Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Arthritis / November 2006
"healing" vs "cure"
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Nann Bell - 17 Nov 2006 12:23 GMT I've been writing down some ruminations on life with chronic illness/pain lately - not sure what it's going to develop into, but something is in the works. One thing I started thinking about is that I now think of healing and cure as meaning different things. The first def. of both in the dictionary is "restoration of health", though there are other meanings of heal listed further on.
Now I want to know if others have come to see a difference between the two words? How do you think of "healing" and "cure"? Is this something that has changed for you since you've had a chronic illness? (or just through other life experiences?)
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
Diane - 17 Nov 2006 17:46 GMT ABOSLUTELY, Nann!! I don't have capital letters big enough for this. I know so many people who talk about healing in the physical sense. But I have felt "healed" for the past ten years, ever since getting a feeling I can only describe as "transcendence" that let me feel "okay" no matter what my physical condition. I know some people who are very into spiritual healing who STILL think it will ultimately lead to physical healing, as though that's the real goal. i have trouble getting into conversations with them.
nann, i have long had the idea of pulling together some of the beautiful sentiments from this group and others on the internet that indicate that healing has nothing to do with being cured, and forming them into a book to inspire people with chronic illness. if you'd like to work on that together, let me know. if you have an idea to work on on your own, go for it.
diane
diclidophora@yahoo.co.uk - 17 Nov 2006 17:53 GMT Hi Nann.
I can see a difference between the two words. To me a cure is the abolition of a particular disease and a return to normal health without further relapse into that diseased state. Healing can be partial or complete. I think if you are completely healed you are cured, but on the other hand, for instance, a wound may heal partially and then become infected so that it does not completely heal. You could be be cured of TB, but still be left with lungs which were not completely healed because they had been irreparably damaged by the disease.
That's the way I see it.
Peter
> I've been writing down some ruminations on life with chronic illness/pain > lately - not sure what it's going to develop into, but something is in the [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > remove the Gator cheer to email me > Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare Donna G. - 18 Nov 2006 00:26 GMT Funny you should mention this, Nann, as I was just having a very similar discussion with someone the other day.
You see, when I was first diagnosed with my lung disease, I was still quite young and thought, ok, no big deal. As things got worse and progressed, and then I ended up on oxygen, I really got scared and quite depressed. I prayed, and prayed, and prayed that I would be healed!
Funny thing is, after a while, I started to realize that I HAD been healed, just not in the way _I_ had thought. I think having a chronic illness can really open our eyes to some things that might otherwise never be seen or never have even taken the time to see, but are seen when one is forced to slow down a bit and perhaps re-evaluate ones life and one's goals, etc. Then, I think we start to realize how truly blessed we have always been and continue to be, despite what we have to deal with. I myself, think I have been "healed" in so many other ways that I could have never even begun to imagine.
Lets face it, everyone has their own burdens to contend with. For some of us, that is health issues, for others something different. I can ALWAYS see the blessings I have in my life n matter how bad things may seem at any given moment and for this I am thankful. Not sure I could have made that statement before I was diagnosed with a few chronic illnesses.
I think chronic illness open our eyes and help us to become more sympathetic, hopefully more understanding of others, more patient of others in their times of need, etc.
Not sure if that is what you are thinking of, but is definitely how I have looked at things over the last 10+ years or so.
Hugs,
Donna G. . . . ANGELS EXIST, but some times, since they don't all have wings, we call them FRIENDS......
Harvey R. Stone - 18 Nov 2006 11:22 GMT > Hi Nann. > [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > Peter and that is pretty close to how I see it. Harv
Ps Nothing that I know of cures inflam.arth.. It could be in the future with todays tech.
Rosemarie Shiver - 18 Nov 2006 00:09 GMT Sure!
Heeling is something well trained dogs do and cure is what you do to ham.<duckin' and gimpin' away>
Hugs from Rosie
 Signature "If you wanna get it done, you gotta fight for yourself." -- Meat Loaf, Bat Outta Hell II
> I've been writing down some ruminations on life with chronic illness/pain > lately - not sure what it's going to develop into, but something is in the [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > changed for you since you've had a chronic illness? (or just through other > life experiences?) Nann Bell - 18 Nov 2006 20:08 GMT Ok, some of you are saying what I kept thinking - healing when you have a chronic illness can be more a matter of learning how to have a good life that *includes* your chronic illness, rather than wishing all the time for a cure. And Peter and Harv's point about a difference in the physical ramifications of a cure and of healing is very good as well.
In what I was writing down, I found myself generalizing to others based on what I'd come to think. It seemed like a good idea to find ouut if some others with chronic health issues really did agree with me!
As for you, Rosie - look out, I'll be in Florida next month! And weren't you a teacher? You should know the difference between healing and heeling then! As for ham cures..... well, we were discussing that yesterday afternoon when we were putting away the ham leftover from the funeral luncheon.
Of course, as a lifelong anglican, I could also get into talking about cure (accent on the "e"), but my fingers are kinda sore.
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
> Sure! > > Heeling is something well trained dogs do and cure is what you do to > ham.<duckin' and gimpin' away> > > Hugs from Rosie Rosemarie Shiver - 18 Nov 2006 20:29 GMT Very kewl, Nann!
We're in Lake Placid if you're anywhere near this area. Yes, I was a teacher but you and I are Fibromites; when you have FM speelung don't count. <g>
Hope we get to see you and yours next month! :-)
Nann Hugs from Rosie
 Signature "If you wanna get it done, you gotta fight for yourself." -- Meat Loaf, Bat Outta Hell II
> Ok, some of you are saying what I kept thinking - healing when you have a > chronic illness can be more a matter of learning how to have a good life that [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] > > > > Hugs from Rosie d'huit - 18 Nov 2006 22:18 GMT yeppers. i think they mean different things to different people, too. i'll offer just a few thoughts for you to think about. you'll have to pardon me, though, because this is where i get into my "philosophizing" about stuff i've been observing about myself for decades. (and please ignore my spelling or grammar, cuz i'm just going to cut loose as if i were writing a first draft.)
to me, there's a healing of the mind or the body or the individual spirit, or all three, or some combination of two of those. for simplification sake, we can call mind, consciousness and individual spirit can be called sub-consciousness. but those two can be called whatever anyone is comfortable calling them. the body is self explanatory, but is totally dependent upon the other two.
i.e. - someone can be completely cured of something, but if their mind and spirit are not healed then their mind and spirit will cause their body to behave like it is still ill or injured. i think of curing as a practical and measurable thing. healing is trickier. it is not as easily quantified, because it goes deeper than curing and is less obvious. so, to me, healing and curing are dependent upon one another for an optimum result, the return to wholeness.
i don't believe a cure is complete without mind and body being also healed. healed of what? of the fear that was caused by experiencing the illness or injury. some of that healing may come with the repetition of rehab helping to lessen resistance to reacquisiton of harmony, but mostly it comes with the releasing of the instilled/acquired fear, by regaining and recognizing a sense of overall comfortableness, a kind of re-establishing harmony among the 3 to make 1 whole again and to make the person feel whole again.
when it comes to chronic illness, the disease is in the body, but doesn't have to be in the mind and/or spirit. i know, that's easy to say, but it can be accomplished, by what diane called transcendance, some might call cooperative denial, others might call it strength of character, and others might even call it optimism or clarity or compartmentalizing or determination or something else, which i think depends upon the individual and how their mind and personal spirit work. to me, when spirit and mind are in harmony, they are powerful, powerful enough to determine how that chronic illness is going to affect the whole person and that one's life and the productivity of that one's life.
kate
I've been writing down some ruminations on life with chronic illness/pain lately - not sure what it's going to develop into, but something is in the works. One thing I started thinking about is that I now think of healing and cure as meaning different things. The first def. of both in the dictionary is "restoration of health", though there are other meanings of heal listed further on.
Now I want to know if others have come to see a difference between the two words? How do you think of "healing" and "cure"? Is this something that has changed for you since you've had a chronic illness? (or just through other life experiences?)
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
d'huit - 19 Nov 2006 08:45 GMT more thoughts about this:
i think faith is an interesting aspect of the healing of fear, brought on by illness or injury. it is something i often think about, without much success in encapsulating.
first off, i'm uncertain if i mean faith, in the religious/spiritual sense (at the conscious or unconscious level), or if i mean it in the everyday sense of the way we make use of or engage faith (at both the conscious and unconscious level, as well), even though a person may not be religious or even consider themselves spiritual.
by everyday sense of the word faith, for want of a better word, i mean something we depend upon, the kind of acceptance and expectation we have of simple and routine things. for instance, turning on a car ignition with the relative unconscious faith that the engine of one's vehicle will start; or we could be taking a step, without worrying about falling . . . etc. there are literally hundreds and perhaps thousands of things we do each day with this kind of unconscious faith in things and in things we do or attempt to do. and without that unconscious faithbased belief that things will work, that we don't have to think or worry about something before doing it, we wouldn't do many things and probably would worry about anything and everything we wanted to do or did do.
in the religious/spiritual sense, faith is a bit more complex. some religions perceive faith in an external/conscious way, while other religions perceive it as being internal/unconscious. often, however, it's expression is external and conscious.
it seems to me that faith (of which kind, i'm not sure) has an essential role in healing mind and personal spirit towards wholeness or even towards sustaining the chronically ill body so that it can live better than it would without the inner-harmony of mind and spirit. without faith nothing would move at any level, in a cure or a healing sense, or even in daily living, without a great deal of angst and inner-conflict. so, faith is a like an invisible tool that we may, or may not take for granted, but that we use so often that we don't even notice when we are relying upon it to get us through each day.
kate
yeppers. i think they mean different things to different people, too. i'll offer just a few thoughts for you to think about. you'll have to pardon me, though, because this is where i get into my "philosophizing" about stuff i've been observing about myself for decades. (and please ignore my spelling or grammar, cuz i'm just going to cut loose as if i were writing a first draft.)
to me, there's a healing of the mind or the body or the individual spirit, or all three, or some combination of two of those. for simplification sake, we can call mind, consciousness and individual spirit can be called sub-consciousness. but those two can be called whatever anyone is comfortable calling them. the body is self explanatory, but is totally dependent upon the other two.
i.e. - someone can be completely cured of something, but if their mind and spirit are not healed then their mind and spirit will cause their body to behave like it is still ill or injured. i think of curing as a practical and measurable thing. healing is trickier. it is not as easily quantified, because it goes deeper than curing and is less obvious. so, to me, healing and curing are dependent upon one another for an optimum result, the return to wholeness.
i don't believe a cure is complete without mind and body being also healed. healed of what? of the fear that was caused by experiencing the illness or injury. some of that healing may come with the repetition of rehab helping to lessen resistance to reacquisiton of harmony, but mostly it comes with the releasing of the instilled/acquired fear, by regaining and recognizing a sense of overall comfortableness, a kind of re-establishing harmony among the 3 to make 1 whole again and to make the person feel whole again.
when it comes to chronic illness, the disease is in the body, but doesn't have to be in the mind and/or spirit. i know, that's easy to say, but it can be accomplished, by what diane called transcendance, some might call cooperative denial, others might call it strength of character, and others might even call it optimism or clarity or compartmentalizing or determination or something else, which i think depends upon the individual and how their mind and personal spirit work. to me, when spirit and mind are in harmony, they are powerful, powerful enough to determine how that chronic illness is going to affect the whole person and that one's life and the productivity of that one's life.
kate
I've been writing down some ruminations on life with chronic illness/pain lately - not sure what it's going to develop into, but something is in the works. One thing I started thinking about is that I now think of healing and cure as meaning different things. The first def. of both in the dictionary is "restoration of health", though there are other meanings of heal listed further on.
Now I want to know if others have come to see a difference between the two words? How do you think of "healing" and "cure"? Is this something that has changed for you since you've had a chronic illness? (or just through other life experiences?)
 Signature Nann remove the Gator cheer to email me Simply the thing I am shall make me live --- William Shakespeare
Ann - 20 Nov 2006 03:11 GMT I think of cure as a physical change and of healing as an emotional or physcological change. For me, both of them have medical and religious implications.
Ann
|
|
|