Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Arthritis / August 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

mtx and enbrel

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Becky - 27 Aug 2005 04:22 GMT
for those of you who take enbrel with MTX, how much of the mtx are you
taking. My doctor told me to start the mtx up again, I was on 17.5 and can
not tolerate that, told me to either take 10 or 12.5, you would think he
could tell me exactly how much to take. His nurse said if it were her  she
would take 15mg, thought it was kinda strange it was left up to me.
Then first enbrel shot went okay.  I seem to have some more anxiety, but I
think it is just me. I am still not able to get the shoes situation under
control. Can't find any pair that works, on about my 10 pair, good thing the
store lets me return them. I used to wear orthodics, and haven't now for
about 4 weeks, not sure if that is why my back is hurting, was told that I
didn't need them they were over correcting me and that is why my hips were
bad. Who knows.
Well just wondering what dosages everyone was taking.
Thanks
Becky
Marshall Arbitman - 27 Aug 2005 05:01 GMT
Becky:

I'm on 25 mg of MTX, injected. The injected form seems to produce fewer
liver and gastro side effects for many. You might look into this. I
simply could not stomach the pills. Turns out 25 mg...even more... is
not a large dose in the greater scheme of things. A recent study found
very little increase in side-effects all the way up to 40 mg. My RD,
who is NOT especially aggressive bumped me up to 50, at one point.

His rationale was simple: We're already doing blood tests for side
effects; if they continue normal good. If they don't, they don't.
There's nothing about 50 mg side effects that are any more emergent--or
any less--than 25 mg side effects: The pulmonary problems are
potentially deadly for ALL doses but very, very, very rare. Anything
else can wait a few weeks between bloodwork.

So stay on top of it. Look into injecting it or dividing the pill
dosage into two days' worth. And remember: Hit it hard!

As for the shoes and feet, give the Enbrel a few weeks, yet. And if it
doesn't work, try Humira, then Remicade, then Kineret or the new one,
Abatacept. Don't get discouraged. Keep asking questions and keep
slugging.
Becky - 27 Aug 2005 05:31 GMT
Thanks Marshall,
You take a big amount of MTX, I couldn't tolerate even the 17.5 made me a
zombie for over half the week and other issues. I will probably try the 12.5
this Saturday and go from there.
This disease is no fun, but I am certainly learning to except what I can do
and not dwell on what I can't do anymore.
Have a good weekend,
Becky
> Becky:
>
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> doesn't work, try Humira, then Remicade, then Kineret or the new one,
> Abatacept. Don't get discouraged. Keep asking questions and keep slugging.
Marshall Arbitman - 27 Aug 2005 06:05 GMT
Becky:

You might try switching to Arava. It has its own set of
benefits/problems and is more costly, but RDs often consider them
somewhat analogous.

The trick to all of this, as I'm sure you're figuring out, is finding
the combination of drugs that brings maximum gain with minimum
side-effects. For me the best, for now is MTX and Enbrel. For you it
might be Arava and Humira. Or something else.

Do NOT give up. Do NOT settle for less than the best you can get. Push,
push, push your doctor. In the medium run, you'll get better relief. In
the long run, less damage. In the short run you'll feel more in
control, and that's never a bad thing. In a few months, you'll know as
much about this disease and what works as your doctor. Hang in there.
RoseB - 27 Aug 2005 06:05 GMT
> for those of you who take enbrel with MTX, how much of the mtx are you
>taking.

    I  am also on 25 mg which is 1 cc by injection.
Enbrel has been great! I was on remicade for close to 5 years, but
developed a very atypical reaction known to this group as "The evil
foot thing". Since stopping remicade, it has not recurred.

    I  find the enbrel very easy to administer and tolerate. I
feel much stronger, have  more energy and spunk, and do not have any
appreciable amount of morning stiffness. I have few, if any, swollen
or painful joints. My ESR was close to 100 while on arava, and never
less than 48 on remicade was around 22 in both of my lab tests since
starting. My CRP was near 80 and is now 7.

    That is not to say that I do not have pain. I have pain from
previous joint damage and from a hip prosthesis that is not
functioning well. I had that surgery in 1982 so it is small wonder
that it needs revising.

You are at the beginning of your journey with enbrel. Hopefully it
will give you super relief.

    Rose   @}>->--
    Being educated means that rather than fearing the unknown, one seeks to understand it. RB

    Please remove "Ima" to reply.
Newsgroup Spambuster - 27 Aug 2005 07:17 GMT
Becky,

I also take 25 mg of mtx with my enbrel.  I do the mtx by injection like
most here do.

Becky, why not give the PT a try like your RD recommended.   You'd be
surprised at how helpful they can be sometimes.    They may even be able
to help you sort out the whole foot/orthotics thing.  Definitely worth
looking into.

I think it is pretty cool that your RD is allowing you to decide what
the best dose of the mtx is for you.   We are all different, and since
your RD knows that you have had problems with the mtx he is allowing you
some lee-way.   You can start at
15 mg and work down if you have problems.

Then enbrel often takes a while to kick in, so you still need to be
hitting the disease hard with the mtx and doing what ever you can to get
things better controlled.  Some warm water exercises can be a wonderful
help as can the PT stuff.   Keep at it and sooner or later you will find
what the best regimen is for you.   Until you find that, go easy on
yourself and try not to stress out over every little thing.   It really
does get better!!!

Donna G
Nann Bell - 27 Aug 2005 12:08 GMT
I was on 20 mg of mtx when we started the Enbrel and continue to take that.  
My RD hoped we'd be able to drop the mtx once the Enbrel got going but it
hasn't been *that* effective for me.  Mind you, I have PA rather than RA and
seem to have one of those cases of it that *really* want to stay active!

I'm thinking that maybe your doctor gave you a choice of dosage due to your
bladder condition that complicates things.  But it would certainly be
appropriate to call and ask for clarification on the dosage if you want to do
so.

Signature

Nann
remove the Gator cheer to email me
Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare

Alison DeLorme - 28 Aug 2005 05:46 GMT
Becky, that fatigue can really get to you. I'm on 22.5mg right now. inject.
I can't go aboove 15mg on the pills without the nausea getting the best of
me. So I'm doing the shots. The fatigue is about the same, as are the mouth
sores. But the RD switched me to leukovorin and I'm doing much better. I
take 10mg a day after the mtx. It's a folic acid erivative. Supposed to be
more effective than the folic acid supplements. It has really haeled with
the fatigue and the sores... one other thing - it takes a good 4-6 wks for
the fatigue to lessen for each dose increase I try... When you were trying
the higher doses, did you stick to them that long? It's really hard, I know,
but it does get better. Your body gets used to it. I now only have about 36
hours of complete fatigue after the shot. It's horrible as I have 3 young
children but it's much better than the 3-4 days worth

take care

alison
Charrlygrl1 - 28 Aug 2005 21:39 GMT
Becky, how are you doing?
How many shots of Enbrel have you done so far? It does take a little
getting used to, doesn't it? I never in a million years thought that I
would be able to give myself an injection. Sometimes I still hover a
little bit just before doing it...then I laugh at myself. What the heck
is a little pinprick compared to the joint pain??
I am on 20mgs of MTX now along with Enbrel, 10 mgs of prednisone and
Azulfidine. I am on leukovorin (sp?) as well right now, but I am really
worried about hair loss. I seem to be losing quite a bit, and my hair
is very thin and fine to start with.
I was on MTX 2 yrs ago when my arthritis first started. My new doc says
that the old one didn't keep me on it long enough, nor at a high enough
dosage. I do have to say that since trying the MTX this time around
(Ive been back on it about 2.5 months now) I think it's actually
helping. Maybe I'm just hopeful...lol.
I am hopeful for you too, however...good luck with whichever dosage you
decide to go with,
Charlene
Athena - 30 Aug 2005 04:13 GMT
I take Enbrel and MTX.  I was taking 20mg of MTX but my hair thinned
out.  I dropped down to 15mg and my hair grew back.  I upped it to
17.5mg and my hair still grew back.  I'm still at 17.5mg.  (This was
done with my doctor's okay.)  I guess 20mg was toxic for me.

This dose plus the Enbrel has worked for me.  I also take 500mg of
Naproxen and Folic Acid for the RA.

Good Luck.
Elizabeth
Athena - 30 Aug 2005 04:14 GMT
I take Enbrel and MTX.  I was taking 20mg of MTX but my hair thinned
out.  I dropped down to 15mg and my hair grew back.  I upped it to
17.5mg and my hair still grew back.  I'm still at 17.5mg.  (This was
done with my doctor's okay.)  I guess 20mg was toxic for me.

This dose plus the Enbrel has worked for me.  I also take 500mg of
Naproxen and Folic Acid for the RA.

Good Luck.
Elizabeth
Becky - 30 Aug 2005 04:26 GMT
Char,
I have only had one shot, will take my next one tomorrow. I had to skip the
mtx last week, was on 17.5 but it was not much for me. So then he said
either 10 or 15 left it up to me, I took 12.5 but it was like starting all
over again, the fatigue and the muscle aches, I don't know. I had thought if
you took enbrel you could lower the mtx. Maybe not.
I really battle some issues with my hips and ankles, but I think they are
not RA, I am sure it is the battle I have been having trying to find a good
pair of shoes. I had worn the same brand and type of shoe for the last 3
years, they don't make them any more and the one that replaced them I don't
like. Anyway started getting really tight muscles in my right leg and hip
and the new foot doc thought it was because I was wearing a shoe that was
slightly corrective and using an orthodic and I was getting over corrected.
Why it didn't t do it a long time ago I am not sure. Needless to say I have
spent my whole summer trying to find some shoes. I go back to work in 2 days
and it looks like I may go barefoot!!!  I bought the asicis gel 2100, I
don't like them but I kept bringing shoes back and decided to stay with
that, usually I wear new balance, anyway the doc is making me some orthodics
for them even though she doesn't think I need them, I bought some super feet
to put in them but they are so hard and wore them today and it made my good
foot go numb and killed my ankles, so I am back to square one, if I could
get this straightened out I would not even complain about he RA I don't have
to much pain, the RA doc thinks the hip is the RA, but the x-rays showed
nothing, and when I asked him for a cortisone shot he said no get PT.
Well didn't mean to ramble, I have just never in my life had such a hard
time finding shoes.
But thanks for asking about how I was doing, I will let you know how the 2
shot goes tomorrow.
Bye
Becky
> Becky, how are you doing?
> How many shots of Enbrel have you done so far? It does take a little
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> decide to go with,
> Charlene
Kelly - 30 Aug 2005 14:50 GMT
Becky,
It can take time for enbrel to work - don't expect miracles on a first shot.
Also don't forget you have made 3 changes quickly - you will feel the
results of those changes - not always in a positive way.

The sore hip can be arthritis in the sense that it could be bursitis or any
amount of things.  Thank goodness he prescribed pt instead of a cortisone
shot - shows he is responsible.  If it is inflammation in that hip the pt
might be able to do something without cortisone.  I have had great luck with
pt modalities on hips.  My rd always likes me to try pt first before any
cortisone shot - less damaging and more long term.  Even when I get a
cortisone shot the pt is usually needed as follow up to ensure that things
continue to improve.

Even if it isn't osteoarthritis in the hip (which is what they are checking
for on the xray) it can still be inflammation from the ra.  That is what the
enbrel and mtx does in most cases - gets rid of that.  It does take time and
yes orthotics may be needed to make sure it doesn't come back.  The
orthotics sometimes take time to experiment with to get the adjustments
right etc - just like the meds.  Nothing is fast in this disease except in
some cases the damage if you don't do anything.

Anyhow just be patient and persistent.  I know it is hard but if you give
everything a chance then eventually you might be able to lower the mtx but
for goodness sake at least the mtx is working. More than some people can
say.

Kelly
Becky - 31 Aug 2005 01:51 GMT
Hi Kelly,
Thanks for the advice. I see my primary care doc in a few days, because of
my insurance he has to refer me to the PT not the RA doc.  Just more red
tape.  I took my second shot of enbrel about a hour ago. It sure does seem
to flare up my interstitial cystitis.  I usually don't have to take any meds
for it, almost gone as long as I don't take anything to flare it up.  The
mtx did at first also, so maybe in time it won't. I got really dizzy about a
half hour after taking it but okay now.  Just hope the other resolves soon.
I start back to work tomorrow and sure hope that I will have the stamina for
it.  I work at an elementary school.  Have to keep working need the
insurance. I couldn't believe how exspensive enbrel is. WOW
Well thanks for the words, if I remember right don't you also have IC?  Do
any of these drugs bother you>
Well I am going to try and take my dogs for a walk, sure do miss exercising
like I use to. I use to go about 5 times a week, now I am lucky if I make it
to they gym 2 times and it isn't much of a work out. I think I am going to
try water aerobics, not sure how that will be.
Well have a great labor day weekend.
Becky
> Becky,
> It can take time for enbrel to work - don't expect miracles on a first
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
>
> Kelly

Rate this thread:






 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.