
Signature
--Rich
Recommended websites:
http://www.ratbags.com/rsoles
http://www.acahf.org.au
http://www.quackwatch.org/
http://www.skeptic.com/
http://www.csicop.org/
> "Chris C" <chrisc@mindspring.com> wrote in message
> > All saturated fats are not the same. A healthy cow treated well,
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> You obviously know nothing about either food science or dairy farming.
It doesn't seem like you do either.
> Neither science nor your body could tell from milk fats what the cow ate or
> how it was treated. Treating cows well is an integral part of dairy farming.
> Happy cows produce more milk, and production is profit.
For one thing.... who said I was talking about milk?
Since we're talking about milk, do you know what makes butter yellow?
(Other than using food coloring that is). Were do you think that
yellow comes from? Grain?
> Dairy farmers are
> not stupid hicks that mistreat their cows for fun. Milk is tested for
> antibiotics, and rejected by the dairy co-op if it is contaminated.
Never said they were, but they are trying to run a business right?
And things like Bgh were initially introduced for that very purpose
correct?
Or was that to make the cows happy and healthy?
>So dairy
> farmers are VERY careful to keep antibiotics out of the milk. Not to say
> that they don't use antibiotics. As you say, healthiness is important for
> cows, and cows, like humans, sometimes need some antibiotics to stay that
> way.
Antibiotics have there place when it comes to saving someone from a
crippling disease when it's a last resort, but for the most part they
are making humans and animals more sickly.
>Grass is an important component of a dairy cow's diet in the
> summertime. It is non-existant in the winter,
Depends on where you live now doesn't it? Or are you under the
impression that the entire earth gets covered in snow every year?
> and replaced by hay, silage,
> or "haylage". Grain supplements are important, too, because grass alone
> could never supply the calorie content needed by a productive cow.
And what ever did those poor cows eat before us people came along?
They must have all starved to death! :-O
I get all the 100% grassfed dairy I want. Well they do get some
alfalfa, etc. I'm sorry I choose cows on a good diet as upposed to a
"productive" diet and no I don't think that grain and industrial waste
products are a good diet, no matter what time of the year.
And you listing a bunch of skeptic sites is just as pathetic as the
hippies you claim to dislike. It just replaces one dogma with another.
Rich Shewmaker - 18 Aug 2005 00:45 GMT
> > "Chris C" <chrisc@mindspring.com> wrote in message
> > > All saturated fats are not the same. A healthy cow treated well,
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> (Other than using food coloring that is). Were do you think that
> yellow comes from? Grain?
Yes, from grain, partly. The yellow color is carotene which the cow obtains
from various sources in her diet. Because the diet of cows changes through
the seasons, so does the color of butter. Now where do YOU think the yellow
in butter comes from?
> > Dairy farmers are
> > not stupid hicks that mistreat their cows for fun. Milk is tested for
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> And things like Bgh were initially introduced for that very purpose
> correct?
Yes, they were, and I've never approved of the practice.
> Or was that to make the cows happy and healthy?
I don't see that BGH affects the happiness of cows one way or another.
> >So dairy
> > farmers are VERY careful to keep antibiotics out of the milk. Not to say
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> crippling disease when it's a last resort, but for the most part they
> are making humans and animals more sickly.
If antibiotic therapy were always delayed until it were a "last resort", it
would indeed be the LAST resort in many cases. You may have difficulty
supporting your thesis that antibiotics "are making humans and animals more
sickly".
> >Grass is an important component of a dairy cow's diet in the
> > summertime. It is non-existant in the winter,
>
> Depends on where you live now doesn't it? Or are you under the
> impression that the entire earth gets covered in snow every year?
Most dairy farming is done in the world's temperate climates.
> > and replaced by hay, silage,
> > or "haylage". Grain supplements are important, too, because grass alone
> > could never supply the calorie content needed by a productive cow.
>
> And what ever did those poor cows eat before us people came along?
> They must have all starved to death! :-O
The modern dairy cow did not exist "before people came along". Their
ancestors probably did starve to death in great numbers during hard winters.
In any case, they were not expected to produce more than ten times their
body weight in milk AND a calf every year. A working dairy cow is
unprofitable if she does not do so.
> I get all the 100% grassfed dairy I want.
That makes the cows happier?
> Well they do get some
> alfalfa, etc. I'm sorry I choose cows on a good diet as upposed to a
> "productive" diet and no I don't think that grain and industrial waste
> products are a good diet, no matter what time of the year.
"Industrial waste products"?
> And you listing a bunch of skeptic sites is just as pathetic as the
> hippies you claim to dislike. It just replaces one dogma with another.
When did I claim to dislike hippies? I'm as much a hippie as anyone in my
generation. But we hippies do not all agree on everything any more than any
other group of people. The skeptic sites offer reality based information,
not dogma. They are a breath of fresh air compared to the miasma of magical
nonsense that pollutes the internet and this ng.
--Rich
("Pathetic" skeptic links omitted because I'm not at my own computer, and I
don't feel like looking up the urls.)