Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Cancer / September 2007
The Problem with British Health care 1/4
|
|
Thread rating:  |
A M L [Manchester England] - 21 Sep 2007 16:27 GMT The Problem with British Health care 1/4
Cooled Boiled Water (as an example)
Every mother in the United Kingdom is told to feed her baby cooled boiled water. Say that to a doctor in continental Europe, and s/he will say "that's because you're British. You can use cooled boiled water if you want, or tap water, or mineral water."
Cooled boiled water is clearly a myth. Had it any truth, it would be used in hospitals, nursing homes, hospices and other places for the infirm. It isn't. There is nothing wrong with British water.
British water is not perfect, but close to it. The number one contaminant in British water is lead. Lead retards a child's brain growth, and is the reason it was removed from British petrol (or gasoline), years after the Americans banned the sale of new car running on leaded petroleum spirit.
If you're worried about lead in British water for your baby, the last thing you would do is boil it. As lead has a higher boiling point than water, boiling the water will increase the concentration of lead, from no detectable parts per million, frankly to no detectable parts per million. There is nothing wrong with British water. Almost all the lead pipes have gone, and they didn't put much in the water anyway.
The doctor may continue.
British health care leads the world, in cardiology, artificial reproduction, . . ., just about anything that captures the headlines, but routine health care in the UK, is stuck in the nineteenth century. The British are told that nature knows best. If nature knew best, we would not have medicine.
So if you have a cancer you will be told "nothing is wrong," or "you probably have a virus," until it's too late. Primary health care, like dentistry and optical care, are shunned by the British system, yet the dentist may be the first to notice an oral abnormality and opticians are the first to notice diabetes.
So long as the British want headlines, the UK will continue to have the worst health outcomes in the developed world.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Roger Dewhurst - 21 Sep 2007 21:54 GMT > The Problem with British Health care 1/4 > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > used in hospitals, nursing homes, hospices and other places for the > infirm. It isn't. There is nothing wrong with British water. There bloody well is. The chlorine in it. Chlorine reacts with various organic compound to form trihalomethanes one of which is the liver carcinogen chloroform. Boil your foodstuffs starting with cold chorinated water and god knows what carcinogens you finish up with. There was a meat processing plant near Thames (New Zealand) which had a consignment of meat rejected by the USA because it was contaminated with chloroform. The chloroform was the product of a reaction between the chlorine added to the water supply and organic compounds from the forested catchment area.
> British water is not perfect, but close to it. The number one > contaminant in British water is lead. Lead retards a child's brain > growth, and is the reason it was removed from British petrol (or > gasoline), years after the Americans banned the sale of new car running > on leaded petroleum spirit. See above.
Boiling water gets rid of the chlorine. There is some sense in doing so.
R
A M L [Manchester England] - 22 Sep 2007 01:21 GMT > Boiling water gets rid of the chlorine. > There is some sense in doing so. Some of it does, as part of making the water safe, and it is removed by boiling.
No evidence of it being harmful, much less of the benefits being less than the dis-benefits.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Roger Dewhurst - 22 Sep 2007 01:53 GMT >> Boiling water gets rid of the chlorine. >> There is some sense in doing so. [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > No evidence of it being harmful, much less of the benefits being less than > the dis-benefits. I have provided the evidence of harm. Benefits only exist where the society does not have clean water and where there is a reservoir of enteric disease. You can make a case for chlorination of water supplies in the third world and those parts of the world which have had massive inflows of people from the third world, the UK for example. Throughout much of New Zealand the groundwater is of adequate purity, the sewage systems are recent, and there is no significant reservoir of enteric disease.
R
Redman - 22 Sep 2007 12:30 GMT > The Problem with British Health care 1/4 > [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] > British are told that nature knows best. If nature knew best, we would > not have medicine. Bollox, Mother Nature does know best, the problem you have and it's worldwide is that Health Care has been taken over by multinational Pharmaceuticals Corporations, they have taken over the medical schools etc, Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers.
Redman
A M L [Manchester England] - 24 Sep 2007 01:08 GMT > Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. As x-posted to alt.support.cancer many of who's subscribers lives will be preserved by doctors prescribing drugs and doctors removed parts of the insides of their bodies.
10/10 for stupidity.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Redman - 24 Sep 2007 09:35 GMT >> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > 10/10 for stupidity. Really!! You honestly believe that? You are more stupid than I thought, do a google for the peoples of the Hunza, Eskimo, Azerbaijan, Karakoram, Masi Mara etc, these are just a few of the 20 or so native peoples around the world that do not succumb to Cancer, Diabetes, Heart Disease etc etc etc, all the disease that afflict Western society, now you have to ask yourself why? simple, they don't eat processed denatured garbage that we call food. If these people are subjected to a Western diet over time they also succumb to all the diseases I have mentioned, it's not f.cking rocket science.
Redman
A M L [Manchester England] - 24 Sep 2007 11:32 GMT >> 10/10 for stupidity. > > Really!! You honestly believe that? You are > more stupid than I thought, Kind of you to say.
> do a google for the peoples of the Hunza, Eskimo, > Azerbaijan, Karakoram, Masi Mara etc, these are just > a few of the 20 or so native peoples around the world > that do not succumb to Cancer, Diabetes, Heart Disease > etc etc etc, all the disease that afflict Western society, They do not live a long as we do.
Azerbaijan 64; Hunza, 50 - 60 years, just like any other region of northern Pakistan. http://biblelife.org/hunza.htm
> [ . . . ] it's not f.cking rocket science. Far more difficult than rocket science. Strange that a man of your calibre does not know how simple rocket science is.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Redman - 24 Sep 2007 13:34 GMT >>> 10/10 for stupidity. >> [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > Azerbaijan 64; > Hunza, 50 - 60 years, just like any other region of northern Pakistan. Death Rides a Slow Bus in Hunza
by Jane Kinderlehrer
How would you like to live in a land where cancer has not yet been invented? A land where an optometrist discovers to his amazement that everyone has perfect 20-20 vision? A land where cardiologists cannot find a single trace of coronary heart disease? How would you like to live in a land where no one ever gets ulcers, appendicitis or gout? A land where men of 80 and 90 father children, and there's nothing unusual about men and women enjoying vigorous life at the age of 100 or 120?
We see a lot of hands going up. Fine. But first, you have to answer a few more questions before setting out for a place called Hunza, a tiny country hidden in the mountain passes of northwest Pakistan. Are you willing to live 20,000 feet up in the mountains, almost completely out of touch with the rest of the world? Are you ready to go outside in every kind of weather to tend your small mountainside garden, while keeping you ears open for an impending avalanche? Are you prepared to give up not only every luxury of civilization, but even reading and writing? We see a lot of hands going down. But if you want the benefits of the pure air that whips by the icy cathedrals of the Himalayan Mountains, the pure water that trickles down from glaciers formed at 25,000 feet, and the mental and spiritual peace that comes from living in a land where there is no crime, taxes, social striving or generation gaps, no banks or stores-in fact,-no money- where are you going to find it outside of Hunza? But don't give up! Not yet, because there is still one more question to be answered. That is: are you prepared to eat the kind of food the Hunzas eat? If you are, then you can rightfully expect to give yourself at least some measure of the super health and resistance to degenerative disease which the Hunzakuts have enjoyed for 2,000 years.
What kind of exotic, ill-tasting grub do these Hunza people eat, you are wondering. Strange as it may sound, virtually everything the Hunzakuts eat is delectable to the western palate, and is readily available in the United States-at least if you shopping horizons do not begin and end at the supermarket. Not only is the Hunza diet not exotic, but there's really nothing terribly mysterious about its health-promoting qualities, Everything we know about food and health, gathered both from clinical studies and the observation of scientists who have traveled throughout the world observing dietary practices and their relationship to health, tells us that it is to be expected that the Hunza diet will go a long way towards improving the total health of anyone, anywhere. The Hunza story is only on of the more dramatic examples of the miraculous health produced by a diet of fresh, natural unprocessed and unadulterated food.
Redman
Redman - 24 Sep 2007 15:56 GMT >>>> 10/10 for stupidity. >>> [quoted text clipped - 61 lines] > > Redman You see it's not rocket science, just don't eat the garbage that you find in supermarkets, i.e. processed food, tv dinners, call it what you like but it's completely void of essential vitamins, minerals, enzymes, fats etc that the body requires, it's really not difficult unless you work for the big pharma companies
Redman
A M L [Manchester England] - 24 Sep 2007 16:39 GMT > You see it's not rocket science, Rocket science is too simple, even for you.
> just don't eat the garbage that you > find in supermarkets, I don't. SosMix.
http://sosmix.broomleigh.com/
> i.e. processed food, tv dinners, call it what you like > but it's completely void of essential vitamins, minerals, > enzymes, fats etc that the body requires, it's really not > difficult unless you work for the big pharma companies You'll be telling me Northern Pakistani food is packed with "goodness" next.
I've choked on SosMix. What will they do in Hunza about that?
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
A M L [Manchester England] - 24 Sep 2007 16:33 GMT > How would you like to live in a land > where cancer has not yet been invented? You sound like Jehovah Witnesses.
"People of the Hunza suffer from malnutrition and nutrition deficiencies just as much as any other remote mountain region in SE Asia. Although the predominantly Ismaeli faith (branch of Shi-ite muslims) are progressive and relatively better off than most of their neighbours in nearby regions, they will all tell any visitor, that their life expectancy is around 50 - 60 years, just like any other region of northern Pakistan."
http://biblelife.org/hunza.htm
Remember: if it sounds to be good to true, it is, so keep using British Telecom Internet, as you do.
Try putting your money where your mouth is. Why are you here, when you could be there, helping out Osama Bin La La? Faith can't move mountains, but it comes close with sky scrapers.
These myths - lies to some of us - damage vulnerable and some not so vulnerable people.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Redman - 24 Sep 2007 20:05 GMT >> How would you like to live in a land >> where cancer has not yet been invented? > > You sound like Jehovah Witnesses. For your information I'm an Atheist
Redman
A M L [Manchester England] - 26 Sep 2007 17:09 GMT "Redman" <redman1977@btinternet.com> wrote in news:4UTJi.210657$gR1.86271 @fe03.news.easynews.com:
> For your information I'm an Atheist Well praise the Lord, but your medical views are counter evidential, like theism.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Steph - 24 Sep 2007 15:58 GMT >>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >> [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > > Redman I have had several "Eskimo" (Inuit) patients with very nasty cancers. I have an Azerbaijani on treatment at the moment, too, though I have to admit I haven't treated any Hunzas......... Why do loonies perpetrate these myths?
A M L [Manchester England] - 24 Sep 2007 16:24 GMT > I have had several "Eskimo" (Inuit) patients with very nasty > cancers. I have an Azerbaijani on treatment at the moment, too, > though I have to admit I haven't treated any Hunzas......... > Why do loonies perpetrate these myths? Off the top of my head:
Medicine is a well paid job for life, and some are jealous;
They want full control of their lives, so they make believe by pretending medicine is useless;
Something about a lie being half way round the world, while the truth is putting on its shoes.
Our Prince Charles is only a step or two away from being like that. He intends to be King George. Can't see it somehow.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Redman - 24 Sep 2007 20:30 GMT >>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>> [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > admit I haven't treated any Hunzas......... > Why do loonies perpetrate these myths? Loonies? Myths? wtf, you people are the ones with your fingers in your ears going la la la I'm not listening, f.cking parasites in the Western Health system, all you know is how to poison people with synthesised chemicals, derivatives of mustard gas for cancer treatment etc etc etc, you're a disgrace but then you really don't know any better, what with the big pharma companies as your paid employer, telling you which drugs to use etc etc etc, I despair I really do, the quicker we get away from big corporations running our so called health care the better, not that I use it anyway.
Redman
Steph - 25 Sep 2007 02:27 GMT >>>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>>> [quoted text clipped - 33 lines] > > Redman Well, apart from the fact that I don't use chemotherapy at all, and my pay comes from the government of my province, which gets the money from taxpayers, I guess you're entitled to your opinion, even though it's pathetically wrong. I notice you didn't mention the "Eskimo" patients I've treated? Bit inconvenient?
Redman - 25 Sep 2007 08:33 GMT >>>>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>>>> [quoted text clipped - 41 lines] > I notice you didn't mention the "Eskimo" patients I've treated? Bit > inconvenient? Can I ask where your Eskimo patient has been living over the last few years? Yes I conceed that nowadays the Eskimo have been infiltrated by Western society diets etc BUT if they live completely on their native diet then they will not succumb to cancer, diabetes, heart disease etc. Please also don't get me wrong, environmental pollution is now endemic the world over, that's not helping anyone but you can do things to reduce by a significant factor your chances of contracting any of these afflictions.
Redman
Steph - 25 Sep 2007 15:54 GMT >>>>>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>>>>> [quoted text clipped - 44 lines] > Can I ask where your Eskimo patient has been living over the last few > years? Iqaluit
> Yes I conceed that nowadays the Eskimo have been infiltrated by Western > society diets etc BUT if they live completely on their native diet then [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > > Redman Environmental toxins are clearly involved in some cancers. But many of those toxins are "natural" not man-made. The main reason that cancer is more common over the years is that the average age of the population in western countries continues to rise, and by and large, cancer is a disease of the elderly.
Your simplistic opinions don't help your cause.
Redman - 25 Sep 2007 17:26 GMT >>>>>>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>>>>>> [quoted text clipped - 63 lines] > > Your simplistic opinions don't help your cause. Please explain what you mean by toxins being natural and not man made? The pollution I am talking about is the man made stuff. Oh and btw you're talking out of your arse ref cancer being a disease of the elderly, maybe 50 years ago but not nowadays, it strikes at any age and the vast majority of it is caused by pollution and lack of proper nutrition but then they don't teach "proper nutrition" in medical schools do they?
Redman
Steph - 26 Sep 2007 03:00 GMT >>>>>>>>> Doctors are nothing more than legalised drug dealers. >>>>>>>> [quoted text clipped - 74 lines] > > Redman Age 0-1 1-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 Rate/100,000 23.66 20.64 11.72 11.36 21.33 32.22 46.88
Age 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 Rate/100,000 71.51 110.81 178.59 303.44 489.38 780.10 1182.18
Age 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85+ Rate/100,000 1590.50 1975.56 2234.14 2342.42 2390.03
These are the rates of cancer per 100,000 Canadians.
If you want to see the UK figures go to http://info.cancerresearchuk.org/cancerstats/incidence/age/
Isn't it annoying when the facts contradict your fantasy? Is that your arse I can hear?
Steph - 26 Sep 2007 03:03 GMT The formatting slipped..........redone here for people who care.
> Age 0-1 1-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 > Rate/100,000 23.66 20.64 11.72 11.36 21.33 32.22 46.88 [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > Isn't it annoying when the facts contradict your fantasy? > Is that your arse I can hear? Steph - 26 Sep 2007 03:13 GMT One more time. Don't you love HTML-txt conversions?
> The formatting slipped..........redone here for people who care. >> [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] >> Isn't it annoying when the facts contradict your fantasy? >> Is that your arse I can hear? Age Rate/100,000 0-1 23.66 1-4 20.64 5-9 11.72 10-14 11.36 15-19 21.33 20-24 32.22 25-29 46.88 30-34 71.51 35-39 110.81 40-44 178.59 45-49 303.44 50-54 489.38 55-59 780.10 60-64 1182.18 65-69 1590.50 70-74 1975.56 75-79 2234.14 80-84 2342.42 85+ 2390.03
So if you take 100,000 25 year olds, about 47 of them will get cancer in a year If you take 100,000 80 year olds, 2342 will get cancer in any year
It's so unfair to use facts against loonies, so please accept my apologies
A M L [Manchester England] - 27 Sep 2007 06:58 GMT "Redman" <redman1977@btinternet.com> wrote in news:C17Ji.86140$1o1.39605@fe12.news.easynews.com:
> "A M L [Manchester England]" <abuse@rochdale.gov.welt> wrote in > message news:Xns99B2A7615C894litigationswanseasoo@204.153.245.17... [quoted text clipped - 39 lines] > > Redman A M L [Manchester England] - 27 Sep 2007 06:04 GMT > [ . . . ] poison people with synthesised chemicals, What is a synthetic chemical?
> derivatives of mustard gas for > cancer treatment etc etc etc, You're using a derivative from war developed error correction.
> you're a disgrace [ . . . ]. That's true, but he can't be wrong all the time.
> but then you really don't know any better, Oh yes he does.
> what with the big pharma companies as your paid employer, Worse than that, he's been taking orders from Affinity Homes Group.
> telling you which drugs to use etc etc etc, Or stopping you from taking needed drugs.
> I despair I really do, the quicker we get away > from big corporations running our so called > health care the better, not that I use it anyway. Is this about medicine, or the ownership of the means of production distribution and exchange?
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
Uncle Sally - 25 Sep 2007 03:44 GMT Steph wrote :
[ in response to geysers of fatuous spew from Redman and AML ]
"Why do loonies perpetrate these myths ?"
Dear Steph,
The best explanation, I read, of the dynamics of the enduring human desire for construction of myths of a "golden age," or myths of a people living "at one with nature" "free" from the "diseases of civilisation" was by Rene Dubos in his 1987 :
Mirage of Health: Utopias, Progress & Biological Change
http://www.amazon.com/Mirage-Health-Utopias-Progress-Biological/dp/0813512603/re f=sr_1_11/002-1056586-9380053?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1190686486&sr=1-11
That was a very long time ago, when I read that book :) Later, when I read Jared Diamond's superb "Guns, Germs, and Steel," I was reminded of Dubos' book. Other authors useful to me in undrestanding the meta-dynamics of human perceptions of health and illness include Foucault, E. O. Wilson, Susan Sontag, Peter Ackroyd (for his stunning historical re-creation of the ambience of the plague years in London in his masterpiece "London : The Biography").
As long as there are new things to learn, new ways to challenge what we assume, I'm a happy camper :) If I had another life, I would go into the biological sciences, genetics, what you might call the Darwinian renaissance of evolutionary theory of Wilson, Dawkins, Gould, and such novel thinkers as Pinker at Harvard attempting to move toward the cognitive from the biological.
best, Uncle Sally
Steph - 25 Sep 2007 08:34 GMT > Steph wrote : > [quoted text clipped - 34 lines] > > best, Uncle Sally I'm afraid your erudition would be pearls before swine when it comes to the loonies.......
A M L [Manchester England] - 29 Sep 2007 21:00 GMT > I'm afraid your erudition would be pearls before swine > when it comes to the loonies....... There you go again.
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
J - 29 Sep 2007 21:55 GMT > > I'm afraid your erudition would be pearls before swine > > when it comes to the loonies....... > > There you go again. Not only did he crosspost, he set followups to him. Beware. Watch your To and Groups lines. J
A M L [Manchester England] - 30 Sep 2007 03:19 GMT > Not only did he crosspost, he set followups to him. > Beware. Watch your To and Groups lines. Do you mind?
 Signature http://broomleigh.com/
oh really - 25 Sep 2007 17:34 GMT > The Problem with British Health care 1/4 "Health Care" is a fallacy
It is sickness, disease, injury, pathology care.
Health care is prevention
Hospitals will never be health care because they are in bed with the drug companies Prescribed Drugs are slowly killing the world's population.
J - 25 Sep 2007 19:53 GMT > Hospitals will never be health care because they are in bed with the drug > companies > Prescribed Drugs are slowly killing the world's population. hey, supplement spammer, there's a Health and wealth seminar in St-Georges de Beauce, tomorrow. :) J
|
|
|