....
> The site claims that this is based on research at Birmingham and
> Loughborough universities in England. If you read through the
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Tony
In some way the device might seem the logical step to overcoming
asthma, namely by opening the constricted airways by improved suction.
However judging from my recollections of moderately severe asthma
attacks, it was not the lack of strength and suction but rather the
lack of coordination which meant I failed to keep my lungs open. My
extremely powerful gasps were just too short to open up the lungs,
because the lung tissue was too inelastic owing to pollen or GERD.
This feature is targeted in ongoing research and means a quest for
drugs to normalize lung tissue properties.
Training in taking deep breaths might have helped.
What seems to be needed is some method which directly quells the
craving for asthma medication and furthermore has not been considered
by medicine so far.
As I've posted here almost ad naseum medical research has ignored the
mechanism of taking a deep breath including suction as a necessary
factor. If this matter were taken into account it might be shown that
asthma is due to a basic mistake about breathing as taught in schools
upwards.
As you hint even gadgets produced by universities might be simple
scams. New asthma drugs may also not involve any progress or even turn
out to be more harmful than those already used. Therefore
modernization of school instruction on breathing might be more
respected and reliable, last but not least because nobody is likely to
make a fortune by amending a few passages in standard textbooks as a
source of expert knowledge. Regards, Richard Friedel
Jason Johnson - 18 May 2006 19:13 GMT
tony broughton wrote:
....
> The site claims that this is based on research at Birmingham and
> Loughborough universities in England. If you read through the
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Tony
In some way the device might seem the logical step to overcoming
asthma, namely by opening the constricted airways by improved suction.
However judging from my recollections of moderately severe asthma
attacks, it was not the lack of strength and suction but rather the
lack of coordination which meant I failed to keep my lungs open. My
extremely powerful gasps were just too short to open up the lungs,
because the lung tissue was too inelastic owing to pollen or GERD.
This feature is targeted in ongoing research and means a quest for
drugs to normalize lung tissue properties.
Training in taking deep breaths might have helped.
What seems to be needed is some method which directly quells the
craving for asthma medication and furthermore has not been considered
by medicine so far.
As I've posted here almost ad naseum medical research has ignored the
mechanism of taking a deep breath including suction as a necessary
factor. If this matter were taken into account it might be shown that
asthma is due to a basic mistake about breathing as taught in schools
upwards.
As you hint even gadgets produced by universities might be simple
scams. New asthma drugs may also not involve any progress or even turn
out to be more harmful than those already used. Therefore
modernization of school instruction on breathing might be more
respected and reliable, last but not least because nobody is likely to
make a fortune by amending a few passages in standard textbooks as a
source of expert knowledge. Regards, Richard Friedel
I have a question for you since it's obvious that you have done lots of
research related to the possible causes of asthma. One of the theories
is that many (if not all) of the people that develop asthma have defective
genes that cause them to have what I will refer to as a compromised (or
weak) breathing system. The triggers for the breathing problems (dust,
bacteria, mold, etc) might be different in various people but all of the
asthma patients have the defective gene. Do you believe that this theory
is true. If it is true, it's my guess that scientists will eventually
track down the exact defective gene or genes.
I should note that even if this theory is true, learning to breath properly
would help everyone--esp. people that have asthma.