Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Asthma / April 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

long term prednisone therapy ????

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
michael - 15 Mar 2005 10:33 GMT
I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago after about
1 year my lungs became infected ..this started a roller coaster health ride
for me ...many antibiotics , inhalers, and way too much predisone ,,,pred
use was almost constant the last 3 years ...anyway seems alot of you here
have similar troubles.

I found the following on the web the interesting thing is long term
prednisone use depresses the immune system leading to opertunistic
infections the biggie is PCP.

I talked my Dr. into a rx for bactrim  ...what a drastic change for the
better..lungs are clear and sinus is the best its been for 3 years..

I'm still taking bactrim so I am hoping the sinus also totally clears we'll
see....so here is some food for thought. ....Michael

Bactrim, an antibacterial combination drug, is prescribed for the treatment
of certain urinary tract infections, severe middle ear infections in
children, long-lasting or frequently recurring bronchitis in adults that has
increased in seriousness, inflammation of the intestine due to a severe
bacterial infection, and travelers' diarrhea in adults. Bactrim is also
prescribed for the treatment of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia, and for
prevention of this type of pneumonia in people with weakened immune systems.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Most important fact about this drug
Return to top

Sulfamethoxazole, an ingredient in Bactrim, is one of a group of drugs
called sulfonamides, which prevent the growth of bacteria in the body. Rare
but sometimes fatal reactions have occurred with use of sulfonamides. These
reactions include Stevens-Johnson syndrome (severe eruptions around the
mouth, anus, or eyes), progressive disintegration of the outer layer of the
skin, sudden and severe liver damage, a severe blood disorder
(agranulocytosis), and a lack of red and white blood cells because of a bone
marrow disorder.

Notify your doctor at the first sign of an adverse reaction such as skin
rash, sore throat, fever, joint pain, cough, shortness of breath, abnormal
skin paleness, reddish or purplish skin spots, or yellowing of the skin or
whites of the eyes.

Frequent blood counts by a doctor are recommended for patients taking
sulfonamide drugs.

Treatment of Pneumocystis Carinii Pneumonia

The recommended dosage is 15 to 20 milligrams of trimethoprim and 75 to 100
milligrams of sulfamethoxazole per 2.2 pounds of body weight per 24 hours
divided into equal doses every 6 hours for 14 to 21 days.

For the treatment of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP):

 a.. Adults and children older than 2 months-Dose is based on body weight.
The usual dose is 18.75 to 25 mg of sulfamethoxazole and 3.75 to 5 mg of
trimethoprim per kg (8.5 to 11.4 mg of sulfamethoxazole and 1.7 to 2.3 mg of
trimethoprim per pound) of body weight every six hours.

Causes: PCP occurs only in immunocompromised individuals, particularly
patients with cell-mediated immune deficiencies. Patients at risk include
the following:

 a.. Persons infected with HIV
   a.. CD4 count less than 200 and not on PCP prophylaxis
   a.. Evidence of oropharyngeal thrush or fever, regardless of CD4 count
   a.. Patients with HIV who have undergone splenectomy - May have
spuriously high CD4 count
 a.. Patients with hematologic malignancies
 a.. Patients on long-term steroids or immunosuppressant therapy, including
patients with systemic vasculitis or other autoimmune diseases
 a.. Organ-transplant recipients
 a.. Patients with other immune deficiencies
   a.. Thymic dysplasia
   a.. Severe combined immunodeficiency
   a.. Hypogammaglobulinemia
 a.. Patients with severe malnutrition
00doc - 15 Mar 2005 20:49 GMT
I doubt chronic PCP issues were causing your symptoms. You have to be
pretty darned immunosuppressed for that. It usually requires end stage
HIV (it is an AIDS defining illness), a combination of high dose
prednisone and other immunosuppressants, or some other severe
immunodeficiency.  It may have been chronic sinus issues that are
finally being addressed.

Just in case anyone is wondering - Bactrim would not normally be
expected to kill mycoplasma and chlamydia.

Signature

00doc

michael - 15 Mar 2005 23:49 GMT
00doc : Yours is the attitude reflected by my prior doctors , which is why I
believe this was overlooked ...only recently end of 2004 have medical
studies shown the link between long term predisone therapy and PCP...  So In
this age of try this one then switch to that one antibioatic therapy
practiced by  doctors ...I'm suggesting if that hasn't helped improve your
health just remind your doctors of bactrim and show them the studies (google
search) .....bactrim has been around along time and is cheap but very
effective for some inlight of the new studies.....Mahalo   Michael
>I doubt chronic PCP issues were causing your symptoms. You have to be
> pretty darned immunosuppressed for that. It usually requires end stage
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> Just in case anyone is wondering - Bactrim would not normally be
> expected to kill mycoplasma and chlamydia.
00doc - 16 Mar 2005 04:18 GMT
> 00doc : Yours is the attitude reflected by my prior
> doctors , which
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> some
> inlight of the new studies.....Mahalo   Michael "00doc"

What you should realize is that it can be diffuicult to
seperate whether the PCP is a harmless colonizer versus and
out of control infection. Response to Bactrim is not
sufficient alone since, as I pointed out, it may be having
several different effects besides killing PCP.

The other thing you should realise is that by analogy to
other immunosuppressed states if yuo do have a PCP issue
then you will need to take Bactrim prophylaxis for as long
as you are similarly immunocompromised. if you can stop the
bactrim while still on the prednisone than the issue was
probably not PCP (or for some reason it is behaving
differently then it does in other examples).

Signature

00doc

00doc - 16 Mar 2005 04:27 GMT
> 00doc : Yours is the attitude reflected by my prior
> doctors , which
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> predisone
> therapy and PCP...

OK - I did searches on several different databases.

I found a few case reports (and you have to go back years to
make it as many as a few) of asthmatics getting full blown
PC pneumonia while on high doses of systemic steroids. I
found one case report of two people who presented with
asthma symptoms that were determined to be PC and who were
then diagnosed with AIDS. I didn't find any "links" between
the two in the sense of asthmatics wheezing for prolonged
periods and having it later discovered that the problem was
undiagnosed PC (except for the two guys with AIDS).

Maybe you could show us these links you are referring to.

Signature

00doc

michael - 16 Mar 2005 11:46 GMT
I'll direct you to the study from 2004 when I find it again,,but the case
studies below take us down the path......PCP and Prednisone......mahalo
Michael

     Heart Lung. 2002 Jan-Feb;31(1):50-2. Related Articles, Links

Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia presenting as a fever of unknown origin in a
patient without AIDS.

Jani K, Mehta NJ.

State University of New York Health Science Center, Division of Pulmonary
and Critical Care Medicine, Brooklyn, USA.

Pneumocystis Carinii pneumonia (PCP) remains an opportunistic infection that
causes substantial morbidity and mortality in patients who have impaired
immune function. PCP in patients who do not have AIDS usually manifests in a
more fulminant manner than in patients with AIDS. In recent years, PCP has
been reported increasingly in patients with connective tissue disorders. The
role of corticosteroids in inducing PCP is well established in humans and
animals, though information is currently lacking about the exact mechanism
of induction, frequency, dosage, and duration of corticosteroid therapy that
predisposes the development of PCP across a variety of patient groups. Until
earlier diagnosis and a better understanding of who is at risk are readily
available, health care providers need to consider the diagnosis of PCP early
in the clinical course of any patient who receives systemic steroid therapy.
We report a case of PCP in a patient who took oral steroid treatment for 2
months for suspected connective tissue disorder. The patient presented with
a fever of unknown origin. The case is unusual because the patient's serial
chest x-ray and gallium scan yielded normal findings and no suggestive
respiratory signs or symptoms were found. The only suggestive finding was a
consistently elevated serum lactate dehydrogenase level. The diagnosis was
established by the identification of Pneumocystic carinii in bronchoalveolar
lavage fluid.

Publication Types:
 a.. Case Reports

PMID: 11805750 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

     Infection. 2000 Jul-Aug;28(4):227-30. Related Articles, Links

Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia as a complication of immunosuppressive
therapy.

Gluck T, Geerdes-Fenge HF, Straub RH, Raffenberg M, Lang B, Lode H,
Scholmerich J.

Dept. of Internal Medicine I, University Medical Center, University of
Regensburg, Germany. thomas.glueck@Klinik.uni-regensburg.de

BACKGROUND: Patients receiving immunosuppressive therapy with
corticosteroids and cytotoxic agents may develop opportunistic infections
such as Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP). This indicates a severe T-cell
defect, but so far there are no established criteria for identifying
patients at risk. PATIENTS AND METHODS: CD4+ and CD8+ T-lymphocyte counts
were determined by flow cytometry in seven HIV-negative patients who
developed PCP as a complication of immunosuppressive treatment. RESULTS:
CD4+ T-lymphocyte counts (T-helper phenotype) were less than 200/microl in
all seven patients (mean 90.6/microl). The markedly reduced CD4 counts
measured in these patients are similar to those observed in organ transplant
recipients who developed PCP during immunosuppressive therapy for prevention
of graft rejection and in HIV-positive patients with PCP as an AIDS-defining
illness. CONCLUSION: Measuring CD4+ T-lymphocyte counts may be helpful in
determining the risk of PCP not only in HIV-positive patients, but also in
patients receiving immunosuppressive therapy. The risk of acquiring PCP
seems to increase when CD4+ lymphocyte counts drop below 200/microl,
regardless of the underlying disease.

Publication Types:
 a.. Case Reports

PMID: 10961529 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

Rheumatology (Oxford). 2004 Apr;43(4):479-85. Epub 2004 Feb 3.  RESULTS:
Detection of P. carinii DNA by PCR was significantly more sensitive than
cytology; 54.5% patients were positive by PCR and only 4.5% by cytology. The
prevalence of PCP was higher than previously considered and was especially
high in patients receiving > 30 mg/day prednisolone with or without other
immunosuppressants.

CONCLUSIONS: PCP may complicate a variety of immunocompromised states
especially autoimmune diseases and hematologic malignancy. Patients who
receive corticosteroids and/or cytotoxic drugs should receive primary PCP
prophylaxis. The mortality rate is high especially in severe cases that need
mechanical ventilation. Intensive care and close monitoring are needed for
these patients.

PMID: 12948254 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

CONCLUSION: Although these results do not suggest that premorbid
administration of corticosteroids is the only factor that contributes to the
development of P. carinii pneumonia in these patients, they show that, in
this large consecutive series, systemic corticosteroid therapy, even in
moderate doses, was administered to most patients during the month preceding
the onset of P. carinii pneumonia. Consideration should be given to
instituting P. carinii prophylaxis (when not contra-indicated) in patients
for whom prolonged systemic corticosteroid therapy is prescribed.  PMID:
8538233 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in patients with ulcerative colitis treated
with corticosteroids.

Bernstein CN, Kolodny M, Block E, Shanahan F.

Department of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles.

Today, Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP) is typically associated with
AIDS. However, in the pre-AIDS era, PCP was known to be associated with
various immunodeficiency states, malignancies, and immunosuppressive
therapy, particularly the use of corticosteroids. PCP has been reported to
occur during immuno-suppressive therapy of some chronic inflammatory states,
but it has never been reported in patients with inflammatory bowel disease.
We report two patients with ulcerative colitis who developed PCP during
high-dose corticosteroid therapy, and review the literature regarding
non-AIDS PCP. PCP should thus be added to the list of bronchopulmonary
complications in inflammatory bowel disease. This report should give
gastroenterologists further impetus to limit immunosuppressive therapy to
its minimal effective dose.

Publication Types:
 a.. Case Reports

PMID: 8470640 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
>> 00doc : Yours is the attitude reflected by my prior
>> doctors , which
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>
> Maybe you could show us these links you are referring to.
00doc - 17 Mar 2005 04:02 GMT
> I'll direct you to the study from 2004 when I find it
> again,,but the
> case studies below take us down the path......PCP and
> Prednisone......mahalo Michael

> The patient
> presented with a fever of unknown origin. The case is
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> findings and no suggestive respiratory signs or symptoms
> were found.

I never said that steroids couldn't cause someone to get PC
pneumonia (PCP). It is just that PCP is not likely to
present as asthma. There was one case report of two guys who
presented with asthma symptoms and were found to have PCP
and AIDS. I haven't found any similar cases in non-AIDS
paitents. Pretty much everyone other report is people who
were on steroids for prolonged periods, often at high doses,
and then got pneumonias which turned out to be PCP.

What all this tells me is that if a steroid dependant
asthmatic gets an unusual pneumonia that pneumocystis should
be kept in mind. It does not support testing for it (which
is hard to do) or empirically treating for it in patients
with asthma symptoms but not overt pneumonia.

In the case you present above the patient dit not even have
respiratory symptoms so it is a bit of a stretch to use it
as you are trying to do.

> Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia as a complication of
> immunosuppressive
[quoted text clipped - 44 lines]
> 200/microl,
> regardless of the underlying disease.

This abstract does not say what the immunosuppressive
therapies were. Presumably at least some of them were on
steroids - probably in combination with other things.
Steroids do not normally deplete the  t-cells or other white
cells. If anything, the white count tends to go up on
steroids. So, again, this really lends no support for what
yuo are saying.

> Publication Types:
>  a.. Case Reports
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> care and
> close monitoring are needed for these patients.

Again - uncommonly high doses for chronic asthma treatment.
Also they say the problem si in patients taking steroids
AND/OR other cytotoxic drugs - not just steroids.

Again - these were people who got pneumonia - a risk I
acknowledge. There is still no mention of PCP masquerading
as asthma.

> CONCLUSION: Although these results do not suggest that
> premorbid
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> [PubMed -
> indexed for MEDLINE]

Ditto - high dose and risk of pneumonia - not mistaken ID.

> Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in patients with ulcerative
> colitis
[quoted text clipped - 29 lines]
> immunosuppressive
> therapy to its minimal effective dose.

Ditto.

The best you can say about hese studies is that people on
high, and maybe moderate doses, of steroids might benefit
from bactrim prophylaxis (more certainly if they are also
taking other immunosuppressives).  Bactrim has its share of
problems and the morbidity seen in AIDS patients taking it
chronically is not insignificant so I would be interested in
seeing controlled trials of this.

Nothing you have posted remotely supports the use you are
touting here.

Signature

00doc

michael - 17 Mar 2005 05:34 GMT
I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago after about
1 year my lungs became infected ..this started a roller coaster health ride
for me ...many antibiotics , inhalers, and way too much predisone ,,,pred
use was almost constant the last 3 years ...anyway seems alot of you here
have similar troubles.

I found the following on the web the interesting thing is long term
prednisone use depresses the immune system leading to opertunistic
infections the biggie is PCP.

I talked my Dr. into a rx for bactrim  ...what a drastic change for the
better..lungs are clear and sinus is the best its been for 3 years..

I'm still taking bactrim so I am hoping the sinus also totally clears we'll
see....so here is some food for thought. ....Michael

The above is my original post .....the connection  for me between
asthma/prednisone/pcp is  I was diagnosed by 5

different (prior)  doctors with asthma , it seems when infected with pcp the
toxins given off caused me to weeze so the

1st. doctor says asthma and with that diagnosis in place all the other
doctors agreed and treated me for the  wrong

thing .....until my new doctor agreed to try bactrim.

some studies indicate 30mg of prednisone daily for 2 months is all the long
term necessary for some people...

My original post was an alert for  some other people that might be
mis-diagnoised  as I was . and a suggestion for them

to follow this info up with their doctor...

You can dive into bactrim prophylaxis and perhaps bring us all more up to
date, however  thats not my

purpose...I know bactrim has been available for a long time and there a
generic versions (cheap)

Are you a doctor?????
                                       Mahalo  Michael
>> I'll direct you to the study from 2004 when I find it again,,but the
>> case studies below take us down the path......PCP and
[quoted text clipped - 127 lines]
>
> Nothing you have posted remotely supports the use you are touting here.
00doc - 18 Mar 2005 00:35 GMT
"The above is my original post .....the connection  for me between
asthma/prednisone/pcp is  I was diagnosed by 5

different (prior)  doctors with asthma , it seems when infected with
pcp the
toxins given off caused me to weeze so the

1st. doctor says asthma and with that diagnosis in place all the other
doctors agreed and treated me for the  wrong

thing .....until my new doctor agreed to try bactrim. "

Three problems:

1) You presumably weren't on the prednisone until after you were
diagnosed with asthma. You presumably would not have gotten the PCP
until after being on the prednisone. So how could the PCP have caused
the erroneous diagnosis of asthma?

2) If you are HIV negative and had years of asthma symptoms that turned
out to be from a chronic, presumably low level, PC infection then you
are the first one (at least as far as my search came up with). None of
the cae reports you cite indicate anything like this. Your doctor
should write it up and submit it.

3) There are more likely reasons to suppose that you may have gotten
better after starting the Bactrim.

Signature

00doc

michael - 18 Mar 2005 02:52 GMT
00doc....Hello again.....

.I was  on prednisone for 11 months for sinus infections  along with many
antibiotics ..My G P then sent me to ent to see if my new chest infection
was connected to the nose problem ent says yes I think so ..so  at the end
of the 11 months i had my first sinus surgery and more
antibiotics/prednisone .......My  G P then about 2 months after the 1st
sinus surgery sends me to a lung specialist who says ASTHMA .............the
sinus surgeries continued  3 more times for the next  two and one half years
and more antibiotics/prednisone therapy............I then changed doctors
and that brings this sad story current.......

There is an old saying when you presume it goes something like this,,,,,when
you PRE / U / ME   ..when you (PRE)sume it makes an a.s outa you(U) and me
(ME).....

I am getting the feeling your whole purpose is to pick things to death  am I
wrong.????.....Are you a doctor.?????.....Mahalo   Michael
> "The above is my original post .....the connection  for me between
> asthma/prednisone/pcp is  I was diagnosed by 5
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> 3) There are more likely reasons to suppose that you may have gotten
> better after starting the Bactrim.
Joy - 18 Mar 2005 04:28 GMT
Michael,

To answer your question, yes, he is a doctor.

Joy
RicAnne - 18 Mar 2005 06:38 GMT
Hello joy
           thank you for the answer...........it does add to my
understanding that as a  doctor his depth of knowledge  goes well beyond
mine in these issues .......but with my past experience with my prior
doctors them either being too busy or perhaps being caught up in the
complicated side of my infections  they overlooked  the simple answers
Mahalo...Michael
> Michael,
>
> To answer your question, yes, he is a doctor.
>
> Joy
Joy - 18 Mar 2005 07:15 GMT
Well, it seems this is a complicated issue. And it is hard to figure out who
is who when testing doesn't ID the victim (as in what exactly is going on
for several particular patient). But CBI (00doc) does ask all the
appropriate questions and we should all appreciate that.. And he does answer
many questions here, so..........

I don't tend to put much on experiences/testamonials. Yet again, I myself
have nothing nice to say about how I was treated by certain members of the
medical profession ("coughing for attention" jerk doc -hope he is not
PRACTICING any longer). As a matter of fact, I think someone should remove
their right to practice. But that means nothing when trying to chase the
causes of asthma which are varied, and that is my current focus. Answer my
question on the sinus newsgroup about why you settled on this bug. If you do
a search you will see I am not adverse to your theory before you think you
are fighting with me. I got better on Zithromax.

Joy
> Hello joy
>             thank you for the answer...........it does add to my
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> >
> > Joy
michael - 18 Mar 2005 08:48 GMT
Hello joy....I have not felt we were fighting about anything ....by the way
I was on zithromax also , 3 months as the blood test showed I think clamidia
, doc said recent trials warranted the longer therapy ....I felt somewhat
better after finishing the first two months then stayed the same thru the
end of the third...but was still short on lung capacity to the point  I
would get winded if I went up 2 small flights of stairs thats when I talked
with Doc about the prednisone and P C P  studies I found on the net...He
agreed  then I started the  bactrim and a  big change......so maybe i had
other issues  also ,,,,,any way it's been a tough 4 years   Mahalo...Michael

> Well, it seems this is a complicated issue. And it is hard to figure out
> who
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
>> >
>> > Joy
Joy - 18 Mar 2005 14:19 GMT
> Hello joy....I have not felt we were fighting about anything ....by the way
> I was on zithromax also , 3 months as the blood test showed I think clamidia
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> agreed  then I started the  bactrim and a  big change......so maybe i had
> other issues  also ,,,,,any way it's been a tough 4 years   Mahalo...Michael

All you stated above makes sense to me. So you took in studies and your doc
treated you based on  that, but never had a positive culture?

Joy
00doc - 18 Mar 2005 14:27 GMT
"All you stated above makes sense to me. So you took in studies and
your doc
treated you based on  that, but never had a positive culture? "

You can't really do a culture or antibody tests for it. You have to get
sputum from deep down (it is harder to do that it seems) and do special
stains on it. I think they may also be able to do pcr on it now.

You have to understand that this is not anywhere near being where Hahn
et al got with his theory. His theory was much more plausible and then
he went out and got data to suggest that it does happen in some
appreciable percentage of asthmatics. If this guy is right he would be
the first (un?)reported case ever.

Basically, you have a short term study of one with no confirmation of
initial infection nor documentation of cure.

Signature

00doc

michael - 18 Mar 2005 09:18 GMT
> Well, it seems this is a complicated issue. And it is hard to figure out
> who
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> answer
> many questions here, so..........

forgot to add.......I always appreciate when a doctor takes the time to be
involved ...00doc thank you for the time and concern....Mahalo...Michael
00doc - 18 Mar 2005 14:31 GMT
Not that it matters. I wouldn't dismiss him because he is not nor would
I expect him to fall in line behind my beliefs because I am. That's why
I made a point of not answering the question.

It is an interesting idea and it certainly is worth looking into.  A
particular patient of my partner's that I end up seeing on cross
coverage int he hospital a lot comes immediately to mind and I am
planning to talk to her pulmonologist about it.

However, I'm thinking more along the lines of maybe we should do some
tests to rule this out rather than considering it an at all comon
example (she is an extreme - and present with a history more consistant
with relapses of PCP then a chronic misdiagnosed infection).

Signature

00doc

Joy - 18 Mar 2005 14:47 GMT
CBI,

I know that the testing isn't what it could be. The way I am looking at it
today is that the antibiotics took away the constant symptoms like SOB most
all of the time I would not be attentive to the inhaled steroid schedule. I
can remember also that Dr Enright at WebMD stated that tiredness was not a
symptom of asthma, but that was certainly on my list. What I am saying is
there are some "signs" I think doctors could use to ID patients like us who
have an infection without waiting for the labs to rise to the occasion.
Course, tiredness could be due to another medical condition.

And yes it is important that you are a doc and have some clue what you are
talking about.

Joy

> Not that it matters. I wouldn't dismiss him because he is not nor would
> I expect him to fall in line behind my beliefs because I am. That's why
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> example (she is an extreme - and present with a history more consistant
> with relapses of PCP then a chronic misdiagnosed infection).
00doc - 18 Mar 2005 20:13 GMT
I really don't want to get into a big fight about it but......

While I agree that a certain percentage of asthmatics may benefit from
long term antibiotics(and it really is not known what that percentage
is) and that there are certain elements of the history that would tend
to suggest certain asthmatics may be more likely to benefit than others
- you seem to think that all asthma symptoms are signs that suggest an
indication for antibitotics. You may say otherwise here but then your
actions say otherwise with you suggesting it to every person who posts.

What you need to understand is that this is not the same as the
mycoplasma issue. Mycoplasma and Chlamydia have been shown or is widely
suspected to be capable of causing a long term subclinical infection
producing a variety of symptoms whereas PC is not. MP and CP are
intracellular organisms, fairly unique in the world of bacteria, so it
is plausible that they could "hide" from the immune system and last for
prolonged periods. PC is an extra cellular organism (they argue about
exactly what it is - yeast vs protozoa (I think things are leaning
toward protozoa right now)) that sets off an intense immune reaction.
Also, there is a fair amount of evidence to suggest that it is likely
that at least some asthmatics are harboring the infection (whereas
there isn't for PC) and there are at least some trials that suggest
long term benefit for at least some of these people (whereas there
isn't for PC).

I'm not saying that it is not known that prolonged high dose steroids
can cause PCP (it is). However, it is not common - the case reports
tend to get printed when they do occur. It also in the known cases
tends to present with pneumonia  (which is what the second "P" in PCP
strands for) - the people are sick.

In this case a guy without pneumonia symptoms is asking you to believe
that he has steroid induced PC inducing his asthma symptoms. He insists
that he is misdiagnosed - all without explaining the orginal asthma
diagnosis that occured before the steroids. Sure, it is possible - but
so are a lot of things without evidence to support them. It is also
possible (and in my opinion more likely) that something entirely else
is going on. But even all that is fairly harmless. Let him believe what
he wants ot believe as long as he keeps it between him and his doc.

What I am objecting to is the specific claims that he has discovered
some kind of link and that other asthmatics should be badgering their
docs to try prolonged courses of Bactrim (not to mention the
implications that this discovery is plain to see but just being over
looked by docs to busy to be bothered to read). Those conclusions are
simply not supported by any shread of eivdence.

Signature

00doc

Joy - 18 Mar 2005 21:33 GMT
> to suggest certain asthmatics may be more likely to benefit than others
> - you seem to think that all asthma symptoms are signs that suggest an
> indication for antibitotics. You may say otherwise here but then your
> actions say otherwise with you suggesting it to every person who posts.

I don't believe all asthma symptoms are signs and I think I stated that we
are looking for tiredness, low grade fevers, adult onset particularly after
an infection, asthma not triggered by allergies, constant SOB in a
nonsmoker...... I am at a loss as to how you have missed this.

And I think you're exaggerating when I say I have suggested it to everyone
who posts. I have even stated that it wouldn't help everyone and I was sorry
for that. That doesn't mean that I believe that the effective rate is in the
high nineties (percentile) as some doctors have stated, but that I tend to
agree with Dr Hahn that it is slightly more than half. It isn't my fault if
it turns out to help people are tired of waiting and taking matters into
their own hands. As a matter of fact, you might look to the medical
profession and the way they stonewalled Dr Hahn for years (instead of
investigating) if you want to start affixing blame. They wasted years. And
if someone is tired of waiting, out of money, not able to work and having
major side effects from the meds or worse, no relief from the meds,  then
yes, I do think they should take long term antibiotics. They MIGHT just be
in the right half. I fully expect most people in the USA will have to wait
for the research to conclude (and that won't happen until they get a
reliable test). My assumption is that most people who visit message boards
are not in the 70% who are doing well on asthma meds.

> What you need to understand is that this is not the same as the
> mycoplasma issue. Mycoplasma and Chlamydia have been shown or is widely
[quoted text clipped - 32 lines]
> looked by docs to busy to be bothered to read). Those conclusions are
> simply not supported by any shread of eivdence.

I agree that he hasn't a leg to stand on about the PCP. He was not confirmed
to have it and the fact that Bactrim worked isn't an indication that he ever
had it. However, it does stand to reason that people want to be better and
they are quite frankly sick of taking steroids which  (as I have stated
before) don't work well or have major side effects. All this while the
medical profession continues to deny to the patient who is expressing
complaints that they have heard before from other patients. Just wander by
any asthma message board for proof. But that aside, here is another case of
someone with asthma, diagnosed by several doctors, who got better on
antibiotics. Just a different one from the one Dr Hahn uses. There is the
hope factor. Someone actually has gotten better. They are not faced with
waiting 15 to 20 plus years. Maybe it all depends on how much your asthma
impacts your life.

Joy
00doc - 19 Mar 2005 02:42 GMT
>> to suggest certain asthmatics may be more likely to
>> benefit than
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> you have
> missed this.

Because you have suggested that people who describe none of
that try antibiotics. You have no idea how much I have been
biting my tongue.

> My assumption is that most people
> who visit message boards are not in the 70% who are doing
> well on
> asthma meds.

Most ? I'm not so sure. I'll grant that the sicker patients
will tend to be more involved with support groups and such
but I'll bet that most of the regular posters here are
fairly well controlled.

Signature

00doc

Joy - 19 Mar 2005 03:05 GMT
> Because you have suggested that people who describe none of
> that try antibiotics. You have no idea how much I have been
> biting my tongue.

Links???

> > My assumption is that most people
> > who visit message boards are not in the 70% who are doing
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> but I'll bet that most of the regular posters here are
> fairly well controlled.

Really? That is why they spend time on it?

Joy
michael - 18 Mar 2005 22:10 GMT
>I really don't want to get into a big fight about it but......
>
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> that he is misdiagnosed - all without explaining the orginal asthma
> diagnosis that occured before the steroids.

Almost 13 months on prednisone/antibiotics/inhalers/ then sinus surgery
..then lung specialist.....my G P started treating me for asthma symptoms at
about the 9th month mark then 2 months later he sent me back to ent to see
if my new chest congestion could be caused by the nose problem....ent says
yes then 1st sinus surgery....

Sure, it is possible - but
> so are a lot of things without evidence to support them. It is also
> possible (and in my opinion more likely) that something entirely else
> is going on. But even all that is fairly harmless. Let him believe what
> he wants ot believe as long as he keeps it between him and his doc.

If I keep it between me and my doc....there occurs no conversation or
exploring of these issues so basically just shut up michael go away!!!
Is that really what you mean???

........The evidence or case studies you look for  to support my claim.... .
wouldn't the evidence be a paper written by a doctor stating how they had
overlooked something???......   How would I present or find evidence of
misdiagnosis ?????

 I think it is more constructive to explore all possibilities openly.....

> What I am objecting to is the specific claims that he has discovered
> some kind of link and that other asthmatics should be badgering their
> docs to try prolonged courses of Bactrim (not to mention the
> implications that this discovery is plain to see but just being over
> looked by docs to busy to be bothered to read). Those conclusions are
> simply not supported by any shread of eivdence.

If my doctor overlooked it there exists perhaps 1 or 2 others ...All
doctors are not as involved and caring as you are......
                                                           I am not used to
putting thoughts into written words so the chronology of my experience needs
some clairifaction  hope this helps.

Mahalo   Michael
00doc - 19 Mar 2005 02:47 GMT
> If I keep it between me and my doc....there occurs no
> conversation or
> exploring of these issues so basically just shut up
> michael go away!!!
> Is that really what you mean???

No - but it would be nice if you had a shred of proof before
popping off about being misdiagnosed and finding links etc
etc.

> ........The evidence or case studies you look for  to
> support my
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> would I
> present or find evidence of misdiagnosis ?????

You could prove that you had PCP then show that the
infection was cleared and that in that period of time your
asthma symptoms (and objective measures of asthma severity)
abated. It would make a nice case report and would be sure
to be published.

>  I think it is more constructive to explore all
> possibilities
> openly.....

Explore - sure.

Claim a new discovery with no evidence - no.

> If my doctor overlooked it there exists perhaps 1 or 2
> others ...All
> doctors are not as involved and caring as you are......

See - there you go again. Who says anyone overlooked
anything?

Signature

00doc

00doc - 18 Mar 2005 20:42 GMT
"There is an old saying when you presume it goes something like
this,,,,,when
you PRE / U / ME   ..when you (PRE)sume it makes an a.s outa you(U) and
me
(ME)..... "

Actually - presuming would make a pres out of you and me - whatever
that means.

If you were on 11 months of steroids for sinus disease then I would say
you changed doctors somewhere between 10 and 11 months too late.

OK- let me tell you this.

PCP in the setting of HIV usually only warrants steroids if it is
severe enough to cause low oxygen levels (other than that they don't
help). Even then they are usually only given for a few days (like 5 to
7) and then they are stopped. Even in the face of the ongoing
immunosuppression of steroids and HIV the Bactrim only needs to be
given at full doses for 2-3 weeks and then the prophylactic doses are
resumed.

The steroids are questionably effective in sinus disease and many ENT's
specifically avoid them due to an increased risk of meningitis and
parameningeal abcesses. I know some do use them but usually only in
short pulses - not long term. Needless to say,  the sinus disease does
not present a clear reason to stay on the steroids (and may be a good
reason to avoid them). If the asthma symptoms are from PC then the
steroids are, again, not useful.

If you think that PCP is causing your lung symptoms why not treat it
like PCP? Take the Bactrim at full PCP doses - 5 mg/kg three times a
day (one Bactrim DS tab has 160mg - for most adults this will be about
5-6 tabs per day) for 21 days. About 7 days into it you should be able
to  taper off the steroids (don't stop them abruptly if you have been
on them for a long time).

You should have a good clue in 3 weeks. If you need the steroids
despite being on Bactrim or if you relapse while no longer
immunosuppressed then it is a strong argument against PCP as the cause.
If you are cured then congratulations - I'm still  not sure what it
proves  - but I would be happy for your good health.

Signature

00doc

iamthezookeeper - 20 Mar 2005 12:27 GMT
I think my ENT is the only one in these past years to treat my
Samters/Polyps with daily prednisone. His reasoning was this...I was using
1200 mg. during a burst which occurred at least four to six times a year.
The total dosage was pretty high in the long run. We figured out 10mg.
daily for four months was equal to one burst. So taking it daily gave me
lower doses in the course of a year. Now we are trying to get to eod
without luck though. Then the CSS started and it gave me relief from that
so it looks like I will be using daily until this goes into remission. It
also has kept the maxillary mucocele from getting any bigger and invading
my orbit floor again. On the down side my bones are suffering. Trudy.

Doc: "The steroids are questionably effective in sinus disease and many
ENT's specifically avoid them due to an increased risk of meningitis and
parameningeal abcesses. I know some do use them but usually only in short
pulses - not long term. Needless to say,  the sinus disease does not
present a clear reason to stay on the steroids (and may be a good reason
to avoid them)."  
00doc - 20 Mar 2005 19:22 GMT
> I think my ENT is the only one in these past years to
> treat my
> Samters/Polyps with daily prednisone.

The polyps change things a bit. They are responsive to
steroids (to some degree). This is a liitle bit different
than using 11 months of steroids for a presumed but
unconfirmed sinus infection.

> His reasoning was this...I was
> using 1200 mg. during a burst which occurred at least four
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> figured out 10mg. daily for four months was equal to one
> burst.

That makes sense - but I am assuming you guys explored all
other avenues of handling this and finally settled on the
steroids as a last resort. This is not quite the same thing
as a primary care doc "shooting forsta nd asking questions
later" by putting you on long term steroids without those
explorations (which he could not have done without making a
referral).

> So
> taking it daily gave me lower doses in the course of a
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> floor again.
> On the down side my bones are suffering. Trudy.

Again - you have other indications then just a clinical
diagnosis of sinusitis (which is always suspect).

Signature

00doc

MikeV - 18 Mar 2005 03:06 GMT
> "The above is my original post .....the connection  for me between
> asthma/prednisone/pcp is  I was diagnosed by 5
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> caused
> the erroneous diagnosis of asthma?

"PCP caused erroneous diagnosis of asthma"? Your words, not his, I
think.

> 2) If you are HIV negative and had years of asthma symptoms that
> turned
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> the cae reports you cite indicate anything like this. Your doctor
> should write it up and submit it.

He did not diagnose his asthma symptoms  .  .  the doctors did.

> 3) There are more likely reasons to suppose that you may have
> gotten
> better after starting the Bactrim.

Indeed, he is searching for reasons why he improved dramatically
after bactrim. One may be opportunistic infection following possibly
excessive prednisone. PCP appears to be one. You appear to be
arguing against your erroneous conclusion rather than Michaels
misconception.
Please read him more carefully.

I came up with a number of references to PCP occurring in both HIV
and non-HIV cases.
.
MikeV
iamthezookeeper - 18 Mar 2005 12:50 GMT
Michael...hope you are feeling better now. I have had Asthma Triad for 23
years with daily prednisone. I have never had pneumonia luckily. I also
heal very well after surgery. I think Nancy is right in that if effects
different people differently. I do have Osteoporsis however and am taking
Actonel to restore bone. As for the Bactrim, I think there are new studies
out lauding the daily use of antibiotics as a prophylactic approach for
sinusitis/asthma and will try to find them. Trudy.
00doc - 18 Mar 2005 20:26 GMT
"PCP caused erroneous diagnosis of asthma"? Your words, not his, I
think. "

It is an accurate paraphrase which he does not dispute.

"> 2) If you are HIV negative and had years of asthma symptoms that
> turned
> out to be from a chronic, presumably low level, PC infection then
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> the cae reports you cite indicate anything like this. Your doctor
> should write it up and submit it.

He did not diagnose his asthma symptoms  .  .  the doctors did. "

That doesn't even make sense.

"Indeed, he is searching for reasons why he improved dramatically
after bactrim. One may be opportunistic infection following possibly
excessive prednisone. PCP appears to be one."

Yep - and another is that the Bactrim is helping his sinus disease
which is contributing to his respiratory symptoms. Given that we know
he has sinus problems and and they can cause asthma symptoms and that
this whole scenario is very common and that if he is right about the
PCP thing he would be the first known case - which do you think is more
likely?

" You appear to be  arguing against your erroneous conclusion rather
than Michaels
misconception. Please read him more carefully. "

No - you are the one who is not reading either one of us correctly.

"I came up with a number of references to PCP occurring in both HIV
and non-HIV cases."

The fact that you would say this shows that you are not reading either
one of us very carefully. We both have posted examples of this and
neither of us disputes it. However, there has never been a case report
that describes this situation (at least none that I have found or he
has posted). I have described the differences in detail - I suggest you
go back and re-read the thread.

I'm not going to go back and forth with you on this. If you post and I
don't respond it will be because what you are saying has been discussed
and I have nothing new to add. In that cae you should go back and read
it again.

Signature

00doc

MikeV - 21 Mar 2005 15:27 GMT
> "PCP caused erroneous diagnosis of asthma"? Your words, not his, I
> think. "
>
> It is an accurate paraphrase which he does not dispute.

God, I hate admitting guilt. Crow for supper again. :-(
I incorrectly inferred from Michael's post, (perhaps from the
subject), that he thought the treatment for asthma and infections
may have set up the conditions for possible PCP complication.
Apologies to all for the inappropriate remarks to 00doc who not only
accused of my own error, but who is clearly a thoughtful and
dedicated contributor.
I do not question his comments on the low probability of PCP.

This appears to be a very knowledgeable and helpful group. It is
actually possible to learn here, from real dicussions.

Never having been a patient nor a health care professional (at 69),
I fear I am not qualified for this company. However I will persist
in the hope that I will learn something to help my sister in law who
is currently quite ill.

Summary:
Former smoker, age 54, mild heart attack 8yrs ago, stent installed.
Asthma began shortly after that. Past year, recurring infections,
extreme violent coughing, increasing weakness.
Currently hospitalized. Staph infection identified, resistant to
vancomycin. Infection was said to be 'resistant' to Bactrim in a
prior treatment (ten day cycle). CHF excluded.
Hypogammaglobulinemic.
Awaiting results on a battery of tests including fungal, possible
multiple myeloma. Doctor suspects that she may have been over
medicated, and has started reducing her prednisone, but she feels
that this is repeating the cycle she has become familiar with.
Congestion increasing, cough more productive.
Family has confidence that her current doctor (internal medicine,
infectious disease) is being very thorough and agressive in trying
to pin down her problems.
(I suspect her pulmonary and cardio docs may have been less so)
I fear she is giving up hope that this can be managed.

Any insights or prior experiences welcomed. No "popping-off" I
promise.

MikeV
MikeV - 24 Mar 2005 05:38 GMT
>> "PCP caused erroneous diagnosis of asthma"? Your words, not his,
>> I
[quoted text clipped - 42 lines]
>
> MikeV

follow up on my sister in law:
Multiple myelitis negative. Now on gamma globulin transfusions, and
zyvox for staph, and whatever else.

MikeV
MikeV - 28 Mar 2005 18:00 GMT
>>> "PCP caused erroneous diagnosis of asthma"? Your words, not his,
>>> I
[quoted text clipped - 48 lines]
>
> MikeV
Sister inlaw has been sent home with situation improving. Zyvox and
gammaglobulin appear to be doing the job. Internist says that
failure to detect staph earlier allowed it to get out of control. It
is not clear to me if other organisms were involved
Bad news: 20 doses of zyvox cost about $1400.
Hope she and her caregivers have learned something, and that this
will not be a repeating cycle.
Hope the above will help someone else avoid her situation.
MikeV
michael - 13 Apr 2005 08:32 GMT
Hello all I have an update ....seems no pcp evidence yet if ever I dont
know....doc( lung guy) looked at  the xray and ct scan and says its not pcp
so he took me off the Bactrim the 22nd last month,,so by the 1st i new i was
getting sick and went in to see him ....doc says we need a sputim sample and
for the ent to to sample sinus area AFTER  I'm off the antibiotics 14 days ,
the ent sampeled on the 7th and put me back on bactrim cause now I'm really
gettin sick ......the 11th I spent 6 hours in emergency before they felt I
could go home however the er doctor asked 3 times if I didn't want to stay
and made me promise to only sit and rest at home , rest was all I felt like
doing.......In ER I got a large iv with avalox and prednisone while using a
neb mask with albuterol for 1 solid hour then again 45 min later for another
hour....Next morning my family doctor called for er update and to  discuss
results of ent swab test it shows Escherichia coli  and Straph auresus
(MARSA) infections  so he says to stop avalox and start bactrim  and for me
to call ent to seek if any further is needed........ent nurse called back
says you were given an RX ( Bactrim) so your being treated ,  I called
family doctor back to update him he is calling an infectious disease doc for
further needs ,,,, should hear tomorrow....This time the bactrim isn;t
working as well or quickly not sure why ,,Any ideas?????   WOW how things
change in less than 3 weeks....Mahalo  Michael
00doc - 13 Apr 2005 14:17 GMT
> Next morning my family doctor called for er
> update and to  discuss results of ent swab test it shows
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> things change
> in less than 3 weeks....Mahalo  Michael

The MRSA could be developing resistance to the Bactrim as
well. Bactrim (and several other older antibiotics) often
work in MRSA. If they know that the Staph aureus (SA) is
resistant to methicillin (and so all penicillins) (MR -
MR+SA = MRSA) then they must have complete susceptibilty
testing and should be able to see what to use.

I cringe a bit at the ID consult. For some reason the
specialists often like to use the new shiny agents despite
no proven advantage. In this case it seems that all the ID
guys are in love with a drug called Zyvox. It is a great
drug and does kill MRSA but it really has no advantage if
other less expensive agents will also kill it. I mean, the
bug is either dead or it isn't. You don't get extra points
for spending more money or killing it extra dead. The
problems using the drug are twofold:

1) 10 days costs about $1000-1200. So to treat a sinus
infection you may get away with "only $1000" but you may
need several times this. As you can imagine pharmacies do
not like to carry $1000 items on their shelves and insurance
carriers are not fond of paying for them. So get ready for a
special order and and an authorization procedure if it is
recommended. [As a personal aside: If the ID guy wants it
tell him to fill out the paperwork explaining why, not the
PCP].

2) It is a new and novel agent. I hate to see it used if
others will do preferring to save it for when nothing else
will work.

Signature

00doc

michael - 13 Apr 2005 14:46 GMT
Thanks 00doc for the feedback.....I think the ID consult is for further on
the Escherichia coli  as bactrim don't touch it and the ent dismissed
treating it......what is you opinion to treat or not????  Mahalo   Michael

> I cringe a bit at the ID consult. For some reason the specialists often
> like to use the new shiny agents despite no proven advantage. In this case
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> 2) It is a new and novel agent. I hate to see it used if others will do
> preferring to save it for when nothing else will work.
00doc - 14 Apr 2005 01:17 GMT
> Thanks 00doc for the feedback.....I think the ID consult
> is for
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> treat or
> not????  Mahalo

E. coli shouldn't be in the sinuses so I have no idea why he
would decide not to treat it. perhaps he thinks it is a
contaminant? Bactrim usually would cover it unless there is
a specific resistance issue.

The best bet would be to look at the resistance patterns and
try to find something that treats both. If that is not
possible it is sometimes reasonable to treat one and see if
the whole thing doesn't clear up (often it will) then treat
the other if it does not rather than "shot gunning" with
several different antibiotics at once.

Signature

00doc

cloud - 14 Apr 2005 01:57 GMT
Hey 00doc... are you a doc... I can't read your handwriting?  : )
Always,
..? ???)) -:?:-
?.?? .????))
((??.?? ..?? cloud -:?:-
-:?:- ((??.??*

> The MRSA could be developing resistance to the Bactrim as well. Bactrim
> (and several other older antibiotics) often work in MRSA. If they know
> that the Staph aureus (SA) is resistant to methicillin (and so all
> penicillins) (MR - MR+SA = MRSA) then they must have complete
> susceptibilty testing and should be able to see what to use.

<snipped for brevity>
MikeV - 25 Apr 2005 06:47 GMT
> Hello all I have an update ....seems no pcp evidence yet if ever I
> dont know....doc( lung guy) looked at  the xray and ct scan and
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> working as well or quickly not sure why ,,Any ideas?????   WOW how
> things change in less than 3 weeks....Mahalo  Michael

Hi Michael: Sorry to hear that you do not have it pinned down yet.
My sister in law is in much the same state:
After a few days at home she started yet another 'round' with severe
spasms and was taken back to the hospital by ambulance.
Her MRSA seems to have been controlled by zyvox. But mycobacterium
avium seems to have showed up, and is being treated with
clarithromycin.
Her asthma/emphysema  is not responding as it should to a fairly
heavy  systemic dose of prednisone. This is causing her severe leg
pains. Naturally the lung guy wants the dose maintained, while the
infectious disease guy would prefer it reduced.
The possibility of lung reduction surgery has been raised, but now I
understand that she may be under consideration for a transplant.

In case it is of interest, I came across this recently. Is cineol
being used clinically yet 00Doc?
MikeV

Posted on Thursday, April 14, 2005 - 04:55 pm:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Cineol

Respir Med. 2003 Mar;97(3):250-6.
Anti-inflammatory activity of 1.8-cineol (eucalyptol) in bronchial
asthma: a double-blind placebo-controlled trial.

Juergens UR, Dethlefsen U, Steinkamp G, Gillissen A, Repges R,
Vetter H.

Department of Pneumology, Medical Outpatient Clinic, Bonn
University Hospital, Germany. uwejuerg...t-online.de

Airway hypersecretion is mediated by increased release of
inflammatory mediators and can be improved by inhibition of mediator
production. We have recently reported that 1.8-cineol (eucalyptol)
which is known as the major monoterpene of eucalyptus oil suppressed
arachidonic acid metabolism and cytokine production in human
monocytes.
Therefore, the aim of this study was to evaluate the
anti-inflammatory
efficacy of 1.8-cineol by determining its prednisolone equivalent
potency in patients with severe asthma. Thirty-two patients with
steroid-dependent bronchial asthma were enrolled in a double-blind,
placebo-controlled trial. After determining the effective oral
steroid
dosage during a 2 month run-in phase, subjects were randomly
allocated
to receive either 200 mg 1.8-cineol t. i.d. or placebo in small gut
soluble capsules for 12 weeks. Oral glucocorticosteroids were
reduced
by 2.5 mg increments every 3 weeks. The primary end point of this
investigation was to establish the oral glucocorticosteroid-sparing
capacity of 1.8-cineol in severe asthma. Reductions in daily
prednisolone dosage of 36% with active treatment (range 2.5-10 mg,
mean: 3.75 mg) vs. a decrease of only 7% (2.5-5 mg, mean: 0.91 mg)
in
the placebo group (P = 0.006) were tolerated. Twelve of 16 cineol
vs.
four out of 16 placebo patients achieved a reduction of oral
steroids
(P = 0.012). Long-term systemic therapy with 1.8-cineol has
asignificant steroid-saving effect in steroid-depending asthma. This
is
the first evidence suggesting an anti-inflammatory activity of the
monoterpene 1.8-cineol in asthma and a new rational for its use as
mucolytic agent in upper and lower airway diseases. Regards, Richard
Friedel
MikeV - 25 Apr 2005 20:30 GMT
monoterpene 1.8-cineol in asthma and a new rational for its use as
> mucolytic agent in upper and lower airway diseases. Regards,
> Richard
> Friedel

I just realized that I had read the Cineol reference earlier on this
group. Posted by Richard Friedel.
Lack of accreditation unintentional.
M
michael - 30 Apr 2005 09:17 GMT
Hello mike....The latest for me is slowly getting better...I quit the lung
doc after a long talk with my P.C. doc who referred me to the ID doc.......
I now have an IV  (cefotan) at home along with 3 other antibiotics in pill
form .....the Iv  is for 4 weeks and shall have lab tests prior to ending IV
.....but am feeling much better now......I was according to new doc on a
dosage way too low for my size along with trying only 1 drug at a time kept
me bouncing between low grade infection of one while the other
flaired........hope your sister in law finds her answer for me it took
changing docs ..so I'm hopeful this may finally clear up......Mahalo Michael

>> Hello all I have an update ....seems no pcp evidence yet if ever I dont
>> know....doc( lung guy) looked at  the xray and ct scan and says its not
[quoted text clipped - 76 lines]
> mucolytic agent in upper and lower airway diseases. Regards, Richard
> Friedel
michael - 17 Mar 2005 05:44 GMT
I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago after about
1 year my lungs became infected ..this started a roller coaster health ride
for me ...many antibiotics , inhalers, and way too much predisone ,,,pred
use was almost constant the last 3 years ...anyway seems alot of you here
have similar troubles.

I found the following on the web the interesting thing is long term
prednisone use depresses the immune system leading to opertunistic
infections the biggie is PCP.

I talked my Dr. into a rx for bactrim  ...what a drastic change for the
better..lungs are clear and sinus is the best its been for 3 years..

I'm still taking bactrim so I am hoping the sinus also totally clears we'll
see....so here is some food for thought. ....Michael

The above is my original post .....the connection  for me between
asthma/prednisone/pcp is  I was diagnosed by 5

different (prior)  doctors with asthma , it seems when infected with pcp the
toxins given off caused me to weeze so the

1st. doctor says asthma and with that diagnosis in place all the other
doctors agreed and treated me for the  wrong

thing .....until my new doctor agreed to try bactrim.

some studies indicate 30mg of prednisone daily for 2 months is all the long
term necessary for some people...

My original post was an alert for  some other people that might be
mis-diagnoised  as I was . and a suggestion for them

to follow this info up with their doctor...

You can dive into bactrim prophylaxis and perhaps bring us all more up to
date, however  thats not my

purpose...I know bactrim has been available for a long time and there a
generic versions (cheap)

Are you a doctor?????
                                       Mahalo  Michael
>> I'll direct you to the study from 2004 when I find it again,,but the
>> case studies below take us down the path......PCP and
[quoted text clipped - 127 lines]
>
> Nothing you have posted remotely supports the use you are touting here.
MikeV - 16 Mar 2005 19:09 GMT
Michael:

Thank you for your post. I am interested in your subject for a
family member who current has a staph pneumonia under similar
circumstances.
She is non-HIV, and is currently receiving gamma globulin,
vancomycin, prednisone.

Hope the following site will be of interest. Both HIV and non-HIV
cases of PCP are referenced.

http://www.medadvocates.org/diseases/opportunistic/pcp/main.html

I hope to hear more about your continued success.

MikeV

>I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago
>after about
[quoted text clipped - 107 lines]
>    a.. Hypogammaglobulinemia
>  a.. Patients with severe malnutrition
michael - 17 Mar 2005 06:28 GMT
thanks mikev for the link  and the new site I can search.....I believe most
doctors are good people and try their best to improve our health ...however
today seems they are  very busy almost to the point of overload .....so
keeping up to date comes slowly...the web and info available to us allows us
to ask informed questions of our doctors  which sometimes reminds them of an
old antibiotic or a new therapy...My( new) doctor doesn't mind this approach
and I feel involved and sometimes helpful........Mahalo Michael
> Michael:
>
[quoted text clipped - 105 lines]
>>    a.. Hypogammaglobulinemia
>>  a.. Patients with severe malnutrition
Nancy - 17 Mar 2005 06:19 GMT
> I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago after about
> 1 year my lungs became infected ..this started a roller coaster health ride
[quoted text clipped - 73 lines]
>     a.. Hypogammaglobulinemia
>   a.. Patients with severe malnutrition

Michael -

Different things affect different people.  I have been on prednisone
since 1998.  I have had daily doses that ranged from 80mgs a day to
where I am now, 5mg.  In that time I have had pneumonia once, and I
think it ended up being pneumonia because I didn't listen to the doc and
go to the hospital when she told me to (It was Christmas).  I don't find
myself more prone to infections then I was before, really.  I tend to
catch colds more easily, and if someone is sick around me, most likely
I'll get it, but I don't get long term infections like the kind you are
speaking of.

Hope this helps.

Life is uncertain - Eat dessert first!
Nancy
8=: )
michael - 17 Mar 2005 06:54 GMT
Hello nancy...I'm glad you don't have to deal with long term infections ,
like you said Different things affect different people ...My original post
was an alert for some  people that might be mis-diagnoised with asthma  as I
was . and a suggestion for them to follow up with their doctor the info
presented ....long term prednisone use depresses the immune system that is
what opens the door for pcp infection ...your right it dosent happen to
everyone.....mahalo  Michael
>> I have struggled with a sinus infection that started 4 years ago after
>> about
[quoted text clipped - 107 lines]
> Nancy
> 8=: )
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.