Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Arthritis / March 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Knee Surgery, I Probably Did The Wrong Thing

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Jack - 02 Mar 2006 13:47 GMT
62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.

It did not affect walking/jogging, only crouching because of inability
to flex fully.  Reluctantly had surgery anyway for partial removal of
torn meniscus, six days ago, and status hasn't improved.  Started
using ski machine four days post surgery and will probably be jogging
within the next few days but still cannot crouch.  

Bad decision.  Waste of time, effort, and resources, not to mention
risking the possibility of infection, nerve damage, etc.
Bonnie Brien - 02 Mar 2006 15:29 GMT
Give it time.......
Harvey R. Stone - 02 Mar 2006 15:30 GMT
> 62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.
>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Bad decision.  Waste of time, effort, and resources, not to mention
> risking the possibility of infection, nerve damage, etc.

Hi Jack,,,,   Anytime a person is operated on for just about anything,,,,,
there is risk.    Many, many people have had the same operation that you did
and have come away improved.   Sorry yours did not go so well and what has
taken place needs to be said.  thanks
Harv
Kurt Ullman - 02 Mar 2006 16:31 GMT
>> 62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>taken place needs to be said.  thanks
>Harv
 It has been six days for the Love of Pete. The swelling probably
hasn't gone down, he also probably hasn't even started the post-op
physical therapy that is going to be needed. You can't say anything
at all about the success of the operation yet.

--
       Then there was the runner-up:  An infinite number of
rednecks riding in an infinite number of pickup trucks fire an
infinite number of shotgun rounds at an infinite number of
highway signs,eventually producing all the world's great
literary works in Braille.

        BONG #469
Me1@Priv1avcy.net - 02 Mar 2006 17:19 GMT
>  It has been six days for the Love of Pete. The swelling probably
>hasn't gone down, he also probably hasn't even started the post-op
>physical therapy that is going to be needed. You can't say anything
>at all about the success of the operation yet.

He's a moron, leave him alone.
Thelma Lubkin - 02 Mar 2006 16:37 GMT
In alt.support.arthritis Jack <windswept@home.net> wrote:
: 62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.

: It did not affect walking/jogging, only crouching because of inability
: to flex fully.  Reluctantly had surgery anyway for partial removal of
: torn meniscus, six days ago, and status hasn't improved.  Started
: using ski machine four days post surgery and will probably be jogging
: within the next few days but still cannot crouch.  

: Bad decision.  Waste of time, effort, and resources, not to mention
: risking the possibility of infection, nerve damage, etc.

     I had my left hip replaced in 2003. For the first week the pain
     from the surgery was strong enough to cover any other pains.

     In the next 3 weeks I experienced exactly the same pain that had
     driven me to have the surgery, and I even spent time crying over the
     useless result.

     After that came the turnaround. I was walking without aid within
     six weeks, and now after three years I walk, bike, swim, sit
     pretzel-style...

     Don't give up yet.
                               --thelma
Me@Privavcy.net - 02 Mar 2006 17:19 GMT
> sit
>      pretzel-style...

Hmm, can I get a jpg?
tsedinger@yahoo.com - 02 Mar 2006 18:05 GMT
> In alt.support.arthritis Jack <windswept@home.net> wrote:
> : 62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
>       Don't give up yet.
>                                 --thelma

Thelma,
I had my left hip replaced Oct. 31. Withing 3 weeks I had no pain
whatsoever. had my right hip replaced Jan 16. I am still experiencing
pretty much the same pain I had before the surgery. I saw the Dr. last
week, had x rays, everything looks perfect. He said that I shouldn't
expect to heal the same and in the same time frame for both sides. It
was six weeks on Mon.
am I jmping the gun on pain? Am I being unrealistic? I go back for a 3
month checkup in april, sure hope I am still not in pain. I admit I'm
pretty discouraged right now.
Thelma Lubkin - 02 Mar 2006 19:06 GMT
In alt.support.arthritis tsedinger@yahoo.com wrote:

                             <snip>
:>       I had my left hip replaced in 2003. For the first week the pain
:>       from the surgery was strong enough to cover any other pains.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
:>       Don't give up yet.
:>                                 --thelma

: Thelma,
: I had my left hip replaced Oct. 31. Withing 3 weeks I had no pain
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
: month checkup in april, sure hope I am still not in pain. I admit I'm
: pretty discouraged right now.

      I don't know. My turnaround came at roughly the four week
      period. But two weeks longer sounds well within statistical range
      for the same [fantastic] outcome as mine: individual details will
      always vary.  After all your three weeks on the left hip was
      a much earlier resolution than mine--I wasn't painfree at the
      moment of turnaround.

      I hope to hear that you're soon 'running around' ready to
      trigger airport metal detectors from both sides.

                              --thelma
Anti-troll@notPrivavcy.net - 02 Mar 2006 23:09 GMT
Thelma,
He's a troll. I asked an MD who said he's lieing.

>In alt.support.arthritis tsedinger@yahoo.com wrote:
>
[quoted text clipped - 35 lines]
>
>                               --thelma
Twittering One - 02 Mar 2006 19:19 GMT
"I had my left hip replaced in 2003.
For the first week the pain
>From the surgery was strong enough to cover any other pains.

In the next 3 weeks
I experienced exactly the same pain
That had driven me to have the surgery,
And I even spent time crying over the useless result.

After that came the turnaround.

I was walking without aid within six weeks,
And now after three years
I walk, bike, swim,

Sit
Pretzel-style ...

Don't give up yet."
~ Thelma

"Thelma, be you
The Raging Queen of Haarlem,
Or The Curious Curator of Epyptian Funerary Sarcafagae ~ ?"
~ Lucas
Twittering One - 02 Mar 2006 19:26 GMT
"I hope to hear that you're soon 'running around'
Ready to
Trigger airport metal detectors
>From both sides."
~ Thelma

"O, Thelma, so hopelessly lost, spinning
Endlessly round ~
Like Little Black Sambo
~ My Tern's
Style ..."
~ Twittering
Me@Privavcy.net - 02 Mar 2006 17:18 GMT
>62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.
>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>Bad decision.  Waste of time, effort, and resources, not to mention
>risking the possibility of infection, nerve damage, etc.

So you're a f.cking moron, what do you want from us?
d'huit - 02 Mar 2006 17:34 GMT
you're kidding, right?  i mean, you're putting us on, right?  you really had
surgery 6 days ago and 4 days later, or two days ago, you were using a ski
machine?  your doctor "told you" it was ok to do that?

i know that arnthroscopic surgery is almost miraculous, but that's almost
absurd.  you need to let things heal, before you tear your meniscus again,
if you haven't already.  healing and rehab needs to be a gentle process in
the beginning.

and btw, how long has it been since you were able to "crouch"?---if it's
been a long time, the rest of your undamaged muscles and tendons have become
accustomed to not stretching in that manner.  they may have even "shrunk"
somewhat, which means they will have to "gradually" be
worked/rehabbed/stretched so that they can function that way again.  if you
keep up this aggressive approach, you may damage something else, if not the
same connective tissues and be worse off than you were before surgery.  i
don't think your surgery has failed, but there definitely IS a failure
here---a failure to communicate.

suggestion:  talk to your surgeon; talk to your surgeon; talk to your
surgeon.  let him/her guide your rehab and let him set you up with a
physical therapist, who will set you up with the correct rehab regimen for
your particular surgical healing process.  ask questions about what and when
it is ok for you to do whatever it is you want to do, like the ski machine,
jogging and such.  don't assume anything is ok, until you ask questions
about it.  and for pete's sake, be gentle with your body.

kate

62-year-old male geezer with torn meniscus.

It did not affect walking/jogging, only crouching because of inability
to flex fully.  Reluctantly had surgery anyway for partial removal of
torn meniscus, six days ago, and status hasn't improved.  Started
using ski machine four days post surgery and will probably be jogging
within the next few days but still cannot crouch.

Bad decision.  Waste of time, effort, and resources, not to mention
risking the possibility of infection, nerve damage, etc.
Jack - 02 Mar 2006 17:56 GMT
>you're kidding, right?  i mean, you're putting us on, right?  you really had
>surgery 6 days ago and 4 days later, or two days ago, you were using a ski
>machine?  your doctor "told you" it was ok to do that?

Talking to the MD is like talking to the wall, but he provided written
instructions to walk and bear weight as tolerated.

The ski machine is a lot more knee-friendly than walking; no pain at
all.

But thanks for your responses.  Maybe it's to early to assess and this
thing will improve and I'll be able to crouch one day and weed the
garden again.
Andrew Heenan - 03 Mar 2006 12:48 GMT
> torn meniscus, six days ago, and status hasn't improved.
> Started using ski machine four days post surgery and will
> probably be jogging within the next few days but still
> cannot crouch.

When your knee seizes up completely / falls apart:

(A) If you followed Doctor's advice, sue. You probably got bad advice.
(B) If you ignored Doctor's advice, think about that for a moment. Or 20
years.

Good Luck,
Signature


Andrew Heenan
http://www.realnurse.net/

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.