Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
GeneralCardiologyVisionDentistryPharmacyLaboratoryNutritionAlternative
Diseases and Disorders
AIDSAlzheimer'sArthritisAsthmaCancerBreast CancerDiabetesEpilepsyGlaucomaHepatitisHerpesLupusProstate BPHProstate CancerProstatitisSinusitisTinnitus

Medical Forum / Diseases and Disorders / Alzheimer's / January 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Lewy Bodies Dementia

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
owliz@hotmail.com - 29 Dec 2005 12:27 GMT
Hi

My name is Liz and I am in Sydney Australia. My husband has had three
different diagnoses, which went from Parkinson's disease to Multiple
System Atrophy and yesterday LBD.

He has been in hospital for about 3 weeks as I came home from work to
find him in a rigid state, which he had held all day so I called the
Ambulance.

I have seen him go from a person who did not know who he was or who I
was to someone who now seems, for some time, quite lucid, but then will
be confused or not able to drink out of a cup with one particularly bad
day where he thought all his teeth were broken and he was seeing his
flesh coming off his hands.

He had an MRI December last year showing Moderate atrophy to the
frontal and cerebral lobe but no one seemed too concerned about it,
however for the past 6 or 7 months his behaviour has been bizarre to
say the least with obsessions relating to sex and money and was so
nasty and spiteful to me that I left the house for a few days as I was
scared he would do something irrational like hurt me, although he has
never laid a finger on me before.

He had a similar period in 1998 but seemed to improve and go back to
his normal self but I am now wondering if that was the beginning of the
LBD?

I work full time and have to decide if I can bring him home from the
hospital or whether I will have to place him in a nursing home?

Sometimes he seems so good I think he will be OK at home, with some
Community help, but then other times I think I probably will not be
able to handle him. He is 5'10" and weighs a reasonable amount and I am
4'11" and I know if he falls I could not pick him up, especially as a
dead weight.

I am looking for some straight talking responses to the issues of
caring for him at home. Am I correct in saying he should not be left
alone for long? This would mean that if there was not continuing
community help I would have to give up my job.

I KNOW that the things I have read all say the average life span is 5-7
years from diagnosis but I am assuming that different people would be
diagnosed at different periods in this illness and he seems so 'lucid
and capable of things, at least some times, that I cannot see that he
is close to the end of this disease.

The deterioration in his condition has been extreme to the point that
no one seemed to believe me that he was suffering from a dementia as
those he spoke to were convinced he was fine, apart from the
Parkinson's. I had him assessed in November and was told he was far
too competent to be considered for placement in a nursing home and it
was suggested to me that he was manipulating me.

This is the hardest thing I have ever had to do, as I am sure many of
you reading this would know, particularly as he sees himself as quite
capable.

Any comments would be greatly appreciated. I have already read a whole
lot of stuff re LBD on the net, including some entries on this
newsgroup.

Thanks for reading
Liz
carolinasongbird@gmail.com - 29 Dec 2005 14:02 GMT
Liz,

My first reaction was that if he has been in hospital due to the
underlying condition alone (and not pneumonia or a broken bone or
something else on top of it), chances are you need to find somewhere
for him to live where he can round the clock care. (You can't do this
at home, unless you stop sleeping -- not advised <G>.)

In the states, we have what are called assisted living homes. They
offer around the clock care, but people who live there are not as
impaired as those in nursing homes. Do you have something similar in
Sydney? They offer activities and such that would keep him active and
involved in those more lucid times.

Best wishes in a tough time -- and welcome to the newsgroup, a place no
one wants to be but is glad they found.

Songbird
owliz@hotmail.com - 29 Dec 2005 14:17 GMT
Songbird
I am not sure yet what is available and one of the difficulties is that
he is only 55.

They also do not seem to know what caused his trance like state
although it kept happening to a much lesser extent for about 2 weeks it
appears to have stopped now so I don't know if that is part of the LBD.

Thank you for your advice and your welcome to the group. I did read in
another thread, may have been an old one, where the question was asked
do I want to keep him at home for him or for me and I am very conscious
of trying to make the best decision for him that I can, which is why I
am thinking nursing home and not me trying to do it.

Regards
Liz

> Liz,
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Songbird
Tumbleweed - 29 Dec 2005 14:22 GMT
Liz, I dont see how anyone could possibly look after soemone else 24x7 with
teh condition you describe. Even if you gave up your job, and never left the
house, there are times you'll be asleep where something bad could happen
because he is alone.

In care, he will get better care than you can provide, and just as
importantly, you'll get better care than you'll give yourself.

I think the experience of many here is that if you do try it 24x7,
eventually a crisis will occur which will mean you wont get to choose the
care for him, and maybe the crisis will be your health, and you certainly
will be in the worst of both worlds then.

Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

>
> Hi
[quoted text clipped - 62 lines]
> Thanks for reading
> Liz
Deborah - 29 Dec 2005 17:36 GMT
<snip>

> Any comments would be greatly appreciated. I have already read a
> whole lot of stuff re LBD on the net, including some entries on
> this newsgroup.
>
> Thanks for reading
> Liz

Liz, look around on this site:

http://www.lewybodydementia.org/index.html

and _do_ sign up for the very, very informative and helpful Yahoo
groups. ("LBD Email Groups" link on the left panel)

Good luck!

Deborah
pattihorgan@gmail.com - 29 Dec 2005 17:43 GMT
Hi,
My name is pat and I am going through the same thing that you are..My
husband has also had 3 DX..Parkinsons, Parkinsons Plus,LBD,and Shy
Drager..He fell again last night and I hsd trouble getting him up...I
finally had to put a pillow under his head and cover him with a blanket
until I could get help....Miraculously he managed to get up....I have a
visiting nurse coming to evaluate him today...he will not go to the
hospital..he has been in 3 times for falls...I went to my lawyer to get
things in order and he has referred me to an expert in Health Care and
Legal issues who is meeting with me at my home in Jan....she will go
over our assests and determine which situation is best for my husband
and financially best for me....I have been to Sydney and loved it...so
glad that we went when we could...I know that things are different
there but will let you know what she suggests...Can not beleive that
this is happenning...

> Hi
>
[quoted text clipped - 61 lines]
> Thanks for reading
> Liz
akiross03@hotmail.com - 29 Dec 2005 17:58 GMT
Liz, I still consider myself fairly new to this group as I've only been
a caregiver about 6 months. And I know that there are variations from
one person to another & severity of their condition. But from what you
describe & knowing what I've learned & personally witnessed, there is
no way I'd leave someone with dementia alone.

Left alone, you have to think about them slipping and falling. Or
thinking they can operate things including sharp knives in the kitchen,
leaving something cooking too long until they & the house goes up in
smoke. And you can't tell when they are going to have another episode &
simply not be able to fend for themselves, even if it is drinking
something or making it to the bathroom.

If your husband is in the early stages, I can see where Assisted Living
might work out. However, because you are working, I'm not even sure if
that would the best situation. If he had a serious problem, would he be
able to pick up the phone & call for help? Is he able to reason with
things like knowing which clothes are appropriate? If a snack is in the
kitchen, is he able to go get it without any problems? If he has meds
he has to take during the day, is he able to take them correctly? Does
he have any problems with toileting - my point being when you gotta go,
you gotta go & if they have a reasoning impairment then they are
probably going to wait until the last second which can cause a mess if
they don't have help ready right there.

My MIL is very fortunate in that I'm with her all day long (we use a
monitor for the night), my husband works out of the house so we are
able to share some of the caretaking, and my SIL lives right up the
street so they also help. But if I were alone or just didn't have
enough help, or needed help beyound our abilities, there is no way - my
MIL would definitely be in a nursing home. When you get to the point
where you need them in a 24 hour watch & professional care, then that
is simply what has to happen.

Call around & see if you can find a support group in your area or
perhaps find a counselor who can help advise you so you can make this
most difficult decision.

Dementia is a truly horrid disease. My heart goes out to you.This is a
fabulous group - lots to learn here & loads of support:)

Octavia

> Hi
>
[quoted text clipped - 61 lines]
> Thanks for reading
> Liz
owliz@hotmail.com - 30 Dec 2005 08:30 GMT
Hi Octavia

The questions you raised about his abilities to do things I would have
said yes he could do that before this hospitalisation. The last time I
saw him for any length was day before yesterday and I would still have
said yes pretty much, as long as the lunch was something easy to eat
like a sandwich and not a hot meal.

However because the doctors at the hospital told him yesterday that
they are looking at placing him in a home, and because it was my fault
he was in the hospital and I would not help him find a lawyer etc, he
doesn't want to talk to me and when I went today told me to *&^% off.

He sounded very lucid even if not necessarily rational, as he believes
that  I obviously don't care about him to leave him there.

He is suing everybody for a variety of things and is suing me for
'every penny I have' and he basically told me not to come back.

This was particularly hurtful for me as I had little sleep and am
increasingly anxious about his condition and despite the problems we
have had over the years this is the longest we have been apart for 25
years and I do miss him and worry about his well being.

I did find out that there are a number of services  in the community,
including day care service, so I would only need to have full care for
him in the evenings and weekends. Apart from some early rising, he is a
very sound sleeper and has had no problems caring for himself if he got
up before me.

This is tearing me apart as I want to have him here as long as
possible, but at the moment he is angry and probably more than a little
scared himself, which just makes me less able to say yes he will be
fine at home, even if my gut feeling is that he would for some time to
come.

Before this 'episode' he had been caring for himself pretty well with
little intervention from me, except for me helping him with doctors
visits etc, which was more about his agoraphobia than the what we
referred to as Parkinsons. I also think some of his symptoms relate to
drug withdrawal as they reduce some meds very quickly.

I have two grown sons who live close by who would help if I needed it,
but at the moment I cannot judge where he is at in terms of abilities,
although I know he has been making cups of tea at the hospital for
himself for the last few days.

Two weeks ago they were ready to discharge him but they decided last
minute to play around with his Parkinson's medication and then we
suddenly got this diagnosis, so one can understand him being angry to a
certain extent, especially as this is the 3rd one. It would appear they
also did not tell him that it is a terminal condition.

I might be fooling myself but I would hope to give him more time in our
home than this, I kinda think that he has that right if he is safe here
and I suppose I need more time to come to terms with this as it was so
unexpected as just before this happened he was setting up a new TV to
work with his video, dvd and set top box.

Another thing that worries me is that one of the things they have based
their diagnosis on was hallucinations, which he did have for only one
day and I believe that was the first day they reduced his meds.

Sorry for rambling, as I said this is tearing me apart as I KNOW that
he KNOWs what is happening to him.

Liz
Dennis P. Harris - 30 Dec 2005 09:57 GMT
> This was particularly hurtful for me as I had little sleep and am
> increasingly anxious about his condition and despite the problems we
> have had over the years this is the longest we have been apart for 25
> years and I do miss him and worry about his well being.

you have to remember that it's not him, it's his damaged brain.
owliz@hotmail.com - 01 Jan 2006 02:00 GMT
Hi Dennis
Thanks for the 'reminder' that it is not him but his damaged brain,
although I do know that it is easy to forget it and buy into the
comments and actions that hurt.

I have been reading all the repsonses and also other topics and  this
group has been of great value and support to me and I thank everyone
that has participated.

One question I still have (well there are lots really but one I am
asking for advice) with frontal lobe dementia, which he may have as
well as the LBD. is is the person 'always'  irrational? I am wondering
if there is still rational thought processes there or am I completely
wasting my time in trying to talk to him about anything and assuming
that some part of him can rationalise what I am saying?

I have noted in some of the topics here that mention is made of
medication that reduces or controls some of the more irrational
behaviour caused by FLD and am wondering whether to persue this will
his specialist ?

Please do not think I have not taken on board the comments and advice
from this group, I surely have, but I suppose for me I need to make
sure that I have done all that can be done to address my concerns so I
can feel OK  when I need to put himto care, and that could be  this
week coming.

I am the only person who is not immediately saying 'put him in a home'
as his family do not really want to know, but I know that placing him
is not the end of the story and I will be involved in his care until
one of us expires.

For many reasons it would be expedient to place him but I need to be
sure in my own mind that I am agreeing to place him for reasons other
than it makes my life easier.

>From what I have read on this group I know that you all have been there
and will know and understand my concerns and I thank you for your
support and I do hope that my persistent questioning does not annoy
anyone too much but I have to  know and who better to ask than people
who are living my nightmare?

Liz
Tumbleweed - 01 Jan 2006 02:19 GMT
> Hi Dennis
> Thanks for the 'reminder' that it is not him but his damaged brain,
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> wasting my time in trying to talk to him about anything and assuming
> that some part of him can rationalise what I am saying?

Yes and no ..everyone is different ..though the main thing with people here
is that since sufferers forget what happened then arguing is
pointless..either you'll convince them but they'll forget so its pointless,
or you wont convince them, and they'll forget so its pointless. Most people
here end up agreeing or ignoring but using diversion to move onto a
different topic whenever possible.

> I have noted in some of the topics here that mention is made of
> medication that reduces or controls some of the more irrational
> behaviour caused by FLD and am wondering whether to persue this will
> his specialist ?

yes it may be possible to be controlled, but things will change and so will
the behaviour, for better or worse, its a damaged brain, so there are no
guarantees..you only need one slip back to the old behaviour.

> Please do not think I have not taken on board the comments and advice
> from this group, I surely have, but I suppose for me I need to make
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> sure in my own mind that I am agreeing to place him for reasons other
> than it makes my life easier.

That is a perfectly good reason for values of 'easier'='not having a nervous
breakdown'.

Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

Gwen Love - 01 Jan 2006 03:24 GMT
Liz, it is perfectly natural and okay for you to want to reassure yourself
that you are going to do the best thing for all concerned.  Nobody can fault
you for that.  It is just that those of us here know that one person cannot
look after a person with dementia 24/7 and live to tell about it.  You will
make yourself sick, plus who will take care of him then?
If he is where someone else is responsible for his upkeep and safety, then
you can visit and be sure everything is being done for him that should be
done.  Then you can go home and rest, which you certainly need by now.  The
people who will be looking after him then can go home after their shift, and
someone fresh comes on duty.  It is much easier to deal with when you are
not worn out and worried all the time.
Gwen

> Hi Dennis
> Thanks for the 'reminder' that it is not him but his damaged brain,
[quoted text clipped - 39 lines]
>
> Liz
Evelyn Ruut - 01 Jan 2006 03:54 GMT
Dear Liz,

Gwen is right in what she says below, as are the others.   It is so much
better for everyone, including the person who is ill, when you can see one
another at both of your best.   Caregiving is relentless and messy and often
very, very difficult.   We did it for almost 4 years, and there came a point
when we were both exhausted beyond words, and we had plenty of help, and
there were two of us.

If I had to do it over again, I think I would seek placement sooner, for the
sake of all concerned.   There is a certain dignity in being cared for by
professionals, as you are not putting anyone out.   Your loved ones get
ragged after a while......    Just pick a really good place and stay on top
of the situation.   Visit often and show you care.   It makes all the
difference in the world, and you get to sleep at night.

Regards,
Evelyn

> Liz, it is perfectly natural and okay for you to want to reassure yourself
> that you are going to do the best thing for all concerned.  Nobody can
[quoted text clipped - 52 lines]
>>
>> Liz
owliz@hotmail.com - 01 Jan 2006 14:02 GMT
Dear Evelyn

Thank you for you advice, I know that it is good advice and I certainly
did not think I could care for him for any great length of time but I
hate the way this has evolved from hime being at home every day and
doing all that needed to be done himself, he even ironed his own
clothes, to him suddenly needing to be placed in care, and he is angry
and upset and anxious and probably lots more because it is all so
sudden.

Perhaps I am an optimist, or foolish as many of my friends have
suggested, but I would have preferred the transition to have been
better planned for and not have it that he was taken from here by
ambulance and will not return here, if you know what I mean.

I agree that it is better for both parties to see each other at their
best and I am not asking or expecting that he would be cared for here
for a long time but it would be nice if he could get some community
care and still be here for a while as he got used to it.

If that cannot happen, well so be it, but it is my preference if
possible for a while so he could feel better about it and so we can
work out where the best place is for him rather than simply take the
first placement available.

Oh God, I don't know what is right or wrong but he is my husband and I
really don't want the parting from home to be tinged with accusations
and questions hurt and again that may be me feeling that I have failed
to give him the best I could and yes I know he will forget all of this
but I won't.

Liz

> Dear Liz,
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Regards,
> Evelyn
Dennis P. Harris - 02 Jan 2006 09:30 GMT
> Oh God, I don't know what is right or wrong but he is my husband and I
> really don't want the parting from home to be tinged with accusations
> and questions hurt and again that may be me feeling that I have failed
> to give him the best I could and yes I know he will forget all of this
> but I won't.

YOU HAVE NOT FAILED.  you did what was humanly possible, and if
professional care is needed you are NOT allowed to feel guilty!  

IT IS NOT YOUR FAULT.  he has a disease.  would you feel guilty
if he had a cancer that was difficult to treat and he had to go
to a care facility?  the only thing different about this disease
is that it steals the person away before they are gone,
substituting someone who can't reason, is paranoid, confused, and
anxious, and in the case of dementias affecting the frontal
lobes, missing many social inhibitions.

remember, his anger is NOT your fault.  he cannot reason with his
damaged brain.

drawing it out will neither help with the transition nor make it
easier.   it's best to simply do it, and if you have a durable
power of attorney to place him, it's best to not discuss it with
him.  he will not be able to reason about it, so discussion of it
is fruitless, and even if he doesn't remember the argument, he
will remember the emotions connected with it.

as far as the move goes, i would let the professionals advise you
on how to do it.  
Tumbleweed - 02 Jan 2006 16:11 GMT
> IT IS NOT YOUR FAULT.  he has a disease.  would you feel guilty
> if he had a cancer that was difficult to treat and he had to go
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> anxious, and in the case of dementias affecting the frontal
> lobes, missing many social inhibitions.

Dennis, thats a great point.
Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

Tumbleweed - 02 Jan 2006 20:54 GMT
> Perhaps I am an optimist, or foolish as many of my friends have
> suggested, but I would have preferred the transition to have been
> better planned for and not have it that he was taken from here by
> ambulance and will not return here, if you know what I mean.

From what I have read here, and in my experience, a gradual transition is
most unlikely to occur. Other than the LO being at day care, then I think
its much better if they are one place or another. Move them between two
places and they are going to be confused at best. At worst, for example if
it is difficult to get them into respite care, then you have that trauma
every time, maybe a few times a month or even a week.

As Dennis cogently pointed out, you wouldnt feel guilty if you couldnt cope
with caring for a seriously ill cancer patient. Your husband has a different
disease, one that, in many respects, requires *much more* care than a cancer
patient.

> I agree that it is better for both parties to see each other at their
> best and I am not asking or expecting that he would be cared for here
> for a long time but it would be nice if he could get some community
> care and still be here for a while as he got used to it.

If he got used to it. My dad *hated* with a vengeance day care, every time
he went it was a huge trauma, because he didnt see why he had to go. In the
end my mother came close to breakdown just because of the anticipation of
the struggle before he went, so that became worse than having him at home,
which was bad enough. I'm not saying that would happen to you, many do go
with no problems, but dont be thinking there is a guaranteed 'sweetness and
light' option you failed to take.

> If that cannot happen, well so be it, but it is my preference if
> possible for a while so he could feel better about it and so we can
> work out where the best place is for him rather than simply take the
> first placement available.

You can still look around (and you'll have the time to do it properly)
whilst he is in whatever care he is now, you can move him. It would be more
difficult for you to look whilst you were caring for him, you'd be squeezing
visits in whenever you could get respite care and possibly hiding the
details from him if he was hostile to it and getting stress because of that.

> Oh God, I don't know what is right or wrong but he is my husband and I
> really don't want the parting from home to be tinged with accusations
> and questions hurt and again that may be me feeling that I have failed
> to give him the best I could and yes I know he will forget all of this
> but I won't.

I go back to dennis's words. If this was any other disease you wouldnt feel
that. This is no different to any other major disease and worse than most in
terms of the level of care needed, more than a single person, even several
people, can provide.

Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

Adelle - 01 Jan 2006 16:59 GMT
Liz,

Hi! Comments are interspersed.

> Hi Dennis
> Thanks for the 'reminder' that it is not him but his damaged brain,
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> wasting my time in trying to talk to him about anything and assuming
> that some part of him can rationalise what I am saying?

It comes and goes. There were longer periods of lucidity earlier, which got
shorter as time when on.

hen my FIL was in the very early stages, he was very oriented to 'time and
place.' could talk about things in the news and about his hobbies. But his
world of familiarity was getting smaller. We only thought his usual hating
of being in social situations had gotten worse, as they would cancel doing
things with us. In hindsight, we can tell FIL was apparantly getting
overwhelmed and tired by trying to be 'normal,' and really couldn't handle
the commotion of  being around an active preschooler.  But during that time,
they vacationed, he did his photography, he did woodworking projects (more
simple than before and from written instructions instead of 'freehand.') and
continued the maintenance on their home. But he was also entering these
contests, hearing voices at night and thinking people were coming in an
taking his photography equipment. In reality, he was 'hiding' things from
the 'intruders' and then couldn't remember where he'd put things.

Within a span of two years, he could no longer do woodworking projects
because he couldn't follow the instructions. Every little frustration would
make his already short temper flare. We came to visit (we live 400 miles
away), and each day was brand new to him, it was the first day of our visit;
at night when we left fot the hotel, we had 'gone home.' But he still did
all his usual chores and did them well. Some things he remembered from day
to day. But he also went arount the house obsessively locking doors (because
of the hallucinations about intruders). The kids and I would be outside on
the lawn playing, or just unloading groceries from the car and would be
locked out.

He continued to drive because if MIL tried to stop him he got violent. Never
any accidents. But he frequently lost his keys by forgetting to take them
out of the car, and she would have to drive to meet him somewhere (which
means he could still work his phone well, relate where he was, etc.).
Sometimes he got lost. Antidepressants helped the parts of his brain 'talk
to' one another and helped a little, perhaps prolonging how long he was
functional. He continued to help with basic household chores and do them
well (washing dishes after meals, showering and cleaning the bathroom,
keeping the house tidy). But his conversations would vere into the absurd if
you allowed him to continue speaking, adding things to conversations about
current events that were patently fantastical.

But then he forgot about his illnesses and decided everyone was trying to
trick him into taking thes drugs that did nothing for him. That instigated
the health crisis that required hospitalization. That's also when my MIL,
exhausted over the past few years and unable to cope emotionally with the
process of placing her husband in full time care called and asked my husband
to drive home immediately. When he arrived, his dad didn't remember him at
first, but did understand things like needing to sign a health care proxy
and making certain wishes about his health known. He seemed to be able to be
rational for about a ten minute conversation. He was always better after
napping. He understood the power of attorney and health documents for the
time they were explained and he signed them (all that was legally required).
Then he started talking about how he was a consultant for this big building
project that was going on on outside the hospital.

But the next visit, he introduced my husband to his doctor without any
prompting at all. My husband cherishes that last "this is my son."

> I have noted in some of the topics here that mention is made of
> medication that reduces or controls some of the more irrational
> behaviour caused by FLD and am wondering whether to persue this will
> his specialist ?

This is very important in controlling the rages. And can't be comfortable
for your husband to always feel what he is feeling. It is kinder to reduce
the hallucinations and paranoia so he is not frightened and raging. It is
not a chemical straight jacket, as some people call it. It is helping your
loved one cope in a world that no longer fully makes sense.With the
confluences of Parkinson's and FLD, it may be trickier. But do consult a
psychiatrist about this. A Neuro-psychiatrist (someone both a neurologist
and a psychiatrist) with experience in geriatrics or dementias is the gold
standard and if there is one in your area, that's really the person you want
caring for your husband. S/He will best understand all the factors which
need consideration in caring for someone with these brain diseases.

> Please do not think I have not taken on board the comments and advice
> from this group, I surely have, but I suppose for me I need to make
> sure that I have done all that can be done to address my concerns so I
> can feel OK  when I need to put himto care, and that could be  this
> week coming.

That is fully understandable.

> I am the only person who is not immediately saying 'put him in a home'
> as his family do not really want to know, but I know that placing him
> is not the end of the story and I will be involved in his care until
> one of us expires.

Very true. He will continually need you in his life. He will always need
someone to love him, even when he is not acting particularly lovable. He
will also need someone to oversee his care. To you, he will always be your
husband. Even when that has little meaning to him, it will have huge meaning
to you.

Until you get a clear picture of what is happening medically, it will seem
you don't have enough information to make a decision (and maybe even not
then, but we do the best we can). As a tool, my husband wouldn't allow his
mom to agree to discharge from hospital until a PET scan was done to find
out what was really wrong and until there was a medication plan in place.
You seem to have a good diagnosis, so now getting the medication plan in
place would be helpful. With the Parkinson's, the paranoia may not be fully
controllable. But it's worth trying.

Adelle
Tumbleweed - 30 Dec 2005 10:06 GMT
> Hi Octavia
>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> He sounded very lucid even if not necessarily rational, as he believes
> that  I obviously don't care about him to leave him there.

you arent the first person to experience this!

> He is suing everybody for a variety of things and is suing me for
> 'every penny I have' and he basically told me not to come back.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> very sound sleeper and has had no problems caring for himself if he got
> up before me.

'has had no problems caring for himself'' being the key words, dont fool
yourself that because he was OK before he'll be OK in even the near the
future. IME if medical staff believe he needs to be in care things are
pretty bad.
From what you write it also sounds as if he could become violent, even if he
never has before, with a damaged brain you arent dealing with the same
person you were before even if sometimes there are glimpses of the old
person.
I think you really should consider *very carefully* if caring for him
yourself is practical and what it would do to your health and your
relationship. Suppose he is back at home but has the same attitude, eg suing
you, swearing at you etc, what sort of life would that be for either of you?

Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

carolinasongbird@gmail.com - 30 Dec 2005 16:46 GMT
<snip> If your husband is in the early stages, I can see where Assisted
Living
might work out. However, because you are working, I'm not even sure if
that would the best situation. If he had a serious problem, would he be

able to pick up the phone & call for help? Is he able to reason with
things like knowing which clothes are appropriate? If a snack is in the

kitchen, is he able to go get it without any problems? If he has meds
he has to take during the day, is he able to take them correctly? Does
he have any problems with toileting - my point being when you gotta go,

you gotta go & if they have a reasoning impairment then they are
probably going to wait until the last second which can cause a mess if
they don't have help ready right there. <end of snip>

These are exactly the types of things assisted living can help him
with. They will supervise meds and meals, make sure he is dressed
*somewhat* appropriately (you choose your battles), and help with
toileting if needed.

This is a lower level of care from a nursing home -- for example,
patients there may be totally bedridden and require bedpans, to be fed,
etc. Obviously if he is still able to get around at all, he would be
bored to death there, where an AL home has movie nights, outings,
sing-alongs, etc.

Songbird
Mary_Gordon@tvo.org - 29 Dec 2005 20:21 GMT
He really sounds very typical for Lewy Body, and I would strongly urge
you NOT to try and look after him at home, unless you can hire full
time help (and even then, it would be a very hard row to hoe). I've
snipped the following description on dementia with lewy bodies
(sometimes called DLB) and you can see he's really classic in terms of
what you are seeing in terms of fluctuations, falls, stupor etc.

Mary G.

Clinical Symptoms of DLB

Following a consensus consortium in 1996, diagnostic criteria for DLB
were devised. Clinical features that were most characteristic of DLB
were a progressive dementia and at least 2 of the following three
characteristics: (1) extrapyramidal (Parkinsonian) signs (typically
bradykinesia, rigidity and postural instability, but rarely tremor);
(2) fluctuating course; and (3) prominent visual hallucinations. Other
features that are supportive but not required for diagnosis include:
(1) increased sensitivity to neuroleptics (antipsychotic medications
such as haloperidol); (2) repeated falls; (3) syncope (fainting spells)
or transient loss of consciousness; (4) systematized delusions
(discussed below); and (5) hallucinations in other modalities
(auditory, olfactory, etc).

The fluctuation in cognition has been the most confusing aspect of the
diagnosis and the most difficult feature to identify and agree on.
Cognitive fluctuation has been defined as the spontaneous impairment of
alertness and concentration (appear drowsy but awake, look dazed, not
be aware of what is going on) that varies from day to day or week to
week (i.e. become worse for a while then improved, up and down course).
Suggestions have been made that fluctuation of 5 points or more in the
Mini-mental State Exam (a commonly used psychological test) total score
over 3 administrations in a 6-month period can be considered
significant fluctuation. Of course, the problem with this
recommendation is that it would be rare to evaluate a patient so often
in a clinician's office unless the patient was part of a specific
research protocol. More recently, several rating scales have been
proposed to quantify the presence and severity of fluctuation, one of
which can be administered by the caregiver.

Extrapyramidal (Parkinsonian) signs have been correlated with the
severity of dementia in DLB. There are several features that may help
distinguish DLB from PD: 1) myoclonus (an irregular jerking movement),
2) absence of rest tremor, 3) no response to levodopa or 4) no
perceived need to treat with levodopa. These signs were 10 times more
likely to be associated with DLB than PD and are not characteristic of
AD. Although clinicians tend to think of DLB only in the presence of
Parkinsonian signs, these features are not absolutely required for the
diagnosis. Several clinicopathological studies have demonstrated that
in the presence of a progressive dementia, fluctuation and visual
hallucinations, the clinical diagnosis of DLB can be made.

Neuropsychiatric Spectrum of DLB

Studies retrospectively examining the psychometric profile of patients
with DLB using Mini-mental State Exam (MMSE) scores, the
information-memory-concentration scores of the Blessed scale or the
Mattis Dementia rating scale have demonstrated that patients with DLB
perform worse than AD patients in tests of visual tracking and visual
attention shifting. DLB patients also performed worse with respect to
verbal and motor initiation capacities and in comparison of the ability
to perform similarities. With regard to visuospatial abilities, DLB
patients perform more poorly than AD patients on visuospatial tests
such as block design and clock draw testing do. DLB patients also
perform worse on the copying portion of tasks such as construction
subtests. Patients with DLB performed equally as poor as AD patients in
regards to verbal and semantic memory, naming, abstraction and episodic
memory tasks.

When these same tasks were applied prospectively to patients who met
clinical criteria for DLB, these patients were found to be more
impaired than AD patients in areas of visuospatial working memory,
timed attention tasks, and copying two- and three- dimensional drawings
and the clock draw.

When followed longitudinally, DLB patients tended to experience a more
rapid decline than seen in AD, especially when motor symptoms were
present. Patients with extrapyramidal motor symptoms deteriorated 67%
faster on the MMSE (4.5 points per year) than patients without motor
symptoms (2.7 points per year). Another study comparing DLB and AD
patients reported that the average rate of MMSE decline in DLB was 5.8
points per year compared to 4.1 points per year in AD. One study
looking at patients with AD and extrapyramidal symptoms demonstrated
greater deficits on tests of verbal comprehension, automatic speech,
semantic fluency and praxis than AD alone.

In summary, longitudinal studies have demonstrated a significantly
faster functional or cognitive decline in DLB or in AD patients with
Parkinsonism compared to AD. The exact profile of decline and the time
period for this decline is still lacking.
michelle - 30 Dec 2005 09:14 GMT
Hi Liz,I am in Adelaide and scorching today.
I have a Mum with late stage AD but also I work in a aged care
home(assisted living)
when I read your intro story it was to me like reliving the story of
one of our past residents.He came to us diagnosed with Parkinsons,then
staff would say he acted like a person with AD/Dementia.
As time went on he had increasingly more falls,would have psychotic
episodes and then appeared to be getting rigidity episodes.
At the time we had a RN who just wouldnt listen,over 2 days I saw this
man get to the stage where he was so rigid he could not even open his
mouth to be fed.I will never forget this day as apart from trying to
get some soft mashed potato in his mouth for the umpteenth time the RN
insisted I push a capsule of his meds in his mouth.When I refused she
pushed it in with her finger.
Needless to say I lost it with her and insisted she get a Dr before I
reported her,she did and he was diagnosed with Frozen Man Syndrome.I
had never heard of it.He was transferred immediately to hospital and
sadly from that day to this about 18 mths I never found out what
happened to him.
My strongest advice to you,push for a placement in a care facility.
michelle - 30 Dec 2005 09:24 GMT
Forgot, My Mum has been diagnosed from the beginning with just memory
loss Haha, Frontal Lobe Dementia,Dementia with Lewy bodies and AD with
frontal lobe dementia and capgrass syndrome.I find the capgrass
syndrome to be very interesting and not widely known of or discussed.
All in all to me they are basically the same thing but with varying
different responses and actions by the sufferer.
Michelle
Adelle - 30 Dec 2005 17:31 GMT
Hi, Liz;

So sorry you are having to deal with this. My father in law had frontal lobe
dementia, though the kind was never diagnosed. Frontal Lobe dementias are a
little more peculiar than AD and may need institutional care earlier.

I know you are sad and frightened over his accusations. It's hard to not
take them personally when they are backed with much emotion and force. But
this is the Dementia and Parkinson's talking, and not the man who loved and
married you. Sadly, the part of your partnership which was mutual and
supportive isn't something he is capable of any more. Not in his current
state. Sometimes, there are antipsychotics that can help, but the
Parkinson's and Lewey Bodies limit what drugs can be tried.

When the frontal lobe is affected, the executive functions are often
affected before memory. So our loved ones appear more lucid, but they
hallucinate more and have no control over emotions. Neither do they have a
sense of what's appropriate. Hence - the frightening anger, the paranoia,
the obsessions over sex and money. The accusations that you are all out to
get him and suing everybody are also part of it. If you can't tell that
people are acting to help you, but they are putting you in hospital, filling
you full of drugs and saying you can't go home again - wouldn't you think
people were out to get you? Parkinson's has a major anger component as well.

My FIL held it together pretty well in doctor's offices but hallucinated at
home, obsessively entered contests and these 'send a dollar to 10 people and
see how much you get back" scams. MIL finally just stopped his access to
money by not keeping cash at home. She also did whatever she could to keep
him from getting violent. She was living on eggshells and under extreme
stress, but wouldn't accept help.

FIL finally decided that he didn't need his cardiac medication anymore (got
violent when you tried to coax) and wound up in hospital with congestive
heart failure. When he couldn't hold it together 24 hrs a day and the
hospital staff noticed just how bad the hallucinations were, the docs
refused to release him except to a nursing home. There, he wound up
'assaulting' another patient (we don't know details) and was sent to a psych
ward.

On the one hand, psych wards aren't set to deal with dementia patients and
no one made him shower or shave - for weeks. On the other hand, they did a
PET scan to finally diagnose what part of the brain was affected and found a
balance of medications which made him his old self - a sweet, calm person
(as long as his meds were given exactly on schedule). He was discharged to
and remained in a nursing home until a cascade of other health events
resulted in death a few months later.

The release from stress by putting her husband in care was extreme. MIL
slept, only rousing to eat, for the first few days, just because she was
exhausted. But then she slowly reclaimed some sense of her own life, which
allowed her to deal with her husband's condition with much better
perspective.

You need to live, too. You need to provide an income for yourself. You need
to eat and sleep. Doing these as a 24 hour caretaker is impossible. You are
not dealing with a toddler who can be put in a crib. Your husband is a large
strong man whose anger could be very destructive - and he can't control it.
Not that he won't, but can't.  You need to protect yourself by creating a
situation that is really in his best interests, even if it is arousing
extreme anger and resentment for the moment.

May the new year bring better things.

Adelle

> Hi
>
[quoted text clipped - 61 lines]
> Thanks for reading
> Liz
Tumbleweed - 30 Dec 2005 17:36 GMT
Well said Adelle.

Signature

Tumbleweed

email replies not necessary but to contact use;
tumbleweednews at hotmail dot com

> Hi, Liz;
>
[quoted text clipped - 128 lines]
>> Thanks for reading
>> Liz
Evelyn Ruut - 30 Dec 2005 19:09 GMT
Bravo Adelle.  Well said.

Evelyn

> Hi, Liz;
>
[quoted text clipped - 128 lines]
>> Thanks for reading
>> Liz
ncgen - 31 Dec 2005 05:01 GMT
Agreed! Very well said, Adelle.
owliz@hotmail.com - 31 Dec 2005 17:00 GMT
Hi Adelle

Thank you for your comments I have found them very helpful having
regard to my experience today.

Yesterday when I went to visit my husband in Hospital he told me to
%$## Off as I didn't bring his credit card so he can make phone calls
to a lawyer to get him out of there. The Nurses told me he had been
making a general nusiance of himself pressing the buzzer and
complaining about everything and trying to get access to the phone.

I left very soon after that and came home in a very distressed state
and felt like I could not handle all of this situation but was still
devastated by the process and the decision I needed to make.

Today I went back to visit, after the nurse told me he had behaved well
all day, but he was again being obnoxious and threatening to sue all
and sundry. Again he told me I don't care for him etc etc adding this
time comments about my boyfriends (that don't exist)

What that visit did for me was to make me acknowledge that even if he
is physically able to come home, and he certainly seemed great, none of
the problems of the past few weeks were observed, although I accept the
information that his abilities will vary depending on time etc, but
that I cannot and will not accept the agressive and irrational
behaviour as it is likely to put my life at risk or create so much
stress via altercations with me and others.

I don't know if it makes sense to anyone  but it made me feel so much
better with the decision that needs to be made, I suppose it is because
it is not just a question of whether I can cope with changing adult
nappies or helping him to eat and drink, shower etc,  it is something
that  no matter what I may want to do I cannot change, and I do not
want to become tomorrow's headlines.

I do know and accept that it is not the person I have known and loved
for so many years making a conscious decision to say the things he does
and actually believe what he is saying is true but I have been there
and done that for the past 6-8 months and the stress was intolerable
and the fear of personal attack made me leave the home for a few days.
I fear that he may be a threat to both my sanity as well as my physcial
well being.

Unless there is a medication that can change his personality back to
someone who is reasonable and who is capable of being reasoned with
then I know that I cannot live with him.

Only time will tell but I do wish this nasty spiteful man who is
inhabiting my husband's body would go away.

Liz

> Hi, Liz;

> ........ You need to live, too. You need to provide an income for yourself. You need
> to eat and sleep. Doing these as a 24 hour caretaker is impossible. You are
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Adelle
Mary_Gordon@tvo.org - 31 Dec 2005 19:34 GMT
Unfortunately, Liz, the nasty spiteful man will go away - but sadly,
the feistiness vanishes with everything else, good, bad and
indifferent. This phase will pass off, but the next phase will not
bring back the man you knew - he will be on to something equally
challenging, but in other ways than physical threats. It's brain damage
talking to you. Safety, both yours and his, trumps every other
consideration.

I think all of us who have faced a decision to place a loved one in a
care facility have been through a similar process. We all torture
ourselves with guilt and "what ifs". We all wish things were different.
We wish none of it was happening. We wish we didn't want or need help.
We wish we could keep them at home.

The process of making the decision is the worst part - the most
painful, the most angst ridden, the most difficult on every front. Once
you have made the decision, and start moving ahead on it, the way will
seem clear.

Certainly for our family, when my mother in law was finally in an
assisted living facility, it was a complete relief for all of us. We
knew we were under strain and worrying constantly, living from crisis
to crisis - but we didn't realize how much stress there was until the
weight was lifted. Once she was safely settled and we could see she was
well looked after, it was like the lifting of a black cloud. Many
people here have gone into a sort of a physical and emotional collapse
after their loved one was finally placed (i.e. they were so exhausted
from caregiving that they just need to curl up for a complete battery
recharge).

Then in the aftermath, when we can see more clearly, most of us wonder
why we didn't take action sooner, since our fears for the person
adjusting are rarely justified.

You've done the best you could. Don't feel guilty for one second.

Mary G.
Gwen Love - 31 Dec 2005 22:24 GMT
Liz, no one on the NG is allowed to feel guilty.  We all have done the best
we could with the information we had at the time, and that is the best
anyone can do.  So don't you dare feel guilt!
Gwen

> Unfortunately, Liz, the nasty spiteful man will go away - but sadly,
> the feistiness vanishes with everything else, good, bad and
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
>
> Mary G.
michelle - 01 Jan 2006 06:51 GMT
I will second that Gwen,because it is so true
Michelle
Anthony Shipley - 02 Jan 2006 07:35 GMT
>Liz, no one on the NG is allowed to feel guilty.  We all have done the best
>we could with the information we had at the time, and that is the best
>anyone can do.  So don't you dare feel guilt!

Probably one of the few times we agree, Gwen.

I'm still cogent enough to recognise the extra load and stress my disease adds
to my working wife's  burdon (She has this year off teaching so she's got only
one pupil from hell this year).

While, at the moment, we might match each other in frustration but I know her
burdon will quickly become the greater.

anthony shipley

Run away with me; I can make you unhappy.
A R Pickett - 01 Jan 2006 21:33 GMT
Liz wrote in part - > Only time will tell but I do wish this nasty spiteful
man who is
> inhabiting my husband's body would go away.

Many of the responses have stressed that the LO is no longer capable of the
interaction that family members and caregivers remember from before the
illness began.

I think we all have stories which vary from one to another in large or small
degrees, but one common theme runs through them all.

Caregivers and family members need to evaluate the ENTIRE situation, and
make the best decision possible based on what they know at the time.  The LO
is not capable of participating in that decision to any meaningful degree,
at least in most cases.

My father has a type of vascular dementia, caused by a series of TIA's (or
mini-strokes)  He is doing quite well where he lives now, in a "supported
independent" apartment.  He has friends, social interaction, interesting
activities to fill his days.  His apartment is a mess, but the housekeeping
service tells us it's "not a problem" and "not as bad as they've seen."  I
think that if I questioned him, he would admit he is better off there.  Yet
he still makes the occasional comment that the decision to move there was
his children's idea, not his, and he wanted to "decide for himself"  Yet I
shudder to think what his life would be like were he still in the home he
and my mother shared.  It was a totally impossible situation.  And I have
come to realize that he is no longer capable of "deciding for himself."  The
father I knew and loved who could evaluate an entire scenario and see the
best way to proceed is gone.  As you comment about your husband someone else
is "inhabiting his body."

Since in concert with my siblings, I still can participate in a decision, I
need to focus on my commitment to providing love and care for him in the
best way possible and to supporting my sister who handles the majority of
the day to day things.

It's not an easy row to hoe.  Everyone who posts here would agree.  It took
me quite sometime to see things in the way I have described.

This is a marvelous group and a good source of support.  Post anytime you
need/want to and keep us up to date on how things are going.

Signature

A R Pickett aka Woodstock

"Sometimes the facts threaten the truth"

Amos Oz, prize winning Israeli author

Read my book reviews at:
http://www.booksnbytes.com/reviews/_idx_ws_all_byauth.html

Remove lower case "e" to respond

So tired - 01 Jan 2006 17:50 GMT
The problem is not what you think.

http://www.midnightcafe.com/alzh/

http://www.midnightcafe.com/alzh/diagnosis5.html#recovery

I went from mean as a snake back to my cheery self by taking Capric acid for
candida yeast. Had to change doctors. Most of the dementia went away also.
Overnight.

However food allergies go hand in hand with yeast infections. Watch how he
acts a hour or two eating!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Can be anything. The butter they put
on hambuger buns at my favorite resturant would send me to lala land. I had
to quit eating potatoes for a year.

Have them tested him for metal poisoning?

Did he have major dental work before this started?

If your health is shot  then something a simple a coke from a can instead of
a bottle can mess you up. I found switching from cans to bottles dramaticly
improved my mental capabilities. Simply reading a book printed with the
wrong ink(fumes) in a closed room would mess me up. I started only reading
where there was a breeze.

This all goes away has your health improves.

Talk to a doctor about Chelation treatment.

http://www.bernardjensen.org/item.jhtml?UCIDs=1060728%7C1063169&PRID=1024630

This is a very effective alternative to chelation treatment at a FRACTION of
the cost.

I strongly advise "The cure for all disease" by Dr. Clark   Her 3 health
purges are a must.

Best of luck. If he won't or can't  do what it takes to help clear this up I
would advise a resthome. When you are that far down you don't want the
people you knew around you. You can't deal with them and don't want them to
see you like that.
Dennis P. Harris - 02 Jan 2006 09:36 GMT
> The problem is not what you think.

quack. quack. quack. PLONK.
So tired - 02 Jan 2006 14:37 GMT
I once went down hill year after year. My doctor was so understanding and
everyone was so sympathetic. Poor fellow, they would say to themselves, he
has alzheimer's. I hated them all.

Then my doctor pissed me off so much I staggered to the libary to find the
cure they all told did not exist. I was realy just pissed off and my only
other option was my shotgun. I prayed this little prayer and look at this
wall of books. The first book I saw at was something like the cure for
chronic fatigue. I said yeah sounds good and decided to read the first
health book I had ever looked at. Too bad I was so screwed up I lost the
book.

It said "If you have this symptom this is the most common cause and this is
the cure."..."If you have this symptom this is the most common cause and
this is the cure"...page after page. He said I didn't have alzheimer's
rather I had a dozen other things wrong that my doctors had diagnosed wrong.
That this is normal for medicine.

My doctor openly laughed in my face when I talked to him about this. Aweek
later I felt better than I had in years.  I got rid of him by the end of the
month.

Just because your doctors say you have alzheimer's doesn't mean you have
Alzheimer's.

> > The problem is not what you think.
> >
> quack. quack. quack. PLONK.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.