Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Cancer / February 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

After the surgery

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Steph - 16 Feb 2006 22:13 GMT
Can anyone tell me what to expect now.  I had a thyroidectomy done last
month, was told that I am now cancer free (I had Papillary carcinoma)
and the advice my doctor gave me was "live".  Seeing as I no longer
have a thyroid, what are the chances of this comming back?  Please I
feel truly alone.  This has all happened so fast.  Anyones input would
be great.

Thanks
J - 16 Feb 2006 23:59 GMT
> Can anyone tell me what to expect now.  I had a thyroidectomy done last
> month, was told that I am now cancer free (I had Papillary carcinoma)
> and the advice my doctor gave me was "live".  Seeing as I no longer
> have a thyroid, what are the chances of this comming back?  Please I
> feel truly alone.  This has all happened so fast.  Anyones input would
> be great.

Hello Stephanie,
As far as I know, often, surgical removal is all that is required.
I think, if clear margins weren't obtained or there was a suspicion of
lymph node involvement, RAI (radioactive iodine therapy) is suggested.
Otherwise, lifelong thyroxine therapy is essential. The thyroxine replaces
what the thyroid should produce. In addition, slightly higher doses than
are necessary for replacement alone appears to reduce the risk of tumour
recurrence. In other words, the TSH should be kept as low as possible, by
means of the thyroxine dose to ensure a low risk of recurrence.  Then you
get on with your life and every 6 - 12 months the patient returns to
his/her endocrinologist for blood tests to determine if the dose of daily
thyroid hormone is correct and to make sure (questions to patient and
physical exam) that the thyroid tumor is not coming back.

Based on what I've seen here by one patient, one gets used to watching out
for signs of trouble and reporting it and eventually, if no problems, the
intervals of recurrence rechecks probably space out even further, with
possibly only the primary care physician making sure the TSH levels are
kept within the optimal low range.

Watch for Steph to correct me or reply to you, if he feels differently.
He's the expert here.

If he does not reply, it means he concurs.
Best wishes . May you remain cancer free for the rest of your life.
J
Steph - 17 Feb 2006 14:06 GMT
Thanks for responding, it's nice to know that there is someone out
there I can talk  to.
Steph
J - 17 Feb 2006 17:28 GMT
> Thanks for responding, it's nice to know that there is someone out
> there I can talk  to.
> Steph

Hello Stephanie,
I'm sorry to bother you; you seem like such a nice person, but would it be
possible, if you're going to continue to post your messages here, to
please change your yahoo "outgoing name"?
In my Yahoo, it's under "options", then "General Preferences".  We can't
have two persons with the same (screen) name here; it would be too
confusing for readers of this newsgroup.
Steph (radiation oncologist) has been here for many years, so he gets
first dibs. In other words, I won't be asking him to change his screen
name.
Please?  I searched archives and there already is a StephA, so if you can
think of a word or name to add to your "Steph" (or a combo of letters
/numbers) that would make your screen name distinctive without upsetting
or confusing those with whom you email, it would be very much appreciated
here..
There doesn't seem to already be a StephXYZ or StephA1
Or maybe if you use Stephanie for your screen name?
(unless that causes name confliicts in your internet entourage)

I hope you can work it, so each of you is distinctive, on this newsgroup.
Meantime, BJ may be around to invite you to a thyroid cancer list.

Steph and I often encourage those who are cured by surgery to get on with
their lives; else cancer recurrence "paranoia" can set in, by hanging out
in this newsgroup. They often do move on and come back, during the :roll
calls" to let us know how they're doing. That works as well, because I
rarely forget a poster and am usually pleased to hear from preivous
posters again. It's also encouraging for the lurkers to know that there
are  treatment successes, so I'll leave that up to you. If you decide to
stay, though, please "screen name change". Thank you.
J
bj - 17 Feb 2006 22:59 GMT
> Can anyone tell me what to expect now.  I had a thyroidectomy done last
> month, was told that I am now cancer free (I had Papillary carcinoma)
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> Meantime, BJ may be around to invite you to a thyroid cancer list.

Sorry for lollygagging, been off getting injured, repaired, resting up,
deciding if I'm more hurt than thought, etc. -- and watching the Olympics
(thank goodness for DVR's & fast forward buttons!).

The web site is www.thyca.org
The main email support group is at
http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/Thyca/
with >4000 members; it's *very* active.
And it's rare that a "new" question gets asked.

Steph -- if you don't mind, would you share more of your history -- such
as -- size of nodule(s), followup plans, medication maintenance plans/goals,
etc. Are you seeing an endo with a lot of experience treating thyroid
cancer? If you have had no further treatment beyond surgery, what was the
basis for that decision? e.g. (why) were you deemed low risk, no need for
RAI, etc.

Thyroid cancer does have a high "cure" rate, the most common forms have
excellent prognosis -- but that kindof assumes good & adequate surgery &
treatment. Also, in case you are worrying about this aspect, plenty of women
have gone on to have babies after thyca (but there are some special
considerations as to timing and hormone monitoring during pregnancy).

BTW, thyca *can* recur decades later, so you need to have some kind of
regular monitoring. Some people need more than one radioactive iodine
treatment in the first go-round (6-12 months apart), then never have any
further problems; others have treatment, then no probs, then have recurrence
& more surgery &/or RAI treatment years later (& no further probs). I had
one treatment & have had no indication of any recurrence or mets after 5
years -- but I still have regular checks and will have a scan this year.

If you are anywhere near a "live" local support group, you may find it very
informative & comforting to go. And there are several spring workshops
planned -- one-day events with several expert speakers at each. These, and
the annual 3-day conference (this year in Orlando, end of October), are
highly recommended as great places to get information & support & meet lots
of fellow-travelers (aka "cut-throats").
Best wishes.
bj
Stephxyz - 20 Feb 2006 16:28 GMT
Hi bj thanks for writing.  Here's my history.  Last December my family
doctor found a bump on my thyroid.  He sent me to an endocronologist
who sent me to have some tests. (Ultrasound, x-rays etc...)  My
endocronologist told me the results showed that I had a multi-nodular
goiter.  He explained that in some cases taking synthroid shrinks the
nodules, so that's what I did.  I started taking a small dose, 0.025,
and then the nodules actually started to grow.  You could see it
sticking out of my neck.  With that my endocronologist decided it would
be best to have the thyroid removed.  I saw a surgeon, and he said he
would only do a partial thyroidectomy, and schedule a second surgery if
needed.  So far 3 doctors, all with different opinions.  No biopsy has
been done.  The day of the surgery is getting close and I start to get
nervous.  I see my family doctor and let him know what's going on.  He
hasn't been informed on anything so he calls the hospital and gets my
files, calls me in and explains that 4 cold nodules have been found,
and that in his opinion there was a slight possibility of cancer.  This
is the first time the word cancer has been used.  2 weeks befor the
surgery.  I call and make another appointment with my endocronologist
to discuss this and he actually got angry with me.  Saying that this is
very routine for him, and the chances of cancer are so small, and even
if it is it is very treatable.  Sure enough the durring the surgery my
surgeon decided on a full thyroidectomy, and it ended up that 3 tumors
were not cancerous.  The last tumor to be found was inside the thyroid,
very small, only 5mm, and that tumor was cancer.  Pappilary carcinoma
is what I was told.  I saw my surgeon a few weeks after the surgery and
he said it was up to my endocronologist to decide on my treatment.
Well, my endocronologist cancelled my appointment so I went to my
family doctor once again.  I am now waiting to see a new
endocronologist, but my appointment is in April.  My family doctor said
that was fine because looking at my results, he said that the tumor
looks like it has not spread.  Anyways, you can see why I  came to this
web site.  I'm sure I'm fine, but at the same time I would like to know
what's going on.  What's routine for someone is completly new to
another.  Thanks for listening,
Stephxyz
matt weber - 21 Feb 2006 00:20 GMT
>Hi bj thanks for writing.  Here's my history.  Last December my family
>doctor found a bump on my thyroid.  He sent me to an endocronologist
[quoted text clipped - 31 lines]
>another.  Thanks for listening,
>Stephxyz
Cold Nodules can be cancerous, but frankly 'Hot' nodules are far more
likely to be cancerous. The difference is whether they take up the
Radioactive iodine used to image the gland. A cold nodule does not
take up the Iodine, and consequently is probably NOT thyroid tissue.

The bottom line is that there no reason to be overly concerned about
'cold' nodules. 'Hot' nodules there is good reason to be concerned
over.
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 06:42 GMT
>>Hi bj thanks for writing.  Here's my history.  Last December my family
>>doctor found a bump on my thyroid.  He sent me to an endocronologist
[quoted text clipped - 35 lines]
> Radioactive iodine used to image the gland. A cold nodule does not
> take up the Iodine, and consequently is probably NOT thyroid tissue.

Matt, your slip is showing.
Cold nodules are likely to be malignant, not hot ones.

> The bottom line is that there no reason to be overly concerned about
> 'cold' nodules. 'Hot' nodules there is good reason to be concerned
> over.

You need to get a bit of a grip before posting "advice"
J - 22 Feb 2006 08:55 GMT
> You need to get a bit of a grip before posting "advice"

Looks like I blew it as well and she should be having RAI..

But then again, the BC Cancer Agency (web page) said that surgery alone is
often all that is needed.
I thought that was why the endocrinologist cancelled her post-op appointment.
The mystery continues on that, then.

J
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 16:14 GMT
>> You need to get a bit of a grip before posting "advice"
>
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> J

For a very small well diff ca, the iodine is controversial. It's just our
policy to do it.
It was the nonsense about hot and cold nodules which I objected to
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 06:43 GMT
> Hi bj thanks for writing.  Here's my history.  Last December my family
> doctor found a bump on my thyroid.  He sent me to an endocronologist
[quoted text clipped - 31 lines]
> another.  Thanks for listening,
> Stephxyz

A 5mm nodule of well diff thyroid cancer has a 100% 10 year survival rate.
We normally advise total thyroidectomy plus radioiodine, but the prognosis
is almost as good as someone who has never had cancer
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 14:17 GMT
Hi Steph,
Thanks for taking the time to write back.  Can you please explain the
10 year survival rate.  Does that mean that after 10 years, if the
cancer hasn't come back, it most probably never will?
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 16:15 GMT
> Hi Steph,
> Thanks for taking the time to write back.  Can you please explain the
> 10 year survival rate.  Does that mean that after 10 years, if the
> cancer hasn't come back, it most probably never will?

Correct.
Occasionally thyroid cancer can recur many years later, but the chances of
that happening for you are very slight indeed.
The cure rate for small well-diff thyroid ca in women is close to 100%
Steph - 22 Feb 2006 19:32 GMT
Thank you everyone for all the information.  I will see my new
endocronologist in April.  I will let you know what he says.

Thanks again for listening
xo
Stephxyz - 20 Feb 2006 16:03 GMT
Good Morning,
Sorry to have caused any confussion with the name.  I'm not to good
with a computer, so I THINK I have changed my name.  Anyways, thanks
for listening, your right on the paranoia part.  Everything has
happened so fast.  I was really looking for a thyroid cancer support
group.  I know I'm better, I just wanted to talk to someone who has
gone through what I have.  So, thanks again
Stephxyz(I hope)
J - 21 Feb 2006 10:24 GMT
> Sorry to have caused any confussion with the name.  I'm not to good
> with a computer, so I THINK I have changed my name.  Anyways, thanks
> for listening, your right on the paranoia part.  Everything has
> happened so fast.  I was really looking for a thyroid cancer support
> group.  I know I'm better, I just wanted to talk to someone who has
> gone through what I have.  So, thanks again

Good morning, Stephanie
That worked very well. :)
Thank you for changing your screen name.

Based on your further clarification and Matt's replly sounds like there
wasn't cancer. (but I'm not an expert on that).

I would ask for a copy of the post-op pathology report, to see what it
says.
There's also alt.support.thyroid, since there's not a lot of thyroid
patients here.
They'll likely tell you the same, about getting the final pathology
report.
Best wishes.
J
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.