Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Prostate Cancer / January 2008
Re: OT: Humor
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Califchief - 07 Jan 2008 07:00 GMT Sy wrote:
> Leah, > As I had mentioned to you in a personal email of several weeks ago, > I happen to think this type of post coming from a woman is plain > weird and crosses an "unspoken" boundary of sorts. I think it's > inappropriate on numerous levels but would like to hear what > others think. I enjoy her postings, and think you're too damn sensitive and/or totally lack a sense of humor.
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12
Califchief - 07 Jan 2008 07:00 GMT Safire wrote:
> Steve Kramer who is proud to have aided and abetted the killing > of innocent Vietnamese children seems to appreciate her jokes. You're crossing the boundries of decency and could be heading to a 2nd libel/slander lawsuit.
When are you going to learn to shut your f.cking mouth?
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12
Califchief - 07 Jan 2008 09:00 GMT Burney wrote:
> Sy, I thought we already went through this drill of commenting > on Leah's humor, at your request, several weeks ago. Maybe I > just dreamed that. No, it wasn't a dream. Sy has a very short memory. And an even shorter fuse on his temper. That may account for "I am scientifically trained and am a skeptic by nature." October 24, 2007
Or "Yes I can be abrasive...." October 24, 2007
Or "I am certainly not 'lashing out at the world' only a few people who don't have the understanding and common sense....." October 31, 2007
Every trait of a troll or warmonger.
> Leah has been a valuable contributor to this group for a long > time. As far as I'm concerned she can say whatever she wants. > If you, or anyone else, doesn't like the humor she offers, > maybe you could just ignore it and keep your thoughts to > yourself. I couldn't have written a better piece, Burney.
Thanks for your concise and truthful contribution to the group.
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12
Sy - 07 Jan 2008 12:21 GMT [[ This message was both posted and mailed: see the "To," "Cc," and "Newsgroups" headers for details. ]]
I guess you don't understand things unless they hit you right over the head. Let me try to explain:
It's obvious that Leah is trying to inject some humor into a very serious subject matter and that can be a good thing.
However for a woman to engage in what's basically "locker room humor" (that's 'men's locker rooms') is weird and intrusive. It would be like me posting "boob" jokes on alt.support.breast.cancer.
Does your mind comprehend the incongruity ofthat? Do you get that? Can you grasp that concept?
Are you related to Leah? I note the email name "calichief" whereas hers is "calilily". Is he/she really "Leah" or maybe "Leon"? Makes one wonder.
And as long as I have a few more minutes to waste your's is the first post I've seen invoking the "F" word. Cute.
Sy
> Sy wrote: > [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > > ___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12 Steve Kramer - 07 Jan 2008 23:27 GMT You know what, Sy? I understand.
No, I really do.
I think there is a less abrasive way of saying it, but, if I may put words in your mouth, you personally find it offensive that a woman would come to this group and joke about male genetalia.
Personnally, I think that is a valid opinion and worthy of mentioning. Knowing just a little about Leah, I think she might have apologized and ceased posting them, at least while you're a member, if you had been more civil about it.
I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 07:37 GMT > You know what, Sy? I understand. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > ceased posting them, at least while you're a member, if you had been more > civil about it. Except that this horse was flogged many weeks ago. Sy doesn't understand that the whole concept of a do-over is to do it *differently* the second time.
I.P.
Steve Kramer - 08 Jan 2008 11:00 GMT >> Personnally, I think that is a valid opinion and worthy of mentioning. >> Knowing just a little about Leah, I think she might have apologized and [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > that the whole concept of a do-over is to do it *differently* the second > time. And now he does. Aint life grand?
 Signature PSA 16 10/17/2000 @ 46 Biopsy 11/01/2000 G7 (3+4), T2c RRP 12/15/2000 G7 (3+4), T3cN0M0 Neg margins PSA <.1 <.1 <.1 .27 .37 .75 PSAD 0.19 years EBRT 05-07/2002 @ 47 PSA .34 .22 .15 .21 .32 PSAD .056 years Lupron 07/03 (1 mo) 8/03 and every 4 months there after PSA .07 .05 .06 .09 .08 .132 .145 PSAD 1.4 years Casodex added daily 07/06 PSA <0.04, <0.05, <0.04, <0.04 10/11/07 Non Illegitimi Carborundum
Sy - 08 Jan 2008 11:07 GMT [[ This message was both posted and mailed: see the "To," "Cc," and "Newsgroups" headers for details. ]]
Hi Steve,
I appreciate that you "get" this.
Leah is free to post whatever she wants and doesn't have to apologize. I'm nobody's censor.
By the same token I expect to be able to render my opinions also.
Sy
> You know what, Sy? I understand. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > ceased posting them, at least while you're a member, if you had been more > civil about it. ronju99 - 08 Jan 2008 13:00 GMT Sy, You are absolutely right in that you have the right to express your opinions also on this forum. Pardon me if I'm not as eloquent as others when I say that discretion is the better part of valor. Yes we should be more tolerant of you at this time in your journey through this cancer process as most of us have traveled much further down the road. In time should you choose to be treated for your disease, especially if you choose RP but Radiation will also result in the same perspective, you probably will lighten up a whole lot when it comes to your genitalia. Most of us never realized or even expected to be discussing such private matters in a public forum such as this. Because you are new, you may not have read the past archives when we have discussed how to deal with our erectile disfunction in graphic detail and how to deal with sex with your partner.
So yes, I agree that we have become somewhat insensitive to others and should do a better job of informing rather than criticizing. We sometimes forget where we came from and how we initially felt as newcomers. Having said that, I can also understand some of the responses being harsh because of many of your past characterizations of posters that have sincerely tried to be of some help and supportive. It works both ways but sugar will result in a sweeter discourse.
Ron S.
-- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html
I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 18:44 GMT > So yes, I agree that we have become somewhat insensitive to others and > should do a better job of informing rather than criticizing. We sometimes [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > to be of some help and supportive. It works both ways but sugar will result > in a sweeter discourse. Who let Sean Hannity in here? ;-)
I.P.
ronju99 - 08 Jan 2008 19:42 GMT I.P., You lost me when you said; "I can understand some of the responses being harsh because of many of your past characterizations of posters that have sincerely tried to be of some help and supportive." Who are you referring to in this quote?
Ron S.
-- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html
I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 20:02 GMT > I.P., > You lost me when you said; "I can understand some of the responses being > harsh because of many of your past characterizations of posters that have > sincerely tried to be of some help and supportive." Who are you referring > to in this quote? You, not I, said that. I simply quoted it in my response.
I.P.
ronju99 - 08 Jan 2008 20:08 GMT Sorry. I'm slowly loosing it as my dementia is getting worse as I age.
Ron S.
-- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html
I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 21:10 GMT > Sorry. I'm slowly loosing it as my dementia is getting worse as I age. I presume that's a joke, but it is completely obvious to me that my word recall has been declining for a few years for real despite a great deal of mental and physical exercise. I just hope I can keep 12 simple words on the tip of my tongue: "OK, doc; it's time. Please pull that plug. I love you, honey."
I.P.
ronju99 - 08 Jan 2008 20:16 GMT Sorry. I'm slowly loosing it as my dementia is getting worse as I age.
Ron S.
-- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html
safire - 08 Jan 2008 20:57 GMT > Sorry. I'm slowly loosing it as my dementia is getting worse as I age. Loosing it? Losing it? You mean you're incontinent? That is a well known side effect. Surely, you've read about in in on Medscape. But it's no excuse for all these double posts or for not properly quoting the message that you're responding to.
> Ron S. > > -- > Message posted using http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ > More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html Slobodon - 08 Jan 2008 21:04 GMT Ron... Time for restraint! Don't answer any more messages...
>> Sorry. I'm slowly loosing it as my dementia is getting worse as I age. > [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >> http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ >> More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 22:45 GMT > Ron... Time for restraint! Don't answer any more messages... Yes, Ron ... by feeding the troll, you're contributing to its pollution of the forum.
Are you aware that "troll" is not a randomly selected pejorative term, but rather a specific internet term for people who sprinkle the internet with deliberately inflammatory statements specifically intended to inflame, thus eliciting responses, i.e., more troll food? Then when a sucker takes the bait, he strikes with both barrels and stays in that forum until it stops feeding him. Trolls are basically arsonists, and you're doing exactly what Safire wants: feeding his sick desire for conflagration. The result is a forum which may repel people. Do you leave your home and car doors open overnight, leave raccoon or skunk or rat food on your porch, paint gang graffiti on the side of your house, or kick mean drunks in the shin? That's what I thought. So don't stroke the troll. If he really has PC (many trolls learn the lingo very well), let him get help at someone else's expense, not ours. Like Jill Bello, he has the option of behaving if he wants advice rather than flame wars.
I.P.
Sy - 08 Jan 2008 20:09 GMT Ron,
I think you are quite as eloquent as anyone else.
My treatment choice had nothing to do with my comments re: Leah's post though and I think this IS the place to discuss erectile dysfunction etc. in detail.
Thanks for your comments.
Sy
In article <df60d2e879528264b38d1d26d70517cb@localhost.talkaboutsupport.com>,
> Sy, > You are absolutely right in that you have the right to express your [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/group/alt.support.cancer.prostate/ > More information at http://www.talkaboutsupport.com/faq.html callalily - 08 Jan 2008 22:19 GMT Dear Steve (and All),
I take your comments very seriously. Just so you know, I'm not a pervert, I don't have a preference for dirty jokes. I get them from various groups (mostly prostate pointers' humor (HAH), joke eruption, aus.jokes), and from friends. Then I let my husband pick his favorite ones. Also asked him about the propriety of posting the joke in question. He approved it, might as well have pressed the "Send" button. His opinion was colored by the fact that the jokes we get from the grandpas in indiana who contribute to the prostate joke list are often far, far, bawdier, than anything I've every posted. Check it out.
I do reject a lot of jokes -- the runner-up this time was about a doc laughing at a guy with a small penis. My husband howled with laughter when he heard it, but you did not see it here. I did post it on HAH, along with a few others, because I have never seen a "protest" letter from anybody on that list (have to repost them because of a technical kink). Just so you know, there is a woman who is highly respected in the online PC world who often posts on the HAH list. You also have to factor int that I stay away from posting ethnic, religious and even regional jokes. So there's not much left to laugh about. And my jokes are never intended to disparage men in a serious way -- I disparage women equally, if I do at all. I don't know how many "dumb blonde" jokes I've posted.
The fact is, I'm glad for the chance to write this. It's painful for me to be thought of as some kind of deviant. In truth, I lead a pretty conservative life: For example, I'm not interested in porn, rarely cuss and have engaged in little else but "plain vanilla sex" (found that out in these forums!). But, because I have been dragged into the PC world, I have no choice but to discuss things many people consider "dirty", such as genitalia, sexual intercourse, ED, penile rehabilitation, and a specialty of mine, priapism. (My husband won't do any research on any of this.) When you become inured to talking about all this, the "boundaries" between good and bad taste sometimes do get blurred.
Take my membership card -- Please!
A man wrote me recently: "I just discovered your blog, really like it. Do you always talk about sex? Hope so!" I felt so bad about this that I wrote to my friend Don Y. in Mo. and asked him, "Hey Don, do you think I'm a slut?" Always a sweetheart, he replied, "No. More like a cross between Dear Abby and Dr. Ruth." I would give anything to strike the "Dr. Ruth" part -- I always thought she needed to have her mouth washed out with soap.
I write my own jokes and repeat those of others to cheer people up, the way they do me. I did work for a number of years as a prof'l writer. But the only literary interest I have now is to one day write a joke book about PC (there is a very successful one for BC), even tho Ted says there's not a big enough market for it. (Bunk!) On my blog, I often make jokes at my own expense. I have written about our own sexual adventures and misadventures, among other things. Believe me, I had reservations about turning my own love life into a "reality show". But I thought it was worth it. And I was right, because I got some good feedback. But Ted is not happy about it. He just asked me to please remove his name from the postings -- just refer to him as DH.
Steve, the real problem I have with this is your dignifying comments from someone who has repeatedly harassed people in this group -- and used them, in the sense that he really doesn't pay attn to what anybody says. And I would not give the time of day to any person who sends hate mail to cancer patients. I received a nasty. nonsensical letter from Sy a few weeks ago, and yes, my husband read it, too. I have never received anything like this before.
I ignored Sy's letter, and I'm not going to talk about the substance of it now, but I am going to post it in a separate message. Why don't you all read the letter for yourselves and decide whether the writer is a reasonable, decent, truthful person, worthy of attention and respect. (As far as necessary medical info, *nobody* should be denied that, no matter how bad their behavior.)
Having said that, I know I have said many very stupid things here, and I apologize for that. Maybe this joke is one of them. I wish I had heeded my father's advice to always keep your mouth shut. I actually post very little these days. But do keep in mind that it's not always easy to say the right thing when, like me, you have a huge sword hanging over you (his srt results).
Take care.
Leah
PS: I just received this note from a guy in the HAH group: "I rarely see jokes of this quality here. Thanks very much, W."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------:------------------------------------ Shakespeare said:
"Be not afraid of greatness; some are born great, some achieve greatness, and others have greatness thrust upon them."
My version: "Some are born lewd, some achieve lewdness, and others have lewdness thrust upon them." I put myself in the last category. Who knows, maybe it will one day lead to greatness.
callalily - 08 Jan 2008 22:28 GMT Part II: Sy's letter to me. (12/9) Will just say that my only comment to Sy about Jersey was that there are great hospitals there.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Leah,
At first I was going to post this to the "group" but decided to send it only to you in the service of ruffling as few feathers as possible given the extraordinary sensitivity and mental fragility of several members of the "group".
I just happened to stumble over this bit of "humor" this morning. As I mentioned a while back, there's something quite weird about a woman posting this kind of stuff. Weird and annoying.
Why annoying? To comment about Prostate Cancer and to even offer free DREs if fully within the purview of a discussion group such as this. However,the material you post is of such a highly, highly, highly personal nature (which in fact physically defines "man")to a Man that you may be unaware that you are crossing a boundary of sorts and entering a place where you aren't really welcome so to speak. Sort of like me posting to alt.menopause.douching.techinques and sounding off about approaches to women's genital hygiene if you catch my drift.
With the Internet though one never knows who's behind the post. You could be a backup NFL quarterback for one of the NYC teams I suppose. Maybe even a starter.
I say "NYC" because some your previous comments contained the characteristic NY-Centric mindset I hear frequently living here in lowly Central, New Jersey. So, working on that assumption and fully aware that I have nowhere near the sophistication (note the prefix "sophist") of the average Manhattanite you sound like you've absorbed enough rants from Andrea Dworkin, Naomi Wolf and other radical feminists that the line between "male" and "female" had been obliterated in your mind long ago.
Just an hypothesis on my part and as I mentioned earlier, you could have no familiarity with Dworkin and Wolfe and be interested only in the writings of Belichick. Note the suffix "chick" in this Kafkaesque matter.
Finally, and to pre-empt the characteristic tantrum you might want to have about your "right" to post anything you want just let me reiterate what I said at the outset and that is that I find it more than a little strange that a woman (and I do actually believe you are a woman) would post this type of stuff. I also notice that no one replied or commented on your posting. Maybe others feel the same way I do but are hesitant to say anything.
Has that thought occurred to you?
Sy
limey - 09 Jan 2008 00:35 GMT > Part II: Sy's letter to me. (12/9) Will just say that my only comment > to Sy about Jersey was that there are great hospitals there. <remainder snipped for brevity>
It took me a while but Sy now happily resides in my killfile. Also in there is Safire, even though he has recently posted using a slightly different address. The peace is wonderful.
Dora
I.P. Freely - 08 Jan 2008 22:51 GMT > I ignored Sy's letter, and I'm not going to talk about the substance > of it now, but I am going to post it in a separate message. Why don't > you all read the letter for yourselves and decide whether the writer > is a reasonable, decent, truthful person, worthy of attention and > respect. Some goon was in my face for weeks until I posted his e-mail on the forum, revealing his public lies. Never heard from him again via e-mail or the forum.
I.P.
Sy - 09 Jan 2008 13:16 GMT YouPee,
Goon"?, "in your face"? You are a real tough guy, but before you start landing blows consider that you'll end up breaking your monitor.
Sy
> > I ignored Sy's letter, and I'm not going to talk about the substance > > of it now, but I am going to post it in a separate message. Why don't [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > I.P. BH - 09 Jan 2008 00:33 GMT >Dear Steve (and All), > >I take your comments very seriously. Just so you know, I'm not a >pervert, I don't have a preference for dirty jokes. Leah, for what little it may be worth, I never thought of you as a pervert. I sincerely appreciate that you have a good sense of humor and welcome your sharing with this group.
>I do reject a lot of jokes -- the runner-up this time was about a doc >laughing at a guy with a small penis. Damn, I'm sorry you didn't post that one. I saw it a month or so ago. If I still had it, I'd post it here now just for kicks. I howled at it, too, even though I, like many men here, have to put up with a shortened member since surgery.
>The fact is, I'm glad for the chance to write this. It's painful for >me to be thought of as some kind of deviant. No pain should be felt over this! I'll offer a thought for your consideration. You could possibly get worse references than being spoken of in an unkind manner by someone like Sy. We all should, and I think we do, consider the source.
Unfortunately, this group has had a few unpleasant people recently. Safire is simply a troll and should be treated accordingly by all who value this group - filter him (or it) out and, by all means, don't feed him.
Sy, on the other hand, is a different sort of character. I don't think he is really trying to be a "bastard". I think it's just a genetic problem. He has shown a bit of improvement at times; but, he has a ways to go. Thanks for posting his letter. Maybe that will help the group handle him more appropriately.
Hang in there with us, Leah. We appreciate you - and your sense of humor. If you still have that joke about the Doc laughing about the small penis, I'd appreciate getting it by email if you don't want to post it.
Burney
>Take my membership card -- Please! No WAY! You're in for the duration. RP in 1995 (age 52) RT in 2000 ADT (Casodex) 10/06 - 8/07
burney dot huff at mindspring dot com
Sy - 09 Jan 2008 13:16 GMT Leah,
Just to be clear, I don't consider you to be a "pervert", or a "slut" or any other such.
I just think you don't get what I'm saying. See Steve's response of a few days ago. He "gets it" perfectly.
Sy
In article <d79162df-628b-4eee-874a-137d9b21fe08@e10g2000prf.googlegroups.com>,
> Dear Steve (and All), > [quoted text clipped - 96 lines] > have lewdness thrust upon them." I put myself in the last category. > Who knows, maybe it will one day lead to greatness.
|
|
|