Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Prostate Cancer / October 2007
end state questions
|
|
Thread rating:  |
nospam@for_me.com - 26 Sep 2007 07:34 GMT Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a few months left to live?
I read lots and lots about prostate cancer treatments but they are mostly for those with early detection. I am to the point there is not much left, and pretty much tired of seeing doctors.
I know most of the men with a very advanced condition probably don't feel much like using the internet. But I would very much like to hear about what I have to expect now that my PSA is skyrocketing. The last stage is chemotherapy but I am not so sure that is a good choice for me.
I have access to various counselors and such, but they require out-of-town trips that are getting logistically difficult for me. In addition, the doctors and such generally won't give me any straight answers and tend to hem and haw lots and in general are really vague. In addition, while I have access to very good doctors they are all overloaded and can't spend adequate time with me.
Once I had a different cancer doctor while mine was on vacation, and I mentioned how much time I probably had left and how much I could expect from chemotherapy, and he mumbled agreement, perhaps not realizing what he was confirming. Other than that, I have had trouble getting much detailed info. In the past I have had numbers based on what I read here and on web sites, and these tended to be more accurate than what I was told by doctors. For example, in asking my prostate cancer specialist, PhD and MD, involved in lots of research projects, what treatment was next, he said don't worry that it will be years before you need to worry about it. Six months later he told me he could do nothing further for me and I was gonna die...seek help elsewhere. It was most strange.
My wife is very concerned and stressed about how she is going to pay all the bills and handle final details. I really hate to burden family more than required. I would like to do as much as I can now while I am still capable, but this is a hard thing to find people with experience in since the experienced are mostly dead. I don't have enough resources to afford nor consult estate planners and such and since I have a negative estate it seems a moot point (I was uninsured, unemployed and too sick with side effects of treatment for years and had to spend everything before the state would pay for anything.)
Any tips, pointers, urls etc. would be appreciated.
c blahblah agoo junkfor spmers dey at wahoo.com (except it is with a y and not a w of course....damn automated address harvesters really suck
fred - 26 Sep 2007 09:21 GMT A fair question, and one that I've thought a lot about myself. My father died of PCa in the 1970s, and the thought of suffering as he did does not appeal to me at all.
Right now, I'm in remission after SRT to deal with a recurrence in 2006, but I'm well aware that I'm one blood test away from moving into the big leagues. If I continue further down this road, I will make an appointment with the doctors at the local (well-respected) Hospice facility that I would likely use, and have them walk me through the expected progression and what they will be able to do to help me through it. I'll also try to meet with other patients (preferably those with PCa) and families currently at Hospice to see how their experience has been, and to better understand what is to come. BTW, Hospice services are paid for in full by most insurances, Medicare and Medicaid.
Over the years, I have had several friends and family members use the local Hospice facility, have visited many of them there and ALL have expressed complete satisfaction with the services they were provided, in terms of pain management, comfort, kindness, psychological and emotional support etc. Based on this track record, I expect that I'm going to be pretty satisfied with what is offerred; I think the Hospice groups have got their act together pretty well, and that things have changed substantially since my father's day (at that time, we had to argue with the doctor to prescribe any narcotic based painkiller even at the very end; his theory was that my dad might get addicted, and morphine would blur his mental acuity....which wasn't a bad thing IMHO).
But if I'm still not satisfied, I will take a hard, long look at moving to Oregon, which allows doctor assisted suicide for terminal patients in their final days (the Death with Dignity law). The experience in Oregon is interesting; the law requires you to apply for the lethal prescription some time in advance. But of those who get and fill the prescription, the numbers of those who actually use it are surprisingly small (only 46 in the entire state in 2006). I think that indicates that people get the prescription as a safeguard if their situation becomes intolerable, but very few actually find that they cannot cope, which may be a tribute to how far we have come in terms of caring for the terminally ill. I hope so anyway. Info about the Oregon law can be found at www.oregon.gov/DHS/ph/pas/ for those who are interested.
Hope these thoughts are helpful.
Fred
Alan Meyer - 26 Sep 2007 18:17 GMT > ... If I continue further down this road, I will make an > appointment with the doctors at the local (well-respected) Hospice > facility that I would likely use, and have them walk me through the > expected progression and what they will be able to do to help me > through it. ... This, and the rest of Fred's advice, seems excellent to me.
When my uncle died of stomach cancer he was placed temporarily in a very good hospice where they completely controlled his pain. However he couldn't afford the costs and had to move to another place that was not as good and didn't do as good a job.
Nospam,
Since you are still able to get around some, use the telephone, and make thoughtful decisions, this is a good time to look at the local hospice options.
Chemotherapy may be of help both in prolonging life and in reducing symptoms, or it may not. Here's one article showing positive results for it: http://tinyurl.com/34s2n5 They claimed a "median time to progression" of 4.4 months. However I'm not sure exactly what that means and whether it translates to 4.4 extra months of life. Nor am I sure if other studies have shown the same benefit, though I do know that other studies have shown some benefit.
One recommendation I sometimes make to people is to write down things that they would like their children and grandchildren to know. If you have children or grandchildren, perhaps you could compose a nice letter to each one expressing your love and best wishes to them, something to be given to them after your death. If there are things you know about your childhood or your parents that others in the family don't know but might like to, you could write those down too. Alternatively you could make tape or video recordings. - Or not if this is not something that appeals to you.
This may also be the last opportunity to overcome any old misunderstandings and conflicts in the family. I know that when I go, I want my wife and children to know that I love and care for them. I want my final days to be as good for them as I can make them. I see it as a final task that I should try to perform as a husband and a father, and something that will help me face death with a purpose and not just with fear and pain.
I wish you the best of luck on the final journey that we all must eventually make.
Best regards,
Alan
Steve Jordan - 26 Sep 2007 20:23 GMT On September 26, Alan Meyer replied to "nospam" in pertinent part:
(snip)
> Chemotherapy may be of help both in prolonging life and in reducing > symptoms, or it may not. Here's one article showing positive results [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > I sure if other studies have shown the same benefit, though I do know > that other studies have shown some benefit. The 4.4 months median means that half the progressions occurred before that point and half afterwards.
But as someone wiser than I has said, "the median is not the message."
My med onc, who is brilliant, and I have discussed this and have agreed that the median applies to a cohort of men in the docetaxel (Taxotere) clinical trials who were far advanced and had no hope. This is not necessarily always the case today.
While I'm on the subject, which I've covered before, I'll say that those brave and selfless men should be accorded all honor due to heroes. They knew the likely outcome, but proceeded anyway in hope of helping those of us who stand on their shoulders.
Regards,
Steve J
"Never -- never -- never give up! Never go gently. There will be plenty of gentle after we die, so until then, fight! Control the rhythms and tempo of the dance, even when you have to let the PCa dancing bear lead for awhile -- even when you have to wear the lead suit as you dance -- never let the bear set the rhythm and tempo of your dance with life -- when the bear finally takes control, it will be a very hollow feeling for him, because I will be gone -- dancing in a better place." --E. B. (Burns) Mixon, PCa survivor, June 14, 2005 Thank you, Burns. Live long and prosper.
Steve Kramer - 26 Sep 2007 12:25 GMT > Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a > few months left to live? [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > stage is chemotherapy but I am not so sure that is a good choice for > me. Nospam,
Are you a new poster? (just curious)
I suspect most of the media referencing prostate cancer is about early diagnosis. To date, that is the topic about which most long-term information exists. All of the newer "end state" developments and discoveries are too new to have a history and some (e.g., Provenge) are still mired in testing.
As to what can be expected, I will tell you of my father. His PCa was diagnosed in 1974 and after cobalt radiation, estrogen ADT, and chemotherapy, he had a near-fatal heart attack, a couple of hernias, broken ribs after sneezing, and literally withered before our eyes and died. In the end, his bones were riddled with cancer and the attendant pain was so bad that it appeared only to be abated when the cancer got into his brain. He liteally faught it ti the last second, but finally died.
I swore, after that, if I ever got the disease, I would not fight it so long and I would not even consider chemo. All chemo did was extend his life and make the quality of that life a horror.
However, that was then and this is now.
Chemotherapy is better. The stuff they have now focuses on prostate cancer. Furthermore, the meds they add to the chemo regimen are much better at keeping the QOL within reason. Radiation is tremendously more accurate and less invasive and exhaustive.
Since I don't know if you're a regular poster with a new addy, I don't know just how far you are into the fight against this bastard. I will therefore assume, based on your statements, you know you are nearing the end. I expect to be there at some point. When I am there, I will accept all the palliative treatments available. Since chemo is better now, I will try it. But, the nice thing about chemo is, if you find your extended life is not worth living, simply stop taking it.
> My wife is very concerned and stressed about how she is going to pay > all the bills and handle final details. I really hate to burden family [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > Any tips, pointers, urls etc. would be appreciated. I wish I had some help for you on this. I cannot even imagine being in that situation.
ronju99 - 26 Sep 2007 12:28 GMT Hi nospam, For those who will be walking the same path as you sometime in the future, what has your psa been and how has it skyrocketed?
Ron S.
doug.gosling@gmail.com - 26 Sep 2007 17:54 GMT > Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a > few months left to live? Likewise, I would be interested in a bit of your history/journey. I may be getting there myself at some point in the future. In the meantime, I can offer you this. I've just started a blogging site called talkingaboutcancer.com to deal exclusively with the emotional aspects of cancer, which you could post your request on. While it is very new, there are a number of folks who may have some good advice to give you and, additionally, the dialog would be of benefit to others. You can go to the site and click on New Post to submit it or just reply to this with your permission to post and I will put it up.
This is a great group, one that I have used myself at various times, so keep active on it as well.
I wish you all the best.
Doug
c palmer - 26 Sep 2007 18:24 GMT Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a few months left to live?
I read lots and lots about prostate cancer treatments but they are mostly for those with early detection. I am to the point there is not much left, and pretty much tired of seeing doctors.
I know most of the men with a very advanced condition probably don't feel much like using the internet. But I would very much like to hear about what I have to expect now that my PSA is skyrocketing. The last stage is chemotherapy but I am not so sure that is a good choice for me.
I have access to various counselors and such, but they require out-of-town trips that are getting logistically difficult for me. In addition, the doctors and such generally won't give me any straight answers and tend to hem and haw lots and in general are really vague. In addition, while I have access to very good doctors they are all overloaded and can't spend adequate time with me.
Once I had a different cancer doctor while mine was on vacation, and I mentioned how much time I probably had left and how much I could expect from chemotherapy, and he mumbled agreement, perhaps not realizing what he was confirming. Other than that, I have had trouble getting much detailed info. In the past I have had numbers based on what I read here and on web sites, and these tended to be more accurate than what I was told by doctors. For example, in asking my prostate cancer specialist, PhD and MD, involved in lots of research projects, what treatment was next, he said don't worry that it will be years before you need to worry about it. Six months later he told me he could do nothing further for me and I was gonna die...seek help elsewhere. It was most strange.
My wife is very concerned and stressed about how she is going to pay all the bills and handle final details. I really hate to burden family more than required. I would like to do as much as I can now while I am still capable, but this is a hard thing to find people with experience in since the experienced are mostly dead. I don't have enough resources to afford nor consult estate planners and such and since I have a negative estate it seems a moot point (I was uninsured, unemployed and too sick with side effects of treatment for years and had to spend everything before the state would pay for anything.) Any tips, pointers, urls etc. would be appreciated.
====> hi no spam - if you want to know more, just write me. i've been down this trail before with my dad. he died FROM the prostate cancer, not with it.
i will try to fill in some of the blanks for you.
judging from what you wrote, you are in the advance stages and on chemo. you are probably hormone refractive. so, when did you go hormone refractive? if you use that date, then, that will give you a ball park figure on how long you have left to live.
as to pain management - there are three stages - going from the light pain management to the extreme pain management. as the skeleton system is compromised by the cancer, it will collapse and pinch the nerves thus causing the pain.
they do have some good end of life pain meds so that part will be ok.
strontium 89 treatments does help on the bone pain.
as far as what to do on dying...... my advice is that you got a chance to put things together. this is something that most don't have the chance to do. it's not like saying, "you know what? the sun is out. the weather is nice and warm. it's a good day to die....."
and then again, there's the attitude of the public on their take about dying. it's so permanent. speaking on that, there was a salesman who sold insurance and was a real good salesman. when the policy holder would take out the coverage and when it would get down to the amount of money they were wanting to take out the insurance for - say 50,000 or 100,000 dollars. he would look at them and say, "you don't plan on staying dead for very long - do you?"
well, anyway, back to the death and dying.......
i will tell you my side of things. i've faced my own death three times so far. i'm not afraid of dying. it's going to happen, so big whoop. i might as well enjoy the ride while i'm here.
so, i've already bought my grave site, my head stone and i've picked out my music that i want to be played. haven't decided on what to be buried it yet. still looking around on that one. i feel why should i bother my family with this stuff. it's my death and i should have my say and what and where i want to be buried.
so, your questions about this post aren't off the mark.
so, i will go back to what you first ask....
Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a few months left to live?
===> i would say. enjoy life - make memories with the ones that you love. take pictures - lots of pictures while you still in good spirits -because this will what they will have left tor remember you by. tie up any loose ends you can so as to not to burden anyone else with having to make the decision. this way, everyone will know what was done was your wishes and there is a comfort in knowing that.
if you can still travel or if there is something that you've always wanted to do in your life..... try to do it.
hope this has helped.
all the best....
~ curtis
knowledge is power - growing old is mandatory - growing wise is optional "Many more men die with prostate cancer than of it. Growing old is invariably fatal. Prostate cancer is only sometimes so." http://community.webtv.net/PALMER_ENT/doc
california_chief - 26 Sep 2007 18:41 GMT > My wife is very concerned and stressed about how she is going to pay > all the bills and handle final details. I really hate to burden family [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > Any tips, pointers, urls etc. would be appreciated. You failed to mention your age, latest PSA, geographical location (with respect to hospitals and treatment centers).
Are you a veteran? AL, VFW, DAV, AMVETS, and other similar organization can help. Veterans are entitled to free burial - including headstone - in any national cemetary.
Are you on SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance) and Medicare? I was 53 when I retired on disability.
You mentioned "the state," and I assume you mean SSI (Supplimental Security Income). Is that correct?
nospam@for_me.com - 12 Oct 2007 05:26 GMT >> My wife is very concerned and stressed about how she is going to pay >> all the bills and handle final details. I really hate to burden family [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] >You mentioned "the state," and I assume you mean SSI (Supplimental Security >Income). Is that correct? My thanks to all who posted and continue to post here and elsewhere. I read it all carefully.
To answer a few questions, I just today received results of my last PSA test. it was 67.31. That means I have more than doubled twice this year.
I am 53 1/2 years old. I live 100 miles from Seattle based specialists but think I actually have better ones more local to me. I was under a Seattle researcher( MD, PhD etc.) but switched back to local ones. He predicted I would be dead within 6-18 months and I have already passed that, so I can't complain too much.
I am now on my wife's pretty good insurance, plus government benefits from SSI. At the time I was diagnosed I had nothing, but eventually qualified for Washington state assistance. While no where near well off, I can now at least afford cable TV and cable Internet (no premium channels of course) so I have something to keep busy with. I start chemotherapy (taxotere) next week, and am told to avoid people so as not to pick up any bugs) so guess I will be spending most of my time watching tv and/or surfing the net.
I have done well to get social security disability. Without it and the benefits I don't know how I could possibly have managed this long. It seems the social security investigator doctor that called my personal doctor, did so on a Friday, and my doctor wasn't scheduled to work, but as often was the case, she was at work catching up on things. She had just left the office when she heard the phone ring. Most people who come in on a day off would have let it ring, but she decided it might be important. She ended up talking to the doctor in charge of approving my benefits for an hour or so. He said he was tired of approving benefits for people that were dead, and approved mine while there was still time to help out. I am either lucky or had a guardian angel on my shoulder.
My doctors all seem competent - I just got a nasty version of cancer. I pretty much can get what I want if it is an approved treatment, but there isn't much yet approved that is that great. I think within a few more years we will see breakthroughs in all areas of cancer treatment - I am just a little to early to see them developed.
Steve Kramer - 12 Oct 2007 13:47 GMT > I am 53 1/2 years old. I live 100 miles from Seattle based specialists > but think I actually have better ones more local to me. I was under a > Seattle researcher( MD, PhD etc.) but switched back to local ones. When did it all start for you, ... er... nospam? What was your beginning PSA, Gleason, Stage, etc.? How well did varioius treatments work along the way?
Forgive me if you've posted before, but your anonymity kind of gets in the way of remembering whether you've been here before.
> My doctors all seem competent - I just got a nasty version of cancer. > I pretty much can get what I want if it is an approved treatment, but > there isn't much yet approved that is that great. I think within a few > more years we will see breakthroughs in all areas of cancer treatment > - I am just a little to early to see them developed. About once a year, I sit down with my doc and discuss what he's heard on the treatment front. That time this year was yesterday. He said about that same. "When your PSA breaks through... [I wish he had said 'if'.] ... there are recent chemo treatments that are much better for PCa victims, but nothing for where you are now."
We discussed Provenge and he agrees with the FDA. He came short of alleging falsified findings, but the discussion was along those lines.
As to cures, there is not much in the near future and when there is, "the FDA process will delay it substantially." I gathered the FDA provides him some cognitive dissonance.
 Signature PSA 16 10/17/2000 @ 46 Biopsy 11/01/2000 G7 (3+4), T2c RRP 12/15/2000 G7 (3+4), T3cN0M0 Neg margins PSA <.1 <.1 <.1 .27 .37 .75 PSAD 0.19 years EBRT 05-07/2002 @ 47 PSA .34 .22 .15 .21 .32 PSAD .056 years Lupron 07/03 (1 mo) 8/03 and every 4 months there after PSA .07 .05 .06 .09 .08 .132 .145 PSAD 1.4 years Casodex added daily 07/06 PSA <0.04, <0.05, <0.04 (06/12/2007) Non Illegitimi Carborundum
I.P. Freely - 26 Sep 2007 18:55 GMT The libraries and book stores contain many books along the lines of "Death With Dignity". They range from the philosophical to the practical, and from the religious to assisted suicide, and I plan to read and/or skim many of them if and when my time approaches. It sounds like your estate planning should include trying to shield your wife, if possible, from your "negative estate" (aka debts). And it looks like you're ready to face this problem head-on, which will serve you well. Your wife needn't fear the administrative preparation -- with no estate that shouldn't take long -- and maybe the books and friends can help ease the emotional impact of the next few months and years.
Even those of us who hope they're cured know they may still face your scenario. Please keep us informed of your findings, feelings, and insights. And both of you must know you have our attention and our support.
I.P.
Alex - 26 Sep 2007 19:06 GMT > The libraries and book stores contain many books along the lines of "Death > With Dignity". They range from the philosophical to the practical, and [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > > I.P. Alex - 26 Sep 2007 20:07 GMT For many years I had the privilege of caring for my mother, who died on Labor Day at a bit over 99. She was a wonderful woman, bright and interested in everything and in relative good health until the last year or so, when colon and skin cancer and several strokes finally began to take their toll. (Yes, she was a strong lady!) So I got an advance look at what is eventually like to happen to me and others in this group.
I can tell you that you should "shop around" carefully for hospice care. There is a real difference in the quality of the care they deliver, their attitude toward pain control, etc. Some with religious affiliations may be a bit less likely to give high levels of pain control meds that could cause "premature" death. Those with thinner funding may send nurses once a week instead of twice or more often, or may rely on family members to let them know when pain med levels need to be increased. That could mean you will be uncomfortable or in real pain until the med level is adjusted.
It will help you a lot if you have a family member or trusted friend who is willing and able to act as your advocate with the hospice folks. As a son, I had no trouble making sure my mother got care. I was cordial but insistant when I felt that she needed attention she wasn't getting I'm not sure how they would have responded to someone who was not a family member, so check that out in advance. You may need to sign a power of attorney or other legal document to give someone the authority to act on your behalf.
You also should sign a living will or advance health care directive that states that you want to be allowed to die without "heroic measures" or other medical intervention. You can find these online, or get one from your local hospital. Make sure it is properly witnessed, and give copies to your caregiver, your physician, your hospice care provider, etc.
You may want to read Medicare's 14-page guide to Hospice Benefits. You can download it at http://www.medicare.gov/Publications/Pubs/pdf/02154.pdf
Medicare covers the cost of hospice care and items like a wheelchair, hospital bed for the home, all pain meds, etc. My mother was not in a hospice facility or nursing home. However, I believe the cost of a nursing home or hospital is often covered by Medicare.
Medicare will NOT cover the cost of in-home aides. If you are not placed in a hospice facility and your family cannot provide around-the-clock care for you in the final weeks or longer, when you are likely to need extensive care, paid in-home aides will cost about $12 to $15 per hour, which adds up pretty quickly. Here too you need to shop for quality and cost.
If you die without being under the care of a physician, your state may require an autopsy, which could be very upsetting for your family. The hospice will assign a doctor to oversee your case. That MD, or your regular one, should see you every few months, so he or she can sign the death certificate without the need for an autopsy.
Unless you are lucky, dying is not quick or pleasant, for you or the people who love you. The pain meds (methadone and morphine are commonly used) will block most or all of the pain. But they may affect your memory, to the point where you don't recognize your own kids or can't finish a sentence. You may have episodes of paranoia, even toward loved ones. You may not recognize your surroundings, or be aware that you are sick. You may not be able to bathe yourself, or go to the bathroom without help. You may have trouble eating or drinking. (Ensure is a godsend.) Despite your weakness, you may sleepwalk, or try to fling yourself out of bed at night. You may lose control of your bowels and have to wear a diaper day and night. Without a special air mattress, you may develop bed sores.
(Remember, I said "may." Your final days may be very different, and hopefully fewer and better.)
For the very last few days, thanks to the powerful meds and the inevitable weakening of your body, you are likely to be asleep or unconscious -- not in any pain, physical or mental. And then it will be over.
My thoughts are with you.
Alex
I.P. Freely - 27 Sep 2007 00:08 GMT > Unless you are lucky, dying is not quick or pleasant, for you or the people > who love you. The pain meds (methadone and morphine are commonly used) will > block most or all of the pain. But they may affect your memory, to the point > where you don't recognize your own kids or can't finish a sentence. You may > have episodes of paranoia, even toward loved ones. You may not recognize > your surroundings, or be aware that you are sick. There's no way in hell I will voluntarily or knowingly put my wife through that, especially at her expense. She has earned a better ending to my life.
> You may not be able to bathe yourself, or go to the bathroom without > help. You may have trouble eating or drinking. (Ensure is a godsend.) > Despite your weakness, you may sleepwalk, or try to fling yourself out > of bed at night. You may lose control of your bowels and have to wear > a diaper day and night. And if I don't recognize my family, why endure this list and its implied next few dozen horrors, especially at their expense? My living will and power of attorney give my wife total decision power at the point I'm not capable of rendering it explicitly.
We've got to have the option of freeing ourselves of the medical profession's obsession with maximizing heartbeat at the expense of the patient and his family. Here's an idea: we need the legal right to have the damn doctors and/or private hospitals foot the bill beyond the point described above.
I.P.
Alan Meyer - 28 Sep 2007 23:32 GMT > For many years I had the privilege of caring for my mother, who died > on Labor Day at a bit over 99. ...
That was a very useful post Alex with a lot of information for all of us.
Thanks.
Alan
callalily - 27 Sep 2007 00:15 GMT > Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a > few months left to live? [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > he could do nothing further for me and I was gonna die...seek help > elsewhere. It was most strange. ===>>I am sorry you find yourself in this situation. But it is brave of you to ask questions, and I hope it will be useful to you. Apparently, the D-word is still taboo in most quarters, including the doctor's office. And even in some of these groups. A man posted a msg saying that he wished his doctors would "give him permission to die." Or at least be honest with him. And, he was dismayed that he did not see any patients writing about what the experience of dying is like.
Later, the man wrote that he'd been deluged with responses -- offline. I wonder if some people don't want to bring up the subject of death because they might be accused of "pessimism" (not uncommon).
You can read about Tom's experiences @ an excellent blog on advanced PC (advancedprostatecancer.net), which is sponsored by Malecare, as is my own. Look under "One Man's View" on August 23. The man who writes this blog, Joel Nowak, is in the same situtation as you. And he is asking himself the same questions you are. (In one of the most recent entries). The writer is also knowledgeable about every detail of treatment, news, etc. And he writes every day.
But I believe things are changing. I am seeing end-of-life issues being discussed often in the paper now.
You might also want to look at a listserv called "The Circle" @ prostatepointers.org. Here, many end-of-life issues are discussed. A woman named Wendy kept an online diary of the last stage of her husband's illness. Amazin .)
> Any tips, pointers, urls etc. would be appreciated. > > c blahblah agoo junkfor spmers dey at wahoo.com (except it > is with a y and not a w of course....damn automated address harvesters > really suck callalily - 27 Sep 2007 01:20 GMT > > Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a > > few months left to live?
> ===>> I am sorry you find yourself in this situation. But it is brave > of you to ask questions, and I hope it will be useful to you. [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > husband's illness. Amazin > .) [Sorry, got cut off in mid-word.] It was very detailed. Wendy's diary was not as depressing as you might think. There is a certain unique pleasure derived from caring for a loved one. I suggested to this woman that she put her diary online in the form of a blog. But she is still active in the group, and she and others may help you with your questions.
If you could tolerate a joke: I was looking on the above list recently, and I saw a post from a woman, saying, "I would like to talk to the wives of men who are end-stage or passed on." For some reason I am not reading things properly these days, my mind being in "cancer mode." (See on my blog, "Notes from Cancerworld.) Anyway, I stared at this msg for a long time, because I thought the lady wanted to talk to *men* who'd passed on. A first!
In the last few week alone, there have been a number of articles in the NY Times about death and dying. There was one on 9/23, written by a doctor who questioned current attitudes toward dying patients. ("Between Comfort and Care," etc.) He writes that doctors need to be trained to "deal with death" as a reality, and to apply this knowledge to various situations. Should doctors always recommend "extraordinary treatment", e.g.? If you can tolerate another bit of black humor: Cited in the article (or maybe the next one) was this: "Why do coffins exist?" "So that the doctors won't do any more chemo."
And how much should doctors tell patients? Many, if not most, doctors lie through the nose. And often they just don't have the answers. The issue of disclosure was treated even more extensively in another article (opinion page) in the NYT ("The Bad News First," by Chritakis, 8/23 or 24). Here the doctor was arguing in favor of giving patients precise prognoses. Like I said, the problem with that is that often doctors are only guessing themselves. For example, I mentioned Tom, the patient who complained the lack of information and discussion about dying. He wants doctors to be straightforward. He also happens to have a PSA of 3800, and was told by his docs, I'm sure in good faith, that he was "dead man walking" long ago. Personally, I think he is death-proof. And then there is the effect of "directness" on the patient and families.
There was a lively response to this article in the Letters to Editor. I must say a lot of them disagreed with the above doctor.
Finally, there is something we can be happy about. Apparently, according to no less than 3 articles in the NYT on this subject a few weeks ago, very few people in the world are given any treatment for cancer pain. The sad thing is, this not because of lack of availability: morphine is cheap and plentiful. It's all about attitude. That's why it surprises me that palliative care has gained acceptance in this country. We are at heart a puritanical bunch. We owe a tremendous death to those that fought for our right to pain- control.
The articles cited in the paper concerns 3 countries: Africa, Japan and India. Different problems prevail in different countries. For example, certain patients fear taking morphine, for various reasons (they've been told it's bad), societies are afraid of drug addiction and trafficking, etc. In India, for example, there is one pain clinic in Calcutta to serve 14 million people. The reason is "regulatory morass". Their narcotics laws are so strict, for example, that you have to get 5 licenses to dispense the drug. And every single morphine pill given to a patient that has not been used has to be returned. (Problem: a lot of the dead are cremated.) Even sympathetic doctors and pharmacists are deterred by this. The sad thing is that most of the world's legal morphine is made in India. In Japan, one of the problems is the "samurai" ethic: courageous people endure pain.
So we are lucky to have access to pain meds and hospice care, which seems to be acclaimed by everybody.
I also think there should be more of a discussion of active suicide. If Hitler could swallow a cyanide pill and die (or become unconscious) in 30 seconds, why should a painless death not be available to better people? I wouldn't mind having one just in case. What bothers me is that just about every religious tradition has such strong taboos against suicide. You can be as depraved as you want, but if you take your own life, you either go to hell or destroy your karma.
Sorry to chew your ear off.
I do wish you the very best, and if I have any ideas about the other issues you raised, I will write more.
Leah
prostatecancerblog.net
Larry Sabo - 27 Sep 2007 01:48 GMT >We >owe a tremendous death to those that fought for our right to pain- ^^^^^
>control. I'm sure you meant, tremenous debt. :)
Larry
callalily - 27 Sep 2007 01:49 GMT Dear No-Spam,
Sorry for the deluge. But I forgot the most important point. People often cite this quote by Churchill as a reason to soldier on under any circumstances:
"Never, never, in nothing great or small, large or petty, never give in except to convictions of honour and good sense. Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy.''
I love Win, but he must have been drunk when he said this. I agree with the part about honor and good sense. But never yield to overwhelming force? How often does David actually slay Goliath? And don't try this at home unless you are assured of divine help, as in" (Psalm 91) "Let 1,000 encamp at your side," but you will not be harmed. Cancer can be an overwhelming force, and sometimes it's good sense to surrender, as well as honorable.
WC was speaking in the context of England's dire situation in Oct' 41, to a bunch of young men, potential military recruits. But it's not as if his situation was truly desperate: WC knew he had the support of FDR, and potentially, the might of America behind him. As an example.
Leah
Leah
djperry42@sbcglobal.net - 27 Sep 2007 23:33 GMT How a person dies is entirely up to him but we all should realize that how we live and die will leave memories for those left behind that will last a lifetime. Of course, we all want to leave good memories but that's not always the case. Here are two people I've known who left me with vastly different perspectives.
The first was a guy, age 54, who had been fighting colon cancer for a couple of years and losing. The last six months he was a walking (barely) corpse yet neither he nor his wife acknowledged death, never discussed it with anyone and in fact maintained a positive but unrealistic outlook the whole time. The last time I saw him, he could barely walk, he needed help getting out of a chair, he was a skeleton, he had death written all over him yet he was talking about his plans for re-doing his backyard among other things. The topper was when he showed me a brochure for a cruise he and his wife were going on in another couple of months, all paid for, etc.. I thought at the time there's something wrong with these people, they're never going on this cruise. He died two weeks later. Am I selfish to feel cheated? We never laughed over the good times we had together, I never thanked him for the otherwise very positive impact he had on my life, nothing was allowed that hinted in any way about the possibility of pending death - it was all business as usual.
The other person was a lady of similar age who had breast cancer, was treated surgically and had made a full recovery. About two years later she and her husband had a huge barbeque at their home for all their friends and family. She spent the day being a gracious hostess, talking with each person, sharing good times, lots of laughter with nary a hint of anything wrong. After she died a couple of months later we realized then that she knew there had been a recurrence and that she wanted to have one last good time with her friends and family.
I know this is really about me and my reaction to these folks, and I realize that neither one discussed the upcoming death but I can't help it that my last memory of the grand lady was her laughter at her barbeque and my last memory of the guy was the foolish futility of him holding his cruise brochure. When it comes my time I plan on a barbeque and to hell with the cruise.
And by the way, here's to Hughie, a guy who knew where he was going and who got there in a most admirable way. Dave Perry
> Summary: got any advice for those in the final stages, with perhaps a > few months left to live? [quoted text clipped - 44 lines] > is with a y and not a w of course....damn automated address harvesters > really suck Alan Meyer - 28 Sep 2007 23:49 GMT Interesting post Dave.
My wife and I took a cruise to Alaska some years ago and met an elderly couple from Oklahoma. The wife was dying of cancer and was in a wheel chair, but she wanted to see Alaska before she went. She was remarkably cheerful and friendly to everyone.
I remember getting off at one stop on the cruise. This dear lady was wheeled off the ship by her attentive husband. She couldn't go very far because of her wheelchair and the rough terrain, but I could see all over her face that she was marvelling at the beauty of the place and loved the trip.
It was a lesson for me in positive attitudes.
Alan
djperry42@sbcglobal.net - 29 Sep 2007 00:57 GMT Alan, I agree positive attitudes are important and the lady you met on the cruise was to be much admired. There was something she wanted to do before she died and she did it. She acknowledged her pending death and as you say "was remarkably cheerful." In addition, she left you and everyone else on that cruise with fond memories of her that you are able to recall years later. My hat's off to her and I hope I can finish my days in a similar fashion.
However, my friend pushed "positive attitude" a bit far. I will not put up a false front of denial that leaves everyone tip-toeing around me afraid to hint that there's any threat on my horizon all the while wiping drool off my chin and helping me to the can. Dave Perry
> Interesting post Dave. > [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > > Alan
|
|
|