Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Arthritis / May 2005
Massages??!!!
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Nevhyn - 19 May 2005 03:58 GMT So I went and saw a CMT with a gift certificate my wife gave me. The massage therapist was pretty knowledgeable about RA and did a good job of ratcheting the intensity up and down based upon my feedback. Didn't feel too bad afterwards, but now, several hours later, I feel like somebody took a baseball bat to me.
Holy cr^p!
Duckie - 19 May 2005 04:59 GMT Water is a must after a massage to rid the body of the toxins. I finally had to give up massages because of that. My acupuncturist gives me the same relief now with NO baseball bat after effects. You might try that. Duckie
> So I went and saw a CMT with a gift certificate my wife gave me. The > massage therapist was pretty knowledgeable about RA and did a good job of [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Holy cr^p!
 Signature _('> (_<_)
_ _('< -quack (_<_)
_ __('< *QUACK!* <_{__)
_('< "|,,|_" (_<_)
_('< "AFLAC!" (_<_)
spodosaurus - 19 May 2005 08:05 GMT > Water is a must after a massage to rid the body of the toxins. Which toxins?
> I finally > had to give up massages because of that. My acupuncturist gives me the [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >> >> Holy cr^p!
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Duckie - 19 May 2005 20:08 GMT Don't have any idea now that you mention it Ari. But every massage I have ever had, they always say 'drink plenty of water to wash out all the toxins' Must be something that is released when the muscles are worked over. Anyone here trained for massage therepy? I have a friend who is and I think I will see her tonight. If I can get my brain to remember to ask, maybe I will have an answer late tonight. Duckie
>> Water is a must after a massage to rid the body of the toxins. > > Which toxins? spodosaurus - 19 May 2005 20:19 GMT > Don't have any idea now that you mention it Ari. But every massage I > have ever had, they always say 'drink plenty of water to wash out all [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > remember to ask, maybe I will have an answer late tonight. > Duckie If you can, try and make sure they give you specific compounds, not just generalised information without justification, like 'metabolic wastes' or similar brush off answers.
>>> Water is a must after a massage to rid the body of the toxins. >> >> Which toxins?
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Duckie - 20 May 2005 17:45 GMT Ari, we were standing on the edge of the dance floor and I got all I could before we both were asked to dance. I do have my priorites. lol But she did say it was normal cell waste and mentioned carbon dioxide as one example. I found this http://bioserv.fiu.edu/~walterm/human_online/urinary/urinary_lecture.htm Didn't know that about the kidneys. They regulate first and excrete second. Interesting. Duckie
> If you can, try and make sure they give you specific compounds, not just > generalised information without justification, like 'metabolic wastes' > or similar brush off answers. spodosaurus - 20 May 2005 18:02 GMT > Ari, we were standing on the edge of the dance floor and I got all I > could before we both were asked to dance. I do have my priorites. lol [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > second. Interesting. > Duckie The body is such an amazing machine. I wish I'd continued on with my human bio degree and gone into medical research rather than pursuing neuroscience and neuropsychology (not that much of neuropsych isn't used in clinical settings, but it's just not the same for me).
Ari
>> If you can, try and make sure they give you specific compounds, not >> just generalised information without justification, like 'metabolic >> wastes' or similar brush off answers.
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Nanny - 20 May 2005 06:01 GMT I'm like you, Duckie - not knowing exactly how the "toxins" process works. I do know that my therapist told me that massage does several things: improves circulation, gives more oxygen to the cells, and increases red blood cells. That last one surprised me. I used to be anemic and on iron supplements, but my doctor took me off them a couple years ago. Coincidence? I don't know. Nanny
> Don't have any idea now that you mention it Ari. But every massage I have > ever had, they always say 'drink plenty of water to wash out all the [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] >> >> Which toxins? Nann Bell - 20 May 2005 14:26 GMT I must admit I don't know if I was told this by someone, or read it or assumed it, but I believe excess lactic acid is the major "toxin". It is, of course, released by working muscles and is a factor in cramped, knotted muscles geting that way. So that massaging the muscles releases the lactic acid, which is also known to cause widespread aching in the body if you don't have endorphins balancing it. Can't give you any source for this info though, as I say, I don't even know where I got it from. (we need Melinda to answer questions like this!)
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
> Don't have any idea now that you mention it Ari. But > every massage I have ever had, they always say 'drink [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >> >> Which toxins? spodosaurus - 20 May 2005 15:42 GMT > I must admit I don't know if I was told this by someone, or read it or > assumed it, but I believe excess lactic acid is the major "toxin". This would indicate a metabolism error if that concetration of lactic acid is just hanging around. You also get that after a good workout, and it's reprocessed to run through the metabolic pathway again and provide more energy.
> It is, of > course, released by working muscles and is a factor in cramped, knotted > muscles geting that way. So that massaging the muscles releases the lactic > acid, which is also known to cause widespread aching in the body if you don't > have endorphins balancing it. If someones muscles have that much lactic acid AT REST, then they have a serious metabolism error and should seek medical advice. Also, a good workout produces far more lactic acid than a massage, and it doesn't result in overall body aches...and here's where hydration comes in:
Most people are chronically dehydrated, and that exacerbates underlying health problems. sometimes it exacerbates them a lot. It's no wonder people feel better after a couple days of proper hydration! Most people who exercise vigourously on a regular basis also keep themselves well hydrated.
There are no toxins being released. Lactic acid is a normal metabolic product of anaerobic metabolism, and is itself reprocessed to provide even more cellular energy when the short term anaerobic stress is removed. I hear about these mythical catch all 'toxins', and it just isn't so.
Massage is good, and relaxing, and that will help reduce muscle and nervous tension which creates chronic stress on the body. There's no need to try and medicalise the terminology by making up things about 'toxins'.
I'm not having a go at you. I appreciate you conveying what you've heard, as all I've ever heard were references to 'toxins' and noone has ever been game enough to try and answer (even strangers, who don't know me well enough to know I would know better). I just prefer truth and evidence to marketting hype and practitioners trying to get themselves to be seen as medical practitioners when they are alternative therapy providers, and there's a huge difference in the level of qualifications between the two. I feel that as consumers of these services (massage really helps free my breathing and reduce the pain from my vertebral injuries) we deserve to be treated with respect, and for practitioners to try and use terms associated with medical treatments in order to pull the wool over our eyes as to the real effectiveness of their services shows an unacceptable degree of disrespect to us all.
> Can't give you any source for this info > though, as I say, I don't even know where I got it from. (we need Melinda to > answer questions like this!)
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Duckie - 20 May 2005 17:39 GMT Okay here is what she said. The cells produce waste like carbon dioxide which you are familiar with and other things which she did not elaborate on but sure could be found on internet search. The blood washes away these wastes. When a muscle decides to knot up, the muscle cells tend to hold on to those wastes. The harder the knot the more wastes the more it holds on. During a massage, the [big word I have forgotten but think it began mya-fibro...] are worked to release these wastes. The harder the knots, the more there is to release. Since the normal ebb and flow had been broken, this release can cause pain if not done properly [her words]. I told her that my fibro got worse with massage and she said it was the [big word again] sheath[?] that was massaged and that would make sense. There is a form of massage she said that would be good for fibro patients. Actually she said, ridding the body of these wastes that have built up is important to everyone but not if they hurt you worse. She suggested that he call the massage therepist and report his reaction to it as she can make suggestions and the next time treat him differently. She did say that lots of water will help these cell bi-products move on out. Hence - drink plenty of water to wash out all the toxins. Now that would have been better coming from her but that was the best I could remember from what she told me. Hope that helps. Duckie
> Don't have any idea now that you mention it Ari. But every massage I > have ever had, they always say 'drink plenty of water to wash out all [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] >> >> Which toxins?
 Signature _('> (_<_)
_ _('< -quack (_<_)
_ __('< *QUACK!* <_{__)
_('< "|,,|_" (_<_)
_('< "AFLAC!" (_<_)
spodosaurus - 20 May 2005 18:02 GMT > Okay here is what she said. > The cells produce waste like carbon dioxide heh ... if they didn't we'd be in big trouble!
> which you are familiar with > and other things which she did not elaborate of course not
> on but sure could be found > on internet search. For what, normal cellular metabolism?
> The blood washes away these wastes. When a muscle > decides to knot up, the muscle cells tend to hold on to those wastes. > The harder the knot the more wastes the more it holds on. During a > massage, the [big word I have forgotten but think it began mya-fibro...] > are worked to release these wastes. myofilaments. They like to use big words to try and bamboozle us to believing their mumbo jumbo pseudo-science babble. They're trying to make it sound like they're medical practitioners, and they haven't a clue what that really means. I really don't understand why they're not satisfied with being providers of useful complementary therapies! I find their need to try and manipulate us highly demeaning and disrespectful. They don't need to behave like snake oil salesmen, but they're indoctrinated to do so.
> The harder the knots, the more there > is to release. Not that much more.
> Since the normal ebb and flow had been broken, this > release can cause pain if not done properly [her words]. well, pressing on a trigger point is often a painful...but very useful...procedure. There's no need to try and manipulate us using high school science terms to try and pretend like there's anything more to it than that. There're no mythical toxins. There are, however, factors such as tension, pain, and fatigue that set in through chronic low level contractions that massage does wonders to assist in relieving! It's a very useful assistive therapy, but there's no need to try and use big words to convince us that it is more than it really is. It's not practicing medicine, it's a massage, and it helps our pain.
> I told her that > my fibro got worse with massage and she said it was the [big word again] > sheath[?] that was massaged and that would make sense. All muscles are encapsulated in a fibrous sheath. Obviously, to press on a muscle belly, you also have to press on this sheath (and the skin, and the subcutaneous tissue, etc.
> There is a form > of massage she said that would be good for fibro patients. Actually she > said, ridding the body of these wastes that have built up is important > to everyone but not if they hurt you worse. These wastes that she declined to name do not build up to form toxic deposits.
> She suggested that he call > the massage therepist and report his reaction to it as she can make > suggestions and the next time treat him differently. > She did say that lots of water will help these cell bi-products move on > out. In my other recent post I mentioned that most people are quite under hydrated. Drinking plenty of water and relieving that situation is going to make you feel better...until you revert to habitual drinking patterns. There's nothing more scientific to it than that.
> Hence - drink plenty of water to wash out all the toxins. Toxins that she declined to name, as I knew she would. She provides a great adjunctive therapy, I really don't understand why she, and others, feel the need to try and convince others that they know more than they do, or that the therapy does things that it doesn't. More people would use alternative and adjunctive treatments if they would stop doing this!
> Now that would have been better coming from her but that was the best I > could remember from what she told me. Hope that helps. [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >>> >>> Which toxins?
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Duckie - 20 May 2005 19:14 GMT She wasn't trying to bamboozle me -- we were chatting between dances - a 30 sec pause. I thought I got a lot for that. She would have written all the words down for me if I had asked - I didn't. Bet she will give me a good link for solid info when I see her next. If she is at the dance this Saturday night, I will try again. She works full time as the head of catering at a large hotel and has been taking classes because she was interested in this form of health care. So except for a choice between steak or fish, she isn't even trying to sell you something. rofl I will see what I can do. Bet she is working on Saturday night though. This is interesting. Glad you put me on to it. I need to get my acupuncturist to explain exactly what chi is while I am at it. :) Duckie
>> Okay here is what she said. >> The cells produce waste like carbon dioxide [quoted text clipped - 90 lines] >>>> >>>> Which toxins?
 Signature _('> (_<_)
_ _('< -quack (_<_)
_ __('< *QUACK!* <_{__)
_('< "|,,|_" (_<_)
_('< "AFLAC!" (_<_)
spodosaurus - 20 May 2005 19:50 GMT > She wasn't trying to bamboozle me I guess not, it was how she was trained. The person who trained her used those terms, and they didn't need to.
> -- we were chatting between dances - a > 30 sec pause. I thought I got a lot for that. She would have written all [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > interested in this form of health care. So except for a choice between > steak or fish, she isn't even trying to sell you something. Fish for me, thanks!
I realise she's not peddling snake oil, I just wish the people teaching alternative therapy techniques would stop using the same tactics as snake oil salesmen! It makes them sound too similar, and while it may work to keep people coming back to the SO salesmen, the legitimate folks like her really don't need to use that tactic.
> rofl > I will see what I can do. Bet she is working on Saturday night though. > This is interesting. Glad you put me on to it. I need to get my > acupuncturist to explain exactly what chi is while I am at it. :) Again, another valuable alternative therapy. But from what I have seen and heard about it, they use the traditional terms (whether they're recognised by western science or not) instead of trying to make it sound like it has a traditional scientific basis.
> Duckie > [quoted text clipped - 93 lines] >>>>> >>>>> Which toxins?
 Signature spammage trappage: replace fishies_ with yahoo
I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor: http://www.abmdr.org.au/ http://www.marrow.org/
Norman Lampert - 23 May 2005 03:54 GMT I don't think that she, or most masseurs/masseuses are trying to "bamboozle us; many of them were trained as if massage were a mystical procedure. I've known a few who think of it as "aligning the aura" (I don't go to them, even when they are friends).
Most of them do seem to have a good working knowledge of musculature and how it works (or refuses to do so) and what it takes to get the muscles moving again (though some of their ideas on "power flows" and such are rather odd).
Massage does seem to help increase blood circulation, which helps the muscles feel better. As far as drinking water, most of us really don't drink enough, so being told to drink more now and then is probably a good idea, even if it doesn't "flush the toxins out of the system".
I know that I have a tendency to "lock up", and a good massage (which IS somewhat painful if I'm really tight) helps me feel better and move better, though I may be a little sore for a bit a few ours later. One thing which helps to lessen the overall pain is paying attention to where the masseuse/masseur is working and intentionally relaxing the muscle "under attack" even if it does hurt at that time.
Some discomfort is OK during the massage, but A LOT OF PAIN is not. If it hurts a lot, tell them to ease up.
Nanny - 20 May 2005 05:55 GMT You're right, Duckie. I forgot to mention how important drinking water after a massage is - to help flush out the toxins in your system. Also, a couple aspirin and/or a muscle relaxer helps afterwards (or even before you go in). Nanny
> Water is a must after a massage to rid the body of the toxins. I finally > had to give up massages because of that. My acupuncturist gives me the [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >> >> Holy cr^p! Norman Lampert - 19 May 2005 06:14 GMT > So I went and saw a CMT with a gift certificate my wife gave me. The > massage therapist was pretty knowledgeable about RA and did a good job of [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Holy cr^p! Many people experience that. I know quite a few who say that this is an indication that something finally loosened up; the way a muscle is sore after a cramp has been released. As Duckie said, drinking water afterwards helps. So does learning to relax a muscle as the therapist works on it. Tensing up if the therapist "finds" a sore spot makes it hurt worse.
Nann Bell - 19 May 2005 14:43 GMT > So I went and saw a CMT with a gift certificate my wife gave me. The > massage therapist was pretty knowledgeable about RA and did a good job of > ratcheting the intensity up and down based upon my feedback. Didn't feel > too bad afterwards, but now, several hours later, I feel like somebody took > a baseball bat to me. drink a lot of water and give it a day. A really good massage will leave your muscles sore for a day or so. Then you realize they are much more relaxed. It is even more true for an initial massage. Massages have a cumulative effect on relaxing the muscles and over time the aching isn't as bad the next day. Drinking lots of waer is becuse the massage, in loosening up the muscles, releases a lot of the waste products of muscle tension and water helps flush these from your body.
I got regular massages last year before I moved away from my therapist, who I really miss! I learned that if I wanted to swim, to do it the day of the massage, before going, because I wouldn't be up to it afterwards or the next day. But the muscles surely felt much better the rest of the time......
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
Nanny - 20 May 2005 05:55 GMT Don't be discouraged by your first experience. I've been getting twice-a-month massages for years. Since the therapist was working on muscles you probably haven't had massaged before, it is not uncommon to hurt for a couple days afterwards. Also, if you go back, let her know just how much pressure you want applied. I like a firm massage, but others can only tolerate a light touch. It's an individual thing.
It is my experience that after awhile I was looking forward to the next appointment. For me, it is totally wonderful to lie there and have hands-on therapy, with absolutely no distractions. Some therapists light aromatherapy candles and/or play soft music. It helps to find a massage therapist you feel comfortable with and form a "bond" with over many treatments. My personal choice is a woman, and my massage therapist happens to be one. She knows my body and all its "lumps and bumps", and I know her touch. I do not like to visit during massage, as it tenses me up instead of relaxing me. We understand each other that way.
Anyhow, hope your next experience will be even better than your first! Nanny
> So I went and saw a CMT with a gift certificate my wife gave me. The > massage therapist was pretty knowledgeable about RA and did a good job of [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Holy cr^p!
|
|
|