Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Arthritis / December 2004
OTP Guards at Tomb of Unknowns--Truth & Error
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Gwen Love - 11 Nov 2004 18:14 GMT First, just a tiny bit of history ... The Tomb of the Unknowns holds three sets of remains, one each from World War I, World War II, and the Korean War. A fourth set of remains from the Vietnam War was formally disinterred in 1998 after DNA testing determined them to belong to First Lieutenant Michael Joseph Blassie. Lt. Blassie is now buried in his hometown of St. Louis, Missouri. The tomb is guarded 24 hours a day and 365 days a year by specially chosen soldiers of the 3rd Infantry Regiment (Old Guard) stationed at nearby Fort Myer.
Now, to the email:
1. How many steps does the guard take during his walk across the tomb of the Unknowns and why?
(21 steps. It alludes to the twenty-one gun salute, which is the highest honor given any military or foreign dignitary.)
This is true. ---------------------------------------------------------- 2. How long does he hesitate after his about-face to begin his return walk and why?
(21 seconds for the same reason as answer #1.)
This is somewhat true but incomplete. The guard does not execute an about-face, and there is more involved in the procedure: (a) The sentinel marches 21 steps across the black mat, past the final resting places of the Unknown Soldiers of World War I, World War II, Korea, and the crypt of the Unknown Soldier of the Vietnam War. (b) With a crisp turn, the sentinel turns 90 degrees (not about-face) to face east for 21 seconds. (c) The sentinel then turns a sharp 90 degrees again to face north for 21 seconds. A crisp "shoulder-arms" movement places the rifle on the shoulder nearest the visitors to signify that the sentinel stands between the tomb and any threat. (d) The sentinel then paces 21 steps north, turns and repeats the process. ---------------------------------------------------------- 3. Why are his gloves wet?
(His gloves are moistened to prevent his losing his grip on the rifle.)
This is true. ---------------------------------------------------------- 4. Does he carry his rifle on the same shoulder all the time, and if not, why not?
(He carries the rifle on the shoulder away from the tomb After his march across the path, he executes an about face, and moves the rifle to the outside shoulder.)
As noted in #2 above, the guard shifts his rifle prior to each 21-step walk to ensure that it is always carried on his outside shoulder, the one away from the Tomb ("to signify that the sentinel stands between the tomb and any threat"). ---------------------------------------------------------- 5. How often are the guards changed?
Guards are changed every thirty minutes, twenty-four hours a day, 365 days a year.
This is basically true. From 1926 through 1937, the Tomb was guarded only during daylight hours. Ever since 1937, the Tomb has been continuously guarded 24 hours a day, every day of the year. Tomb guards are changed every thirty minutes between 8 AM and 7 PM during the period from early Spring to early Autumn (April 1 through September 30), and every hour between 8 AM to 5 PM the rest of the year. At all other times (i.e., while the cemetery is closed), the guard is changed every two hours.
This seems like an appropriate spot to mention another email about the sentries at the Tomb of the Unknowns. This one deals with Hurricane Isabel and claims that during Hurricane Isabel, sentries guarding the Tomb of the Unknowns remained at their posts.
This is true. When Hurricane Isabel hit on 19 September 2003, sentries charged with guarding the Tomb of the Unknowns did indeed spend the entire night out in the weather rather than leave their posts. It is untrue, however, that they disobeyed a direct order to do so, as some e-mail versions of this story maintain.
There is a contingency plan that if winds reached 120 mph the guards could retreat from their usual exposed-to-the-elements posts in the tomb plaza to take up positions in the trophy room, which is above the tomb plaza and has a clear view of the sepulcher. This plan was not put into effect. ---------------------------------------------------------- 6. What are the physical traits of the guard limited to?
(For a person to apply for guard duty at the tomb, he must be between 5' 10" and 6' 2" tall and his waist size cannot exceed 30".)
This is true. Each soldier must be in superb physical condition, possess an unblemished military record and be between 5 feet, 10 inches and 6 feet, 4 inches tall, with a proportionate weight and build. ---------------------------------------------------------- 7. They must commit 2 years of life to guard the tomb, live in a barracks under the tomb, and cannot drink any alcohol on or off duty for the rest of their lives. Not quite true. Sentinels at the Tomb do not have to commit to serving there for any fixed period of time, and the average tour of duty is only about half the two year period claimed in the email. Like most servicemen, Tomb guards may live either on-base (at nearby Fort Myer) or off-base in housing of their choosing. There are no restrictions on guards' off-duty drinking. ---------------------------------------------------------- 8. They cannot swear in public for the rest of their lives and cannot disgrace the uniform (fighting) or the tomb in any way. After two years, the guard is given a wreath pin that is worn on their lapel signifying they served as guard of the tomb. There are only 400 presently worn. The guard must obey these rules for the rest of their lives or give up the wreath pin.
Parts are true and parts are not. The Tomb Guard Identification Badge, first awarded in 1957, is a honor for which a guard qualifies by "flawlessly performing his duty for several months" and passing a test, not something simply handed out to everyone who serves for a given period of time: Once the sentinel has completed his or her training, he or she is examined formally for proficiency in performing the duties and in knowledge of Alington National Cemetery. He or she must first pass a written examination of 100 questions about the cemetery and then be evaluated on proficiency in keeping watch at the Tomb of the Unknowns.
Upon successful completion, the soldier is awarded a temporary Tomb Guard's Badge at a ceremony presided over by the company commander. The Badge is one of the Army's higher honors and can be taken away from the soldier if he or she does not continue to maintain the highest military standards.
The 500th Tomb Guard Identification Badge was awarded in early 2002, and the total number of recipients is now about 525. The award is, as its name states, a badge worn on the pocket of a uniform jacket, not a pin worn in the lapel.
Although the claim that guards "cannot swear in public for the rest of their lives" is fallacious, there is some truth to the notion that the Tomb Guard Identification Badge can be taken away, even after the recipient has left the service. According to Old Guard Public Affairs: "The Tomb Guard Identification Badge is one of the least awarded badges in the Army, second only to the Astronaut Badge. Since the sentinels are held to such a high standard, if they ever do anything that is deemed behavior unbecoming a Tomb Guard or brings dishonor upon the Tomb, their badges may be revoked, even after [the sentinels] have left active duty military service."
As of early 2002, there had been nine revocations of the Tomb Guard Identification Badge. ---------------------------------------------------------- 9. The shoes are specially made with very thick soles to keep the heat and cold from their feet. There are metal heel plates that extend to the top of the shoe in order to make the loud click as they come to a halt. There are no wrinkles, folds or lint on the uniform. Guards dress for duty in front of a full-length mirror.
Somewhat true. The shoes are standard issue military dress shoes. They are built up so the sole and heel are equal in height. This allows the Sentinel to stand so that his back is straight and perpendicular to the ground. A side effect of this is that the Sentinel can "roll" on the outside of the build up as he walks down the mat. This allows him to move in a fluid fashion. If he does this correctly, his hat and bayonet will appear to not "bob" up and down with each step. It gives him a more formal and smooth look to his walk, rather than a "marching" appearance.
The soles have a steel tip on the toe and a "horseshoe" steel plate on the heel. This prevents wear on the sole and allows the Sentinel to move smoothly during his movements when he turns to face the Tomb and then back down the mat. ---------------------------------------------------------- 10. The first six months of duty a guard cannot talk to anyone, nor watch TV. All off duty time is spent studying the 175 notable people laid to rest in Arlington National Cemetery. A guard must memorize who they are and where they are interred. Every guard spends five hours a day getting his uniforms ready for guard duty.
Again, some truth, some non-truth. A Tomb guard's behavior is not so stringently regulated that he is prohibited from speaking to anyone for a full six months (someone seems to have confused the Old Guard with a monastery!), and guards may do whatever they want (including watching TV) during their off-duty hours. But since any soldier wishing to become a sentinel must undergo rigorous training, including several hours a day of marching, rifle drill and uniform preparation, and every tomb sentinel is expected to be completely versed in the history of both the tomb and of Arlington National Cemetery (including knowing how to find the graves of all the prominent person buried in the cemetery), they don't necessarily have a lot of free time to devote to recreational activities. ----------------------------------------------------------
My source for this is the Snopes.Com Urban Legend website. http://www.snopes.com/military/unknown.asp First, just a tiny bit of history ... The Tomb of the Unknowns holds three sets of remains, one each from World War I, World War II, and the Korean War. A fourth set of remains from the Vietnam War was formally disinterred in 1998 after DNA testing determined them to belong to First Lieutenant Michael Joseph Blassie. Lt. Blassie is now buried in his hometown of St. Louis, Missouri. The tomb is guarded 24 hours a day and 365 days a year by specially chosen soldiers of the 3rd Infantry Regiment (Old Guard) stationed at nearby Fort Myer.
Now, to the email:
1. How many steps does the guard take during his walk across the tomb of the Unknowns and why?
(21 steps. It alludes to the twenty-one gun salute, which is the highest honor given any military or foreign dignitary.)
This is true. ---------------------------------------------------------- 2. How long does he hesitate after his about-face to begin his return walk and why?
(21 seconds for the same reason as answer #1.)
This is somewhat true but incomplete. The guard does not execute an about-face, and there is more involved in the procedure: (a) The sentinel marches 21 steps across the black mat, past the final resting places of the Unknown Soldiers of World War I, World War II, Korea, and the crypt of the Unknown Soldier of the Vietnam War. (b) With a crisp turn, the sentinel turns 90 degrees (not about-face) to face east for 21 seconds. (c) The sentinel then turns a sharp 90 degrees again to face north for 21 seconds. A crisp "shoulder-arms" movement places the rifle on the shoulder nearest the visitors to signify that the sentinel stands between the tomb and any threat. (d) The sentinel then paces 21 steps north, turns and repeats the process. ---------------------------------------------------------- 3. Why are his gloves wet?
(His gloves are moistened to prevent his losing his grip on the rifle.)
This is true. ---------------------------------------------------------- 4. Does he carry his rifle on the same shoulder all the time, and if not, why not?
(He carries the rifle on the shoulder away from the tomb After his march across the path, he executes an about face, and moves the rifle to the outside shoulder.)
As noted in #2 above, the guard shifts his rifle prior to each 21-step walk to ensure that it is always carried on his outside shoulder, the one away from the Tomb ("to signify that the sentinel stands between the tomb and any threat"). ---------------------------------------------------------- 5. How often are the guards changed?
Guards are changed every thirty minutes, twenty-four hours a day, 365 days a year.
This is basically true. From 1926 through 1937, the Tomb was guarded only during daylight hours. Ever since 1937, the Tomb has been continuously guarded 24 hours a day, every day of the year. Tomb guards are changed every thirty minutes between 8 AM and 7 PM during the period from early Spring to early Autumn (April 1 through September 30), and every hour between 8 AM to 5 PM the rest of the year. At all other times (i.e., while the cemetery is closed), the guard is changed every two hours.
This seems like an appropriate spot to mention another email about the sentries at the Tomb of the Unknowns. This one deals with Hurricane Isabel and claims that during Hurricane Isabel, sentries guarding the Tomb of the Unknowns remained at their posts.
This is true. When Hurricane Isabel hit on 19 September 2003, sentries charged with guarding the Tomb of the Unknowns did indeed spend the entire night out in the weather rather than leave their posts. It is untrue, however, that they disobeyed a direct order to do so, as some e-mail versions of this story maintain.
There is a contingency plan that if winds reached 120 mph the guards could retreat from their usual exposed-to-the-elements posts in the tomb plaza to take up positions in the trophy room, which is above the tomb plaza and has a clear view of the sepulcher. This plan was not put into effect. ---------------------------------------------------------- 6. What are the physical traits of the guard limited to?
(For a person to apply for guard duty at the tomb, he must be between 5' 10" and 6' 2" tall and his waist size cannot exceed 30".)
This is true. Each soldier must be in superb physical condition, possess an unblemished military record and be between 5 feet, 10 inches and 6 feet, 4 inches tall, with a proportionate weight and build. ---------------------------------------------------------- 7. They must commit 2 years of life to guard the tomb, live in a barracks under the tomb, and cannot drink any alcohol on or off duty for the rest of their lives. Not quite true. Sentinels at the Tomb do not have to commit to serving there for any fixed period of time, and the average tour of duty is only about half the two year period claimed in the email. Like most servicemen, Tomb guards may live either on-base (at nearby Fort Myer) or off-base in housing of their choosing. There are no restrictions on guards' off-duty drinking. ---------------------------------------------------------- 8. They cannot swear in public for the rest of their lives and cannot disgrace the uniform (fighting) or the tomb in any way. After two years, the guard is given a wreath pin that is worn on their lapel signifying they served as guard of the tomb. There are only 400 presently worn. The guard must obey these rules for the rest of their lives or give up the wreath pin.
Parts are true and parts are not. The Tomb Guard Identification Badge, first awarded in 1957, is a honor for which a guard qualifies by "flawlessly performing his duty for several months" and passing a test, not something simply handed out to everyone who serves for a given period of time: Once the sentinel has completed his or her training, he or she is examined formally for proficiency in performing the duties and in knowledge of Alington National Cemetery. He or she must first pass a written examination of 100 questions about the cemetery and then be evaluated on proficiency in keeping watch at the Tomb of the Unknowns.
Upon successful completion, the soldier is awarded a temporary Tomb Guard's Badge at a ceremony presided over by the company commander. The Badge is one of the Army's higher honors and can be taken away from the soldier if he or she does not continue to maintain the highest military standards.
The 500th Tomb Guard Identification Badge was awarded in early 2002, and the total number of recipients is now about 525. The award is, as its name states, a badge worn on the pocket of a uniform jacket, not a pin worn in the lapel.
Although the claim that guards "cannot swear in public for the rest of their lives" is fallacious, there is some truth to the notion that the Tomb Guard Identification Badge can be taken away, even after the recipient has left the service. According to Old Guard Public Affairs: "The Tomb Guard Identification Badge is one of the least awarded badges in the Army, second only to the Astronaut Badge. Since the sentinels are held to such a high standard, if they ever do anything that is deemed behavior unbecoming a Tomb Guard or brings dishonor upon the Tomb, their badges may be revoked, even after [the sentinels] have left active duty military service."
As of early 2002, there had been nine revocations of the Tomb Guard Identification Badge. ---------------------------------------------------------- 9. The shoes are specially made with very thick soles to keep the heat and cold from their feet. There are metal heel plates that extend to the top of the shoe in order to make the loud click as they come to a halt. There are no wrinkles, folds or lint on the uniform. Guards dress for duty in front of a full-length mirror.
Somewhat true. The shoes are standard issue military dress shoes. They are built up so the sole and heel are equal in height. This allows the Sentinel to stand so that his back is straight and perpendicular to the ground. A side effect of this is that the Sentinel can "roll" on the outside of the build up as he walks down the mat. This allows him to move in a fluid fashion. If he does this correctly, his hat and bayonet will appear to not "bob" up and down with each step. It gives him a more formal and smooth look to his walk, rather than a "marching" appearance.
The soles have a steel tip on the toe and a "horseshoe" steel plate on the heel. This prevents wear on the sole and allows the Sentinel to move smoothly during his movements when he turns to face the Tomb and then back down the mat. ---------------------------------------------------------- 10. The first six months of duty a guard cannot talk to anyone, nor watch TV. All off duty time is spent studying the 175 notable people laid to rest in Arlington National Cemetery. A guard must memorize who they are and where they are interred. Every guard spends five hours a day getting his uniforms ready for guard duty.
Again, some truth, some non-truth. A Tomb guard's behavior is not so stringently regulated that he is prohibited from speaking to anyone for a full six months (someone seems to have confused the Old Guard with a monastery!), and guards may do whatever they want (including watching TV) during their off-duty hours. But since any soldier wishing to become a sentinel must undergo rigorous training, including several hours a day of marching, rifle drill and uniform preparation, and every tomb sentinel is expected to be completely versed in the history of both the tomb and of Arlington National Cemetery (including knowing how to find the graves of all the prominent person buried in the cemetery), they don't necessarily have a lot of free time to devote to recreational activities. ----------------------------------------------------------
Source for this is the Snopes.Com Urban Legend website. http://www.snopes.com/military/unknown.asp
 Signature ============================================ My kids never had the advantage I had: I was born poor. Kirk Douglas==================================
Val in Boise - 11 Nov 2004 22:18 GMT Gwen. What is the significance of "21"?
Val in Boise
| First, just a tiny bit of history ... The Tomb of the | Unknowns holds three sets of remains, one each from World [quoted text clipped - 436 lines] | Source for this is the Snopes.Com Urban Legend website. | http://www.snopes.com/military/unknown.asp Gwen Love - 11 Nov 2004 23:23 GMT Val, this came from Google. Gwen
The 21-Gun Salute
The 21-gun salute honoring the President of the United States, like many American military traditions, appears to be another custom inherited from Great Britain. In early times, it was customary for a ship entering a friendly port to discharge its broadsides to demonstrate that they were unloaded; eventually it became a British practice to fire a seven-gun salute. The forts ashore would fire three shots for each shot fired afloat. The three guns fired on shore to one gun fired on ship had a practical explanation. In earlier days, gunpowder was made of sodium nitrate and was easier to keep on shore than at sea. When gunpowder was improved by the use of potassium nitrate, the sea salute was made equal to the shore salute. The use of numbers "seven" and "three" in early gun salutes probably was connected to the mystical or religious significance surrounding these numbers in many cultures.
Gun salutes continue to be fired in odd numbers, of course, and this is likely because of ancient superstitions that uneven numbers are lucky. As early as 1685, the firing of an even number of guns in salute was taken as indicating that a ship's captain, master, or master gunner had died on a voyage. Indeed, the firing of an even number of salute guns at the coronation of George VI in 1937 was regarded by at least one observer as an "ominous" portent. Incidentally, the normal interval of five seconds in the firing of gun salutes likely is in order for the salute to have full auditory effect, and also to give the salute a more solemn character.
The United States presidential salute has not always been 21 guns. In 1812 and 1821 it was the same as the number of states, i.e. 18 and 24, respectively, which was also our international salute. After 1841 the President received a salute of 21 guns and the Vice President 17; currently the Vice President receives a salute of 19 guns.
There has evolved over the last 175 years or so a prescribed number of guns, set forth in various Army regulations, to be fired for various dignitaries in accordance with the perceived importance of their positions. On 18 August 1875, the United States and Great Britain announced an agreement to return salutes "gun for gun," with the 21-gun salute as the highest national honor.
Today, a 21-gun salute on arrival and departure, with 4 ruffles and flourishes, is rendered to the President of the United States, to an ex-President, and to a President elect. The national anthem or "Hail to the Chief," as appropriate, is played for the President, and the national anthem for the others. A 21-gun salute on arrival and departure with 4 ruffles and flourishes also is rendered to the sovereign or chief of state of a foreign country, or a member of a reigning royal family. In these ceremonies, the national anthem of his or her country also is played.
Incidentally, U.S. Naval Regulations require that a 21-gun salute be fired at noon on Presidents Day, Independence Day, and Memorial Day.
Reference Section History and Museums Division
> Gwen. What is the significance of "21"? > [quoted text clipped - 440 lines] > | Source for this is the Snopes.Com Urban Legend website. > | http://www.snopes.com/military/unknown.asp DeeTee and Bob Taggart - 12 Nov 2004 16:35 GMT The 21-gun salute became the highest honor a nation rendered. Varying customs among the maritime powers led to confusion in saluting and return of salutes. Great Britain, the world's preeminent seapower in the 18th and 19th centuries, compelled weaker nations to salute first, and for a time monarchies received more guns than did republics. Eventually, by agreement, the international salute was established at 21 guns, although the United States did not agree on this procedure until August 1875. [http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/faq/salute.htm]
DeeTee ________________________________ DeeTee and Bob Taggart http://www.marykay.com/dtaggart3 http://mysite.verizon.net/vze8fwov/ ________________________________
> Gwen. What is the significance of "21"? > [quoted text clipped - 440 lines] > | Source for this is the Snopes.Com Urban Legend website. > | http://www.snopes.com/military/unknown.asp ephraim - 03 Dec 2004 09:22 GMT http://www.ardice.com/Arts/Music/Bands_and_Artists/2/21_Guns
Nann Bell - 12 Nov 2004 16:16 GMT very intersting, thanks Gwen. I wonder if they tell you these things when you visit the tomb. It would certainly make the visit more meaningful. (I was 10 when we visited, so I hardly remember much beyond what my parents told me!)
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
Jo Firey - 12 Nov 2004 20:47 GMT > very intersting, thanks Gwen. I wonder if they tell you these things when > you visit the tomb. It would certainly make the visit more meaningful. > (I > was 10 when we visited, so I hardly remember much beyond what my parents > told > me!) But the way I remember it, if you even stand there for thirty minutes, read the inscription on the tomb, and really look at the guards. Look at their faces and the pride in them. You do understand.
Jo
|
|
|