> Almost as compassionate as this response
> http://groups.google.com/group/alt.support.cancer/browse_thread/thread
b5f4c192d45a1cf2/be6bd60c72887212?q=dolphin&rnum=2#be6bd60c72887212
(Do these google group message not make it to Usenet? I never see them)
> Why not, "I'm so sorry for what you are going through". That would
> have been compassionate. There is no sympathy in this world.
You sell us short. There are many ways of providing support, and each of us
has different capabilities and abilities. I am not sure what you were
expecting. We have people here who have expert knowlege. We have people
here who go through similar experiences. We have people here who are
survivors and people making the last mile. If symapathy is all you want,
you can get that too.
Why
> would I have expected anything but responses like your two and the link
> I listed, at least his hostility wasn't masked in pseudo sympathy. He
> had the courage to go for blood and tell be to F$%& off. I guess that
> didn't warrant a comment.
I still have not seen his comment or even know who he is.
What is it about this story that falls on
> deaf ears even in a group for Cancer Support. Is it because it's a
> child. Or because it couldn't be true because I wrote it as if it were
> Paige writing.
Not that it could not be true. Maybe underlying the story I found it
manipulative, but first and foremost I found it confusing and not
straighforward. So why did you write it as if Paige was writing instead of
yourself?
>Both of you are good with criticism. Has either of you
> been looking down the barrel of a gun ready to take your child's life.
> Shame, shame.
Shame on us? I can't believe you wrote that. Paige is nowhere near any
consideration of euthanasia. And some of us never believe in it. Get
couseling now! Your seeing hostility in our not liking your style and
reflecting hostility back is but a drop in the bucket.
Support Groups, News Group, it doesn't matter. People
> can dish out plenty of criticism, but when it comes to sympathy that's
> an entirely different story.
Sympathy for Paige, yes, but sympathy for you will be much harder for me to
recreate.
Emily - 28 Aug 2005 20:05 GMT
mness215@comcast.net said...
> > What is it about this story that falls on
> > deaf ears even in a group for Cancer Support. Is it because it's a
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> straighforward. So why did you write it as if Paige was writing instead of
> yourself?
I think the problem I had with it was that it was written in the first
person singular as if autobiographical; yet it was obviously not the
work of a young child. I don't have a problem with sympathising with a
person of any age going through the cancer journey, but somehow the very
adult and technical language purporting to be from a youngster grated
more than somewhat. I honestly feel that if the original post had been
written in the third person I would have reacted more positively. And
as I said before, I *would* like to see Paige's own words describing her
experiences - but they must be her own words and not someone else's.
It's not a question of believability but rather of style.
Please don't accuse me of being heartless either. As the mother of 5
children I think I've got more than a small idea of what it's like to be
occasionally worried about one's offspring...

Signature
Emily
red.gt@hotmail.com - 29 Aug 2005 00:29 GMT
Clueless woman ! Having 5 children is nothing like watching your only
child wither away. Knowing that within weeks she will be dead cannont
be compared to the sniffles. In neither post did I ask for sympathy.
I merely noted that neither of you were sympathetic. Even now, neither
of you are sympathetic to my situation. Shame, shame, shame. At least
you didn't profess to be Christian's !
J - 29 Aug 2005 01:13 GMT
> Knowing that within weeks she will be dead cannont
> be compared to the sniffles. In neither post did I ask for sympathy.
> I merely noted that neither of you were sympathetic. Even now, neither
> of you are sympathetic to my situation.
I'm very sorry about your daughter.
Please don't start a flame war here.
Obviously you're distressed and angry. Obviously they missed the point of
your post.
I cannot apologize for them; they have to do it themselves.
If you want support, you'll get it.
Please tell your daughter she's cute as a button and I love her outfit.
Please give her a gentle hug for me.
J
red.gt@hotmail.com - 29 Aug 2005 00:36 GMT
What are your qualifications to be in this group slinging out criticism
like this ? You obviously don't have children ...
J - 29 Aug 2005 01:56 GMT
> You obviously don't have children ...
For quite a while, back in 1998 - 2000, there was a lady here who posted
about her daughter who had a brain tumour (I think discovered shortly after
birth). She passed away at age 2. The lady was very good at supporting
other parents.
We're not had parents with children with cancer for quite a while. As a
consequence, I've usually referred them to other resources.Sure, you may
stay here, but you may decide you'll relate better with groups of other
parents (whose kids have cancer).
Another resource is alt.support.grief. I'm sure you'll find other parents
of children who've passed away, there.
I see someone misunderstood your post there, as well, but others may come
along and be compassionate to you.
Other resources: http://www.kidscancernetwork.org/grieving.html
Tell us about Paige. Is she really going back to school next week? Is she
excited about it?
Share with us what makes Paige special. Each person is special in their own
way.
Do you have counselling service at a hospital where you and/or your partner
can talk with others.
The thought of losing such a beautiful child must be incredibly painful.
Share with us. I can assure you there are caring people here.
There's also an ACOR listserve for same with 200 subscribers
http://www.acor.org/mailing.html?l=r
There's also a hospice list for children
http://www.acor.org/mailing.html?l=p Hospice Care for Children
I'll leave you to decide where you think is best for you.
J