"Med diet 'could prevent asthma'", BBC News, April 5, 2007,
Link: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6525237.stm
Eating a Mediterranean diet could help protect children from
respiratory allergies and asthma, a study suggests.
UK, Greek and Spanish researchers assessed the diet and health of
almost 700 children living in rural areas of Crete, where such
conditions are rare.
They found those with a diet rich in fruit and vegetables were
protected against both conditions.
UK experts said the study, in Thorax, added to existing evidence that
diet could help control asthma symptoms.
More than five million people in the UK currently have asthma, and one
in 10 children is affected.
Asthma 'rare'
The research was carried out by experts from the UK's National Heart
and Lung Institute, the University of Crete, Venezelio General
Hospital, in Crete, and the Centre for Research in Environmental
Epidemiology, in Barcelona.
The team wanted to examine why children in some parts of Europe, such
as the UK, get asthma while others, in places like Crete, do not.
They looked at the incidence of asthma symptoms, such as wheezing, and
of allergic rhinitis, caused by dust mite or pet allergies.
Parents of the children, who were aged between seven and 18, were also
asked how often they ate 58 foods in nine categories; vegetables,
fruits, nuts, fish, cereal, dairy products, meat, poultry and
margarines and oils.
The Mediterranean diet is rich in vegetables and fruit and low in
saturated fats.
Skin allergies are relatively common in Crete - meaning that, in
tests, children react to allergens such as dust mites.
But these do not appear to translate into respiratory allergies, such
as asthma and allergic rhinitis.
The research found 80% of the children ate fresh fruit, and over two-
thirds of them fresh vegetables, at least twice a day.
Nuts 'beneficial'
Eating oranges, apples, tomatoes and grapes each day, which around 300
children did, was shown to have a protective effect against wheezing
and allergic rhinitis.
Red grape skin contains high levels of antioxidants as well as
resveratrol, a potent polyphenol, known to curb inflammatory activity,
say the authors.
Children who ate nuts - a rich source of vitamin E - at least three
times a week, again just over 300, were less likely to wheeze.
Vitamin E is the body's main defence against cell damage caused by
free radicals.
Nuts also contain high levels of magnesium, which other research has
suggested may protect against asthma and boost lung power.
However, high consumption of margarine more than once a week (331
children) doubled the chances of asthma and allergic rhinitis,
compared with those who ate it less frequently, the findings showed.
Dr Paul Cullinan, of the Royal Brompton Hospital and National Heart
and Lung Institute, said: "It may be that diet is an important link in
translating skin test responses to actual allergies.
"The message of the study is that foods with high antioxidant levels
are good for you."
Leanne Male, assistant director of research at Asthma UK said: "The
results of this study add to the existing evidence which indicates
that a healthy diet can play an important role in the control of
asthma symptoms.
"They demonstrate that the Mediterranean diet, which traditionally
contains higher levels of fresh fruit and vegetables, can have a
beneficial effect on asthma symptoms in children.
"This benefit is thought to be linked to the vitamins and antioxidants
which they contain and Asthma UK is currently funding a number of
research projects to further explore this association."
Ted Edwards - 06 Apr 2007 00:47 GMT
> "Med diet 'could prevent asthma'", BBC News, April 5, 2007,
> Link: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6525237.stm
>
> Eating a Mediterranean diet could help protect children from
> respiratory allergies and asthma, a study suggests.
I can think of at least three possible confounding factors:
Crete has a warm climate and the rural areas are relatively poor
compared to the UK. If true, this suggests that a far larger fraction
of Crete children would play and/or work outdoors rather than play
computer games and/or watch TV.
I don't know for sure but isn't the air a lot less polluted in rural
Crete than in the UK?
Were the children selected in the UK from rural areas or from cities
where the above comments would apply even more.
I don't doubt that the Mediterranean diet may well be a factor but, from
your description, it sounds like a selected group of children was
compared to the whole UK.
Way back when the first study on second hand cigarette smoke was done by
comparing a sample of non-smoking people from a rural religious group
that farmed, got lots of exercise, ate a simple healthy diet, etc. The
second group was smokers from a major city, L.A. IIRC, who lived a life
style with far more negative features. This was done at a time when air
pollution was really bad in big cities. I know two scientists that
wrote a paper criticizing the study but had a very hard time getting it
published. Political correctness has a large effect on what gets
published. Note: They did not claim second hand smoke was harmless,
they claimed that the study was flawed and didn't prove the claimed
hypothesis.
Ted
Citizen Jimserac - 21 Apr 2007 20:42 GMT
> > "Med diet 'could prevent asthma'", BBC News, April 5, 2007,
> > Link:http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6525237.stm
[quoted text clipped - 32 lines]
>
> Ted
Ted, have you checked out acupuncture and Chinese
Herbology regarding Asthma?
There is tons of information on the web that you'll have
to sift through, some of it disinformation from parties
who would rather you NOT discover this valuble alternative
health resource. As an example of progress in
recognizing what it can do, the WHO
(World Health Organization) recently recognized the Chinese
herb "Qing Hao" (artemisia) as a treatment for Malaria
which was superiour in some respects to other more
traditional treatments.
James Pannozzi
mcs - 06 Apr 2007 02:00 GMT
> "Med diet 'could prevent asthma'", BBC News, April 5, 2007,
> Link: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6525237.stm
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> almost 700 children living in rural areas of Crete, where such
> conditions are rare.
hello rural areas , rare? why are they testing there? lol
> They found those with a diet rich in fruit and vegetables were
> protected against both conditions.
How about living away from pollution? that usually does the same thing in
US, produce much less asthma especially onset adult asthma.. the other
things are only guesses cause researchers don't do comparisons with
something that obviously kills and makes sick with such force and
certainty...they can't associate the comparisons in us between health and
bad health with air pollution... at least not too much...too much truth is
not good for oil business or control
> Try doing the studies in air where furnace filters turn black in 29 days
> and you can't sue the polluters. then get back to me with protection and
> studies ok?
> UK experts said the study, in Thorax, added to existing evidence that
> diet could help control asthma symptoms.
You don't want too many coulds that would make more sense do you? Better to
study fat and vegetables instead of the real causes: cigarettes , smoke and
pollution
> More than five million people in the UK currently have asthma, and one
> in 10 children is affected.
>
> Asthma 'rare'