Veteran Files Claim After Wrong Testicle Is Removed at VA Hospital in
Los Angeles
Wednesday, April 4, 2007 1423 PDT
LOS ANGELES, California -- An Air Force veteran has filed a federal
claim after an operation at a Veterans Administration hospital in
which a healthy testicle was removed instead of a potentially
cancerous one.
Benjamin Houghton, 47, was to have had his left testicle removed June
14 at the West Los Angeles VA Medical Center because there was a
chance it could harbor cancer cells. It also was atrophied and
painful.
But doctors mistakenly removed the right testicle, according to
medical records and the claim, which seeks $200,000 for future care
and unspecified damages. He still hasn't had the other testicle
removed.
"At first I thought it was a joke," Houghton told the Los Angeles
Times. "Then I was shocked. I told them, 'What do I do now?'"
Houghton, his wife, Monica, and their attorney, Dr. Susan Friery, said
they hoped to get the VA's attention by going public with the
situation.
Dr. Dean Norman, chief of staff for the Greater Los Angeles VA system,
has formally apologized to Houghton and his wife.
"We are making every attempt that we can to care for Mr. Houghton, but
it's in litigation, and that's all we can tell you," he said. The
hospital changed practices as a result of the case, he added.
rosbif - 05 Apr 2007 07:43 GMT
Very bad news. Is there an objective and standard definition for left
and right when there is both observed and observer?
...is it the red wire or the blue wire? (beads of sweat).
chasjac - 05 Apr 2007 14:46 GMT
> Very bad news. Is there an objective and standard definition for left
> and right when there is both observed and observer?
How about ... the one that's "atrophied"? Didn't these guys even look
at what they were operating on?
--charlie
Alex - 05 Apr 2007 15:23 GMT
>> Very bad news. Is there an objective and standard definition for left
>> and right when there is both observed and observer?
>
> How about ... the one that's "atrophied"? Didn't these guys even look
> at what they were operating on?
A friend of mine, who is himself a surgeon, wrote "Remove other kidney" on
one side of his abdomen in Magic Marker when going in for kidney removal
surgery. He'd seen too many "regrettable mistakes."
Not a lot of note-writing room on a testicle, though. Maybe "Keep" on one,
"Take" on the other?
Alex
kh - 05 Apr 2007 16:48 GMT
On Apr 5, 10:23 am, "Alex" <tuchasoffentisch@_NO_SPAM_gmail.com>
wrote:
> A friend of mine, who is himself a surgeon, wrote "Remove other kidney" on
> one side of his abdomen in Magic Marker when going in for kidney removal
> surgery. He'd seen too many "regrettable mistakes."
> Not a lot of note-writing room on a testicle, though. Maybe "Keep" on one,
> "Take" on the other?
I'd write on my thigh or tummy with arrows pointing.
Keep >>----> OO <----<< Cut this one off!
-kh
I.P. Freely - 05 Apr 2007 22:47 GMT
It's SOP at many hospitals -- including my VA hospital -- now to have
the patient mark himself, under observation so any questions can be
settled right then and there, with a magic marker instructing the
surgeons what to do. The last thing before surgery I remember was
writing words and diagrams on my own belly just before they began
prepping me for the OR . . . something like "Cut on dotted line and
remove prostate and ascending colon."
I.P.
Bill - 05 Apr 2007 15:21 GMT
Well, I guess that's the way the ball bounces. :-)
Seriously, I wonder if they can get displaced? If the surgeon was not
involved in Dx and Tx leading up to the operation, and just had an
order to remove the left testicle, he might not even have known to
check for atrophy.
Bill Denton
RP 2/12/02
PSA 1.6
Memphis