> I will be taking 6 weeks off to heal and will keep in touch. I read
> often but post not-that-often. I hope each of you had a Merry Christmas
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Phil
> (philski)
...
> > ... Instead,
> > he found that the disks for my lower 3 vertibrae are "bulging" (his
> > word)
...
> ... Some research studies have shown that while surgery can
> help with the pain, in the long term, you can't tell the difference
> between conservative treatment like mine and surgery.
I'll second that. Of the few people I've known who have had back
surgeries, the outcomes in each case were uncertain at best.
One guy had everything made worse. Two others that I know
had some reduction in pain, but wound up with new symptoms
like tingling and numbness in their feet after the surgery.
My own experience with surgery (on my knee) was bad enough
that I felt safer using radiation on the PCa than surgery.
I suggest trying everything else - physical therapy, stretching
and exercise, aspirin or ibuprofen, walking, rest, new posture,
changed lifestyle, ice, heat, whatever, before trying surgery.
Like most things involving surgery, the surgeon cuts things
that weren't cut before and what he does can rarely be undone.
So be careful with it.
Alan
Dave Perry - 08 Jan 2004 15:44 GMT
My feelings exactly. Even though I opted for surgery to remove my
PCa, I am pretty sure I would not do any surgery that was for
something not life threatening. I am six months post-op and still
somewhat incontinent and my doc is already talking slings for
incontinence and implants for erections. No way, he will have to
practice his medicine on someone else. My spouse volunteered for many
years in a VA hospital and she saw some of the side effects of
implants which were not pretty (not that anything down there is
pretty). If I have to wear pads the rest of my life I can do that in
the same way people live with hearing aids and glasses. A bit of a
pain but so what? As for erections, if they come back that is fine
but if not, we will deal with it in other ways. Back surgery can be
especially tricky since the surgery involves spinal cords. All us PCa
guys know what happens when nerves are damaged during surgery. Good
luck with whatever path you take but I too would lean toward the
conservative side before doing anything that involves cutting.
Dave Perry
> I'll second that. Of the few people I've known who have had back
> surgeries, the outcomes in each case were uncertain at best.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Alan
Heather - 08 Jan 2004 18:11 GMT
May I offer a suggestion......and I know that there are those who will
not agree with me......but as one of 3 generations in my family with
scoliosis (congenital curvature of the spine), plus a dumb ornamental
diving overextension at 4 am while under the influence of some whiskey
(G).....I have had my fair share of back pain.
I have gone to chiropractors since I was 18 (65 now)......and PROVIDED
you find a good one, I can highly recommend using that mode of
treatment. I had a choice of 6 months in bed in a body cast at 18 or
chiro treatments for a year......needless to say, I did the latter. I
saw the before and after x-rays......and I don't even need to say how
good the chiropractor was.
Even with all of the above in spinal problems, I probably have less pain
than the average person......thanks to my present excellent chiro who
rarely does manipulation but works it a different way.
Just some words of support for the excellent chiros.....coz there are
some real quacks out there. But we have been lucky to find 3 good ones
who have looked after my Dad, my daughter and myself for more years than
I want to count. And I mean that 2 of the 3 looked after 3 generations.
The orthopedic surgeon wanted to put a steel rod in my daughter's spine
at age 14.....no blinkin' way!!!! She rarely has any pain from the
scoliosis.
Nowadays, you have to be 'your own doctor'.....because if you don't know
all the ins and outs of every treatment......or side effects from
surgeries, and so on.......you can end up worse than you started with.
I know.....been there, done that.
Happy New Year to all the 'boys' and may this year be a far, far better
one that 2003 for all of you. Ron is doing just fine, btw. It seems
like a bad dream now.
Cheers.....Heather
> I'll second that. Of the few people I've known who have had back
> surgeries, the outcomes in each case were uncertain at best.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Alan
Leonard Evens - 08 Jan 2004 21:11 GMT
> May I offer a suggestion......and I know that there are those who will
> not agree with me......but as one of 3 generations in my family with
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> who have looked after my Dad, my daughter and myself for more years than
> I want to count. And I mean that 2 of the 3 looked after 3 generations.
We all have different experiences. At one point I went to a highly
regarded chiropractor to deal with a running injury. The result was a
disaster.
Chiropractors can often help with ordinary garden variety back pain.
The patient may have some minor pathology in the spine, but the pain is
caused by muscle spasm, and the methods chiropractors use can often help
in such cases. Remember that 80 percent of the population has back
problems some time in life, and the overwhelming majority of those have
to do with poorly toned muscles and bad habits in using the back. But
some involve some significant pathology. When a herniated disk presses
on a nerve, inducing intense pain and also neurological symptoms in the
lower body, you want a medical doctor who is expert in treating such
conditions. Thye chiropractors have managed to convince the public and
politicians that what they do is useful, but I've never been able to
make sense of their underlying theory. Albeit imperfectly, medicine is
based on real biological science. The specialists who deal with backs
are orthopedic surgeons (whether they operate or not) and specialists in
physical medicine. Unfortunately, these people are usually only
interested in treating really bad cases and leave most painful backs and
some chronic conditions that are difficult to treat to others.
Chiropractors may in some cases be useful for that, but personally I've
had greater luck with physical therapists. They understand how the
muscles work much better than the MDs, and they are willing to take time
with you. They have certainly helped me deal with what would otherwise
be an incapacitating spinal condition.
> The orthopedic surgeon wanted to put a steel rod in my daughter's spine
> at age 14.....no blinkin' way!!!! She rarely has any pain from the
[quoted text clipped - 29 lines]
>>
>> Alan