I'm hoping someone here can resolve a disagreement between my wife and
I. We have an ongoing argument about the use of household fans:
ceiling fans, pedestal fans, window fans, anything that moves air
around. She does not like them and swears that they *cause* asthma.
I say that is nonsense. To say that a fan *causes* asthma is to simply
say that *moving air* causes asthma, in which case simply going
outside in the wind would *cause* asthma.
Neither of us have asthma.
All other factors being equal, is there any basis whatsoever for
saying that the use of fans indoors can *cause* asthma in an otherwise
healthy adult?
Dick Evans
Colin Campbell - 23 Sep 2003 05:18 GMT
>All other factors being equal, is there any basis whatsoever for
>saying that the use of fans indoors can *cause* asthma in an otherwise
>healthy adult?
No.
--
We make war so we may live in peace.
Aristotle
CBI - 23 Sep 2003 13:39 GMT
> All other factors being equal, is there any basis whatsoever for
> saying that the use of fans indoors can *cause* asthma in an otherwise
> healthy adult?
No.
--
CBI, MD
Vivian - 23 Sep 2003 23:49 GMT
> All other factors being equal, is there any basis whatsoever for
> saying that the use of fans indoors can *cause* asthma in an otherwise
> healthy adult?
>
> Dick
Fans do not cause asthma. Fans may circulate dust and allergens into the
air and cause sneezing and an asthmatic person may in turn get an attack as
an allergic reaction. However, fans themselves do not cause asthma.
What causes asthma? It could be in your genetic makeup. It can also be
caused by allergens such as mold and pollen to then become an allergic
reaction in an asthmatic person. It can also develop from bronchitis. An
asthmatic person can also get an attack from exercise and stress.
As for what exactly "causes" asthma, there are no answers.