> I.P.
>> Flax seed oil is great stuff, highly advisable for several reasons ...
>> except for prostate cancer patients, whose affliction it feeds. Drop
>> that one ASAP.
> I believe there are as many who espouse your opinion on flaxseed oil
> as argue the opposite view.
Could be, but when the two top gurus on the more scientific cancer
newsgroups (Matti Narkia and "the other guy" whose name I forget)
debated Omega 3 fatty acids' impact on PC at great length and in great
detail a year ago, the one thing they most agreed on was that PC pts
must avoid flax. That's good enough for me; YMMV.
Many people support many supplements without proof, so I form my
opinions not on the number of supporters but on their reputation and
their sources. Narkia and "the other guy" (sorry, but I haven't visited
those forums in a long time) are highly respected and cited many
references in detail, to the point I chucked all my new flax seeds and
stowed the grinder until the research swings the other way again.
They agreed to disagree on walnuts, close to the fence but on opposite
sides, so I still eat those but in lesser quantity.
I.P.
alva36@gmail.com - 03 May 2008 22:32 GMT
to the point I chucked all my new flax seeds and
> stowed the grinder until the research swings the other way again.
>
> I.P.
I.P.-
There, apparently, is a big diff between flax seeds and flaxseed oil.
Those who say the oil is good, say the seeds are not. Who knows?
-Les
I.P. Freely - 04 May 2008 01:47 GMT
> to the point I chucked all my new flax seeds and
>> stowed the grinder until the research swings the other way again.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> There, apparently, is a big diff between flax seeds and flaxseed oil.
> Those who say the oil is good, say the seeds are not. Who knows?
The benefits and pitfalls (and the debates) of flax are in its oil; the
fiber we can get many ways.
I.P.
Steve Jordan - 04 May 2008 00:18 GMT
On May 3, Mike Freely wrote:
> Could be, but when the two top gurus on the more scientific cancer
> newsgroups (Matti Narkia and "the other guy" whose name I forget)
> debated Omega 3 fatty acids' impact on PC at great length and in great
> detail a year ago, the one thing they most agreed on was that PC pts
> must avoid flax. That's good enough for me; YMMV.
Well, MM most certainly varies with regard to Narkia.
Google shows him/her as an "IT Consultant" with various posts and an
argument with one Steve Harris on health subjects. See, frex,
http://www.naymz.com/search/matti/narkia/1005708
> Many people support many supplements without proof, so I form my
> opinions not on the number of supporters but on their reputation and
> their sources. Narkia and "the other guy" (sorry, but I haven't visited
> those forums in a long time) are highly respected....
By whom?
Regards,
Steve J
"What are the facts? Again and again and again -- what are the facts?
Shun wishful thinking, ignore divine revelation, forget 'what the stars
foretell,' avoid opinion, care not what the neighbors think, never mind
the unguessable 'verdict of history' -- what are the facts, and to how
many decimal places? You pilot always into an unknown future; facts are
your single clue. Get the facts!"
--Lazarus Long