My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
we should receive the results tomorrow.
During our last visit, the doctor informed us that he will eventually ask us
to visit his office in order to hear a forty-five minute talk about things
we need to know.
I have a question: Do you think the doctor will allow me to record his talk
with a small voice recorder? Has anyone else done this? I don't want to miss
a thing that he says, but I'm concerned about the medical establishment's
attitude towards recording conversations.
Thanks ahead of time.
One more thing; Thank you for all of the help so far and thanks for
recommending Dr. Walsh's book.
Davis
olfart - 23 Feb 2004 00:06 GMT
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Davis
You might call ahead and ask the nurse or receptionist, but I doubt that the
recorder will be a problem. The Dr may also hand out literature along with
his talk as was the case when I had my evaluation meeting. They realize that
it's hard to remember everything given in a lecture or talk and so most good
Doctors will be helpful in this area.
Your father's PSA is high, but not unmanageable. Keep us posted and *good
thoughts* to both of you.
Age - 68
8/12/02 - PSA 3.7
10/13/03 - PSA 4.69
11/11/03 - PSA 4.8
11/18/03 - Biopsy - 10 cores
one core-25% of core-Gleason 4+4=8
all other cores benign tissue
12/10/03 - Consult - Oncologist
12/16/03 - Consult - Radiation Oncologist
Treatment Plan -
HT - started 12/17/03 - Eulixen & Lupron
2/10/04 - Started - Flowmax and Megastrol
Radiation - IMRT to begin 3/14/04 - for 5 weeks
Theraseed implant after Radiation completed
Tom Cular - 23 Feb 2004 01:13 GMT
I doubt that the Dr. would object to you recording the meeting if the intent
is to use the recording as a "notepad" and ask him beforehand and offer to
provide him with a copy of the tape or the opportunity to review and revise
it before you leave. If the Dr. feels that you're setting him up with a
"well, you said this or you said that", he will probably be reluctant to
having his every word recorded.
I use a recorder daily at work for notes, however, at meetings, I've found
that keeping written notes makes everyone more comfortable, if he/she speaks
too fast for your note keeping; ask him/her to slow down or repeat.
Doctors know, or should, that you are experiencing a shocking conversation
and will not remember most of what was discussed unless you record the
meeting in some fashion, I still think that written notes are preferable.
It would be helpful for you to write down any questions you may have, prior
to the meeting. Also write down any questions that may surface after your
meeting and ask those by phone or at your next visit.
I can't speak for everyone, but, I and many others never heard much more
than the word "cancer" at the initial meeting.
Tom
'
> > My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week
> and
[quoted text clipped - 40 lines]
> Radiation - IMRT to begin 3/14/04 - for 5 weeks
> Theraseed implant after Radiation completed
Leonard Evens - 23 Feb 2004 01:42 GMT
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
>
> During our last visit, the doctor informed us that he will eventually ask us
> to visit his office in order to hear a forty-five minute talk about things
> we need to know.
It sounds as if he is planning to play a tape for you rather than
deliver a lecture.
> I have a question: Do you think the doctor will allow me to record his talk
> with a small voice recorder? Has anyone else done this? I don't want to miss
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Davis
Steve Kramer - 23 Feb 2004 02:51 GMT
He'll probably feel uneasy about it, but will probably allow it. I this
litigious society, I'm sure most docs are reasonably apprehensive of tape
recorders.

Signature
Prostate Cancer Survivor (so far), not a doctor
PSA 16 10/17/2000 @ 46
Biopsy 11/01/2000 G7 (3+4), T2c
RRP 12/15/2000
PSA .1 .1 .1 .3 .4 .8
EBRT 05-07/2002 @ 47
PSA .3 .2 .2 .2 .3
Erection 05/12/2003 @ 48
HTbegins 07/21/2003 @ 48
PSA .1
Lupron 7/03, 8/03, 12/03
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Davis
Lillian - 23 Feb 2004 13:26 GMT
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Davis
I took lots of notes, and the doctor stopped several times for me to
get everything down. He also let us schedule a second meeting a week
later to go over everything one more time and clear up any questions
we had. He told us to call whenever we had a question between now and
March 15 when the surgery is scheduled. This doctor probably would
not have had a problem with recording his answers. But like the
others said, I would call first and check.
Robert Austin - 26 Feb 2004 16:54 GMT
<Snip>
>I have a question: Do you think the doctor will allow me to record his talk
>with a small voice recorder? Has anyone else done this? I don't want to miss
>a thing that he says, but I'm concerned about the medical establishment's
>attitude towards recording conversations.
<Snip>
Hello Gang -
My surgeon asked me to bring my wife, take notes or bring a tape
recorder to go over my case and the options on dealing with my Pca.
Afterward, I wanted a second opinion and went to a leading oncologist
to get his opinion. His nurse came into the exam room and said the
doctor would be in soon and would record the consultation.
As soon as the doctor had exchanged pleasantries he popped a tape into
a small tape recorder and turned it on. When the visit was over he
removed the tape and handed it to me to keep. I played that tape back
several times and found it valuable in helping me make decisions about
the whole RP process.
I would be suspicious of any doctor that would object to having a
conversation taped of such a serious matter. Maybe my experience was
just luck, but I rather doubt it.
Bob Austin
Age 74
PSA 7 Free PSA 12
1st round of biopsies clear, 2nd. 2 positives
Gleason 9
Cryosurgery 03/11/03
Post Op PSA's .04 & .01
RobertBob.Austin@NoSpam.Att.Net
Davis - 27 Feb 2004 05:57 GMT
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Davis
Thanks again for all of the help. The biopsy result arrived and yes, cancer
is confirmed. On Tuesday, my father is going for a CT scan and a bone scan.
After those results are in, we will make an appointment with the doctor for
the consultation.
Davis - 27 Feb 2004 06:14 GMT
> My seventy-eight year old father (PSA39.5) had a biopsy taken last week and
> we should receive the results tomorrow.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Davis
Thanks again for all of the help. The biopsy result arrived and yes, cancer
is confirmed. On Tuesday, my father is going for a CT scan and a bone scan.
After those results are in, we will make an appointment with the doctor for
the consultation.
Danny McCarty - 27 Feb 2004 21:29 GMT
>Subject: Re: Speaking With Doctor
>From: "Davis" nospam@nospam.com
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
>After those results are in, we will make an appointment with the doctor for
>the consultation.
My 82 year old uncle had an RRP when he was 76. He is doing very well. Hope
you father is the same...