Friend:
There are five painfully expensive words no one likes to hear from their dentist or endodontist: "You need a root canal." It's bad enough to hear this once, but some people have had three, four, or even ten root canals. In fact, for most people, this procedure is just another routine and accepted solution to tooth problems, just like a filling, but it shouldn't be.
One fellow I met went to his dentist with an achy tooth he'd had for several months. The dentist took an x-ray, made an immediate diagnosis, and told him he needed a root canal. The patient had decided years before—after reading about potential negative consequences—that a root canal would be a last ditch option, so he sought a second opinion. The second dentist told him, "You're getting older, you have some minor cracks in your teeth, but you don't need a root canal. It's not unusual to have some minor tooth pain; it's normal, and will probably pass soon." The pain did pass, and after many years the problem hasn't recurred. (I might add that this fellow added green tea to his supplement regimen after that experience.)
The story isn't always going have a happy ending. Here are three things to keep in mind about tooth problems:
Don't put off getting a diagnosis. Maintain a healthy skepticism when you get a diagnosis that will have a serious (and expensive) health consequence, such as a root canal. Get a second, and possibly even a third, opinion.
What's at the Root of Root Canals?
Three parts of the tooth are of particular importance: the pulp chamber, the dentin, and the enamel. The inner pulp chamber contains blood vessels, nerves, and lymph fluid.
Nutrients and blood, which keep the tooth alive, enter the pulp through lateral accessory canals and the main canal at the root of the tooth. From there, these circulating fluids pass through the microscopic network of tubules called the dentin and eventually reach the enamel. We tend to think of the enamel as a hard, impenetrable substance, but it is actually living tissue much like the skin. It presents a more formidable barrier than the skin, but fluids, minerals, and nutrients from both the saliva and the dentin can still pass back and forth through enamel.
The dentin makes up the majority of the tooth's structure. To the naked eye it appears to be solid; however, when viewed through a microscope, millions of small hollow tubules are visible. If all of the tubules in an average-size front tooth were placed end to end they would form a hollow tube over three miles long!
Problems can begin when the tooth is damaged from trauma, poor bite, or from caries (Caries is Latin for rot or rotten. In this case, it means tooth decay, or cavities.) Caries begin with the formation of plaque, a sticky film created from saliva and food compounds. Plaque harbors large numbers of bacteria, which rely on carbohydrates (sugars) to grow and multiply. These bacteria release various acids and enzymes, which digest the protective protein and calcium layers of the enamel, creating a cavity, or caries. Bacteria in deep, inflamed pockets in the gum tissue of adjoining teeth can also enter the pulp through one of the lateral canals and infect the tooth.
You Say "Root Canal," I Say Risky
When dental caries or infection has damaged the dentin and pulp, a simple filling will not always arrest the decay. In an effort to save the tooth, dentists perform a root canal; a process where the pulp material is mechanically stripped from the tooth and the remaining cavity is temporarily packed with medication in an attempt to sterilize the area. The pulp chamber and root canals are then filled with a pliable, hopefully inert, material which later dries and hardens. The problem, a curious doctor named Dr. Weston Price found, was that the materials used to fill the pulp chamber and root canals exhibited a significant degree of shrinkage as they cooled and hardened. The shrinkage provided enough space for bacteria to flourish until an escape route into the body's general circulation could be found. Unsatisfied with the results of root canals Dr. Price spent 25 years in the early 1900s researching the relationship between root canals and many of the degenerative diseases (heart disease, arthritis, kidney and bladder problems, etc.) He found a direct link.
Learning the dangers associated with root canals will change your thoughts forever about this simple procedure, and quite possibly change the quality and length of your life. To order the Alternatives back issue this Dispatch is based on, and learn what you need to know in order to make an informed decision about root canals, click here.
If You're Still Not Convinced
Much of the research was performed 80 to 100 years ago [a dentist who doesn't use mercury amalgam and whom we respect for his dental work, said that Dr. Meinig's work is 'old research'. He adds that if it is done well there shouldn't be any problems. See my article below - TD], so if you are a little skeptical about avoiding root canals I wouldn't be surprised. You would think that changes in root canal procedures, along with the introduction of better materials and more effective antibiotics, would have made the research obsolete. But, strange as it may seem, that's not the case. Very little about root canal procedures has changed. Today's antibiotics are still unable to permeate and sterilize the three miles of dentin tubules, and the most popular root canal filling material in Dr. Price's time, guttapercha, is still the most widely used today. One possible bright spot concerning root canals is that newer laser technology may help improve the ability to disinfect these areas of the tooth. Initial research looks promising. Hopefully this will happen in the near future.
Should you get a root canal? Knowing what I know right now, I would say no. I won't have one done, and I wouldn't recommend the procedure until better techniques have been developed and tested.
Millions of root canals are performed each year in the United States. It's long past time to re-evaluate what's being done and develop procedures to guarantee that the health of the patient isn't being placed in jeopardy. Until this happens, I'd avoid root canals like the plague.
Till Next Time, Dr. David Williams UNQUOTE http://www.drdavidwilliams.com/index.asp "Alternatives".
|
|
|